'Wild goose chase': Patterson accused of inventing Asian grocer
Prosecutors have accused Erin Patterson of fabricating a key detail in her defence, telling the Supreme Court of Victoria she lied about buying mushrooms from an Asian grocery store in a bid to cover up the alleged poisoning of her in-laws.
The Crown argues Patterson deliberately misled health authorities, doctors and police by claiming she purchased dried mushrooms from a shop in Melbourne's southeast, despite being unable to name the store or its location.
"You lied about the source of the death cap mushrooms because you knew you were guilty of deliberately poisoning your four [relatives]," Crown Prosecutor Dr Nanette Rogers SC said in court.
"Incorrect," Patterson replied.
Rogers told the court that Patterson had claimed to public health official Sally Ann Atkinson that she bought the mushrooms from a store somewhere in Oakleigh or Glen Waverley – areas she would be familiar with, having worked for the Monash Council. Yet, Patterson has never identified the store.
ADVERTISEMENT
"The Asian grocer story was a deliberate lie," Rogers alleged.
Patterson insisted she wasn't sure where the mushrooms came from, but was trying to help.
"I clarified... I think I made it clear at all times that I really wasn't sure, but I was trying to be helpful," she said.
Woman accused of killing three people with poisonous mushrooms in beef Wellington testifies in her defence. (Source: 1News)
She also told the court the mushrooms "smelled funny" when she first bought them, so she transferred them to a Tupperware container and later ran them through a food dehydrator – a detail Rogers suggested was "invented" to make the story sound more plausible.
"You described the packaging in this way because you wanted it to sound like they were not commercially [provided] mushrooms," Rogers said.
"That's incorrect," Patterson replied.
ADVERTISEMENT
In a tense back-and-forth, Patterson said she couldn't remember some of the details, including whether she herself accessed the iNaturalist website where sightings of death cap mushrooms had been logged in the months before the fatal lunch.
"Well, somebody did," she said, "and that somebody could've been me."
She also rejected allegations that she told doctors inconsistent things about where the mushrooms came from. When Rogers suggested she had changed her story about the mushrooms' weight and packaging to different officials, Patterson maintained: "It would have been me trying to clarify, not change."
The prosecution argued the story mattered because it prompted a full-scale investigation by health officials – one they say was needlessly complicated by Patterson's misleading and inconsistent accounts. Patterson's defence lawyer Colin Mandy SC told the jury in opening remarks that these were not calculated lies, but rather actions made in panic and fear, as Patterson worried about being blamed.
'You went to Loch to collect death caps'
Death cap mushrooms (file image). (Source: istock.com)
Prosecutors pointed to mobile phone data showing Patterson travelled to the town of Loch where death cap mushrooms had previously been spotted just hours before buying a food dehydrator.
ADVERTISEMENT
Dr Rogers alleged: "You went to Loch to collect death cap mushrooms. Within two hours, you bought a dehydrator."
Patterson replied: "The only part of that that is true is that I bought a dehydrator."
The court also heard further phone tower data allegedly placed Patterson in the Outtrim area on May 22, near a site where a well-known fungi expert had flagged death cap mushrooms on iNaturalist just one day earlier.
Patterson said she didn't go there deliberately: "I didn't go to Outtrim, to Neilson St, and I don't remember going to Outtrim as a destination."
Asked whether she may have passed through, she said: "That is possible, because you can pass through Outtrim on the way to Wonthaggi or Phillip Island."
Rogers also suggested Patterson had "blitzed" dehydrated death cap mushrooms into powder and used it in the beef Wellingtons, comparing the method to how she'd previously hidden powdered mushrooms in her children's meals.
Patterson rejected that claim, responding simply: "Disagree."
ADVERTISEMENT
Feeding leftovers to her children
Most recipes for the dish found online contain mushrooms. (Source: istock.com)
Patterson admitted serving her children leftovers from the same lunch, telling the court: "It was the same lunch, yes." But she insisted the mushrooms had been removed.
When asked why she proceeded with the meal after learning her in-laws were unwell, she said: "I didn't know or suspect that."
When prosecutors suggested she hesitated to take her children to hospital for assessment after the lunch, Patterson admitted she asked doctors if it was "really necessary" because they had no symptoms.
Rogers said it was not credible that, "if you thought, genuinely, that your children had eaten a potentially fatal poison... you'd be worried or stressed about pulling them out of school."
Patterson replied: "The issue was mushrooms and they had not eaten the mushrooms." When asked if she loved her children, she responded: "I still love them."
Patterson has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder and one of attempted murder, maintaining the fatal July 2023 lunch was a tragic accident.
