Military asked to consider dismissing members after 1st offence of unwanted sexual touching
Defence Minister David McGuinty wants the military to review a trend in civilian court toward judges supporting workplaces firing Canadians for any unwanted sexual touching on the job — even if it happened once.
The Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) is launching new advisory panels this fall to discipline military members for sexually inappropriate behaviour.
The minister is supportive, his office said, of an external monitor's recent recommendation that if the military wants to modernize its conduct process, it could look at a clear pattern in civilian court over the past decade.
"Now, more than ever, any type of non-consensual touching of a sexual nature within the context of one's employment is likely to lead to dismissal, even for a single event and even if there are mitigating factors," external monitor Jocelyne Therrien wrote in her June report.
Victims and experts have long raised concerns that the military has moved members involved in cases like groping to other units, given them warnings or other remedial measures. Therrien wrote that gone are the days where that's a "viable solution" and it could expose the victim or other staff to risk.
The government hired Therrien to track the military's progress implementing changes to try and reform its handling of sexual misconduct.
Retired Supreme Court justice Louise Arbour's landmark 2022 report made sweeping recommendations after a series of senior military leaders were removed from prominent roles amid allegations, causing a damaging and high-profile crisis.
Therrien estimates the military is on track to meet "the intent" of Arbour's recommendations by the end of the year. But she flags one of the biggest challenges for military is that files related to misconduct are scattered across different databases which makes it difficult to get a clearer picture of the current state of the issue.
WATCH | Can the military change how it handles sexual misconduct?:
Is the military capable of changing how it handles sexual misconduct?
3 years ago
Therrien's latest report said case law has "rapidly" and "significantly" evolved over the past 10 years.
"In reviewing these judgments, I note a clear trend towards supporting dismissal for any sexual touching in the workplace," she wrote.
More civilian judges are using the logic that sexual harassment involving unwanted touching is "unequivocally" considered sexual assault which is a criminal offence in Canada, she wrote.
Changes to the Canadian Labour Code in 2021 also require federally regulated workplaces to ensure they are harassment-free. Not dismissing people in some cases can lead to liability claims, wrote Therrien.
"The fact that similar cases in the past were dealt with through administrative measures other than dismissal no longer carries any weight," Therrien said.
The minister's office says McGuinty supports Therrien's recommendation that "the significant evolution in workplace harassment case law should be considered as the CAF continues modernization."
McGuinty's office told CBC News the minister will be looking for the upcoming panels "to yield real results." They will include law and sexual misconduct experts, the office said.
Therrien's report also said the military is considering launching a "scale of severity" to help determine if members should be kicked out or otherwise reprimanded.
People moved around
Megan MacKenzie, a professor at Simon Fraser University who specializes in military culture, says the CAF should adopt a one-strike-you're-out policy for unwanted sexual touching.
"This is a really significant recommendation," said MacKenzie.
"There is just no ambiguity for anyone in any workplace at this point in time that inappropriate touching, touching of a sexual nature, is not OK."
In the past, these kinds of cases were often called "low-level harassing behaviours" and the military dealt with it internally including by shuffling people around as a temporary solution, she said.
"That doesn't solve the problem," she said. "It moves the problem to a different unit and the alleged victim and the accuser may still have interactions with each other."
The CAF has been grappling with sexual misconduct for decades while saying it has a "zero-tolerance policy," she said.
MacKenzie said kicking out people for unwanted touching would demonstrate that policy.
Supporting victims
Retired master corporal Sherry Bordage, who reported being groped by her superior, said it's time for the military to act.
"Why allow predators to continue to hide within the ranks? What possible good could that serve?" she said.
Bordage reported her platoon commander touched her breast and made inappropriate comments at a mess dinner in 2010 at CFB Borden.
In military court, a Canadian Armed Forces judge stayed proceedings for the criminal sexual assault charge against Master Warrant Officer D.J. Prosser, according to the court martial documents.
Prosser pleaded guilty to a lesser military service offence for ill treatment of a subordinate, the records show.
Military judge Lt.-Col. Louis-Vincent d'Auteuil noted he took into consideration several mitigating factors, including that it was "an isolated incident" and "unusual" for Prosser who had spent 30 years serving in the military at that time, his reason for sentencing said.
The military judge gave Prosser a reprimand and a $1,500 fine — and allowed him to continue serving.
Bordage said she left the forces in 2014 because she didn't feel safe and faced reprisals from her chain of command for reporting the incident.
She says the military should kick out members for unwanted sexual touching to keep others safe.
"This decision, had it been implemented during my time, would have been night and day," said Bordage.
