AI 171 report claims state of 'confusion' between pilots
Dhalla emphasised the word 'transitioned', which was mentioned in the report. He further explained that this report suggests a challenge-and-response dynamic exists between the two pilots, with one questioning the other, and a state of confusion.
"The report uses a particular word - 'transitioned'. The fuel control switches transitioned, according to the report. This report suggests that a challenge-and-response dynamic exists between the two pilots, with one questioning the other, and a state of confusion between the pilots, potentially leading to a breakdown in Crew Resource Management (CRM)," Captain Prashant Dhalla said.
"If any changes were made due to a failure in this aircraft, they would have used these switches to regain power. If there was a problem with the locking mechanism of these switches, then the pilots were also helpless," Captain Dhalla added further.
Meanwhile, the Federation of Indian Pilots (FIP) President, CS Randhawa, on Thursday, condemned a media report that claimed that the captain of the flight deliberately cut off fuel to the engines.
Captain Randhawa emphasised that the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau's (AAIB) preliminary report makes no mention of the pilots turning off the switches controlling fuel flow to the engines.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
15 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Aviation Minister slams foreign media reports on probe, says they may have ‘vested interest'
Three days after the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) cautioned against 'spreading premature narratives' surrounding the June 12 Air India flight AI 171 crash in Ahmedabad, Union Civil Aviation Minister Ram Mohan Naidu Kinjarapu rubbished Western media reports and accused them of having vested interests. Naidu's remarks come after certain Western media outlets blamed the action by one of the pilots as the cause of the crash, which killed 260 people — 241 of the 242 people on board and 19 on the ground. Speaking to the media in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, Kinjarappu said, 'AAIB has made an appeal to all, especially Western media houses, which may have a vested interest in the kind of articles they are trying to publish.' Exuding confidence in the ongoing probe conducted by AAIB, Naidu said, 'I believe in AAIB… They have done a wonderful job in decoding the black box in India itself… Making any comments until the final report comes out is not a good exercise… There is no point in jumping to conclusions at this point.' #WATCH | Ghaziabad, UP | Civil Aviation Minister Ram Mohan Naidu Kinjarapu says, 'AAIB has made an appeal to all, especially Western media houses, which may have a vested interest in the kind of articles they are trying to publish. I believe in AAIB… They have done a wonderful… — ANI (@ANI) July 20, 2025 In an appeal issued on July 17, AAIB Director General GVG Yugandhar urged the public and the media to 'refrain from spreading premature narratives' around the worst aviation disaster involving an Indian airline in four decades. He also termed it 'irresponsible' that sections of the international news publications are 'repeatedly attempting to draw conclusions through selective and unverified reporting'. Stressing on the need to respect the sensitivity of loss faced by kin of the victims, Yugandhar noted that the preliminary report only attempts to merely provide information on what happened in the crash, and that it is too early to arrive at any definitive conclusions. As per the preliminary investigation report released by AAIB, a month following the tragic incident, the Air India Boeing 787-8 aircraft crashed after both its engines were starved of fuel as the two fuel control switches transitioned from 'RUN' to 'CUTOFF' position within a second of each other moments after lift-off. The report also added that one of the pilots asked the other why he cut off the fuel, to which the other pilot responded saying he did not, according to the cockpit voice recorder data. The report does not mention that the fuel control switches — which allow and cut fuel flow to the plane's engines — moved physically, and uses the term 'transitioned' to describe the change of mode from RUN to CUTOFF. It also does not state these were moved by either of the pilots. However, the selective information presented in the report had many believing that it implicitly pointed a finger at one of the pilots. A few experts and industry watchers had raised issues of scarce flow of official information, absence of regular updates, and briefings on the investigation.
