EBay customer support agent sanctioned for four minutes of inactivity loses dismissal case
eBay
customer support agent who quit after being written up for failing to explain four minutes of inactivity on his computer to his manager's satisfaction has lost his claim for constructive dismissal.
The employee told the
Workplace Relations Commission
(WRC) earlier this year he had 'people dying left, right and centre' in his personal life at the time of the events that led to the warning, including a friend who 'went into the river in Navan'.
His former manager said: 'Anything over 60 seconds is considered work avoidance.'
A claim for constructive dismissal brought by the worker, Eanna Donoghue, under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 against eBay Europe Services Ltd, has been rejected by the tribunal.
READ MORE
Mr Donoghue quit on March 5th, 2024, the day he was told a company appeals officer had decided to leave a written warning for 'work avoidance' on his personnel file – effectively barring him from seeking promotion for a time, he said.
He had been in the €41,000-a-year job for just short of seven years.
The tribunal heard Mr Donoghue's former line manager, Niamh Seoighe, wrote to him on Thursday, December 21st, 2024 telling him she had observed on a screen recording that he closed off a customer issue by email in a minute and 36 seconds, but left the page open for a few minutes.
'I couldn't take it any longer,' Mr Donoghue said, telling the WRC the reprimand for 'work avoidance' followed a period when he had 'people dying left, right and centre' in his personal life, including a friend who 'went into the river in Navan'.
'For some reason that was just ignored. A perfect record for seven years, and she [his line manager] still thought it was reasonable and fair to give me a warning on that incident,' he said.
Mr Donoghue's said the reprimand over the four-minute inactivity incident in January 2024 and informal 'verbal counselling' on November 28th, 2023 for lateness was linked to filing grievances, starting with complaints against two operations managers on November 16th that year.
He said he was aggrieved to get 'a warning for going to the bathroom for four minutes, for not closing off an email' when he claimed he had called people out for 'doing 10 times worse' in the past.
Mr Donoghue had 'informal verbal counselling' for lateness in the months before the downtime issue arose, the tribunal heard. Three instances of lateness were officially recorded on Mr Donoghue's file. The company submitted he had actually arrived late on eight occasions.
The tribunal heard Mr Donoghue had car trouble at the time and was trying to get from Navan, Co Meath, to Blanchardstown, Dublin 15, by bus. He told the WRC the Minister for Transport had admitted to a newspaper 'the NX [bus] didn't turn up'.
'That was out of my control, I couldn't get to work,' he said.
Mr Donoghue's position during a disciplinary meeting had been that he 'forgot to close the email' before taking a break, and that 'he might have gone to get a cup of tea', counsel for the respondent Mark Curran BL said in cross-examination.
'To this day I'm not sure,' Mr Donoghue said. 'I took a couple of calls in this time,' he said.
'You did say you took a personal call about the person in the river,' he said.
'I took a personal call, but I'm not sure if it was in that four minutes,' the complainant said.
Ms Seoighe said in her evidence that she wrote to Mr Donoghue before Christmas that year looking for an explanation after observing on a screen recording from his computer that he had finished responding to the email but failed to mark himself as available for up to five minutes.
'It was call avoidance,' she said. 'If I'm going on the 'break unpaid' ops code, I'm being skipped; it's going to someone else on the team, they're getting additional calls,' she said.
'[For] idle time on an email, anything over 60 seconds is considered work avoidance,' she said. Her position was that the issue was exacerbated by Mr Donoghue's failure to use an hour specifically allotted for him to answer her queries on the downtime and because of that she 'had to follow up several times'.
The written warning given to Mr Donoghue by Ms Seoighe was upheld in a paper-based appeal.
In her decision, adjudicator Eileen Campbell wrote that she had 'every sympathy' for the difficulties Mr Donoghue had experienced in his personal life.
She wrote that Mr Donoghue 'appears to feel that he has been treated unfairly by the imposition of a first written warning for behaviour of a type he would have called out in respect of agents in the past'.
