Unpacking the complexities of plane crash survival beyond seat 11A
Aviation experts say it is not so straightforward because aircraft vary widely in seat configurations, crashes are unique and survival often hinges on a complex interplay of factors.
"Each accident is different, and it is impossible to predict survivability based on seat location," said Mitchell Fox, a director at Flight Safety Foundation, a US-based nonprofit.
Ramesh Viswashkumar said his 11A seat was near an emergency exit on the London-bound Air India Boeing 787 Dreamliner that crashed in Ahmedabad on Thursday, and he managed to walk out.
Sitting next to an exit door might help you survive an accident but it won't always be 11A because aircraft can have dozens of different configurations.
"In this particular instance, because the passenger was sitting adjacent to the emergency exit, this was obviously the safest seat on the day," said Ron Bartsch, chairman at Sydney-based AvLaw Aviation Consulting.
"But it's not always 11A, it's just 11A on this configuration of the Boeing 787."
A 2007 Popular Mechanics study of crashes since 1971 found that passengers towards the back of the plane had better survival odds. Some experts suggest the wing section offers more stability.
Sitting next to an exit door, like Viswashkumar, gives you an opportunity to be one of the first out of the plane, although some exits don't function after a crash.
The opposite side of the plane was blocked by the wall of a building it crashed into, he said.
In January last year, a panel missing several bolts blew off the side of a Boeing 737 MAX mid-flight, creating a gaping hole and damaging the adjacent seat.
Fortunately, no one was seated there at the time, and the incident resulted in no fatalities.
Sitting by the aisle might offer you a speedier escape but it increases the likelihood of being hit in the head by luggage falling out of the overhead bins — a much more common occurrence than major crashes.
Paying attention to the safety briefing at the start of your flight — often dismissed as routine — is likely the best way to improve your chances of survival, experts say.
Disciplined compliance with cabin crew evacuation advice, including leaving bags behind, was a key factor in saving the lives of all 379 passengers and crew aboard a Japan Airlines flight in January last year.
The Airbus A350 aircraft had collided with a Coast Guard plane at Tokyo's Haneda Airport, killing five of the six crew members on the smaller aircraft.
Safety briefings typically cover critical instructions such as how to fasten your seatbelt securely, adopt the correct brace position and plan your evacuation route.
A common tip is to count the number of rows between your seat and the nearest exit — vital knowledge if the cabin fills with smoke and visibility is low.
Despite disasters such as the Air India crash, plane designs have evolved to increase the likelihood of passengers walking away from a rare plane accident, Fox said.
These include floor path lighting, fire detection and extinguishers, less flammable cabin materials and improved access to emergency exits.
"There have been remarkable advancements in airplane cabin design that have improved the survivability of accidents on or near the ground," Fox added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
12 hours ago
- The Star
Families mark 40 years since deadly Japan Airlines crash with hike up mountain site
TOKYO: Family members of victims in the world's deadliest single-aircraft accident hiked Tuesday (Aug 12) to the mountainous site in Japan where the plane went down, as the country marked 40 years since the tragedy that killed 520 people. On August 12, 1985, the doomed Boeing 747 was around 40 minutes into an hour-long flight from Tokyo to Osaka, when it crashed into a mountain about 120 kilometres (75 miles) northwest of the capital. Tuesday saw hundreds of people -- including bereaved families and friends -- hike the trails up to the cenotaph erected on Mount Osutaka where the jet crashed. Among them was a woman who lost her younger brother in the accident. "I want to tell him that all of his family members are alive, with his soul on our shoulders", she told broadcaster Fuji TV. "We're doing our best to live our lives". Japan Airlines Flight 123 lost control soon after take-off, with a loud noise heard about 10 minutes into the trip and an emergency declared, before shaking violently and crashing. The plane was almost full, with many holidaymakers flying back to their hometowns during Japan's "obon" mid-summer festival. In the end, 505 passengers -- including a dozen infants -- and 15 crew members perished. Just four passengers survived. Imperfect repairs to the aircraft's rear bulkhead by Boeing engineers seven years earlier -- coupled with JAL's subsequent lack of oversight -- were blamed for the accident. Numerous, tiny cracks on the bulkhead -- unnoticed on prior flights -- burst, destroying a tail fin, rupturing hydraulic systems and sending the plane hurtling downward. The world's worst airline disaster was the 1977 runway collision of two 747s on Tenerife in the Canary Islands that left 583 dead. More recently in Japan, a near-catastrophic collision occurred at Haneda airport between a Japan Airlines aircraft and a smaller coast guard plane in January 2024. All 379 people on board the JAL Airbus escaped just before the aircraft was engulfed in flames, but five of the six people on the smaller aircraft died. - AFP
