Indian man seeks asylum in Canada, claims 'murder framing' in Haryana; 200 others told the same story
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
But Parwinder Singh's latest plea for refugee status was not rejected, as the judge noted that refugee claims are not a novel-writing contest and therefore there is no requirement for originality.
Singh's case has been sent for review, the National Post reported.
'Asylum narratives are not exercises in creative writing, and a lack of prosaic originality should not be confused for falsehood, fraud, or the deliberate plagiarism of another person's story.
In this case, the RAD put form over substance in its analysis of Mr Singh's narrative. Its conclusion that the narrative was not genuine is therefore unreasonable," Justice Guy Régimbald wrote in a recent decision out of Ottawa.
RAD is Canada's Refugee Appeal Division.
Lawyers representing RAD said they found Singh's story to be fraudulent as individuals who traveled to Canada with him also had the same story.
What is Parwinder Singh's story?
According to the report, Parwinder Singh left India in 2019 when he was a 16-year-old boy.
One day when he was walking home from school with a group of friends, they were accosted by another group who had knives. A brawl breaks out, Singh fled the spot, but one of the boys was stabbed and killed. "The group allegedly responsible for his death includes the nephew of a well-known politician," the report said adding that police visited his home and he was being framed for the murder.
Police kept him in custody for three days, beat him up but released him after taking bribe.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Before his release, Singh's fingerprints were taken and he was threatened to stay quiet.
He was again called to the police station, made to wait for hours and insulted and told ti return again in two weeks.
T
hen Singh's father decided to send him to Canada as staying in India did not seem safe. With the help of an immigration agent, Singh traveled to Canada falsely claiming to be participating in a Tae Kwon Do tournament.
Immigration ministry intervened in Singh's case in 2023 and called the story fake and 200 other claims, all from India, have the same story. Singh then said he supports Khalistan and hence fears persecution in India. RAD claimed this too was a fake story to stay in Canada.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
17 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Dalai Lama succession: Govt says it doesn't take position on issues related to practices of faith
The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) has addressed the Dalai Lama's July statement regarding his succession, clarifying that the Indian government maintains a neutral stance on religious beliefs and practices. India has conveyed its position, emphasizing religious freedom, to the Chinese side. The Central Tibetan Administration (CTA) head Penpa Tsering has challenged China's claim to the next Dalai Lama's reincarnation. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) on Thursday said it has seen a statement issued by the 14th Dalai Lama in July about the institution of the Dalai Lama, and underlined that it "does not take any position" on matters concerning beliefs and practices of faith and of State for External Affairs Kirti Vardhan Singh said this in a written response to queries in the Rajya MEA was asked whether it is a fact that the government has "openly backed Dalai Lama's right to decide on his own succession"."Government has seen a statement regarding the institution of Dalai Lama issued by His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama on 02 July 2025. Government of India does not take any position on matters concerning beliefs and practices of faith and religion," the MoS said."Government has always upheld freedom of religion for all in India and will continue to do so. Government's position has also been conveyed to the Chinese side," he July, Central Tibetan Administration (CTA) head Penpa Tsering countered the Chinese government's claim to the next Dalai Lama and said they should first look for the reincarnations of its own leadership."The Chinese government also says they will look for the Dalai Lama's reincarnation within the borders of China. His Holiness is going to be reborn; he will decide where he wants to be reborn. How can the Chinese government dictate a lama, a spiritual being, where he or she should be reborn," Tsering had told PTI ahead of the 90th birthday celebration of the 14th Dalai Lama.