'When his team leader does her job and addresses an issue with the complainant he considers it to be unreasonable behaviour and alleges he is being targeted,' she wrote.
She noted further that Mr Donoghue quit 'without any attempt at raising a grievance' about the warning.
'I am not persuaded by the complainant that resignation was his only option,' she concluded, dismissing the complaint.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Serbian leader vows tough response against protesters after riots
Serbian president Aleksandar Vucic has announced tough measures against anti-government protesters following days of riots in the streets of Serbia that have challenged his increasingly autocratic rule in the Balkan country. In one of his frequent TV addresses to the public, Mr Vucic accused the anti-government demonstrators of 'pure terrorism' and reiterated his claims that months of persistent protests against his rule have been orchestrated in the West and aimed at destroying Serbia . 'Our country is in grave danger, they have jeopardised all our values, normal life, each individual,' said Mr Vucic, alleging an elaborate scheme that would eventually install 'anarcho-leftist' authorities in the future. He did not offer any concrete evidence for his claims. Supporters of Serbian president Aleksandar Vucic hurl flares at protesters during an anti-government protest. Photograph: Darko Vojinovic/AP 'Unless we undertake tougher steps, it is a question of days when they [protesters] will kill someone,' said Mr Vucic. 'I am saying this for history.' The stern warnings came after five consecutive nights of clashes between the protesters on one side and police and Vucic loyalists on the other. Angry demonstrators on Saturday evening torched Mr Vucic's governing Serbian Progressive Party offices in a town in western Serbia, and those of other ruling coalition allies. The demonstrators also clashed with police in Belgrade, the capital, and in the northern city of Novi Sad. Riot officers used tear gas against protesters who hurled stun grenades, flares and bottles at them. [ Serbian protesters and president trade 'civil war' warnings after street clashes Opens in new window ] Mr Vucic did not specify the state response that he said would come within a week. But he stressed that a state of emergency is not imminent. Scores of people have already been detained and injured in the past days, while police have faced accusations of excessive force and arbitrary detentions of protesters. 'You will witness the determination of the state of Serbia,' said Mr Vucic. 'We will use everything at our disposal to restore peace and order in the country.' The clashes last week marked a significant escalation following more than nine months of largely peaceful demonstrations that started after a concrete canopy collapsed at a train station in Serbia's north, killing 16 people. Many in Serbia blamed the incident on alleged widespread corruption in state-run infrastructure projects that they say fuelled poor renovation work. The Serbian president has faced accusations of stifling democratic freedoms while allowing organised crime and corruption to flourish. He has denied this. Serbia is formally seeking EU membership, but Mr Vucic has maintained strong ties with Russia and China. On Sunday, he praised Russia's backing for his government against what he called a 'coloured revolution' against his government.
Irish Times
14 hours ago
- Irish Times
BBC reporter Peter Taylor: ‘People forget how we got to Good Friday – how precious it is'
In a lifetime as a journalist, Peter Taylor has spent his career searching for the answer to a single question. His introduction to Ireland was Derry on the evening of January 30th, 1972; only hours earlier, 13 people had been killed when members of the British army's Parachute Regiment opened fire on anti-internment marchers in the city's Bogside, with a 14th dying later. 'I felt guilty that my soldiers – me being a Brit – appeared to have been responsible for what appeared to be a massacre, and I felt guilty that I, as a young, 30-year-old journalist, was so ignorant. 'I thought, I'd better find out, and I spent the next 50 years. It was a seminal moment for me.' READ MORE Taylor had found his calling; in the years that followed, his quest to understand what had happened, and why, made the BBC journalist, to quote this newspaper, 'by far the most knowledgeable British – or Irish – television reporter on Northern Irish affairs'. He has won many awards for his work, including Journalist of the Year and Lifetime Achievements Awards from both BAFTA and the Royal Television Society. He revealed Derry businessman Brendan Duddy as the intermediary between the IRA and the British government in 2008's The Secret Peacemaker, while his most recent documentary – and accompanying book – tells the previously untold story of Operation Chiffon, a top-secret British intelligence operation aimed at bringing the IRA's armed campaign to an end. [ 'Secret peacemaker' Brendan Duddy 'risked life for peace' Opens in new window ] [ Brendan Duddy: From chip-shop owner to secret peacemaker Opens in new window ] Yet it might have begun so differently. In 1972 Taylor was working for Thames Television's This Week programme when instinct told him 'there was likely to be trouble on the march, given what had happened at Magilligan [the week before], when the Paras had laid into the civil right marchers.' He suggested they cover it; a plan for three camera crews – one with the British army, one with the marchers and another roaming free – was 'all set to go' until the union 'vetoed its members going because Thames Television wouldn't agree to pay danger money'. They might have had footage 'of everything', concedes Taylor with a groan of regret. 