The Star
4 days ago
- The Star
Climate change forces denizens of ancient Himalayan village to relocate
The Himalayan village of Samjung did not die in a day. Perched in a wind-carved valley in Nepal's Upper Mustang, more than 13,000 feet (3,962 meters) above sea level, the Buddhist village lived by slow, deliberate rhythms – herding yaks and sheep and harvesting barley under sheer ochre cliffs honeycombed with "sky caves' – 2,000-year-old chambers used for ancestral burials, meditation and shelter. Then the water dried up. Snow-capped mountains turned brown and barren as, year after year, snowfall declined. Springs and canals vanished and when it did rain, the water came all at once, flooding fields and melting away the mud homes. Families left one by one, leaving the skeletal remains of a community transformed by climate change: crumbling mud homes, cracked terraces and unkempt shrines. Villagers take a break while working in a field at the newly relocated settlement. The Hindu Kush and Himalayan mountain regions – stretching from Afghanistan to Myanmar – hold more ice than anywhere else outside the Arctic and Antarctic. Their glaciers feed major rivers that support 240 million people in the mountains – and 1.65 billion more downstream. Such high-altitude areas are warming faster than lowlands. Glaciers are retreating and permafrost areas are thawing as snowfall becomes scarcer and more erratic, according to the Kathmandu-based International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development or ICMOD. Kunga Gurung is among many in the high Himalayas already living through the irreversible effects of climate change. "We moved because there was no water. We need water to drink and to farm. But there is none there. Three streams, and all three dried up,' said Gurung, 54. A herd of sheep passes through an alley as they are taken for grazing near the hills. Climate change is quietly reshaping where people can live and work by disrupting farming, water access and weather patterns, said Neil Adger, a professor of human geography at the University of Exeter. In places like Mustang, that's making life harder, even if people don't always say climate change is why they moved. "On the everyday basis, the changing weather patterns... it's actually affecting the ability of people to live in particular places,' Adger said. Forced to move Around the globe, extreme weather due to climate change is forcing communities to move, whether it's powerful tropical storms in The Philippines and Honduras, drought in Somalia or forest fires in California. The abandoned village of Samjung, with ancient caves carved in the cliffs in the background. In the world's highest mountains, Samjung isn't the only community to have to start over, said Amina Maharjan, a migration specialist at ICMOD. Some villages move only short distances, but inevitably the key driver is lack of water. "The water scarcity is getting chronic,' she said. Retreating glaciers – rivers of ice shrinking back as the world warms – are the most tangible and direct evidence of climate change. Up to 80% of the glacier volume in the Hindu Kush and Himalayas could vanish in this century if greenhouse gas emissions aren't drastically cut, a 2023 report warned. A woman washes her hands in a river at the new area. It hasn't snowed in Upper Mustang for nearly three years, a dire blow for those living and farming in high-altitude villages. Snowfall traditionally sets the seasonal calendar, determining when crops of barley, buckwheat, and potatoes are planted and affecting the health of grazing livestock. "It is critically important," Maharjan said. For Samjung, the drought and mounting losses began around the turn of the century. Traditional mud homes built for a dry, cold mountain climate fell apart as monsoon rains grew more intense – a shift scientists link to climate change. The region's steep slopes and narrow valleys funnel water into flash floods that destroyed homes and farmland, triggering a wave of migration that began a decade ago. Villagers walk towards a field to plant apple trees in the new home. Access and support Moving a village – even