Perth and Kinross councillors reject plans for solar farm
It was refused by a single vote after objectors raised fears about going from living in open countryside to being in the middle of an industrial site.
Elected members in the SNP administration – who voted to approve the application – were outnumbered by opposition councillors who voted for refusal.
READ MORE: Time Team archaeologists hunt for Viking boat burial on Scottish island
Milton Keynes-based Greentech Invest UK (9) submitted plans to develop a 22MW solar farm on 46 hectares of land 320m north-west of Peattie Farm, Kinnochtry near Coupar Angus. The solar panels themselves would occupy around 24 hectares of the site.
PKC received 44 letters of objection to the application and just one letter of support.
Kettins Parish Community Council and Burrelton And District Community Council both objected to the proposal.
Campmuir resident Dave Ritchie, addressed the council on behalf of local residents opposed to the proposal.
He said: 'While we all recognise the requirements to produce green energy, the use of prime agricultural land is a real concern, particularly in light of the recent political and economical uncertainties when arguments for food security are stronger than ever.
'There's only eight per cent of Scotland that's prime agricultural land, so there must be plenty more room on other land to put these solar farms on. We've got brownfield sites, rooftops and plenty of unproductive sites.'
(Image: Perth and Kinross Council)
He highlighted concern about the swathe of renewable energy developments in the Coupar Angus area.
Ritchie said: 'There's a gathering pace of solar development – all on prime agricultural land.
'Of particular concern to residents is the prospect of being sandwiched between two separate developments – one which is at Markethill, 250 acres, (which is awaiting a decision from Scottish Ministers) and this one here at Peattie which is 110 acres.
'Before long, we'll no longer be living in the countryside but on a solar farm.'
He told councillors the arable land was used every year to grow crops such as potatoes, barley, carrots and turnips.
Objector Polly Jones' home neighbours the site.
Addressing councillors, she said: 'My concern, I believe, is shared by all of my neighbours and many of the residents of Campmuir.
'We were actually really shocked to hear this was being considered for approval, given the size of it and the impact it's going to have on all of us.
'Currently, we look at a wide open expanse of beautiful agricultural land. We bought our properties due to their location, at a price which reflected that setting and we pay our council tax to reflect that value and setting.
'If this proposal is allowed I and my neighbours will be faced directly with a minimum six-metre wall of solar panels.'
With the application site opposite her home being on a slope she explained they were 'very sceptical the screening will have any effect and even once the screening is fully grown, we're still going to be dwarfed by the panels that are visible higher up the hill'.
She added: 'As developments – like these – crowd in and around the substation there is a risk in Coupar Angus (with multiple developments proposed) that if they go ahead we won't be living in the countryside any more but in an industrial site.
'I feel, in Scotland, we don't have to have the trade-off between energy and food because we have a lot of land that is not prime agricultural land.'
Greentech senior planning manager James Jenkins told councillors: 'We estimate the project will deliver over £4.5 million of construction work that can be delivered by local contractors and specialists.'
He said rent paid to the landowner would 'ensure they could continue investing in their farming enterprise and maintain it as a viable operation' and the community would benefit from around £500 per MW (£11,000).
When councillors questioned the use of prime agricultural land, PKC's Major Applications and Enforcement team leader Sean Panton told councillors: 'The loss of prime agricultural land is regrettable but national planning policy does allow it.'
National Planning Framework 4 permits development on prime agricultural land for 'essential infrastructure and there is a specific locational need and no other suitable site'.
Blairgowrie and Glens councillor Bob Brawn moved to refuse the application.
The Conservative councillor said: 'This part of the world, Coupar Angus, has already lost prime agricultural land to battery storage at Pleasance Road; last month we, as consultees, agreed to battery storage at Kettins on prime agricultural land; Markethill is still in abeyance and could happen (but we can't use that as a justification); there's also a solar farm development at Keithick.
READ MORE: Inquiry held up as SNP change policy on protected Highlands beach
'The exception for the use of prime agricultural land is for essential renewable energy. I would argue that Coupar Angus has done its bit for renewable energy already and I don't believe this is now classed as essential in this area.
'I feel the need for prime agricultural land outweighs the need for renewable energy in this area.'
Conservative councillor Ian James seconded the motion for refusal.
SNP councillor Ken Harvey moved to approve the plans and claimed the land was 'in a poor state and doesn't appear to have been used for anything other than silage the past few years'.
Following a brief recess, he corrected himself and said: 'I said it was getting used for silage. Obviously not, there are potatoes and what looked like turnips being grown.'
He added: 'The loss of prime agricultural land is outweighed by the benefit of solar energy we're getting. We are constrained by where the substations are for such developments and we need to take due cognisance of that going forward with the other developments but I think this development is reasonable.'
It was seconded by Bailie Mike Williamson.