The CAF has not yet responded to a CBC News request for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
3 minutes ago
- CTV News
One dead, two others injured after apartment fire in Toronto's east end
Toronto police and fire crews responding to a fire inside an apartment along Gerrard Street East on Sunday July 20, 2025 (CP24 photo). Toronto fire officials say one person has died and two others were rushed to hospital following a fire inside a five-storey apartment building near Gerrard Street East and Glenside Avenue. Toronto police say crews responded shortly after midnight early Sunday morning to reports of a fire. Fire officials tell CP24 that their crews were met with 'heavy smoke' on the fourth floor of the building, adding that one person was pronounced dead. Toronto paramedics say a man in his 60s was transported to hospital in critical condition, while a woman in her 70s was taken to hospital in serious, life-threatening condition. A third patient was transported with minor injuries. The cause of the fire remains unknown but is under investigation. Gerrard Street East remains closed at Greenwood Avenue. Police are asking drivers to use 'alternate routes.'
CBC
3 minutes ago
- CBC
Pharmacist suspended, fined after leaving unlabelled drugs at fast-food restaurant for patient
A Winnipeg pharmacist who left unlabelled prescription drugs in an unmarked bag for pickup with an employee at a fast-food restaurant has been disciplined for professional misconduct. One of the medications was in the narcotic category, according to a decision recently released by the College of Pharmacists of Manitoba. An investigator with the regulatory body for pharmacists found the case revealed issues with narcotic accountability and with dispensing frequent and high doses of opioids. The case goes back to 2019, when the college received a police report about the pharmacist leaving the unlabelled drugs at a Dairy Queen restaurant. The pharmacist had been contacted by a patient who had pain and fever following dental surgery, says the decision by a College of Pharmacists discipline committee. A nurse practitioner had prescribed the patient naproxen (an anti-inflammatory sold under brand names like Aleve), clindamycin (an antibiotic) and Tylenol No. 3 with codeine, which is classified as a narcotic, the decision says. The prescription was faxed to the pharmacy, which was closed at the time, but the pharmacist drove there and prepared medications for the patient. The pharmacist took the unlabelled drugs in an unmarked bag to a nearby Dairy Queen and handed it to "a young employee" of the restaurant, the decision says. "She did not confirm the name of the DQ staff member nor did she make any attempt to confirm that the staff member was familiar with [the] patient," according to the decision. The pharmacist then sent a text to someone — whose name is redacted in the report — saying "meds done and delivered." It's not clear from the decision why the pharmacist took the medications to the restaurant, as opposed to another location. Escorted back to pharmacy by police A person, whose name is redacted, arrived to pick up the prescription, but the Dairy Queen owners refused to release the medications, the decision says. Police were then contacted and arrived at the restaurant. The pharmacist also returned there, after which police escorted her back to the pharmacy. She attached prescription labels to the medication bottles, which police then delivered, the decision says. It says the panel found the pharmacist's actions contravened the requirement under Canada's Narcotic Control Regulations to ensure that all drugs "are secured against theft, loss or diversion." The regulations also require that if a drug is a narcotic, the packaging must have a warning sticker, and the patient must be given an information handout specific to the narcotic being sold, the decision says. After the incident, the pharmacist voluntarily surrendered her licence to practise and resigned as manager of the pharmacy. Her licence was reinstated by the college's complaints committee in September 2020. However, the decision says the pharmacist was "found to be practising as a pharmacist in the dispensary at the pharmacy" while her licence was voluntarily surrendered. That resulted in an additional disciplinary charge. A hearing into disciplinary charges against the pharmacist was held in December 2023, where she entered guilty pleas to multiple counts under the Pharmaceutical Act. The complaints committee entered a stay for some of the counts. The pharmacist was ordered to pay $150,000 in penalties, including a fine of $20,000 and $130,000 toward the costs of the investigation and hearing. She was given a one-year suspension from practice, but was given credit for 10 months of the time during which she had voluntarily surrendered her licence. Sorry for mistake: pharmacist The discipline panel issued its decision in March 2024, but the pharmacist then filed an appeal at the Manitoba Court of Appeal. The appeal was discontinued in April 2025, and the regulatory body published the case on its website a few weeks later. Neely Hammerberg, a communications co-ordinator for the pharmacists' college, said in a statement to CBC the discipline panel issued an order "to publish and make available to the public the decision, which serves to protect the public and uphold transparency and trust in the pharmacy profession." CBC also contacted the pharmacist after the decision was released. "I'm sorry for making the mistake," she said, adding that she's working with the college on the guidelines she's been given. "All I wanted was what is best for my patient," she said. "My patients are still my priority, and their care is still my priority, and I'll continue working towards fixing my practices." In addition to the Dairy Queen incident, the college's investigation also found the pharmacy where the pharmacist worked had a counselling room for patients, which was described as having prescription files stacked nearly to the ceiling. Using that room for patient consultations "put the confidentiality of patient information at risk," because the labels of prescription bags contained confidential health information, the decision said. The counselling room also had a large narcotic safe, which was left unlocked and open, according to the decision. Anyone coming in through the building's back door "had a view of the interior of the narcotic safe, with nothing to stop them from accessing narcotic storage," it says. The investigation also found that the pharmacy didn't keep accurate counts of drugs in its inventory of narcotic and controlled substances. Narcotic counts completed at the pharmacy "revealed that there were significant unexplained drug shortages," the decision says. It also says the pharmacy dispensed a lot of opioid prescriptions for many patients, with some at very high doses. The pharmacist had no documentation to show she had been working with prescribers to lower patients' high doses of opioids, and admitted she didn't meet her professional obligations on that, the decision says. The March 2024 decision notes the pharmacist had previously been disciplined, while practising as a pharmacist in British Columbia. In 2012, the College of Pharmacists of British Columbia found she had prepared "a fraudulent employment document under the letterhead and purported signature of her current employer," which she then submitted to a prospective employer. She was given a 30-day licence suspension and fined $3,000.
