SEC suffocates Big Ten's rigged College Football Playoff plan
SEC commissioner Greg Sankey extinguished what little life remained for the Big Ten's auto-bid-laden plan when he put his foot down last week at his conference's media days. If the SEC doesn't secure one of the expanded playoff plans it desires, Sankey said, then it's comfortable sticking with the current 12-team playoff format. And the SEC doesn't want the Big Ten's plan.
Well, that's that then.
PART OF PLAN?: NCAA settlement for college sports already faces challenges
PLAYOFF PROBLEM?: Why committee could be tested by two SEC teams
Big Ten's College Football Playoff plan stalls without SEC support
The 12-team playoff will be in place for 2025. The format for 2026 and beyond remains under debate. To expand the playoff, the SEC and Big Ten would need to align behind a plan by a Dec. 1 deadline.
Sankey referenced multiple playoff plans the SEC remains willing to consider. Notable by its omission: The Big Ten's plan that would earmark 13 of 16 spots as automatic bids preassigned to conferences.
"We're going to have 5+7, 5+9, (or) 5+11," Sankey said.
The Big 12 and ACC support the 5+11 plan. The SEC retains interest in it, too.
In the math equations Sankey mentioned, the "5" means five automatic bids - one each going to the five-best conference champions. The second number in the equation means the number of at-large bids.
"We'll continue to debate whether expansion beyond 12 is appropriate," Sankey said.
That debate won't, apparently, include the Big Ten's favored 4+4+2+2+1+3 plan, which would have awarded four automatic bids to the Big Ten, four more to the SEC, two apiece to the ACC and Big 12, and one to the next-best conference champion, leaving three at-large bids.
The SEC soured on this auto-bid plan in the spring, and, in Sankey's annual state-of-the-conference address, he offered no sign of retreating toward the Big Ten's plan.
No individual conference wields the authority to unilaterally push through an expanded playoff. College Football Playoff executive director Rich Clark told reporters last month that playoff expansion would require the SEC and Big Ten to agree upon a plan. What if they can't agree? That's a win for the status quo.
"We have a 12-team playoff, (including) five conference champions," Sankey said. "That could stay if we can't agree."
Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti will get the next word in this debate when his conference's media days begin this week. But, really, what can he say?
Sankey insists the SEC is comfortable staying at 12 if it can't achieve one of its preferred playoff expansion plans. If that's the case, then the Big Ten's pursuit of a 4+4+2+2+1+3 playoff has died on the vine.
To which I say, good riddance.
The 12-team playoff relies on a committee of subjective and imperfect humans to select most of the field, but subjectivity and imperfection are insufficient grounds to scrap this system in favor of a playoff that would pre-emptively reward conferences based on their history, brand and clout, instead of letting on-field results determine bid allocation.
Big Ten, SEC alliance fizzles amid competing interests
Early last year, the SEC and Big Ten announced a pact to work together to chart college sports' future. Stakeholders from the two super conferences met multiple times and discussed playoff expansion possibilities. Much like the Big Ten's previous alliance with the ACC and Pac-12, the bromance between the Big Ten and the SEC fizzled in the face of competing interests.
There's "no rift" between Sankey and Petitti, the SEC commissioner said on his conference's television network last week, but they have "different views."
The Big Ten, according to multiple reports, might be willing to compromise in favor of a 5+11 playoff if the SEC and ACC add another conference game and join the Big Ten and Big 12 in playing nine conference games.
That's a fine wish, but the Big Ten lacks the muscle to force another conference to change its schedule. Sankey would like the SEC add a ninth conference game, but his membership has resisted his preference.
The Big Ten played its playoff hand, but it lacked the cards to win the bet.
"You always want to have a really good set of cards," Sankey said. "You want to have a good hand to play, right? I think we have the best hand."
The Big Ten is running out of moves.
Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network's national college football columnist. Email him at BToppmeyer@gannett.com and follow him on X @btoppmeyer.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
3 hours ago
- STV News
Commonwealth 2026: One-year countdown to scaled-down Glasgow games
The Commonwealth Games is exactly one year away, as Glasgow gets set to host the event for the second time in 12 years. Some of the world's top athletes will arrive in the city next summer for the 2026 games, which kick off on July 23. The 2014 edition was considered a massive success, with the likes of fastest man on the planet Usain Bolt entertaining fans throughout a memorable summer. Team Scotland athletes also did their part and had the home crowd cheering them on in every event as they scooped 19 gold, 15 silver, and 19 bronze medals to finish fourth in the overall table. The games are now returning to Glasgow after the original 2026 host, Victoria, in Australia, pulled out for financial reasons. Around 3,000 athletes from 74 nations will be competing for over 200 medals, although the number of events has been reduced to fit a tighter schedule. It will be a much scaled-down version of the usual Commonwealth Games, due to the short notice to prepare, with confirmation only coming at the end of 2024. Athletes from ten different sports will be competing at the 2026 games, seven down from the 17 featured 12 years ago. The sports on show will be athletics, swimming, track cycling, weightlifting, lawn bowls, judo, 3×3 basketball, gymnastics, netball, and boxing. Six of those sports, athletics, swimming, track cycling, weightlifting, lawn bowls, and 3×3 basketball, will also feature para events. The 3×3 wheelchair basketball event, which debuted at the Birmingham 2022 Games, will return for a second Commonwealth Games appearance. The events will take place at four venues: Scotstoun Stadium, Tollcross International Swimming Centre, Emirates Arena, and the Scottish Event Campus. The venues being used are all within eight miles of each other. Work is under way to upgrade Scotstoun Stadium, which will host the athletics programme, to get it ready in time for the games. The work at the home of the Glasgow Warriors rugby team has been described as a 'significant milestone'. An existing athletic track and temporary stands on either side will be removed, and a new surface is being laid. The Tollcross International Swimming Centre will be the home of swimming, while the Emirates Arena, including the Sir Chris Hoy Velodrome, and the SEC will host the other eight sports. Athletes and support staff will be housed in hotel accommodations. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The Herald Scotland
5 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
College Football Playoff's next Indiana is difficult team to find
The Indianapolis Star took "a pretty big leap" while predicting an 8-4 regular season for the Hoosiers. Another Big Ten newspaper of record, the Omaha World-Herald, surmised a "bowl bid is not out of the question," while projecting 6-6. Indiana's accommodating schedule aided its thrill ride, but even knowing that schedule, who foresaw the Hoosiers smashing Nebraska, handling a Michigan team that later beat Alabama, and securing playoff viability at 11-1? So, when trying to pinpoint the next Indiana, it becomes an injustice to the 2024 Hoosiers to include any preseason Top 25 team. How to find next Indiana for College Football Playoff Illinois attracts comparisons to the 2024 Hoosiers, as basketball-leaning Big Ten schools without a history of football greatness. But, Illinois returns most of its starters from a 10-win team. Expectations are too great and too reasonable to earmark the Illini as the next Indiana. Like Illinois, Texas Tech could pursue the program's first playoff appearance, but the Red Raiders don't emulate 2024 Indiana. The Hoosiers assembled their playoff squad from the transfer portal's bargain rack. Texas Tech launched an expensive player-buying campaign fueled by billionaire booster Cody Campbell. Hardly comparable. After putting aside playoff hopefuls like Illinois and Texas Tech, what's left? Teams like UCLA, California and West Virginia are ultimate longshots, built from the portal's fires. Hear me, I'm not suggesting those teams as likely playoff contenders, but, that's sort of the point, isn't it? The ultimate dark horse, Indiana stunningly crafted a warp-speed turnabout with the help of 31 transfers, a cocksure coach in Cignetti, and a favorable schedule, of which they took full advantage. UCLA, Cal and West Virginia each brought in more than 30 transfers apiece. Each has an over/under of 5 1/2 victories. That's Indiana territory. The Bruins made one of the offseason's biggest acquisitions by plundering a quarterback, Nico Iamaleava, who's a former five-star recruit. He started a playoff game last season for Tennessee. UCLA, fresh off a 5-7 finish in its Big Ten debut, will endure a schedule that includes Big Ten front-runners Ohio State and Penn State, plus a non-conference tilt against Utah. Iamaleava's arrival