one with fewer than 100 residents like Samjung – was no simple endeavour. They needed reliable access to water and nearby communities for support during disasters. Relocating closer to winding mountain roads would allow villagers to market their crops and benefit from growing tourism. Eventually, the king of Mustang, who still owns large tracts of land in the area nearly two decades after Nepal abolished its monarchy, provided suitable land for a new village. Pemba Gurung, 18, and her sister Toshi Lama Gurung, 22, don't remember much about the move from their old village. But they remember how hard it was to start over. A dried-up water tap is seen in the abandoned village of Samjung. Families spent years gathering materials to build new mud homes with bright tin roofs on the banks of the glacial Kali Gandaki river, nearly 15 kilometres away. They constructed shelters for livestock and canals to bring water to their homes. Only then could they move. Some villagers still herd sheep and yak, but life is a bit different in New Samjung, which is close to Lo Manthang, a medieval walled city cut off from the world until 1992, when foreigners were first allowed to visit. It's a hub for pilgrims and tourists who want to trek in the high mountains and explore its ancient Buddhist culture, so some villagers work in tourism. The sisters Pemba and Toshi are grateful not to have to spend hours fetching water every day. But they miss their old home. "It is the place of our origin. We wish to go back. But I don't think it will ever be possible,' said Toshi. – By ANIRUDDHA GHOSAL and NIRANJAN SHRESTHA/AP
The Star
5 days ago
- The Star
Not just cool pets: Why owning a reptile requires commitment and hard work
It was love at first sight for Ooi Kang Shen. While reptiles may seem like an unusual – even daunting – choice of pet for most Malaysian households, the Johor-based engineer was instantly captivated by their appearance and behaviour, particularly tortoises. 'They look special and unique to me, with different patterns on their shells. Plus, they require a different kind of care compared to common pets like cats and dogs,' says Ooi. Far from riding on the pet reptile bandwagon or making an impulse purchase – which is often the case with cute hatchlings like red-eared sliders or baby lizards –Ooi's involvement in reptile-keeping was intentional and well- researched. 'I did all my research and homework well in advance regarding their basic needs before committing to having them,' says the 30-year-old, who has cared for his pet tortoises – an Aldabra, a red-foot and a star tortoise – for over five years. Before bringing his tortoises home, Ooi made sure to thoroughly research their basic needs. — OOI KANG SHEN As tortoises are not a common choice for pets in Malaysia compared to cats or dogs, Ooi notes that reliable care information is considerably limited. 'I had to rely on information from other countries where there's a larger population of reptile pet owners,' he says, adding that he frequently watches YouTube channels such as Kamp Kenan and Garden State Tortoise for guidance. Based on what he has learned, Ooi lets his tortoises roam freely in his garden, grazing on grass and nibbling on cactus, mulberry and hibiscus plants, which he has purposefully planted for these animals with hard, rounded shell. Ooi says his tortoises are attached to him. Photo: OOI KANG SHEN Reality check Dr Nur Asyikin Haron, a veterinarian at Exopet Veterinary Clinic in Skudai, Johor, also understands the predicament of not having enough local information about caring for reptile pets. With a decade of experience under her belt – five years at the University Veterinary Hospital in Universiti Putra Malaysia and another five at her current clinic which she co-founded – she specialises in exotic animals, including reptiles. 'When I first started, there were very limited references – a few books and some articles or research papers on reptile medicine,' she recalls, adding that there were also very few vets treating reptiles, as they were not commonly kept as pets, compared to mammals. Fortunately, she notes, more resources are now available as the field continues to grow. Despite the common misconception that they're low- maintenance, Nur Asyikin says reptiles have highly specific needs – dietary, environmental and behavioural. 'Reptiles are not beginner- friendly pets. They have specific and often complex husbandry requirements,' she stresses. She adds, 'They are also masters at hiding signs of illness, so by the time owners seek veterinary care, the condition is often already advanced or critical.' Because of this, Ooi makes it a point to monitor his tortoises closely for any unusual behaviour – reduced appetite, excessive naps, decreased movement or droopy eyelids, among others. 