Hong Kong retailers under strain as changing trends drive store closures
HONG KONG: Hong Kong's retailers are battling against shifting consumer habits, as visitors spend less and locals head across the border to China for cheaper dining and shopping, leading to a wave of store closures.
A 36-year-old Chinese seafood restaurant chain and a popular high-end food court in the bustling Causeway Bay district closed this week.
Other recent closures in the financial hub include cinema chains, a major catering group, a 41-year-old bakery and a three-decade-old congee chain.
Weak domestic spending and cheaper prices in Shenzhen, bordering Hong Kong, have compounded retailers' woes, according to industry figures and analysts.
Furthermore, China's economic slowdown, US-China geopolitical tensions and a national security clampdown have also weighed on business sentiment and hurt Hong Kong's small and open economy.
The city's GDP is forecast to grow between 2%-3% this year, compared with 2.5% last year and 3.2% in 2023.
"The change in consumption patterns is irreversible," said Annie Yau Tse, chairwoman of Hong Kong's Retail Management Association.
Hong Kong was once a prime destination for high-spending mainland visitors but mass anti-government protests in 2019 and Covid restrictions led to a decline in its appeal.
The authorities have launched initiatives to revive tourism, including hosting large-scale events such as Coldplay concerts and a Manchester United exhibition match at a new harbourside stadium.
While visitors are returning to near 2018 levels with May arrivals up 20% to 4.08 million visitors versus 4.95 million in 2018, spending remains soft.
Retail sales by value rose 2.4% in May from a year earlier to HK$31.3 billion (US$4 billion), the first rise in 14 months, government data showed on Wednesday. However, it remains only around 77% of the HK$40.5 billion in May 2018.
"We are trying hard to think of ways to turn the traffic into business," Yau Tse said.
Jack Tong, director of Savills Research & Consultancy, said the recent string of closures was due to a "structural shift in the local retail market" starting from 2023.
It is "no longer strong enough to support such retail trades and would be beyond repair even by further reducing rents."
Overall prime street rents in the first quarter have fallen back to 2003 levels, he said.
"The rise in local outbound travel in Hong Kong and changes in mainland tourists' spending patterns and preferences in Hong Kong and Macau continued to weigh on the overall retail sector during the financial year," jeweller Chow Tai Fook said.
Last month, Cafe de Coral reported a 29.6% drop in net profit for the 2024/25 year ended in March, citing a weak economy and consumer sentiment.
Despite the tough conditions, some signs of recovery are emerging.
Vipul Sutariya, who attended the jewellery fair in June, said Chinese dealers were back at the fair "not to buy immediately but to ask, which is the biggest change in the past 1.5 years," he said. "In my view that's a good sign." - Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Indonesia says it will sign US$34bil pact with US partners ahead of tariff talks deadline
Indonesia's Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs Airlangga Hartarto said the MoU is due to be signed on July 7, 2025. - Photo: Reuters JAKARTA: Indonesia will sign a pact worth US$34 billion with business partners next week to boost purchases from the United States, as part of efforts to strike a trade deal with Washington ahead of the July 9 deadline, Indonesia's chief economic minister said on Thursday (July 3). The deal would include increasing imports of fuels and investment by Indonesian companies in energy and agriculture sectors in the United States. Separately, flag carrier Garuda Indonesia also said it is in talks to buy up to 75 jets from Boeing. Jakarta is facing a 32% tariff in US markets and has previously offered to increase US imports to facilitate trade talks between the two sides. Indonesia enjoyed a goods trade surplus of $17.9 billion with the United States in 2024, according to the U.S. Trade Representative. Speaking to journalists, Minister Airlangga Hartarto said the memorandum of understanding due to be signed on July 7 will deploy the $34 billion for new Indonesian investments and purchases in the United States. "This shows that government, regulators, state-owned enterprises and the private sector are together in responding to the imposition of US reciprocal tariffs," Airlangga said. He said that by addressing the trade balance with the United States, Indonesia hoped to get a better trade deal than the one struck with Vietnam. The United States announced on Wednesday that it will place a lower-than-promised 20% tariff on many Vietnamese exports, down from the original 46% announced by President Donald Trump in April. Meanwhile, Garuda's potential jet purchase may include 737 Max 8 and 787 jets, its chief executive Wamildan Tsani told reporters after meeting Airlangga. It was unclear whether Garuda's discussion with Boeing is part of the tariff negotiations. The airline is struggling to recover from the impact of the pandemic. It secured a $405 million loan from sovereign wealth fund Danantara Indonesia in June for maintenance, repair and overhaul of its fleet. - Reuters
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Subsidy reform must be done gradually with inclusion as core principle: Expert
KUALA LUMPUR: Subsidy reform is often considered a necessity, especially as governments grapple with fiscal constraints. however, the way subsidies are targeted can have serious implications for the poor. Dr Muhammed Abdul Khalid, research fellow at Institute of Malaysian and International Studies (Ikmas), Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia. said targeted subsidies frequently fail to reach the most vulnerable segments of society. Citing global examples, Muhammed highlighted Brazil's experience, where targeted median subsidies excluded a significant portion of the bottom 20–30% of the population. Similarly, he said, the Philippines cash transfer programme, one of the largest of its kind, also failed to include many in the lowest income bracket. 'Even in Malaysia, studies conducted before and during the Covid-19 pandemic found that around 30% of those living in low-cost housing did not receive any form of cash aid. 'In 2022 alone, 30% of needy residents in Kuala Lumpur were excluded from assistance,' he said at the Intellectual Discourse @ INCEIF titled 'The Rising Costs vs Flat Wages – Escaping the Wallet Squeeze' panel discussion today. Muhammed said this consistent pattern of exclusion underscores a key point: targeting the poor is inherently difficult, whereas identifying and excluding the rich is far easier. 