EBay customer support agent sanctioned for four minutes of inactivity loses dismissal case
An
eBay
customer support agent who quit after being written up for failing to explain four minutes of inactivity on his computer to his manager's satisfaction has lost his claim for constructive dismissal.
The employee told the
Workplace Relations Commission
(WRC) earlier this year he had 'people dying left, right and centre' in his personal life at the time of the events that led to the warning, including a friend who 'went into the river in Navan'.
His former manager said: 'Anything over 60 seconds is considered work avoidance.'
A claim for constructive dismissal brought by the worker, Eanna Donoghue, under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 against eBay Europe Services Ltd, has been rejected by the tribunal.
READ MORE
Mr Donoghue quit on March 5th, 2024, the day he was told a company appeals officer had decided to leave a written warning for 'work avoidance' on his personnel file – effectively barring him from seeking promotion for a time, he said.
He had been in the €41,000-a-year job for just short of seven years.
The tribunal heard Mr Donoghue's former line manager, Niamh Seoighe, wrote to him on Thursday, December 21st, 2024 telling him she had observed on a screen recording that he closed off a customer issue by email in a minute and 36 seconds, but left the page open for a few minutes.
'I couldn't take it any longer,' Mr Donoghue said, telling the WRC the reprimand for 'work avoidance' followed a period when he had 'people dying left, right and centre' in his personal life, including a friend who 'went into the river in Navan'.
'For some reason that was just ignored. A perfect record for seven years, and she [his line manager] still thought it was reasonable and fair to give me a warning on that incident,' he said.
Mr Donoghue's said the reprimand over the four-minute inactivity incident in January 2024 and informal 'verbal counselling' on November 28th, 2023 for lateness was linked to filing grievances, starting with complaints against two operations managers on November 16th that year.
He said he was aggrieved to get 'a warning for going to the bathroom for four minutes, for not closing off an email' when he claimed he had called people out for 'doing 10 times worse' in the past.
Mr Donoghue had 'informal verbal counselling' for lateness in the months before the downtime issue arose, the tribunal heard. Three instances of lateness were officially recorded on Mr Donoghue's file. The company submitted he had actually arrived late on eight occasions.
The tribunal heard Mr Donoghue had car trouble at the time and was trying to get from Navan, Co Meath, to Blanchardstown, Dublin 15, by bus. He told the WRC the Minister for Transport had admitted to a newspaper 'the NX [bus] didn't turn up'.
'That was out of my control, I couldn't get to work,' he said.
Mr Donoghue's position during a disciplinary meeting had been that he 'forgot to close the email' before taking a break, and that 'he might have gone to get a cup of tea', counsel for the respondent Mark Curran BL said in cross-examination.
'To this day I'm not sure,' Mr Donoghue said. 'I took a couple of calls in this time,' he said.
'You did say you took a personal call about the person in the river,' he said.
'I took a personal call, but I'm not sure if it was in that four minutes,' the complainant said.
Ms Seoighe said in her evidence that she wrote to Mr Donoghue before Christmas that year looking for an explanation after observing on a screen recording from his computer that he had finished responding to the email but failed to mark himself as available for up to five minutes.
'It was call avoidance,' she said. 'If I'm going on the 'break unpaid' ops code, I'm being skipped; it's going to someone else on the team, they're getting additional calls,' she said.
'[For] idle time on an email, anything over 60 seconds is considered work avoidance,' she said. Her position was that the issue was exacerbated by Mr Donoghue's failure to use an hour specifically allotted for him to answer her queries on the downtime and because of that she 'had to follow up several times'.
The written warning given to Mr Donoghue by Ms Seoighe was upheld in a paper-based appeal.
In her decision, adjudicator Eileen Campbell wrote that she had 'every sympathy' for the difficulties Mr Donoghue had experienced in his personal life.
She wrote that Mr Donoghue 'appears to feel that he has been treated unfairly by the imposition of a first written warning for behaviour of a type he would have called out in respect of agents in the past'.
'When his team leader does her job and addresses an issue with the complainant he considers it to be unreasonable behaviour and alleges he is being targeted,' she wrote.
She noted further that Mr Donoghue quit 'without any attempt at raising a grievance' about the warning.