'When these symptoms happen, I'll immediately get them treated,' he says, adding that it was initially challenging to find a vet who treats exotic animals like his tortoises. As he believes caring for a pet is a huge commitment, Ooi routinely takes his pets for check-ups. 'I want to make sure that my pets are healthy and I did not want to miss any sign of illness.' Nur Asyikin with a rescued bearded dragon. Photo: Dr NUR ASYIKIN HARON Misconceptions debunked One of the most common medical conditions Nur Asyikin encounters in pet reptiles is Metabolic Bone Disease (MBD). This is a serious illness caused by poor nutrition and lack of ultraviolet-B (UVB) exposure. This condition, she says, is especially prevalent among tortoises and turtles kept indoors, without proper lighting. 'UVB light enables reptiles to synthesise vitamin D3, which helps in absorbing calcium. Without this, their bones will grow weak,' she explains. 'It's an entirely preventable condition, but sadly, it is very common. Proper education on their basic needs could help reduce many of the cases we see.' Nur Asyikin points out that part of the problem stems from how reptiles are perceived and sold. She cites red-eared sliders as a common example. The small turtle, recognisable by the distinctive red mark on each side of its head, is one of the most popular pet reptiles in Malaysia, particularly among children and first-time owners. Unfortunately, they're often marketed as cheap and low- maintenance. Ooi's tortoises roam freely in his home garden in Johor Bahru. Photo: OOI KANG SHEN 'They're cute when they're small, so many people buy them without realising they can grow up to 30cm, live for 20 to 30 years and require extensive care – like a filtered tank, basking area and UV lighting,' she says. Dr Nur Asyikin adds that treating reptiles involves a unique set of challenges, unlike cats and dogs. 'Even basic things like blood tests are not straightforward,' she says. 'Their blood has to be analysed manually, which takes time. And collecting a sample is tricky – their veins aren't visible, and sometimes we even need to sedate them just to get it.' Imaging also poses difficulties. 'For tortoises and turtles, their shells can block internal organs from view on X-rays. Computed tomography (CT) scans give better results, but they're costly and that is not always an option for pet owners.' Medication access is another ongoing issue. 'There are fewer drugs available for reptiles here and getting new ones to be approved takes time,' she notes. 'And then there's the insurance gap. Most pet insurance in Malaysia only covers cats and dogs. I really hope exotic pets will be included one day, so owners can access proper veterinary care without financial strain,' says the veterinarian, who also holds a Master's degree in Equine Medicine. Tips to care for a reptile. Photo: StarGraphics Beyond the scales and shells What about the perception that reptiles are emotionless and even scary? Ooi is quick to dispel the myth. 'My pet tortoises act like dogs. They come to me when I wave and follow me around the garden,' he says. 'Once you interact with them long enough, they develop an attachment to you and they show it. Like other animals, they have feelings too.' He treats them like any other cherished family pet. When he travels, he leaves them with trusted friends or checks them into a reptile-friendly pet hotel. 'They're part of the family now. Even my parents have grown fond of them. They were shocked at first, but now, they're inseparable.' Nur Asyikin shares this appreciation for reptiles, though from a professional perspective. Wearing two hats – as veterinarian and pet shop co-owner – she sees her role as one of both caregiver and educator. 'We work closely with pet owners right from the start – advising on feeding, habitat setup and long-term care. That early guidance often prevents many of the problems we later see in the clinic,' she says. Dr Nur Asyikin keeps four rescued cats and a bearded dragon named Zuko, a clinic rescue that now greets visitors from the waiting area. While reptiles may not be cuddly, she finds caring for them equally rewarding, though more high-maintenance. 'You really need to understand their biology and behaviour,' she says, noting that caring for reptiles involves daily food preparation and a carefully controlled environment. 'I love reptiles and furry pets. But I appreciate the calm and fascinating nature of reptiles: there's something therapeutic about watching them.' With reptile ownership steadily increasing in Malaysia, both Ooi and Nur Asyikin hope that prospective owners take the responsibility seriously. 'It's a long-term commitment,' Nur Asyikin stresses. 'You need to research thoroughly, understand the species' needs, and be fully prepared for the journey ahead.'
