Elise Sebastian's inquest: 'We were short-staffed', NHS boss says
A clinical director criticised staff shortages and NHS budgets at an inquest into the death of a teenager at a mental health unit.Elise Sebastian was 16 years old when she was found unresponsive in her bedroom at the St Aubyn Centre, Colchester, in April 2021.At the inquest, Brian O'Donnell, clinical lead at the centre, told the jury he had "constantly" raised concerns about staffing numbers with senior management."Our budget would always be overspent - my argument was that we were underfunded", Mr O'Donnell said.The Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust (EPUT), which runs the centre, said it should not have let her in the room unsupervised.
'Bad habits'
The inquest previously heard that Elise was supposed to receive one-to-one care, but an alert system - linked with her bedroom - was muted and she was left alone for 28 minutes.Mr O'Donnell, who was the ward manager at the time, told the jury how staff were being asked on occasions to check as many as 15 patients with less than a minute to speak to each one."Looking back, it's unbelievable that we used to do that", he told the jury, referring to it as a "tick-box exercise" where staff would look at a patient quickly and "move on".Mr O'Donnell said staff were meant to randomise the times they checked on patients but often did not do so, "pre-populating" the patient's observation sheet with timings."People had got into a bad habit of doing it over the years - it was a very bad ingrained piece of practice", Mr O'Donnell said.He added that he had written 56 letters to individual members of staff about not recording observations properly, but "no matter what I did, there always seemed to be gaps".He added that the practice continued "even to this day".The clinical director said on other occasions, the patients on the ward had not been checked for hours, which left him so concerned that he reported it to the Care Quality Commission on three occasions.
Mr O'Donnell said the over-reliance on using agency and bank staff to cover staff shortages was "a risky strategy", and added that patients would push the boundaries with them."If a young person is intent on harming themselves, they'll pick weaknesses in a team," he told the inquest."They'll ask staff for something they know they shouldn't have until they find someone who'll let them have [it], or take them somewhere they're not meant to go."He added: "Even the best agency or bank staff don't know the ward like we do."
'People in tears'
When asked by the area coroner, Sonia Hayes, about staffing levels, Mr O'Donnell said "the trust do look at the bare minimum that you need to cover observations - it really stretches staff"."I've seen huge pressure on people - I've seen people in tears before," he told the jury, adding there was "real concern about safety on the wards, and staff are too worried to say anything about it".
Elise died in hospital two days after being found in her bedroom at the centre.EPUT accepted its failures were "causative of [Elise's] death", and its lawyer, Pravin Fernando, said: "[It] failed in its responsibility by allowing her to enter her bedroom unsupervised."Elise's family attended the first day of her inquest and were participating in the ongoing Lampard public inquiry, which is investigating the deaths of more than 2,000 people under mental health services in Essex over 24 years.The Lampard Inquiry team will monitor Ms Sebastian's inquest, which is due to last for four weeks.
Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Inside London's wild fox ambulance service
Nicki Townsend rescues injured foxes in London, a city with an estimated 15,000 foxes adapting to urban life. The Fox Project, founded by Trevor Williams, rescues around 1,400 foxes annually, addressing myths and providing care. Urban foxes face dangers like cars and injuries, often requiring Townsend's intervention as part of their 'ambulance service'. Townsend deals with heartbreaking cases, including cubs with severe injuries, balancing the grim realities with the joy of successful releases. A study indicates released foxes may face challenges readjusting to their territory, highlighting a need for further research on their post-release survival. In London, the wild fox has its own ambulance service when it needs help
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Will Porton Down government science labs actually move?