provides hope for improvement, but it's hard to see that schedule as a recipe toward being the next Indiana. What, then, about California? The Bears nabbed former Ohio State backup Devin Brown as a transfer quarterback. Cal, which hasn't won more than eight games since 2008, will avoid Clemson and Miami, two ACC favorites. The schedule, though, includes six road games and a matchup with SMU, a playoff qualifier from last year. That's enough to prevent Cal from becoming the next Indiana. West Virginia overhauled its roster with 52 transfers after hiring Rich Rodriguez for a homecoming. It would be more appropriate to view the Mountaineers, though, through the lens of 2024 Arizona State. The Sun Devils won the Big 12 championship after the media picked them to finish last in the conference. In the unpredictable Big 12, any number of teams could ascend and claim the auto-bid entry to the playoff. Missouri profiles as a playoff sleeper, after the media picked it to finish 12th in the SEC. The Tigers secured a fine collection of portal prizes, including former Penn State backup quarterback Beau Pribula. Missouri's accommodating schedule positions it to exceed its Vegas over/under of 7 1/2 wins. But, the Tigers won 21 games the past two seasons. They've been too good recently to aptly compare to Indiana. POWER RANKINGS: Where the Big Ten teams stack from first to worst DEAD PLAN: SEC suffocates the Big Ten's plan to rig playoff Would next Indiana come from Big Ten? As I search for the next Indiana, I circle back to the Big Ten. The conference is so big that teams only play half the membership, and there's no requirement to play a Power Four non-conference opponent. That's a breeding ground for a fortunate schedule draw. Consider Maryland. The Terrapins won't play a non-conference Power Four foe, and they avoid Ohio State, Penn State and Oregon. Expectations remain low. Vegas sets the over/under at 4 1/2 wins. Maryland likely will start several transfers after finishing 4-8 last season, and four-star freshman Malik Washington projects as the starting quarterback. Maryland cashing in on a favorable schedule to the extent it could make the playoff sounds highly improbable. When trying to unearth an Indiana sequel, that's the assignment. If the idea doesn't sound absurd, then that team doesn't count as the next Indiana. Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network's national college football columnist. Email him at BToppmeyer@ and follow him on X @btoppmeyer.
The Herald Scotland
5 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Big Ten power rankings for college football season have two leaders
Penn State lands atop USA TODAY Sports' rankings based on an edge in experience at key positions such as quarterback, an improved collection of skill talent, maybe the best offensive line of the James Franklin era and the makings of another top-ranked defense. Landing behind these two front-runners are national contenders in Oregon and Michigan, both of which will be defined in large part by the play of relatively young and unproven quarterbacks: Dante Moore for the Ducks and true freshman Bryce Underwood for the Wolverines. In the end, look for at least four and upwards of six or even seven Big Ten teams to factor into the playoff race over the final weeks of the regular season. Here's how the conference looks heading into preseason camp: 1. Penn State Former Syracuse receiver Trebor Pena (84 receptions for 941 yards in 2024) may end up being one of the most influential offseason additions in the Big Ten. With Drew Allar ensconced at quarterback and running backs Kaytron Allen (1,108 yards) and Nick Singleton (1,099 yards) driving a ferocious ground game, Pena's ability to be Allar's move-the-chains target will help PSU replace star tight end Ty Warren. Sixteen of Pena's 21 third-down grabs in 2024 went for a first down. 2. Ohio State All the deserved attention paid to quarterback Julian Sayin's ascension to the starting job has overshadowed the Buckeyes' significant changes on the defensive side. Just three starters return, though one is superstar safety Caleb Downs, and there's a new coordinator in former NFL coach and longtime pro football assistant Matt Patricia. He hasn't worked in college since serving as a graduate assistant at Syracuse in the early 2000s. ICONIC LOCALES: Ranking all the Big Ten college football stadiums DEAD PLAN: How the SEC crushed the Big Ten's attempt to rig playoff 3. Oregon Moore isn't technically a first-year starter after starting most of his freshman season at UCLA in 2023 before transferring to Oregon. While rocky, that experience and his growing knowledge of the Ducks' scheme last season suggests Moore will step right into the lineup and produce at a high clip. 4. Michigan The Wolverines will be strong on special teams and look particularly stout in the defensive back seven, especially at linebacker. Newcomers at receiver and running back will help ease Underwood's transition. But is he definitely going to start? Not necessarily. While he's the odds-on favorite, coach Sherrone Moore may slow Underwood's climb up the depth chart by tapping Fresno State transfer Mikey Keene, who once played for new Michigan coordinator Chip Lindsey at Central Florida. The pieces are in place for an outstanding season. One of the most experienced teams in the Power Four, Illinois plays a bruising, physical style that helped yield a 6-1 mark last season in games decided by 10 or fewer points. The Illini could very well notch double-digit wins and earn a playoff berth. 