The cross-examination of Erin Patterson in her triple murder trial continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
12 hours ago
- Scoop
New Zealand's Warning About Drugs In The Pacific
Article – RNZ The report said that the Pacific serves as both a cautionary tale and a direct source of risk for New Zealand. Kaya Selby As the threat of organised crime looms large over the Pacific, New Zealand is being warned that the region serves as both a cautionary tale and a direct source of risk. This is according to a report delivered to associate police minister Casey Costello by the Ministerial Advisory Group on Transnational, Serious and Organised Crime, a group she set up in February 2025. 'The discovery of multi-tonne methamphetamine shipments in Fiji and the arrest of high-ranking officials in Tonga underscore the scale of the problem,' the report stated. 'These developments are not isolated; they are part of a broader pattern of transnational criminal infiltration that increasingly implicates New Zealand, both as a destination and as a contributor through deportations and economic ties.' The state of things According to the United Nations the Pacific has traditionally been used as a corridor for drug shipments between two production and consumption hotspots – southeast Asia and Central America. Drugs are smuggled and transitted across the Pacific Ocean in massive quantities via planes, yachts and ships. But thanks to the involvement of police and customs officials in the islands, much of that product never reaches its destination. According to the Ministerial Advisory Group Report, it instead ends up on island streets – where the ease and prevalence of this drug supply has incensed an addiction-fuelled demand, which in turn fuels a greater supply, and so on. 'While there are variations between different Pacific nations, many share common forms of corruption, including bribery, nepotism, cronyism, and political corruption. 'Drug cartels from the Americas, organised crime groups from New Zealand and Australia, as well as Asian criminal networks are all increasing their involvement in the Pacific. Fiji, in particular, has emerged as a key transit point for major drug shipments.' In January 2024, authorities in Fiji seized almost five tonnes of methamphetamine in raids on two houses in Nadi, where upon a police officer tried to scoop up crystals from the scene. Less than a month later, in Tonga, a senior Reserve Bank official was arrested after police seized 15 kilograms of meth at their home and office. More recently, in January 2025, Samoan authorities intercepted 10 kilograms of meth, which the Samoan Observer described as 'the largest known drug smuggling operation' on the island. Minister Costello said that the government's response to the recommendations will be made in due course. 'While we maintain high standards and enjoy low corruption, we can't be naïve or complacent in this space.' Is Aotearoa doing enough? As far as New Zealand is concerned, the report said the country's obligation to assist the region goes beyond a moral one. '(There is) a very practical reason to do so, as the Pacific is a front door for the physical trade in illegal goods to New Zealand.' Associate Police Minister Casey Costello told RNZ it was important New Zealand supported its economic growth and viability. 'When people are poor then the amount of money you need to corrupt someone is relatively low.' Costello said that the solution lies in 'leaning in more' on current support measures. For her, that means strengthening customs services and excise duty collection from legitimate trade, and continuing existing support measures. Currently, that consists of the provision of drug-sniffing dogs and handlers, training Pacific personnel in Aotearoa, and intelligence capacity with staff members deployed in the islands. Police Commissioner Richard Chambers told RNZ Pacific in May that island police leaders had asked for more help from New Zealand, and that they were prepared to continue current levels of assistance. Minister Costello said she has been advised that the police will increase funding for staff deployment overseas, as well as support to the Pacific Islands Chiefs of Police. 'The revised amounts for the 2025/26 financial year will be reported as part of the 2025/26 supplementary estimates document.' University of Canterbury Associate Professor Jose Sousa-Santos said that the government isn't doing enough to engage with the Pacific on these issues. 'It's very much looking at the issues in the Pacific from a New Zealand-centric lens.' Pacific island nations want to be respected and trusted when they engage with the international community, and to build that means to build capacity for vetting government officials, Sousa-Santos said Right now, the world views developing nations in the Pacific with suspicion, he said. 'Currently, due to the lack of vetting security, intelligence cannot be shared and joint operations are minimal. That does not only take away the mana from Pacific neighbors, but it also compromises regional security.' 'Tsunami' of deportations expected to hurt With the United States ramping up deportations, Pacific islanders in the country are getting swept up, which the report acknowledged. 'American deportations are set to make the problem significantly worse,' it said. 'Recent initiatives focused on deportations are set to create a Pacific tsunami, with somewhere around 1,000 deportations set to occur, with 500 arriving in Fiji alone. 'The inflows of high-level criminality within small populations will always create problems, but these are exacerbated in the Pacific by cultural norms.' While exact numbers are not available yet, TVNZ reported in February that some 350 migrants from Fiji, 150 from Tonga and 57 people from Samoa, among others, have been earmarked for deportation. It was enough to draw Fiji's Prime Minister, Sitiveni Rabuka, to the US House of Representatives to raise concerns about the safety risk it poses to his country. Sean O'Niell, a senior State Department official for East Asian and Pacific affairs, told RNZ that the nations these deportees are destined for should not expect any help from the United States. 'With respect to aliens who are returning to their country of origin, as a general matter that's the responsibility of that country,' he said. 'The United States does continue to provide foreign assistance… much of that assistance might be geared towards addressing specific needs of an entire population, but I'm not aware of anything that's addressed to that now.' The report acknowledged that Pacific nations are nervous about whether they will be able to handle that influx, coupled with existing criminal deportations from Australia and New Zealand. Beyond a lack of ability to handle the population increase, Jose Sousa-Santos said that the return of criminals means the strengthening of criminal networks into the region. 'We are sending some who have been incarcerated for serious crimes. We've been able to create links to outlaw motorcycle gangs and drug importing syndicates who have been able to deal with the darker side of their community. 'When they get deported, they don't have the same support systems in place. They find it hard to reintegrate back into into the society and communities in their own countries.'