Indian Express
18 minutes ago
- Indian Express
CM Devendra Fadnavis urges industry to turn US tariff crisis into opportunity
Amid growing concerns over the tariff imposed by the United States on Indian goods, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis on Thursday said the US's decision to impose tariffs on Indian goods should not be seen as a setback but as an opportunity to expand exports and find alternative markets. Chairing a review meeting on global import-export strategy at Sahyadri Guest House, Fadnavis said Maharashtra must step forward to turn adversity into opportunity. 'The US has tried to put India in a difficult position by raising tariffs. But instead of treating this as a crisis, we should look for new markets and ensure Maharashtra becomes a driving force in India's economic growth,' the Fadnavis said. As a solution to this, Fadnavis directed the creation of a dedicated 'Ease of Doing Business War Room' to monitor reforms, address bottlenecks and review progress every month. He said that the disruption in global trade highlighted the need for Maharashtra to accelerate policy changes, attract fresh investments and provide greater support to exporters. Fadnavis underlined that the state must cut procedural delays and strengthen its single-window clearance system so that industries do not face hurdles in acquiring permissions. For agriculture-linked businesses on more than five hectares, he said prior approvals should not be required. He also called for speeding up land measurement processes and clearing environmental permissions in a fixed timeframe, while ensuring that industries which do not harm the environment are not subjected to punitive fines. To spread industrial growth beyond existing hubs, the Chief Minister urged officials to frame a clear policy for private industrial parks outside state-run MIDC estates, with a special focus on small and medium enterprises. 'Industrialisation will bring prosperity and create jobs, but for that the system must be efficient and responsive,' he said. At the meeting, officials presented a review of reforms already implemented in Maharashtra. The state has become the first in the country to issue year-long fire safety clearances, enacted the Maitri Act 2023 to streamline permissions, launched a single-window system for electricity connections requiring only two documents, and rolled out a Building Plan Management System to fast-track construction approvals. The Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation has also operationalised MILAP, an online portal for transparent land allocation. Looking ahead, the state government outlined several new measures. These include creating a land bank to make plots available quickly, making the allotment process more transparent and efficient, and ensuring environmental permissions are granted within 60 days. At the district level, a mechanism will be set up to attract investment, while a dedicated export portal will be launched to help local businesses reach global buyers. A 'One Taluka, One Cluster' initiative will also be introduced to promote localised industrial growth. Fadnavis further stressed that the government was committed not only to attracting new industries but also to supporting existing ones. He said reforms should result in real, on-ground change. 'This is not about cosmetic reform. The real test is whether approvals come faster, whether industries face fewer hurdles, and whether jobs and prosperity are being created,' he said.
Hindustan Times
18 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Assam to halt Aadhaar issuance for adults from October 1 to curb infiltration: CM Sarma
Silchar: Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma on Thursday said the state government will stop issuing first-time Aadhaar cards to people above 18 years of age as part of efforts to check infiltration from Bangladesh, as the state has already reached the 'saturation point' in Aadhaar enrolment, with coverage crossing 102%. The chief minister pointed out that Aadhaar enrolment in Assam has already exceeded the population count. (Representative photo) The new order will come into effect from October 1, with exceptions for Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Tea Tribes, Sarma said after attending a cabinet meeting in Guwahati. Sarma said that only a one-month window — from September 1 to 30 — will be available for adults who do not yet have Aadhaar cards to apply. After that, enrolment will be permanently restricted. 'This is a precautionary measure to ensure no illegal foreigner can become an Indian citizen in the future. It is irrespective of religion or any other criteria. We are committed to safeguarding Assam from infiltration,' he added. The chief minister pointed out that Aadhaar enrolment in Assam has already exceeded the population count. 'The saturation among the general population is 102%, which means the number of cards is higher than the number of people. But in the case of Tea Tribes, SC, and ST, saturation is only 96%, which is why they need more time,' he explained. Sarma said that in rare cases where a genuine Indian adult citizen has been left out, they may approach the district commissioner, who will verify credentials and approve Aadhaar issuance in the 'rarest of rare' circumstances. Referring to the state's continuous crackdown on illegal immigration from Bangladesh, he said, 'In the last one year, we have been detaining and deporting illegal Bangladeshi immigrants almost every day. Just yesterday, seven people were deported. But we cannot rule out the possibility that some may have slipped through. This restriction will act as a deterrent measure.' Also read: Aadhaar for adults in Assam likely to require deputy commissioner clearance: CM 'In many areas, indigenous Assamese people have lost jobs, land, and other facilities to illegal migrants. During eviction drives, they have even attacked government officials. In Uriamghat, 12,000 to 15,000 people gathered to resist officials. Many were not locals, they came from different districts. This shows a larger conspiracy, and we are fighting against it,' he added. Earlier, the state government had considered giving district commissioners the power to approve or reject Aadhaar enrolment of individuals above 18. However, Sarma said the cabinet finally decided that a blanket restriction would be more effective. He also argued that there is hardly any need for new Aadhaar enrolment among adults, as most of them already have the unique identity card. 'Only children and newborns now require Aadhaar enrolment,' he said.