'I am not persuaded by the complainant that resignation was his only option,' she concluded, dismissing the complaint.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Prominent businessman loses bid for reporting restrictions on £1bn loan fraud trial
A prominent Belfast businessman accused of fraud in relation to a £1 billion (€1.2 billion) loan deal has been unsuccessful in his bid to have reporting restrictions imposed on the trial. Frank Cushnahan has pleaded not guilty to all charges. He had sought to have reporting restrictions put in place during the trial. His co-accused, Ian Coulter, has also pleaded not guilty to all charges. Mr Coulter did not seek to have reporting restrictions applied. The charges against the men relate to the sale of a loan book held by the National Asset Management Agency (Nama), which was set up by the Irish government to deal with toxic property loans after the banking crisis in 2008. READ MORE Mr Cushnahan had sought an order from the court pursuant to section 4 (2) of the Contempt of Court Act 1981, which states that reporting on certain proceedings may be postponed if there is 'a substantial risk of prejudice to the administration of justice in those proceedings'. In dismissing the application, Mr Justice Ian Huddleston of the Crown Court of Northern Ireland said there was 'no substantial risk to the applicant on the facts'. He said there is 'substantial public interest' in the trial. 'The public interest in fair and accurate reporting of criminal trials generally, and the promotion of public confidence in the administration of justice and the rule of law, is something which very much tends to the dismissal of the application,' the judge said. Nama's Northern Ireland loan book was sold to a US investment fund in 2014. Mr Cushnahan, a former member of Nama's Northern Ireland advisory committee, is charged with fraud for allegedly failing to disclose information to Nama between April 1st and November 7th, 2013. Mr Coulter, a solicitor, is alleged to have made a false representation to a law firm on or around September 11th, 2014. He is also charged with making an article in connection with a fraud, namely a £9 million invoice, and two counts of concealing or transferring criminal property on various dates in 2014. Both men are accused of making a false representation to Nama and a law firm in April 2014. They deny all charges. In his written judgment, which was delivered on Wednesday, Mr Justice Huddleston said: 'The application to this court was essentially by way of written submissions made by Mr Cushnahan's counsel as expanded upon orally but acknowledged by him to be unsupported by any evidential basis or other supporting information.' Mr Cushnahan was represented by Frank O'Donoghue KC and Bobbie-Leigh Herdman BL, instructed by Paul Dougan from John J Rice Solicitors. Four media organisations intervened in the case – The Irish Times, RTÉ, BBC and Mediahuis. They were represented by Richard Coghlin KC, instructed by Fergal McGoldrick of Carson McDowell LLP. Jonathan Kinnear KC and Lauren Cheshire BL, instructed by the Public Prosecution Service, supported the media interveners' submissions.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Co Limerick garda acquitted of charges he fixed motoring offences for drivers
A Limerick-based garda has been found not guilty of attempting to pervert the course of justice after allegations he fixed motoring offences for drivers. Garda Thomas Flavin was acquitted of a total of 22 counts of allegedly attempting to pervert the course of justice by a jury at Limerick Circuit Criminal Court following an eight day trial. The jury returned unanimous not guilty verdicts on 17 of the charges. Earlier, the jury was directed by the trial judge, Colin Daly, to return not guilty verdicts in respect of five counts against Garda Flavin. The garda, who had denied all of the charges, was supported in court throughout the trial by family friends and colleagues. READ MORE Garda Flavin was arrested following an investigation by the Garda National Bureau of Criminal Investigation (GNBCI). He was accused of knowingly entering false motor insurance details on the Garda Pulse computer records system, in an attempt to frustrate potential prosecutions against people for driving without insurance. His trial heard the drivers involved were stopped at routine Garda checkpoints around the country and asked by the garda present to produce their insurance and licence details at a nominated Garda station within 10 days of the traffic stop. All of the drivers involved nominated Rathkeale Garda station, and, later, when the investigating garda in each of the traffic stops carried out follow up checks of Pulse they were satisfied the details entered indicated that the driver in each case was insured. However, the court heard some of the drivers were actually not insured and had been prosecuted in court after pleading guilty to driving without insurance. On Thursday, Garda Flavin's barrister, senior counsel Mark Nicholas, instructed by solicitor Dan O'Gorman, urged the jury to acquit his client of all of the charges and said there was no evidence of wrongdoing. Mr Nicholas told the jury Garda Flavin was an exemplary garda who had served with dedication in Croom and Rathkeale, Co Limerick, for many years. Mr Nicholas spoke of the 'unique challenges' gardaí face in Rathkeale as opposed to other jurisdictions. 