French Constitutional Council strikes down return of banned pesticide
A student-led petition against the bill garnered more than two million signatures after lawmakers adopted it on July 8, with the bill's critics saying it had been rushed through a divided lower house of parliament without a proper debate.
The Constitutional Council said, in its ruling, that a provision in the bill allowing exemptions to the ban of products containing neonicotinoid chemicals, such as acetamiprid, would violate France's environmental charter, which has constitutional legal status. The legislature undermined "the right to live in a balanced and healthy environment" enshrined in the charter, the council said.
"Neonicotinoids have an impact on biodiversity, in particular on pollinating insects and birds, as well as consequences for water and soil quality, and pose risks to human health," the council said.
Macron will enact the law and respect the ruling
In 2020, the council granted a temporary exemption to the ban, limited to the beet sector and seed coating. However, the ruling said this measure did not go into enough detail about how long the pesticides could be used, how they would be applied, or which crops they would affect.
The Constitutional Council also approved two other measures in the law: one allowing for the construction of water storage for agricultural purposes, and another raising thresholds at which pig and poultry farms require prior authorisation.
French President Emmanuel Macron took "note" of the ruling, his office said on Thursday. The president will enact the law as soon as possible in a form that takes the ruling into account, the Elysée said.
A contentious chemical
Banned in France since 2018, acetamiprid remains legal in the European Union, and proponents said that some French farmers needed it to help them compete economically. The insecticide is particularly sought after by beet and hazelnut growers, who say that they have no alternative against pests and face unfair competition.
However, a petition on the website of France's Assemblée Nationale, which garnered more than 2.1 million signatures, called the measure a "frontal attack on public health." Beekeepers have described the chemical as "a bee killer," and its possible effects on humans are also a source of concern, though its risk remains unclear in the absence of large-scale studies.
For some opponents, frustration stretched beyond environmental and health concerns to exasperation over the country's political deadlock. In late June, before the law's passage, several thousand demonstrators – including farmers, environmental organisations and scientists – rallied across France calling for the bill to be withdrawn.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
4 hours ago
- Euronews
UK makes first arrests under one in, one out migrant deal with France
UK border authorities said on Thursday that they had detained the first group of migrants illegally crossing the English Channel and will send them back to France under a new pilot scheme. The migrants were detained on Wednesday, the day the plan came into force, and will be held at immigration removal centres until being returned to France. "That sends a message to every migrant currently thinking of paying organised crime gangs to go to the UK that they will be risking their lives and throwing away their money if they get into a small boat," British Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said in a statement. Under the scheme, France will accept the returned migrants in exchange for the UK taking in an equal number of asylum seekers who have family ties to Britain. UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron announced the deal last month. Although limited in scope, UK officials hailed it as a breakthrough and said it sets a precedent that allows migrants arriving illegally to be sent back across the Channel. However, critics say the programme will do little to deter migrants because the numbers returned to France are small and loopholes in the treaty will allow many people who enter the UK illegally to remain in the country as they pursue human rights claims. Dangerous crossings have become a potent political issue in the UK. Over 21,000 people arrived in the country so far this year, a 56% increase from the same period in 2024. Macron said the agreement was intended to have a deterrent effect. "I'm totally committed to make it work, because this is clearly our willingness and our common interest," he said. Potential challenges to the programme include the extent to which the UK is willing to invest in policing small boats, possible legal challenges in France, and opposition from other European nations. Discussions on halting irregular migration across the Channel date back decades. In the early 2000s, efforts focused on preventing stowaways from entering the UK through the Channel Tunnel in vehicles. Recently, smugglers have increasingly turned to sea routes. The previous Conservative government's controversial plan to deport asylum seekers to Rwanda was scrapped by Starmer shortly after he took office in July 2024.
LeMonde
6 hours ago
- LeMonde
Israel's ultra-Orthodox vow to push back after students' arrests
Israel's ultra-Orthodox Jewish community pledged to resist government moves to call up seminary students for military service on Thursday, August 7, as demonstrators took to the streets to protest the arrest of two objectors. "The authorities will face a united global ultra-Orthodox Judaism fighting for its soul," the spiritual leader of ultra-Orthodox Jews of European descent, Rabbi Dov Landau, told the community's leading newspaper Yated Ne'eman under the front-page headline "War." The exemption of many ultra-Orthodox men from the military service performed by other Jews has long been a contentious issue in Israel but it has become more so as the Gaza war has dragged on, putting a strain on army reservists. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government has depended on the support of two ultra-Orthodox parties for its majority in parliament. But its failure to pass new legislation to give full-time seminary students continued exemption from military service has tested that support. Both ultra-Orthodox parties have withdrawn their ministers from the government, while one has also stopped supporting it in parliament. The ultra-Orthodox community represents 14 % of Israel's Jewish population − about 1.3 million people − and around 66,000 men of military age previously benefited each year from exemptions. The Israeli army announced in early July that tens of thousands of conscription orders would be sent out to ultra-Orthodox Jews. Earlier this week, authorities arrested two brothers, both full-time seminary students, after they failed to heed their call-up papers. In Jerusalem on Thursday evening, ultra-Orthodox Jewish demonstrators gathered to protest the arrests, with police later using water cannon to disperse the crowd.
Euronews
6 hours ago
- Euronews
France's top court strikes down pesticide clause in farming law
France's highest court on Thursday blocked a key part of a contentious farming law that would have brought back a banned pesticide. According to the French Constitutional Court, the measure failed to protect the environment and future generations. The rest of the law - known as the 'Duplomb law,' after the senator who proposed it - was allowed to stand. The bill aimed to loosen rules for farmers and fast-track projects like water storage. It was backed by the government and major farming unions and passed in early July. However, it was met with fierce competition from scientists, health experts and green groups. At the heart of the controversy was acetamiprid, a pesticide banned in France since 2018 for its role in harming bees and other pollinators. Some farmers, especially beet growers, had pushed for its return. A student-led petition against the law drew more than 2 million signatures - one of the biggest in French history. Opponents said that the bill was rushed through parliament with barely any debate, and warned that it put public health and biodiversity at risk. On Thursday, the French court ruled that the proposal previously passed was not strict enough and ignored France's constitutional commitment to environment protection. The ruling is a blow to President Emmanuel Macron's government, which had defended the bill until the end. Left wing politicians were quick to react on social media. Manuel Bompard, coordinator of France Insoumise, said that: "The mobilization must continue until the law is withdrawn and a government, more dangerous than ever for the environment and health, is censored." Ian Brossat, co-chairman of the Communist group on the Paris council, welcomed the "excellent news for public health and the environment" and denounced what he described as an "absurd and dangerous" law. Critics called the decision a win for democracy and the planet. Some lawmakers have already vowed to push for a full repeal in the coming months. Acetamiprid is currently approved by the European Union until 2033, and authorized in other member countries.