Scoop
15 hours ago
- Scoop
New Zealand's Warning About Drugs In The Pacific
As the threat of organised crime looms large over the Pacific, New Zealand is being warned that the region serves as both a cautionary tale and a direct source of risk. This is according to a report delivered to associate police minister Casey Costello by the Ministerial Advisory Group on Transnational, Serious and Organised Crime, a group she set up in February 2025. "The discovery of multi-tonne methamphetamine shipments in Fiji and the arrest of high-ranking officials in Tonga underscore the scale of the problem," the report stated. "These developments are not isolated; they are part of a broader pattern of transnational criminal infiltration that increasingly implicates New Zealand, both as a destination and as a contributor through deportations and economic ties." The state of things According to the United Nations the Pacific has traditionally been used as a corridor for drug shipments between two production and consumption hotspots - southeast Asia and Central America. Drugs are smuggled and transitted across the Pacific Ocean in massive quantities via planes, yachts and ships. But thanks to the involvement of police and customs officials in the islands, much of that product never reaches its destination. According to the Ministerial Advisory Group Report, it instead ends up on island streets - where the ease and prevalence of this drug supply has incensed an addiction-fuelled demand, which in turn fuels a greater supply, and so on. "While there are variations between different Pacific nations, many share common forms of corruption, including bribery, nepotism, cronyism, and political corruption. "Drug cartels from the Americas, organised crime groups from New Zealand and Australia, as well as Asian criminal networks are all increasing their involvement in the Pacific. Fiji, in particular, has emerged as a key transit point for major drug shipments." In January 2024, authorities in Fiji seized almost five tonnes of methamphetamine in raids on two houses in Nadi, where upon a police officer tried to scoop up crystals from the scene. Less than a month later, in Tonga, a senior Reserve Bank official was arrested after police seized 15 kilograms of meth at their home and office. More recently, in January 2025, Samoan authorities intercepted 10 kilograms of meth, which the Samoan Observer described as "the largest known drug smuggling operation" on the island. Minister Costello said that the government's response to the recommendations will be made in due course. "While we maintain high standards and enjoy low corruption, we can't be naïve or complacent in this space." Is Aotearoa doing enough? As far as New Zealand is concerned, the report said the country's obligation to assist the region goes beyond a moral one. "(There is) a very practical reason to do so, as the Pacific is a front door for the physical trade in illegal goods to New Zealand." Associate Police Minister Casey Costello told RNZ it was important New Zealand supported its economic growth and viability. "When people are poor then the amount of money you need to corrupt someone is relatively low." Costello said that the solution lies in "leaning in more" on current support measures. For her, that means strengthening customs services and excise duty collection from legitimate trade, and continuing existing support measures. Currently, that consists of the provision of drug-sniffing dogs and handlers, training Pacific personnel in Aotearoa, and intelligence capacity with staff members deployed in the islands. Police Commissioner Richard Chambers told RNZ Pacific in May that island police leaders had asked for more help from New Zealand, and that they were prepared to continue current levels of assistance. Minister Costello said she has been advised that the police will increase funding for staff deployment overseas, as well as support to the Pacific Islands Chiefs of Police. "The revised amounts for the 2025/26 financial year will be reported as part of the 2025/26 supplementary estimates document." University of Canterbury Associate Professor Jose Sousa-Santos said that the government isn't doing enough to engage with the Pacific on these issues. "It's very much looking at the issues in the Pacific from a New Zealand-centric lens." Pacific island nations want to be respected and trusted when they engage with the international community, and to build that means to build capacity for vetting government officials, Sousa-Santos said Right now, the world views developing nations in the Pacific with suspicion, he said. "Currently, due to the lack of vetting security, intelligence cannot be shared and joint operations are minimal. That does not only take away the mana from Pacific neighbors, but it also compromises regional security." "Tsunami" of deportations expected to hurt With the United States ramping up deportations, Pacific islanders