'Administrative databases more prominently display the rich due to their smaller numbers. The poor, however, often fall through bureaucratic cracks due to informal employment, inconsistent documentation, or geographic isolation.' Muhammed said rather than stigmatise the poor with means-testing and labelling, a universal approach is more just and effective. In countries like Indonesia, he cited, programmes such as subsidised petrol have inadvertently caused hardship for the poor, forcing them to queue for basic entitlements and suffer the indignity of being publicly marked as 'needy'. If subsidy rationalisation is to be implemented, Muhammed said, it should be done gradually, with price floating introduced carefully to avoid shocks to vulnerable groups. 'At the heart of reform must be the principle of inclusion – not exclusion.' Muhammed also addressed broader fiscal and governance challenges. He said Malaysia's taxation system is described as regressive, where individuals are taxed heavily on basic consumption and wages but lightly on dividends and luxury assets. 'For instance, buying a cheap car incurs tax, while luxury vehicles often escape it. Salary earners may pay up to 24% in taxes, but dividend income is taxed at only 2%,' Muhammed pointed out. He questioned how tax revenue, particularly the recently introduced expanded Sales and Service Tax, is utilised. He said investing in mega projects such as high-speed rail, which mainly benefit the top 1% to 3% of the population, was criticised as an inefficient use of public funds, especially in the early stages of budget reform. Instead, spending should focus on public goods such as education, healthcare and public transport – services that benefit the majority. 'Ultimately, it comes down to governance. Countries with high tax rates, like those in the Nordic region, also have high trust in government and low levels of tax evasion. 'Why? Because their citizens see tangible outcomes: clean governance, quality public services, and accountability. When trust exists, people are more willing to contribute to the system,' Muhammed said. Bank Negara Malaysia assistant governor Fraziali Ismail said Malaysia's long-standing low-cost economic model – anchored by broad subsidies and price controls – is increasingly showing signs of strain. He said while this approach historically enabled competitiveness and affordability, especially for lower-income groups, he argue that the system may now be holding the country back. 'We've built our economy on being cost-competitive – producing and selling goods at low prices both domestically and internationally. But that model is fraying,' Fraziali said at the forum. He said subsidies have played a central role in sustaining Malaysia's affordability model, particularly in essential sectors such as fuel, utilities, and food. However, the policy's effectiveness is diminishing. 'Subsidies are not inherently bad. However, we have overextended them to their limits. We have maxed out the role of price controls and subsidies to the point where, instead of helping, they are starting to hinder further progress.' Fraziali said massive subsidies – estimated at RM60 billion with RM50 billion alone on fuel – have increasingly become regressive, benefitting the wealthier population more than the poor. And with the current fiscal situation, continuing this trajectory is neither sustainable nor equitable. 'We must shift away from blanket subsidies that distort prices and adopt better-targeted, inclusive policies. If we want to reform subsidies, we need to do it gradually, with floating prices and mechanisms to protect the vulnerable,' Fraziali said. Beyond subsidies, he said Malaysia is grappling with a broader cost-of-living crisis, a challenge that is both structural and global. While the official inflation rate is relatively low, reported at just 1.2%, many households continue to struggle. 'Affordability shouldn't come at the expense of progress. 'If we are serious about tackling the cost-of-living crisis and ensuring long-term prosperity, we must transition toward an economy driven by productivity, fair wages, and smarter social support, not just low prices,' Fraziali said.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Anwar holds talks with Italian PM Meloni to boost bilateral ties
ROME: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim was accorded a guard of honour upon his arrival at Chigi Palace, the official residence of his Italian counterpart Giorgia Meloni, on Thursday. Anwar, who arrived here on Tuesday for a three-day working visit to Italy, was received by Meloni before the national anthems of both countries were played. Meloni then introduced her delegation, which included Italy's Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister, Antonio Tajani, before Anwar introduced his. During a meeting, both leaders reaffirmed their commitment to strengthening bilateral relations through more comprehensive cooperation. They also discussed a wide range of issues, including collaboration in the economic sector, particularly trade and investment, as well as cooperation in defence, renewable energy, environmental sustainability, agro-commodities and the digital economy. The two leaders also exchanged views on regional and international developments, including the ongoing conflict between Iran and Israel and the resulting humanitarian crisis in the Middle East. Anwar was accompanied by Foreign Minister Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan, Transport Minister Anthony Loke, Defence Minister Datuk Seri Mohamed Khaled Nordin, as well as Investment, Trade and Industry Minister Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz. Also present was Malaysian Ambassador to Italy, Datuk Zahid Rastam. In 2024, total trade between Malaysia and Italy increased by two per cent to RM14.61 billion (US$3.18 billion), compared to 2023. From January to May 2025, bilateral trade rose 3.3 per cent year-on-year to RM6.5 billion (US$1.48 billion). Italy remained Malaysia's fifth-largest trading partner and the third-largest importer of Malaysian palm oil among European Union member states last year. Anwar is scheduled to depart for Paris next, where he will meet with French President Emmanuel Macron during his two-day visit. Following that, the Prime Minister will head to Rio de Janeiro to attend the 17th BRICS Leaders' Summit at the invitation of Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.