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Trade top of mind as Canada's premiers are set to hold three-day meeting in Ontario
TORONTO – Tariffs and trade are top of the agenda as the country's premiers arrive in Ontario's cottage country for a three-day meeting that comes at a pivotal time for both Canada-U.S. and domestic relations. The premiers' summer gathering in Muskoka will also feature a Tuesday meeting with Prime Minister Mark Carney, as trade talks with the United States are expected to intensify. Most of what the premiers are likely to discuss stems from U.S. President Donald Trump's tariffs: trade negotiations, the direct impact on industries such as steel and aluminum, the increased pushes to remove interprovincial trade barriers and speed up major infrastructure and natural resource projects to counteract the effects of tariffs, as well as Indigenous communities' concerns about them. Day 1 of the premiers' meeting involves discussions with Indigenous leaders including the Assembly of First Nations, the Métis National Council and the Native Women's Association of Canada. Carney himself is fresh off a meeting with hundreds of First Nations chiefs, many of whom have expressed concerns about their rights being sidelined as the prime minister looks to accelerate projects in the 'national interest.' Some of the top priorities premiers are pushing include pipelines and mining in Ontario's Ring of Fire region, and chiefs have said that must not happen by governments skirting their duty to consult. Ontario Premier Doug Ford, who has served for the past year as head of the Council of the Federation, is host of the meeting and said in a statement that protecting national interests will be top of mind. 'This meeting will be an opportunity to work together on how to respond to President Trump's latest threat and how we can unleash the full potential of Canada's economy,' Ford wrote. Trump and Carney agreed in June at the G7 summit to try and reach a trade deal by July 21 but Trump recently moved that deadline to Aug. 1, while telling Carney he intends to impose 35 per cent across-the-board tariffs on Canada that same day. Carney has said Canada is trying to get an agreement on softwood lumber exports included in the negotiations with the United States. British Columbia Premier David Eby said he intends to raise the issue and others of particular importance to B.C. at the meeting. '(We want to) get access to the same level of attention, for example, on the softwood lumber as Ontario gets on the auto parts sector, (and) that we get the same amount of attention on capital projects as Alberta is currently getting in relation to their proposals,' Eby said last week in Victoria. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has been making a big push for new pipelines, but said during a press conference Friday that her focus would also be on premiers working together to address the tariff threat, including interprovincial trade. 'I was really pleased to sign (a memorandum of understanding) with Doug Ford during the time he was here in during Stampede, and other provinces are working on those same kind of collaborative agreements,' she said. 'We need to do more to trade with each other, and I hope that that's the spirit of the discussion.' Smith and Ford signed an MOU earlier this month to study new pipelines and rail lines between provinces, and both premiers also talked about wanting Carney to repeal a number of energy regulations like net-zero targets, the West Coast tanker ban and a proposed emissions cap. Ford has also taken a lead role on increasing interprovincial trade, signing MOUs with several provinces and enacting a law to remove all of Ontario's exceptions to free trade between the provinces and territories. Nova Scotia's Tim Houston is another premier banging the drum of interprovincial trade, saying the trade war is forcing action on it. 'We're seeing the benefit of working together to respond to economic threats from the U.S. by breaking down internal trade barriers and opportunities to expand in other international markets,' he wrote in a statement. Ford has said the premiers will also talk about emergency management, energy security, sovereignty and national security, health, and public safety. The premiers have also been pushing the federal government to reform bail laws and Carney said last week that legislation will be introduced in the fall and he expects to discuss the issue with the premiers on Tuesday. The premiers' summer meeting also signals a changing of the guard, with the role of chair of Council of the Federation moving between provinces annually. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. But after Ford is no longer chair, he's not expected to take too much of a back seat on all of the aforementioned issues. He is still premier of the most populous province, has built a strong relationship with Carney, often singing the prime minister's praises, and has done frequent American TV interviews making the case for increased trade over tariffs. Those network appearances, in part, earned him a nickname of 'Captain Canada' — a persona he used to massive political benefit. Ford made the fight against tariffs and Trump the central part of his re-election campaign and voters returned him to government with a third consecutive majority. — With files from Wolfgang Depner in Victoria, Keith Doucette in Halifax and Lisa Johnson in Edmonton This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 20, 2025.
