Palestinian NHS nurse takes legal action over rebuke for 'antisemitic' watermelon video call
Ahmad Baker's employers at Whipps Cross Hospital in London said the image of the fruit could be considered as antisemitic, The Guardian reported on Thursday.
According to the newspaper, Baker and two other employees said a ban on NHS employees displaying political or national symbols is discriminatory.
They said the Barts Health NHS trust, which administers the hospital, had expressed solidarity with Ukraine after its invasion by Russia.
"Being told that a still-life painting containing a watermelon could be perceived as antisemitic and being threatened with disciplinary action is deeply upsetting," Baker said.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
The watermelon has become a symbol of solidarity with the Palestinian cause, as it shares its colours with the Palestinian flag and is harder for social media algorithms to censor.
However, since the 7 October 2023 attacks by Palestinian fighters on southern Israel and the subsequent Israeli war on Gaza, there has been widespread censorship of Palestinian symbols within western institutions.
Such symbols are claimed to be antisemitic by supporters of Israel, an accusation dismissed by supporters of the Palestinian cause as an attempt to conflate criticism of Israel with hatred of Jewish people.
'Shut up and fall in line': Israel, Palestine and the dawn of a new censorship in western art Read More »
In October 2023, Middle East Eye reported that NHS staff were fearful of expressing solidarity with the Palestinian cause, even in their personal lives, because of potential repercussions from managers.
Medical workers said the threats of being referred to the General Medical Council, the government's Prevent anti-terrorism strategy, intimidation from the media and statements made by British politicians made them hesitant to speak up.
Many of those who spoke to MEE say the intimidation began when a social media account called @NHSWATCH1948 emerged and began urging people to report any healthcare workers who posted anything pro-Palestine.
Mohamed Amir, a Palestinian origin doctor working for the NHS, said he noticed a difference in the way staff were allowed to express views on the conflicts in Ukraine and Palestine.
"If you look at it relative to the Ukraine war, it makes you wonder why Palestine is seen as so controversial, because we've had fundraisers at the front of the hospital raising money for Ukraine, and our screensavers had a pro-Ukraine image," Amir said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
11 hours ago
- The National
Aid lorry overturns and kills 20 in Gaza as UN blames Israel for starving Palestinians
At least 20 people have been killed after an aid lorry overturned on a crowd of people in central Gaza – as condemnation of starvation caused by Israel's blockade grows. Footage posted by the Palestinian Wafa news agency showed dead and injured bodies after the lorry overturned near the Nuseirat refugee camp on Wednesday. It is the latest in a string of tragedies to affect aid seekers. Gaza's civil defence agency spokesperson, Mahmoud Bassal, told AFP that the lorry was driving on an unsafe road that Israel had previously bombed. Hamas has accused Israel of forcing lorry drivers to take dangerous routes to reach aid distribution centres and says it is aimed at 'engineering' starvation and chaos. Israel 'forces drivers to navigate routes overcrowded with starving civilians who have been waiting for weeks for the most basic necessities,' Hamas's media office said in a statement. Israel's government maintains it is not to blame for harrowing images of emaciated children in Gaza begging for food, or crying at some of the last remaining charity kitchens for a spoonful of beans. It says there are unused aid supplies in Gaza and accuses Hamas and the UN of preventing their delivery. But an Israeli blockade on the enclave has made the delivery of supplies almost impossible. The UAE and Jordan are among several countries carrying out airdrops of aid in an attempt to provide some humanitarian relief in the Gaza Strip, where warnings of a famine are on the rise. The Gaza Health Ministry said five more Palestinians have died of malnutrition and starvation in the past 24 hours. This brings the number of those who have died from hunger during the conflict to 193, including 96 children, the ministry added. Members of the UN Security Council have blamed Israel for starving Palestinians in Gaza after imposing a two-month blockade on all food and medical assistance and condemned reports that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu plans to reoccupy Gaza, calling them 'deeply alarming' if true. The UN comments were made at an emergency meeting called for by Israel, after seeing footage of their hostages emaciated. At the meeting, Algeria's Ambassador to the UN, Amar Bendjama, held a picture of a malnourished child towards Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar. UN assistant secretary general Miroslav Jenca told the Security Council that reoccupying the whole of Gaza 'would risk catastrophic consequences … and could further endanger the lives of the remaining hostages'. The comments came after Israeli media reported that Mr Netanyahu is now pushing for a complete takeover of the enclave. Before the UN Security Council met on Tuesday, US President Donald Trump said the US was focused on bringing food into the enclave. He was responding to a question about whether he would support Israel reoccupying all of Gaza. 'As far as the rest of it, I really can't say. That's going to be pretty much up to Israel,' he said, in comments that distance the US from Israel's military plans for Gaza. At the UN meeting, Mr Saar accused Russia and other council members, as well as the international media, of perpetuating 'so many lies' regarding the situation in Gaza – particularly on starvation. British Ambassador to the UN Barbara Woodward said the UK supported the release of hostages but said that their suffering and that of Palestinian civilians in Gaza had sunk to new depths. She blamed Israel for the situation, saying that it is Israel's aid restrictions that have led to a famine – as declared by the IPC hunger monitor last week. Ms Woodward said she spoke to doctors last week who had served in Gaza and had seen children so malnourished that 'their wounds festered for months without healing'. The doctors also saw baby formula confiscated by the Israeli military, she said. Acting US Ambassador Dorothy Shea reiterated Mr Trump's recognition of the 'real starvation' in Gaza. On the same day, Mr Trump said: 'Israel is going to help us with that in terms of distribution and also money. 'Arab states are also going to help us with that in terms of money and possibly distribution.' He stated his primary focus was feeding people in Gaza 'who are obviously not doing too well with the food.' When asked by reporters about Israeli plans to take over the entire enclave, he said it was 'pretty much going to be up to Israel'.
Middle East Eye
a day ago
- Middle East Eye
Israel kills 81 Palestinians since dawn on Tuesday
Gaza health officials said that 81 Palestinians have been killed by Israel since dawn on Tuesday. More than half - 57 - were seeking aid when they were shot by Israeli soldiers.
Middle East Eye
a day ago
- Middle East Eye
Majority of Palestinians are too weak from starvation to access aid, report says
Seventy percent of Palestinians in Gaza are experiencing extreme weakness from starvation, hindering their ability to access humanitarian aid, the Danish Refugee Council (DRC) said on Tuesday. "The physical exhaustion is so profound that many are unable to make the long journey on foot to distribution sites or carry heavy loads even if they receive assistance," said the organisation in a statement as it released the findings of a survey of Palestinians in Deir al-Balah, Khan Younis, Gaza City and North Gaza. "The survey exposes the life-threatening consequences of the American and Israeli-backed distribution scheme and the severe psychological toll on a population with no safe haven," the statement said. The organisation also said Palestinians trying to access the militarised-backed distribution scheme said they witnessed people, including family members, being deliberately targeted, shot, and killed by soldiers.