Time of India
24 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Don't jump to conclusions': Centre on AI 171 probe; questions western media motives
NEW DELHI: Union Civil Aviation Minister Ram Mohan Naidu Kinjarapu on Sunday expressed his confidence in Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB)'s probe into AI 171 crash, urging people to avoid "jumping to conclusions" till the final report was out. He also questioned the coverage of the crash probe by the Western media houses pointing out that they may have a "vested interest" behind their articles. "I believe in AAIB... They have done a wonderful job in decoding the black box in India itself... Making any comments until the final report comes out is not a good exercise... There is no point in jumping to conclusions at this point," ANI quoted the minister saying. "AAIB has made an appeal to all, especially Western media houses, which may have a vested interest in the kind of articles they are trying to publish," he said. The comments come after AAIB raised concerns over 'selective and unverified reporting' by certain international outlets on the Ahmedabad plane crash that squarely pointed the blame on the captain of the aircraft based on information from US authorities. "It is essential to respect the sensitivity of the loss faced by family members of deceased passengers, crew of the aircraft and other deceased persons on the ground. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Sticky Sweet Treat Is Healthier Than You Think – 15 Reasons to Add It to Your Diet! Learn More Undo It has come to our attention that certain sections of the international media are repeatedly attempting to draw conclusions through selective and unverified reporting. Such actions are irresponsible, especially while the investigation remains ongoing. We urge both the public and the media to refrain from spreading premature narratives that risk undermining the integrity of the investigative process," AAIB said in a statement, earlier this week. The bureau released its statement following a report by The Wall Street Journal, which claimed, citing sources familiar with the early assessment by US officials, that the captain may have "accidentally or deliberately" turned off switches controlling fuel supply to the aircraft's two engines.
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
"Bring Him Back": Indian Family's Urgent Appeal After Son's Kidnapping In Niger
The family of Ranjit Singh, an Indian national kidnapped in Niger's Dosso region, is pleading for the government's help to bring him back home safely. Ranjit Singh, a resident of Jammu and Kashmir's Ramban district, was working at a construction site when unidentified gunmen attacked, killing two Indians and abducting him. Located in the remote village of Chakka Kundi in Ramban, the family of Ranjit Singh sat shrouded unaware of his whereabouts. Ranjit Singh's father, Mohan Lal Sen, is urging the Government of India to take immediate action to secure his son's release, expressing concern for his well-being and safety. In an exclusive interview to ANI, father of Ranjit Singh, Mohan Lal Sen, said, "We want to tell Modiji to act on it, Government of India should work to bring him back. We have been suffering from the last 5-6 days. He has little children. We are very worried about him- where is he abducted, has he eaten anything or not". His mother, Sadhu Devi, is distraught, hasn't slept or eaten since the incident, and is desperate to see her son return home. The grieving mother, Sadhu Devi told ANI, "Please bring my son back. I want him back. I haven't slept in nights or eaten anything. When will my son come back?" Tears rolling down her face, she said, "We are very worried about his whereabouts. He has three small children, they are also worried. We want our son to come back home safe and sound." In a heinous terror attack, two Indians were killed while one was abducted in the Dosso region of Niger, as noted by the Indian Embassy in Niger. The Indian Embassy in Niamey is in touch with the local authorities to repatriate the bodies of those killed and ensure safe release of the abducted Indian. The mission also cautioned all Indians in Niger to remain vigilant. The Indian Embassy in Niger is working closely with local authorities to repatriate the dead bodies of the two Indians and ensure Ranjit Singh's safe release. In a post on X it said, "In a heinous terror attack on 15 July in Niger's Dosso region, two Indian nationals tragically lost their lives and one was abducted. Our heartfelt condolences to the bereaved families. Mission in Niamey is in touch with local authorities to repatriate remains and ensure safe release of the abducted Indian. All Indians in Niger are advised to remain vigilant." Arab News reported citing local sources that unidentified armed attackers ambushed a Nigerien army unit providing security at a construction site for an electrical line in the Dosso region, around 100 kilometres (63 miles) from the capital city of Niamey. Previously in March, Niger had seen a terrorist attack by the Islamic State in Great Sahara in Kokorou, which had resulted in the deaths of at least 44 civilians and had left 13 severely injured, as reported by UN Security Council Press. US State Department's 2023 Country Report on Terrorism for Niger had observed, that terrorist organizations exploited Niger's extensive borderlands and sparsely populated regions to attack and recruit among populations where access to government services was weak and economic opportunity negligible. Due to the small size of its "defence force, ineffective coordination among security services, budget shortfalls, and instability in Burkina Faso, Libya, Mali, Nigeria, and the Lake Chad Basin", Niger's efforts to fight terrorism were hampered. Niger is in the midst of a political upheaval as a military coup has taken control, ousting the democratically elected President. Niger has been facing a severe security crisis due to jihadist insurgencies linked to Al-Qaida and the Islamic State, exacerbated by a military coup in July 2023. In July, 2023 President Mohamed Bazoum was detained by the Presidential Guard and General Abdourahamane Tchiani declared himself the new leader. This event led to widespread international condemnation. The Niger coup is the seventh such event in West and Central Africa since 2020, highlighting a concerning trend of military interventions in the region. The region has seen several attacks targeting foreigners, including kidnappings of aid workers and Indian nationals.