A decision is finally expected on whether to move hundreds of government science jobs out of Wiltshire to Health Security Agency at Porton Down researches how to tackle the world's most infectious diseases, and prepare the UK for future the last 15 years plans have been worked up to relocate its 900 workers to new facilities in Harlow, but the estimated costs have spiralled - ministers expect a final decision in Wednesday's government spending MP covering Porton Down - Conservative John Glen - said: "It's taken 10 years to still be in doubt whether this should still happen and the costs have gone up six-fold." The National Audit Office reported the cost of the whole project is estimated to be £3.2bn, a figure more than 500% higher than the initial forecast of £530m. When it was officially announced in 2015 that the labs would move to Harlow, Essex, the MP there at the time said he was pleased and it would "bring thousands of jobs".Speaking to the BBC this week, Mr Glen said the new build would be "dressed up" as a world-class hub."But Porton Down already is world-class," he said."We've already got the world's best scientists doing amazing collaborative work." He added staff get paid to do work for other countries, including the US, and when unions asked workers there several years ago, most did not want to said: "There's an established pattern of activity there. We do need more investment but not the extent of building and refurbishing an unsuitable lab in Harlow."Scientific work has been going on at Porton Down for 100 years, but much the infrastructure is Mr Glen said there had been "additional investment" because of the Covid-19 pandemic, so the government needs to "be realistic"."This is an opportunity to save money, to reverse George Osborne's ambitious decision but still invest in science and an established rhythm of work," he said. No construction work has started at the Harlow site, which is being maintained by staff to keep it government said it had been considering options and whether building a new facility is still estimates if the Harlow centre is built, it will not open before 2036 - some 15 years behind Health Secretary Wes Streeting was asked about the possible move in March, he said: "[This] has been running around the system so long that it is now used in a case study for senior civil servant recruitment," he said."The worst decision is indecision."It has plagued us for too long and I hope we can soon report back to the house with a decision on that for everyone's benefit."
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Why milk, cheese (and even a smidgen of butter) is good for your health
Queue for a coffee in your local café and you'll hear a dizzying array of orders – oat flat whites, almond macchiatos, soya lattes. Increasingly rarely will anyone order a drink made with dairy, which has fallen so far out of fashion that in some circles it's become a dirty word. Since the 1970s, our consumption of cow's milk has halved – from an average of 140 litres per person per year to 70. Today, just under 35 per cent of British households buy plant-based alternatives, according to data firm Kantar, with annual sales of oat milk alone topping £275 million – up from £155 million five years ago. But while vegan alternatives are generally considered better for the environment than cow's milk, is giving up dairy good for our health? The latest research suggests not. A new study from the University of Reading has found that including dairy in your diet may help control blood sugar levels more effectively than a plant-only diet – and could help prevent diabetes. Participants were either vegetarians who included dairy in their diets, or vegans. Blood tests showed the dairy group had higher levels of acetyl carnitine – a compound that helps cells use fat for energy and reduces oxidative stress, the damage that can occur when blood sugar is too high. And this is far from the only benefit. 'Eating dairy is one of the easiest ways to get enough calcium,' says Dr Emily Leeming, a microbiome scientist at King's College London, dietitian and author of Genius Gut. Calcium is vital for bone health, muscle, nerve and heart function – and it's also strongly linked to protection against bowel cancer. The largest study to date on diet and bowel cancer found that people who ate more dairy tended to have a lower risk of developing the disease. 'An extra 300mg of calcium – found in a typical glass of milk – is associated with a 17 per cent lower risk of bowel cancer,' says Dr Leeming. Alongside calcium, 'dairy contains a high level of protein and other important nutrients including vitamin B12, iodine, phosphorus, potassium and riboflavin,' says Laura Southern, founder of London Food Therapy. So what type of dairy should we be going for – and how much? Skip to: Milk Cheese Yogurt Butter Milk can lower your risk of heart disease Many adults today claim to be lactose intolerant – a condition in which the body doesn't produce enough of the enzyme lactase to break down the sugar in cow's milk. It's believed to affect around 15–20 per cent of the population. Cow's milk protein allergy is common in babies – affecting around seven per cent of those under one – but most outgrow it, and in adults it's very rare. For most people, then, choosing a plant-based alternative is a lifestyle decision – but one that could have unintended health consequences. Our declining intake of cow's milk has led to a drop in iodine consumption – a trace mineral that's crucial for thyroid function. A 200ml glass of milk provides around 70mcg of iodine, half the adult recommended daily intake of 140mcg. 'Iodine is quite difficult to find in our diets, but it goes into cattle feed – which means it's in milk,' says Southern. 