in the country are getting swept up, which the report acknowledged. "American deportations are set to make the problem significantly worse," it said. "Recent initiatives focused on deportations are set to create a Pacific tsunami, with somewhere around 1,000 deportations set to occur, with 500 arriving in Fiji alone. "The inflows of high-level criminality within small populations will always create problems, but these are exacerbated in the Pacific by cultural norms." While exact numbers are not available yet, TVNZ reported in February that some 350 migrants from Fiji, 150 from Tonga and 57 people from Samoa, among others, have been earmarked for deportation. It was enough to draw Fiji's Prime Minister, Sitiveni Rabuka, to the US House of Representatives to raise concerns about the safety risk it poses to his country. Sean O'Niell, a senior State Department official for East Asian and Pacific affairs, told RNZ that the nations these deportees are destined for should not expect any help from the United States. "With respect to aliens who are returning to their country of origin, as a general matter that's the responsibility of that country," he said. "The United States does continue to provide foreign assistance... much of that assistance might be geared towards addressing specific needs of an entire population, but I'm not aware of anything that's addressed to that now." The report acknowledged that Pacific nations are nervous about whether they will be able to handle that influx, coupled with existing criminal deportations from Australia and New Zealand. Beyond a lack of ability to handle the population increase, Jose Sousa-Santos said that the return of criminals means the strengthening of criminal networks into the region. "We are sending some who have been incarcerated for serious crimes. We've been able to create links to outlaw motorcycle gangs and drug importing syndicates who have been able to deal with the darker side of their community. "When they get deported, they don't have the same support systems in place. They find it hard to reintegrate back into into the society and communities in their own countries."
1News
a day ago
- 1News
Sydney underworld figure offers cemetery as bail security
An underworld figure, desperate for release from prison, has wagered a multimillion-dollar cemetery as collateral, taking a judge by surprise. Omar Haouchar, 32, was arrested in January over an alleged conspiracy to murder a rival gang member outside the Day St police station in Sydney's city centre. His barrister told a Supreme Court bail hearing that a person close to Haouchar had put forward a cemetery as security to support his release application. "I've never seen a cemetery offered as security before," Justice Ian Harrison told the NSW Supreme Court today. The valuation of the cemetery was uncertain because, unlike its surrounding property, it was not available for subdivision, barrister Ertunc Ozen SC said. ADVERTISEMENT But it was estimated to be worth millions of dollars. Haouchar, who appeared in court via a video link from the Goulburn supermax remand centre, was previously denied bail in February. Since that time, Ozen said further documents had been tendered to the court by prosecutors, detailing evidence against his client. Associates of the Haouchar crime network allegedly used encrypted app Threema to discuss murdering 30-year-old Andre Kallita in December 2023. Prosecutors claimed that Haouchar was using the handle "Invisible" in an encrypted group chat titled "URGENT". The murder plot involved a lookout, waiting to see Kallita report to the police station for bail, alerting two shooters waiting close by, according to a police statement filed with the NSW Supreme Court. But Ozen said there was insufficient evidence to prove Haouchar was Invisible. ADVERTISEMENT "The Crown simply cannot tie Invisible to this applicant," he told the court. "This is the crux of the crown case, and without that attribution, the crown case fails." He also argued that since Haouchar's transfer to supermax, his ability to communicate with his legal team had been limited and this would result in delays to court proceedings. "The conditions of custody make it nearly impossible for him to prepare for this matter," Ozen said. Crown prosecutor Rebecca Stefani opposed bail, arguing Haouchar posed a risk of committing further offences and attempting to leave the state. She told the court he had spent 11 years in custody for a slew of offences. These included reckless wounding, aggravated burglary and directing the activities of a criminal group. The Haouchar syndicate, largely operated by leaders based in Lebanon, has been tied to AU$1.5 billion (NZ$1.6 billion) in cryptocurrency transactions and various firearm, drug, tobacco and money-laundering offences, police said previously. Justice Harrison will make his decision on the bail application after further submissions have been filed.