Six Conservative, Independent and Liberal Democrat councillors voted to refuse the application and the five SNP councillors on the committee voted to approve the application. It was refused by one vote.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
40 minutes ago
- The Sun
Tearful Red Bull F1 staff ordered to ‘smile more' after being rocked by Christian Horner axe
TEARFUL staff rocked by Red Bull chief Christian Horner's axing have been ordered to 'smile more' by their new Austrian and German bosses. Loyal workers were stunned when the British Formula One team's supremo Horner, 51, was ousted following a stellar 20-year reign. 2 2 He helped Red Bull win eight drivers' championships and six constructors' crowns. And sources told SunSport new Austrian boss Helmut Marko upset staff who gathered to meet him at the team's HQ in Milton Keynes — with some now threatening to quit. A female Red Bull worker revealed: 'It was only a day after Christian was sacked and a lot of the team were still upset when Mr Marko addressed us. 'But he just made a joke of it and told us to cheer up — he said, 'You need to smile more'. 'It didn't endear him to anyone as what is there to smile about?' Horner's roles as chief executive officer and team principal have been usurped by Austrian team adviser Marko, 82, and German ex-football official Oliver Mintzlaff, 49. While French engineer and motorsport exec Laurent Mekies, 48, was quickly unveiled as Horner's replacement last week. But insiders have insisted Mintzlaff and Marko are now the men in the driving seat — and revealed their first address to staff at Milton Keynes was a 'car crash'. Mintzlaff sparked more anger when he joked about the brutal axing of senior staff including Horner, chief marketing officer Oliver Hughes and director of communications Paul Smith. Horner was summoned to London on July 9 believing he was attending a regular team meeting. Christian Horner 'in tears' during farewell speech to Red Bull employees as sacked boss admits decision came as 'shock' But he was then relieved of his duties on the spot and put on gardening leave. Hughes and Smith were called into an office and also told they were no longer part of Red Bull's future. They were escorted out of the building after having their company devices taken from them — leaving hundreds of staff with no bosses to answer to. And another staff member told SunSport: 'Mintzlaff also said, 'If you have any problems, just text your line manager'. 'Then he added, 'Oh, and if you don't have a line manager any more, just text me!' and started laughing.' Red Bull supremo Horner knew nothing of the plans to get rid of him, 18 months after he was accused of a sexting scandal which broke the heart of his Spice Girl wife Geri, 52. And the £12million-a-year chief was replaced within 24 hours by Marko and Mintzlaff, who arrived to address staff members, 90 per cent of whom are British. Emotional Red Bull insiders spoke in depth for the first time yesterday over their shock at the loss of their boss. They also laid bare the chaos that is now gripping this once all-conquering F1 team. And long-standing family friends who have spoken to Horner admitted he was left stunned by his ruthless removal. One told SunSport: 'Christian told me how hurt and betrayed he felt after all that he and Geri and their family have been through over the past 18 months. 'He was cleared twice over the texting scandal but is now on gardening leave and has still been given no explanation why he's lost the job he loved. 'Red Bull's Austrian bosses have always resented the fact that so much of their F1 success was down to a team that Christian built in Britain. 'That is what lies behind this — as well as the hangover from the terrible headlines last year. 'Christian was called to a London meeting and had no idea what it was about. 'He was just told, 'You have to be there' and was dumbfounded when he was ushered into a room and effectively sacked on the spot. 'It left him totally blindsided — he thought he'd been called in to speak about another issue. 'But the staff are nearly all Brits and are fiercely loyal to him and are now talking about walking out. 'It was a targeted attack for control of the race team because Red Bull's Austrian HQ didn't like a British man running their race team. 'But now the team is in chaos — Red Bull at Milton Keynes has hit the skids.'
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
Andrej Bacanin transfer bombshell as Celtic and Rangers 'on the phone' with prodigy's exit timeline set
The 18-year-old has turned heads with the SuperLiga side and their chief Vladimir Matijašević expects a sale Celtic and Rangers are reportedly keen on Cukaricki prodigy Andrej Bačanin with the club's sporting director claiming a deal to secure his exit will be struck within the next 10 days. The 18-year-old has turned heads with the SuperLiga side and their chief Vladimir Matijašević has namechecked the Glasgow giants as clubs who have been on the phone about a player tipped to become a star at international level. Brendan Rodgers and Russell Martin have both been forthright in their hunt for fresh faces, however, Matijašević appears a talent for the future despite his experience at first team level. The defensive midfielder excelled at youth level before earning significant game time last season. Speaking in his homeland, Matijašević revealed a signing battle is now taking place for the star whose imminent sale will cover the club's outgoings. He stated: "There is a lot of interest in our young players, and the current focus is on the transfer of Andrej Bačanin. He attracted the attention of numerous clubs with his performances for our team last season, as well as for the Serbian national team at his age. "We had calls from Scottish giants Celtic and Rangers, Ajax, Udinese, and some other teams are interested... It is possible that other options will emerge, and I expect the transfer to be completed in the next 10 days. I expect this to be another big exit transfer for Čukarički, which would cover our club's budget." You can get all the news you need on our dedicated Celtic page, and sign up to our newsletters to make sure you never miss a beat throughout the season.
