Public opinion is now toxic, warns former minister for health
Northern Ireland
must wait 11 times longer than people in the Republic for urgent operations, yet the
HSE
gets no credit, a former minister for health has said.
Stephen Donnelly
said waiting lists in the Republic have fallen by 60 per cent over the last three years, yet few in the public know anything about it, or want to know anything about it.
'It is improving rapidly. They're doing incredible work. It's not all the way there, but it's moving really quickly,' the former minister told the Patrick MacGill Summer School in Glenties, Co Donegal.
'It's hard to find another country in Europe that has achieved anything like that. Emergency department pressures are falling. Women's healthcare is being transformed. There's a lot of really good things happening now,' he said.
READ MORE
'Don't get me wrong. Not for a moment am I suggesting that it's fixed, or that everything is right. It's not. I know it's not. But it's moving in the right direction so quickly that we are on track to have achieved universal healthcare within the next five years.'
Despite the improvements, the public narrative about the Republic's health system is 'a black hole', said Mr Donnelly, who served as served as health minister from June 2020 to January 2025.
'Contrary to the national view on this, we have a public health service that is improving at an extraordinary rate,' he said.
The negativity surrounding public attitudes towards the health service is typical of the attitudes towards nearly every other element of Irish public life, which is increasingly corrosive and destructive, said Mr Donnelly, who lost the seat he held for Fianna Fáil in Wicklow at the last general election.
'If we are to be serious about navigating what is an increasingly fractured and turbulent world, we're going to have to have a different conversation about who we are. We need to balance the conversation,' he told the summer school.
[
Warning labels on alcohol an idea from 'different time', Minister warned Cabinet colleague
Opens in new window
]
'It's not that we shouldn't shine a light on the challenges that exist. Of course we should, we do and we must always do that, but we've got to start bringing some balance.'
Six months after he stepped down as minister for health, Mr Donnelly said: 'What strikes me is that the political debate has become harsher and harsher. You would be forgiven if you were watching a lot of TV for believing we live in a failed state.
'And we really, really don't.
Social media
has just gone completely off the reservation. Fourteen years ago when I was first in politics, it was fairly all right. People used it to put out their ideas and have chats. Now, it's just poison.
'There's lies and misinformation and hatred and racism and poison, and ... but it is being consumed all the time,' said Mr Donnelly, who was a Social Democrat TD before he joined Fianna Fáil.
Social media would have us believe that Ireland is in 'a state of perpetual crisis', he said. 'That the doctors and the nurses are all leaving. The teachers are all leaving. The young people are all leaving, or the Government is uncaring, incompetent and corrupt.'
[
Brother of Veronica Guerin criticises Catherine Connolly over nomination of Gemma O'Doherty for 2018 election
Opens in new window
]
Foreign friends who have visited Ireland say they have heard nothing but complaints when they have travelled around the country for a week, he said. 'You meet them, and they just say, 'What is wrong with you people?''
Ireland does face some 'immense, some deadly serious challenges', but so does every other country, he said. 'The level of negativity that we see here is not normal. It does feel like there is something particular going on in Ireland at the moment.'
