Victim of alleged Dublin mugger got tetanus shot after accomplice 'dug' her fingernails into his arms
Robert Maguire, 35, was charged with robbery on Sycamore Street on 31 May last and refused bail by Judge Máire Conneely at Dublin District Court today.
Garda Shane McConkey stated that at around 3.15am, the injured party was on his way home after socialising in the city centre. He turned onto Sycamore Street, in Dublin 2, when Maguire and a woman allegedly pursued him.
The accused, who resided at a hostel on Merchant's Quay, Dublin 8, reportedly punched him in the back of the head, causing him to become disoriented.
The pair then wrestled him into a doorway before another male became involved, and they threw him to the ground.
The complainant dropped his iPhone 15.
The second male robber picked it up as the female accomplice allegedly 'dug her nails into his forearm and attempted to pull his watch off of his wrist'.
The garda who objected to bail stated that this caused the man extreme pain.
'He attempted to fight back but was overwhelmed when the third male returned and helped pin him to the ground.'
It was alleged that the three suspects then rooted through his pockets.
Advertisement
The man shouted for help, and the trio fled when several members of the public approached.
The court heard there was an unsuccessful bid to use his bank card, which had been in his phone case, in a shop at O'Connell Street.
It was claimed the man suffered bruising to both his elbows, scrapes to his right forearm, and deep nail marks on his wrist and left bicep.
He went to a doctor the following day and needed a tetanus shot due to the deep nail marks on his arms becoming infected.
Judge Conneely was informed that the man had to take antibiotics for several days. He also missed work due to his injuries and psychological effects.
CCTV footage was obtained.
A decision awaits on whether the accused will be tried in the District Court or the Circuit Court, which has wider sentencing powers.
Defence counsel Sam Friel argued that his client, who has yet to plead, was entitled to the presumption of innocence and could face a lengthy period of pre-trial detention.
Garda McConkey agreed that the identification evidence did not come from the complainant but was based on the belief of gardaí that the accused was the person in the CCTV footage.
However, he asserted that a jacket had been seized from the accused's hostel room, which matched the video evidence.
Legal aid was granted.
Earlier this month, a 34-year-old woman who allegedly dug her fingernails into the man's arms was refused bail after she too was charged with robbery.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
an hour ago
- Sunday World
Face of Dublin man accused of strangling woman during assault in his home
He appeared before Judge Patricia Cronin at Cloverhill District Court on Tuesday for developments in his case, which was upgraded with a more serious charge. A Dublin man is to stand trial accused of strangling a woman during a non-fatal assault at his home. Lee Quinn, 29, of Keeper Road, Dublin 12 was initially charged with criminal damage to a door, bed and window and a minor category assault of a named woman, at his home address on June 3 last. He was remanded in custody the following day. News in 90 Seconds - August 6th He appeared before Judge Patricia Cronin at Cloverhill District Court on Tuesday for developments in his case, which was upgraded with a more serious charge. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) authorised investigating officer, Garda Adam Deegan, to bring an additional charge under section 3A of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act for strangulation of the woman, who did not have to attend the proceedings today. The Sundrive Road-based garda told Judge Cronin that the DPP has directed 'trial on indictment' in the Circuit Court, and that the accused could be sent forward for sentencing on a signed plea should that arise. Garda Deegan said Mr Quinn was cautioned and 'made no reply' when the extra alleged offence was put to him today shortly before his court hearing. Defence solicitor Katie Dowling said her client, who did not address the court, was not applying for bail. She also granted an order for disclosure of evidence for Mr Quinn to consider, if he wished to enter a guilty plea. Judge Cronin remanded him in custody to appear again in one week, the longest period available, due to the new charge. She said that was to let the accused consider his position, but noted that he may not have had an opportunity to do so by that stage. Legal aid was granted to Mr Quinn, who will appear again via video link at his next hearing.
Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'Non-binary' Syrian learns fate after 'unprovoked' attack on female jogger
A woman was the victim of a random "unprovoked" attack where she was kicked in the stomach, knocked to the ground and left in pain after she went jogging in Dublin, a court has heard. Hoyda Hamad, a Syrian national of no fixed abode who has used multiple identities, was jailed for three months on Wednesday over the incident at East Wall Road, Dublin 3, on the morning of July 26 last. It happened 18 days after he was handed a suspended sentence for an earlier theft crime. The 35-year-old, a barber by trade, was charged with a section 2 assault, which carries a six-month sentence, as well as with providing a false or misleading name and address to a member of An Garda Síochána and with using threatening, abusive, or insulting words or behaviour. "This was an unprovoked attack on a female member of the community who was going about her own business, out for a jog, and was attacked by someone who was unknown to her, and suffered pain and suffering," said Judge Patricia Cronin at the sentence hearing at Cloverhill District Court. Cloverhill District Court Hamad pleaded guilty last week, and the case was adjourned until Wednesday for facts and a victim statement. The woman did not have to attend the hearing or give evidence because of the guilty plea. Court Sergeant Olyn Murphy outlined the prosecution's evidence on behalf of investigating officer Garda Ruth Redmond. Judge Cronin heard that the incident happened at around 10.05 am when the defendant assaulted the woman "by kicking her in the stomach, causing her to fall back on the ground," and Hamad was verbally abusive toward her. She also suffered a back injury, a swollen finger, and her head was "throbbing" after being attacked by Hamad. Gardai attended the scene and Hamad gave a false name and date of birth before being arrested and brought to a station to be charged. Judge Cronin noted that he had two sets of prior convictions, one under the name Hamad with two theft convictions which led to the imposition of a two-month sentence, suspended for one year, in Wexford District Court on July 8. That term could now be activated. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week He also committed several other crimes under a different name: three for vehicle theft and driving offences, one for drug possession, another for burglary, one trespass and another for failing to provide a passport as required. That resulted in a 10-month prison sentence from Cork District Court on July 31 last year. In a mitigation plea, the defence counsel asked the judge to heed that he had pleaded guilty at an early stage, which was valuable given the moving victim impact statement, which was not read aloud during the hearing. The defence stressed that Hamad did not prolong the ordeal for the woman who did not have to testify, and that he had no prior assault convictions, and should be given significant credit for those factors. Later in the hearing, the defence described Hamad as non-binary and originally from Syria, having come through France. Over recent months, the accused had a transient living situation and was in a transient relationship with a supportive partner, counsel said. Hoyda Hamad. (Image: Irish Mirror) Pleading for leniency, the defence described the situation as a "chaotic set of circumstances". Hamad's recollection of events was minimal, and he was apologetic, and his expression of remorse was evidenced by his early guilty plea, the barrister submitted. The accused had been remanded in custody on the date of the incident. Hamad did not testify and spoke only to instruct his barrister that he wished to have the case finalised. Judge Cronin remarked how the victim's statement was eloquent and outlined the psychological and physical injuries, "significant impact", and the life changes the woman made since the attack. The judge found her account to be honest and not exaggerated, and she took notice of the fact that her employer was assisting her in getting counselling. Sentencing, the judge took into account Hamad's plea and prior convictions and that he had none under the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act or similar public order matters. The early guilty plea meant the victim did not have to come to court, she noted. However, she had to take into account all the circumstances and the mitigating factors. The sentence was backdated to July 26, and the judge expressed her wish for the woman to know that she was well in her recovery. The three-month term was handed down on the assault charge, with the two remaining offences taken into consideration. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
More than 100 retailers found non-compliant with laws on sale of vapes
More than 100 retailers across the country were found to be non-compliant with laws around the sale of vapes to children over the past 18 months, according to new Health Service Executive (HSE) figures. It has been illegal since December 22nd, 2023, to sell nicotine-inhaling products such as e-cigarettes – more commonly known as vapes – to children under the age of 18. Under the law, a person can be fined up to €4,000, as well as facing up to six months imprisonment. The HSE's National Environmental Health Service monitors compliance with the legislation through an annual test-purchase inspection programme. READ MORE Last year, the service conducted 389 test purchase inspections. Of those, some 52 were found to be non-compliant – where one of these products was sold to a child. In the first six months of this year, 310 inspections were carried out, of which 50 were found to be non-compliant. Of the 52 non-compliant inspections found in 2024, 19 proceedings have been heard to date in the District Court . Twelve of those cases resulted in a conviction with a fine, the number of cases in which the probation Act was applied was six and one case was struck out, withdrawn or dismissed by the court. The HSE said other proceedings were 'still in train', while proceedings relating to non-compliances identified this year are expected to be heard in 2026. The figures were released to Social Democrats TD Aidan Farrelly, who said: 'We need to make sure the enforcement works. 'You can see the level of inspections in the first half of this year is almost at the same level as all of last year. But what I'm looking at is the number of non-compliances versus prosecutions. 'The numbers [of prosecutions] are very low. I understand the court system could have much more pressing issues, but a law is only as strong as its enforceability. We have to make sure retailers are complying.' Mark Murphy, senior policy manager at the Irish Heart Foundation , said it was 'absolutely imperative' the ban on the sale of vapes to children is enforced. 'Vapes are not harm-free and evidence shows that e-cigarettes can damage the brain, heart, lungs and even blood vessels. Moreover, e-cigarettes contain nicotine, one of the most addictive substances on the planet,' he said. 'And medical research shows that the younger you are when you start using nicotine, the more likely you are to become addicted.' Ireland intends to increase the legal age of sale of cigarettes from 18 to 21 in 2028, but Mr Murphy has called for this to be extended to e-cigarettes to 'protect children from ever taking up vaping'. Last year, the Government approved plans to ban the manufacture or import of single-use or disposable vapes in Ireland and to limit vape flavours, coloured packaging and descriptions, as well as the level of advertising of such products.