'People who live down here know it has an enormous population, transient, in and out at various times of the year. 'One policeman said (the population) quadruples and with that comes its own set of problems and own sets of vehicles – UK car registrations, UK insurance, some not insured, some not being entirely truthful," he said. 'We know that a certain number of times that people who were pulled up and stopped and asked for their documentation, produced bogus insurance certificates.' The court heard evidence that people had provided certain documents at Rathkeale Garda station, where Garda Flavin was based at the time. However it was unclear who produced the documents nor was it clear what documents they produced. Fiona Murphy SC, prosecuting, had alleged that the evidence would show that Garda Flavin had 'sorted out' the uninsured drivers by inputting data into Pulse to try to frustrate prosecutions against them. Ms Murphy had told the jury that the prosecution case was 'a circumstantial case' with 'no direct evidence'. 'Instead, the prosecution relies on indirect evidence,' she said. She had argued that all of the relevant data entries into Pulse 'were entered under the ID of Thomas Flavin'. She alleged Garda Flavin knew the drivers were not insured and that he entered their details on to Pulse to ensure they appeared covered. 'Mr Flavin knew what he was doing, and he did so to ensure those people were insured (on Pulse) when they were not, in order to ensure there was no prosecution,' Ms Murphy said. However, after deliberating for three hours and 21 minutes, the jury unanimously dismissed all of the allegations.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Boy (12) who fell from Cliffs of Moher had ‘instantaneous' death, says coroner
A 12-year old boy lost his balance after slipping in a puddle close to the edge of the Cliffs of Moher before falling over the edge to his death, his inquest has heard. In eye-witness testimony at the Clare coroner's court, reviewing the accidental death of Zhihan Zhao at the Cliffs of Moher last July, French tourist Marion Tourgon described seeing him fall over the edge at about 1.45pm on the day. Zhihan had set out on walking the Cliffs of Moher trail with his mother, Xianhong Huang, and her friends. In her evidence, a tearful Ms Huang said Zhihan was walking ahead of her on the trail when she lost sight of him. READ MORE Ms Tourgon told the inquest she and her family were taking a selfie when she saw a young Asian boy, who was alone, come into view. She said she saw his right foot slip into a puddle and his left foot ended up in the air as he tried to stop himself from falling. 'It was very quick. He found himself in an awkward position with his left foot in a void over the cliff and his right knee on the edge of the cliff.' 'His right knee eventually fell into the void over the cliff and he was trying to grasp the grass with his hands to pull himself up. He didn't shout and there was no noise.' She said her family alerted the emergency services by phone. Speaking through an interpreter Ms Huang said her son walked 'very fast and was ahead of us by 50 metres'. 'As there was only one path I thought we would meet him along the way. When I didn't I walked to the visitor centre and I checked the visitor centre.' When she couldn't find her son there, she walked back along the path to search for him and then reported him missing. Ms Huang asked: 'What exactly caused Zhihan to fall from the Cliffs?' Clare coroner Isobel O'Dea said Ms Tourgon's evidence would help answer that question. Sgt Claire McGuigan said Ms Huang provided a photo of Zhihan she had taken taken earlier on the Cliffs of Moher trail. Garda Colm Collins said the Coastguard later spotted a body at the base of the cliffs. A lifeboat was launched but it could not access the area due to the sea conditions. Zhihan's body was recovered from the sea five days later after it was spotted by fisherman, Matthew O'Halloran from Corofin, Co Clare. The coroner said the post mortem found Zhihan died from multiple traumatic injuries consistent with a fall from a height. Ms O'Dea said her verdict was one of 'accidental death'. 'It is clear from evidence we heard that Zhihan slipped off the cliffs rather than any other way. His death would have been very quick - instantaneous.' Ms O'Dea told Ms Huang: 'I can't imagine how upsetting this is for you'. On August 22nd of last year, the Clare Local Development Company, which manages the trail, closed off large sections of the route, which remain closed off today due to continuing safety concerns. At the time, the company confirmed it was taking the action following two recent fatal accidents on the trail. In May 2024, a woman in her 20s from Belgium died after she fell from the cliffs.