Ireland is 'incredibly well placed' to become a world leader in the use of artificial intelligence in healthcare, he said. 'There's a wave of innovation coming. Some of it's already here.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
13 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Former Health Minister Stephen Donnelly believes public must become comfortable with use of AI in health service
Stephen Donnelly, who was Minister of Health and is a Health Consultant, was speaking during a panel discussion at the MacGill Summer School in Glenties, Co Donegal. During the discussion on 'Taboo Ideas to Transform Ireland?', Mr Donnelly said he believed Ireland could be a global leader in AI related health care. He said for the country to succeed in the field, the public would have to become comfortable sharing their data with AI platforms and algorithms. The host of the panel, Jess Majekodunmi, Design Historian & Innovation Researcher said there is a lot of anxiety and concerns about the use of AI and she questioned if the use of AI is already creeping into the health service. Mr Donnelly said the use of AI and algorithms is increasing and already present in the health service. 'In more and more GP services now, we may not know it, but there is an algorithm listening to the entire conversation, categorising what we say and when we leave, it is saying, Stephen referenced these four things, you never checked them. 'In more hospitals in Ireland now, there is a machine beside the bed and the patient is wired up to it and it is monitoring all sorts of stuff at a level of complexity that doctors and nurses will struggle to maintain consistently and flagging saying this person is going to crash in half an hour, you need to intervene. 'AI is coming in to help clinicians anyway. 'If you go into your hospital today or your GP, there is a decent chance it will already be involved in some way,' said Mr Donnelly. However, Mr Donnelly said all advances must link back to a human being and there must be transparency for it to be a success. 'Within healthcare there has to be accountability. ADVERTISEMENT 'There has to be security of data, and we probably need to have a complex conversation by being very respectful of people's anxieties, very respectful of the fact it is new and people are trying to get their head around it,' said Mr Donnelly. When asked by Ms Majekodunmi about his predictions for the timescale of the developments, Mr Donnelly said it is moving so quickly it is difficult to say. 'I would be very surprised if healthcare does not look quite different 10 years from now,' said he said. However, he said in order for the development to be introduced on a wider scale, people must get more comfortable with the use of AI. 'Most of us would have to be comfortable sharing our data and I mean data right down to the genetic level. 'In order for these things to work you have to have a big pool of data and it is much better if it is national data rather than international data. 'If we could get our heads around becoming comfortable with AI and the idea that this is a public good and our data is a public good with the right protections around it, we could become one of the handful of countries in the world that does something truly mind blowing and extraordinary and flips our entire concept of what a public health service is, into one that keeps us well. 'It is very important to me anyway that it is a public service. It cannot be something that only wealthy people can afford.' Mr Donnelly. He said the introduction of AI and new technologies would see a major move towards preventative healthcare. Mr Donnelly used the example of who fells unwell and visits their GP who carries out a number of tests. The patient is then diagnosed with Type Two Diabetes. However, with the new technology, the patient would get an alert notifying the patient of changes in their cells which if left untreated, could result in Type 2 Diabetes in five years. 'All over the world, the health service says if you get sick, we will fix you. 'There is a wave off innovation coming. 'AI is the glue that holds a lot of it together, but it is geo typing, robotics, genetics, bio printing, printing replacement organs in hospitals rather than having to use donors. 'There is a vast wave coming. 'The entire purpose of a health service shifts from one that tries to fix you when you get sick to one that keeps you well for as long as possible. 'And then inevitably, if something bad happens, can fix you,' said Mr Donnelly. Mr Donnelly said he believes Ireland is 'incredibly placed' to be a world leader in innovative healthcare. 'I would love to see us make a stand on this and say look we have a healthcare service that is getting better at an incredible rate. 'We are rolling out a new health strategy, so we are going to have the digital infrastructure in place soon enough. 'We have a pharma hub, a health tech hub, a digital hub so we have brains to burn around the country in terms of some of the things that can happen. 'We have a very attractive country for these things. 'It is big enough that you can really roll these things out but small and integrated enough that you can get your head around doing it at the population level,' said Mr Donnelly.
Irish Independent
17 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Boil water noticed in Cork affecting almost 4,700 customers
Corkman A boil water notice has been issued in Macroom following a combination of elevated levels of turbidity and operational issues at the treatment plant. Approximately 4,697 customers are impacted by the notice. Following a consultation with the Health Service Executive (HSE), Uisce Éireann issued the notice to protect the health of residents, and they said works to lift the notice is their priority. Brian O'Leary, Uisce Éireann Regional Operations Manager, said: 'We acknowledge the frustration felt by the local community and the significant inconvenience that customers on this supply have experienced in recent years and would like to reassure those impacted that we are working as quickly and efficiently as possible to complete these vital upgrade works.' Uisce Éireann added that the presence of turbidity in the incoming raw water is largely influenced by seasonal changes in Irish weather and given the limitations of the existing water treatment plant and pump station. Vulnerable customers who have registered with Uisce Éireann receive direct communication on Boil Water Notices. Customers are reminded that the water is safe to consume once boiled. Water must be boiled for: drinking; brushing teeth; drinks made with water; during the preparation of foods as well as making ice. Affected customers can use the water for personal hygiene except brushing teeth. Customers can check if their property is included by visiting and entering the property's Eircode or by calling the Uisce Éireann customer care helpline, open 24/7, on 1800 278 278. Great care should be taken with boiled water to avoid burns and scalds as accidents can easily happen, especially with children. Updates will be made available via on X (formerly Twitter) and the customer care helpline on 1800 278 278.