'That was one of the great what-ifs, and I was so pissed off, angry, and that was just one of those things.' At home in London that Sunday afternoon, he heard what had happened on the news and immediately joined 'the long queue of journalists on a flight to Belfast'. 'I actually arrived in Derry on the night of the killings … I think I stayed in a B&B, and I remember going to bed that night nervous in case a sniper would hit me through the window. It just shows how alien my mindset was.' The next morning, he went to the Bogside. 'That's where I saw the wreaths and the blood relatively fresh on the ground, and knocked on doors. 'I was welcomed, rather than excoriated, as a visiting Brit. I always remember that.' This week he was welcomed back to Derry yet again, as a guest of the city's féile. He has visited old friends, including the Duddy family, and enjoyed chance meetings with everyone from Eamonn McCann to the Undertones' Mickey Bradley. 'It's nostalgic, it's invigorating, it's sad, it brings back memories, it's great to see how things have changed.' [ Eamonn McCann: 'How did I get to be 80? This doesn't feel like 80 is supposed to feel' Opens in new window ] Eamonn McCann and Peter Taylor at a concert at Derry's Féile last weekend Taylor points out that the hotel terrace where he is speaking to The Irish Times 'used to be the Brits' barracks, Ebrington Barracks … and here we are on a beautiful sunny morning, people out, relaxing, running, lots of tourists. Normality. It's beautiful.' 'Yet just over there, in the Bogside and in the Fountain, are huge bonfires,' he says. Sectarianism 'is still there … it has never gone away'. But compared with the Derry he first knew in 1972, the 'transformation is phenomenal, and it's the peace dividend, the result of [the] Good Friday [Belfast Agreement], and we must never forget what we all went through … and we have to protect it. It's not over. 'People forget how we got to Good Friday, and how precious it is, and we forget that at our peril, and in the end, those historical knots have to be untied, and something has to emerge which transforms the nature of the Irish State, Irish society. 'And unionists, loyalists, have to be party to it, that's the key thing.' With the caveat that 'there's no such thing as historical inevitability', he believes 'if you look at the history of Ireland, the division of Ireland, there is a certain inevitability that in the end, at some stage, further down the road and all those qualifications, in the next 20, 30 years there is likely to be some form of unity.' In the meantime, 'an awful lot of work has to be done … I don't think the work has been done on our side, the British side, that is being done on the Irish side, and both sides need to work together to try and work out a formula that would work and be acceptable. BBC journalist Peter Taylor in Derry. Photograph: Trevor McBride 'It has to be engagement, dialogue, intimate discussions between the two governments' and reassurance 'that all that is dear to unionists and loyalists is still there, and the traditions on both sides have to be respected'. 'The big obstacle to that is sectarianism … but despite that, the effort has to be made, because I think there is no other solution.' More than 50 years on, many questions remain, not least for Taylor himself. After all his searching, has he found his answer? 'Not to my satisfaction yet, because there are still too many unknowns and too much has to happen.' The next programme he wants to make 'would be a realistic analysis of what the possibility of a united Ireland is, in whatever form it may be – and that will be the thing to consider'. Yet he is all too aware of how journalism is 'under threat' from multiple challenges from disinformation and claims of 'fake news' to a 'desperate' shortage of resources. He compares how he was able to report first-hand from Bogside in the immediate aftermath of Bloody Sunday to the situation now in Gaza, 'where [BBC correspondent] Jeremy Bowen and his colleagues are not allowed, The Irish Times is not allowed to have access.' A journalist's job 'is to report accurately, as independently as one can and, in particular, to get up the closest to the truth of what the situation is like'. 'I want to hear from Jeremy Bowen or John Simpson or whoever in one of the food distribution centres saying, I believe that what has happened here is true, and it's difficult to find a word other than genocide to describe it.' [ John Simpson: 'It's been great to watch how Ireland went from a pretty backward country to a real powerhouse in Europe' Opens in new window ] In Derry, Taylor did get up close; he is respected as one who listened, who gave people a voice, and who told their story. 'At my talk, I got two or three cards and notes from people, just saying, 'thank you'. I got the 'thank you' many times from people, who just said, 'thank you, for all you've done'. 'That means a huge – it means so much. It means more than anything.'