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Westminster will never feel any heat from the FM's hot air and bluff
A credible plan that adds up and includes answers to the currency question and real figures for an independent Scottish budget. Is that too much to ask? READ MORE: Mike Small: I pored over John Swinney's strategy – here's what we must do now If this three-point plan is all we are to get from the SNP and its leadership between now and May 2026 then we are, at best, looking at ten or more years of trying, and increasingly failing, to make the devolution settlement add up. Scotland free by 2033, perhaps. Council Tax will be unaffordable for many households while radical and practical solutions like Annual Ground Rent will continue to be ignored. Jobs in vital industries will continue to be lost and the wind turbines which increasingly dominate our landscapes will continue to export their electricity to our southern neighbours. READ MORE: SNP must realise Yes groups aren't rivals – they're reinforcements John needs to wake up and smell the Scottish political coffee. It has gone well off the boil in the past 10 years. SNP support is falling well behind support for independence and this latest three-point plan will do nothing to close that gap. Apparently John is ready to 'turn the heat up on Westminster'. The last time I looked, [[Westminster]] had a massive Unionist majority – it always has and always will. They will never feel any heat from John's hot air and bluff. It is clear that the SNP's message is "keep the faith and vote for us in May so that we can just keep on doing the same as we have been doing for the past ten years for another ten years at least." John Baird Largs FRIDAY'S National devoted two full pages to 'John Swinney: Why I'm launching a renewed strategy for independence'. I firstly had to wonder if John penned this article himself, or was it the product of AI and the efforts of one of the Scottish Government's small army of special advisers, then simply approved by John? It is clear that the renewed strategy is cauld political porridge reheated and served up to try and fill the empty bellies of Scotland's independence supporters who are desperately hungry, virtually starving in fact, for new initiatives with hopefully a wee sprinkling of inspiration. I had to wait until I reached the very bottom scrapings of John's porridge bowl to find his scarce-in-detail three-part plan. The final 329 words to be exact. There are more words in this letter! READ MORE: John Swinney's plan can't be the final word on independence John claims that 'first, it will be a campaign designed to build the highest levels of support possible for independence as the best future for Scotland'. This is welcome but it's nothing new. The SNP have been trying to do it for almost 100 years. The real problem for John is that SNP support is now firmly anchored well below support for independence. Some might even argue it is dragging it down. Second in John's plan is 'building public pressure around Scotland's fundamental national rights. We are ready to turn the heat up on Westminster and its anti-democratic stance, mobilising the support, energy and the impetus of people in Scotland behind the simple idea: no ifs, no buts, Scotland has the right to choose'. This is fighting talk, just talk, but with the loss of almost all of the SNP's MPs just over a year ago, Westminster is not going to listen, John. The Scottish public need to hear what is the SNP's practical road map to independence – if they even have one. The third point: 'The way to deliver independence is only with an emphatic SNP win' is simply longhand for "vote SNP on both ballot papers so that the SNP can try to manage devolution for yet another five years." Is that the best we can hope for? Brian Lawson Paisley JOHN Swinney is asking us to imagine this and imagine that. What the hell for? It's a sure sign he is out of touch with Scotland. We don't need to imagine anything he is asking for. It might be in his imagination, but not ours. Just what does he think we have been doing since 2014? We, the people of Scotland, know what we want. So it's time he got out of his SNP bubble and talked to us through a national public convention. This is the diplomatic way forward, just to remind him. Not a dictatorial set of notions of his own making. And yes, I am still an SNP member. Alan Magnus-Bennett Fife READ MORE: Pro-independence politicians respond to John Swinney's strategy I HAVE a lot of sympathy for John Swinney. I think fundamentally he's a good guy with an almost impossible job to do. There's no doubt he's improved the SNP position since he took over. He's a good manager, but as a radical independence motivating force ... err no, that's not going to happen! I know it's been tried before (with the wrong people in my view ) but I believe John should appoint Stephen Flynn as indy minister. He already has a known media profile, he seems to have a bit of fire in him and is a bit of a disruptor. I don't know if that's a realistic possibility, but we desperately need someone from the [[SNP]] to be 100% dedicated to promoting the benefits of indy and the depressing reality of the union. We need someone to be working with other indy parties as a united front, someone who will attend rallies, etc. We need action urgently – time is running out, John!! Colin T Largs