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Public opinion is now toxic, warns former minister for health
People in Northern Ireland must wait 11 times longer than people in the Republic for urgent operations, yet the HSE gets no credit, a former minister for health has said. Stephen Donnelly said waiting lists in the Republic have fallen by 60 per cent over the last three years, yet few in the public know anything about it, or want to know anything about it. 'It is improving rapidly. They're doing incredible work. It's not all the way there, but it's moving really quickly,' the former minister told the Patrick MacGill Summer School in Glenties, Co Donegal. 'It's hard to find another country in Europe that has achieved anything like that. Emergency department pressures are falling. Women's healthcare is being transformed. There's a lot of really good things happening now,' he said. READ MORE 'Don't get me wrong. Not for a moment am I suggesting that it's fixed, or that everything is right. It's not. I know it's not. But it's moving in the right direction so quickly that we are on track to have achieved universal healthcare within the next five years.' Despite the improvements, the public narrative about the Republic's health system is 'a black hole', said Mr Donnelly, who served as served as health minister from June 2020 to January 2025. 'Contrary to the national view on this, we have a public health service that is improving at an extraordinary rate,' he said. The negativity surrounding public attitudes towards the health service is typical of the attitudes towards nearly every other element of Irish public life, which is increasingly corrosive and destructive, said Mr Donnelly, who lost the seat he held for Fianna Fáil in Wicklow at the last general election. 'If we are to be serious about navigating what is an increasingly fractured and turbulent world, we're going to have to have a different conversation about who we are. We need to balance the conversation,' he told the summer school. [ Warning labels on alcohol an idea from 'different time', Minister warned Cabinet colleague Opens in new window ] 'It's not that we shouldn't shine a light on the challenges that exist. Of course we should, we do and we must always do that, but we've got to start bringing some balance.' Six months after he stepped down as minister for health, Mr Donnelly said: 'What strikes me is that the political debate has become harsher and harsher. You would be forgiven if you were watching a lot of TV for believing we live in a failed state. 'And we really, really don't. Social media has just gone completely off the reservation. Fourteen years ago when I was first in politics, it was fairly all right. People used it to put out their ideas and have chats. Now, it's just poison. 'There's lies and misinformation and hatred and racism and poison, and ... but it is being consumed all the time,' said Mr Donnelly, who was a Social Democrat TD before he joined Fianna Fáil. Social media would have us believe that Ireland is in 'a state of perpetual crisis', he said. 'That the doctors and the nurses are all leaving. The teachers are all leaving. The young people are all leaving, or the Government is uncaring, incompetent and corrupt.' [ Brother of Veronica Guerin criticises Catherine Connolly over nomination of Gemma O'Doherty for 2018 election Opens in new window ] Foreign friends who have visited Ireland say they have heard nothing but complaints when they have travelled around the country for a week, he said. 'You meet them, and they just say, 'What is wrong with you people?'' Ireland does face some 'immense, some deadly serious challenges', but so does every other country, he said. 'The level of negativity that we see here is not normal. It does feel like there is something particular going on in Ireland at the moment.' Ireland is 'incredibly well placed' to become a world leader in the use of artificial intelligence in healthcare, he said. 'There's a wave of innovation coming. Some of it's already here.'