6. Nebraska The Cornhuskers are climbing the ladder under third-year coach Matt Rhule, whose previous teams at Temple and Baylor popped in his third season. Dylan Raiola will take a leap in his sophomore year and the offense should shine under coordinator Dana Holgorsen, but line play on both sides will decide Nebraska's fate. 7. Iowa Iowa has tossed a combined 19 touchdowns against 19 interceptions the past two years, with this futility offsetting more excellence from one of the most consistent defenses in the country. The Hawkeyes hope to change the narrative with the addition of former South Dakota State quarterback Mark Gronowski, formerly one of the top players in the Championship Subdivision. 8. Southern California The number to watch: 24. USC went 0-6 during the regular season in 2024 when allowing 24 or more points, including single-possession losses to Michigan, Minnesota, Penn State, Maryland and Washington. A defense that finished 16th in the Big Ten last year in yards per play must take a huge leap for the Trojans to exceed their preseason hype. 9. Indiana Kaelon Black (251 yards) will take over as Indiana's primary running back, joined by a pair of transfers: Lee Beebe Jr. (884 yards) from Alabama-Birmingham and Roman Hemby (607 yards) from Maryland. Hemby has the bonus of being an effective receiver after making 40 grabs for the Terrapins last season. 10. Washington The Huskies look on much sturdier ground heading into coach Jedd Fisch's second season. Part of that is due to increased depth after struggling through large-scale attrition in the wake of Kalen DeBoer's departure for Alabama. Fisch brought in several starting-level defenders through the portal, including cornerback Tacario Davis and edge rusher Ta'ita'i Uiagalelei from Arizona. 11. Minnesota With only senior Le'Meke Brockington set to return from last year's receiver rotation, the Gophers went heavy in the portal to find weapons for new quarterback Drake Lindsey. Three new wideouts to watch: Javon Tracy (57 receptions, 818 yards in 2024) from Miami (Ohio), Logan Loya (109 career grabs) from UCLA and former top-ranked recruit Malachi Coleman from Nebraska. 12. Wisconsin These are unsteady times for Wisconsin, which missed a bowl game last year for the first time since 2001 and desperately needs a winning season to rebuild the damaged faith in third-year coach Luke Fickell. But given a schedule that includes Alabama, Michigan, Iowa, Ohio State, Oregon and Illinois, almost everything would have to go right to win eight games. 13. UCLA Former Tennessee quarterback Nico Iamaleava changes the complexion of Deshaun Foster's second season and paints the Bruins as a threat to add one or two wins to last year's 5-7 record. But UCLA remains very unproven on the offensive line, making that group a major question mark heading into September. The Bruins also take on Utah and UNLV in non-conference play before facing Penn State and Indiana in October and Nebraska, Ohio State, Washington and USC in November. 14. Rutgers Rutgers has stacked back-to-back winning seasons for the first time since 2011-12, illustrating the program's steady growth under coach Greg Schiano. While the roster continues to improve, the Scarlet Knights will have to manage a Big Ten schedule that includes Iowa, Illinois, Oregon, Penn State and Ohio State. 15. Michigan State There are a ton of unknowns, including whether second-year starter Aidan Chiles cracks into his potential after an uneven first season on campus. But the schedule isn't too daunting and the Spartans have added another round of impact transfers, so this team could win seven games by playing cleaner football and avoiding another rash of injuries. 16. Northwestern The Wildcats might be better than expected and make a run at six wins if SMU transfer quarterback Preston Stone solidifies the passing game and newcomers strengthen the offensive line. Two position groups of strength are the backfield and the defensive front. 17. Maryland If not by the season opener, look for the Terrapins to eventually hand the reins to true freshman quarterback Malik Washington and take the lumps that come with rolling the dice on his combination of potential and inexperience. Either way, the overall picture isn't pretty: Maryland has one of the weakest rosters in the Big Ten and probably the worst defense. Anything more than two league wins would be surprising. 18. Purdue Purdue hired the right coach in Barry Odom, who pulled off a borderline miracle at UNLV and would have to do the same to get the Boilermakers back into the postseason. Even if this process eventually pays off, don't expect anything more than a small handful of wins in 2025.