Irish Times
18 hours ago
- Irish Times
Woman granted barring order over abusive behaviour by partner
A woman whose partner allegedly 'forces' her to have sex 'every second night' has been granted an interim barring order against him. The woman, who sought the order against her partner of more than a decade at the emergency domestic violence court at Dublin's Dolphin House, claimed on one occasion she was left covered in bruises. She told Judge Mark O'Connell that her partner has had a cocaine addiction for two years, claiming he gets 'very paranoid' and abusive. 'He always thinks I'm cheating on him, and he follows me everywhere,' she said. READ MORE She added that her partner, with whom she has a child, wakes her up in the middle of the night and 'forces' her to have sex, which I don't want.' Noting this constitutes rape, the judge asked how often it occurs, with the woman saying it was 'every second night'. 'One night, he uses me, and the other night, he sleeps,' she said. On one occasion, the woman said she was brought to the Sexual Assault Treatment Unit at the Rotunda Hospital by gardaí and was 'all bruises.' She said her partner has been charged by the gardaí. 'He is behaving in an absolutely violent and unacceptable way,' said the judge. 'He has to leave.' She was granted an interim barring order against her partner until a full hearing, in which one of up to three years could be granted. The temporary order will mean her partner is removed from the home by gardaí and prohibited from contacting her. She was one of about 15 people, the vast majority women, to seek emergency protection at the court on Friday morning. Another woman, who said she was 'in fear of my life and my kids' lives', was granted a protection order against her former partner. She claimed he was sharing her current location online and posting allegations that she is a 'child molester' and 'running a paedophile ring'. 'It's putting the lives of my kids in danger,' she told the judge. The woman, who is staying in emergency accommodation with her children, said she is 'petrified that he's going to send people.' 'I've been in and out of hostels and this is my fifth homeless accommodation because of this man, because he keeps turning up with blades, turning up with baseball bats, with hatchets. 'He has beat me so bad that he made me urinate myself. I'm in fear of my life and my kids' lives,' she said. She claimed on one occasion, she was held hostage by the man for a week in his house and was seriously assaulted, saying she subsequently required brain scans at a hospital. 'I was bleeding from the ears,' she said. The woman, who is originally from another county in Ireland, said she did not report the ordeal to gardaí as she was 'petrified.' She also alleged that the man has been attending her children's schools and trying to contact her older child on social media, through 'other children.' 'I can't take it any more,' she said. The judge granted the protection order until a full hearing. The order prohibits any contact, intimidation, and violence, and if breached, can result in a fine, prison sentence or both. Another woman was granted a protection order after telling the judge her former partner was allegedly using drugs in front of their children on a trip abroad. She said her son, aged over 10, had been 'acting out' over the last year or so, and after he began to attend counselling sessions, 'it all came out' that his father had used drugs in front of him at a hotel abroad. 'He actually took 12 tablets and told the kids that if he doesn't wake up, to go down and tell the reception. The kids were petrified; they sat in the room for the whole two days,' she said.