'We need iodine for our thyroid hormones. Thyroid disorders can cause low energy levels, poor metabolism, fertility problems and issues with foetal development during pregnancy.' Contrary to what many believe, milk isn't likely to make you gain weight or raise your cholesterol. Research from the University of Reading found that milk drinkers had lower cholesterol levels – and a 14 per cent lower risk of coronary heart disease. And semi-skimmed or skimmed options may not be the healthier choice. A 2024 study in the US revealed that drinking whole milk was associated with lower weight, BMI and obesity prevalence. Some plant-based drinks are fortified with calcium, vitamin B12 and iodine – others are not. Organic versions, which are the least processed, cannot legally be fortified. And while some fortified drinks contain added calcium, not all forms are equally well absorbed. The calcium in cow's milk is naturally occurring – and more readily used by the body. 'Cow's milk is a really good package of nutrients in an unprocessed bundle,' says Southern. Eat cheese to ward off dementia Cheese has long been vilified for its high levels of saturated fat and salt – but recent research suggests it offers far greater health benefits than previously assumed. In 2023, a review of dozens of studies by scientists in China and at Harvard University found that eating cheese – around 40g per day – was linked to a lower risk of heart disease, stroke and dementia. A possible explanation for its cardiovascular benefits may lie in its fermentation process, says Southern. 'The beneficial microbes break down the lactose – or milk sugar – and the proteins in cheese. Those are the elements that can have an inflammatory effect in the body,' she explains. 'What's left are the health-promoting components.' Bacteria in many cheeses – including Parmesan and cheddar – break down milk proteins into compounds similar to those found in blood pressure drugs known as ACE (angiotensin-converting-enzyme) inhibitors, potentially helping to prevent hypertension. Fermentation also produces vitamin K, which has been shown to slow the build-up of calcium deposits in the arteries and valves of the heart. Camembert and Edam contain the highest levels. A 2023 study of older adults in Japan found that eating cheese was associated with better cognitive function and lower rates of dementia. The cheese-eating group also had slightly lower BMIs and blood pressure – and walked faster. Hard cheeses are particularly rich in calcium. Parmesan contains 19 per cent of the recommended daily amount in just one 30g serving. Official guidance recommends no more than 30g of cheese a day. 'We don't want to eat too much because of its fat content, but I advise clients to measure two fingers' worth of hard cheese, chop it up and sprinkle it into a salad,' says Southern. 'That way you're getting the benefits, plus flavour, protein and satiety.' Vegan alternatives are another matter. 'They're mostly salt and fat and are very highly processed,' says Southern. 'Most varieties aren't health-enhancing – and cheese is notoriously difficult to replicate.' The benefits of the good bacteria in 'live' yoghurt for the gut microbiome are well established – making a daily portion one of the healthiest dairy choices around. 'I often advise clients to start their day with a couple of tablespoons of fermented or Greek yoghurt with seeds,' says Southern. 'It's very satiating, provides a high level of protein and helps keep blood sugar steady throughout the morning.' Several major studies have highlighted further health advantages. The most recent – published in Gut Microbes – showed that long-term consumption of two or more servings of yoghurt per week was linked to lower rates of one type of bowel cancer. Another study, based on data from 5,000 people, found that eating 40g of yoghurt daily lowered the risk of liver cancer by 5.4 per cent. Research from the Medical Research Council's epidemiology unit at the University of Cambridge also found that people who regularly ate natural, unsweetened yoghurt had a 28 per cent lower risk of developing type 2 diabetes than those who never consumed it. Still not convinced? A comprehensive 2023 meta-analysis published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, which examined data from almost 900,000 participants, found that higher yogurt intake was significantly associated with a lower risk of death from all causes – and from cardiovascular disease. Dairy-free alternatives generally contain far less calcium, protein and potassium – although some now include added probiotics to support gut health. Butter – stick to small amounts Who doesn't love a slice of hot toast slathered in melting butter? Delicious as it is, butter is high in saturated fat – so 'moderation is key,' says Southern. One analysis, which included data from more than 600,000 people, found that moderate butter consumption wasn't linked to a higher risk of heart disease – and may even offer slight protection against type 2 diabetes. But compared to other forms of dairy, its benefits are limited. 'New research has shown that it's not just the nutrients themselves that affect health – it's how they're packaged within a food, something called the food matrix,' says Dr Leeming. She points to a study comparing the matched nutrients in cheese and butter, which found that cheese lowered levels of 'bad' LDL cholesterol – while butter did not. 'It suggests the food matrix plays a role in how our bodies respond,' she says. A major study published earlier this year, involving more than 200,000 people followed over 30 years, found that those who consumed more plant-based oils – particularly olive, rapeseed and soya – had a 17 per cent lower risk of death than those who regularly ate butter. 'We don't need to be frightened of butter,' says Southern. 'Although plant-based spreads are now largely free from unhealthy trans fats, I'd still choose butter for toast or baking. But for cooking, a good quality oil is much better for us.'
