Neighbors back Arizona man in fight against HOA after he was repeatedly fined $100 for handing out free bottles of water
David Martin of Goodyear, Arizona, has racked up hundreds of dollars in fines this summer from the Canyon Trails Homeowners Association and its management company, FirstService Residential, for placing a cooler full of bottled water on the sidewalk near his home.
'Here we are in July, the hottest day of the year, and we are still talking about a water cooler with free cold water,' Martin told KPHO last week. 'It's ridiculous that they are adding violations to a total that's not going to get paid, because I'm giving out free water.'
Now, Martin and his neighbors have fought to unseat some HOA board members.
Martin started a petition this month to remove three HOA board members, garnering enough signatures to trigger a special vote on Thursday, local outlet 12News reports. Two board members whose seats weren't at stake attended the meeting, along with dozens of Martin's neighbors.
"I'm not the only one that sees there's something wrong in our community," Martin told 12News.
At the meeting, Martin's neighbors raised various other issues with the HOA, including concerns that their voices weren't being heard and issues weren't being fixed in a timely manner, 12News reports.
Out of 210 ballots, 190 people voted to remove the board members. Homeowners association member Deryl Riley said there were enough votes for a quorum, meaning the board members would be removed, 12News reports.
But the three board members who were removed say the vote wasn't legal, according to 12News. The members argue Martin didn't garner enough signatures on his petition. They also claim the vote was invalid because a 24-hour notice wasn't given to homeowners.
The board members also raised concerns over whether 210 votes were enough for a quorum, given the community has more than 1,000 homes.
Martin says he's prepared for a legal battle and wants to keep fighting for his cause.
"It's not just about water, it's about the community as a whole," he told 12News.
FirstService Residential previously told 12News the HOA 'does not object' to Martin handing out free water bottles, but instead takes issue with him advertising it.
'The Association does not object to a resident providing free water bottles to the community; however, the community's rules do not allow a resident to advertise water bottle distribution from a portable ice chest, located next to their garage that is visible from neighboring property,' the company said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
8 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Insane oversight in the Democratic Party's autopsy of the disastrous 2024 election
The Democratic party plans to dissect what exactly went wrong in the 2024 presidential election - with two glaring exceptions in the analysis. The 'after-action review' commissioned by the Democratic National Committee (DNC) won't question the timing of President Biden's decision to stand down shortly before the election, people with knowledge of the findings told The New York Times. The review will also steer clear of finding out whether Kamala Harris was the best pick to replace Biden following his disastrous debate performance against President Donald Trump, those briefed on its progress also told the outlet. It won't look into her campaign or the decision by staffers to frame it as a choice between democracy and fascism. Officials told the outlet that it will examine the election as a whole and not on the campaign, instead looking at actions taken by groups associated with the party, with a focus on super PACs that funded the campaigns of Biden and Harris. The Times reported that blame would be thrown at Future Forward, the party's main super PAC. Those briefed on its contents said that the group, w ho spent $560 million to support the two presidential hopefuls spent too much propping up Harris and not on attacking Trump. The group's advertising approach is to be criticized as being too focused on television programs and not effective. DNC spokesperson Rosemary Boeglin told the outlet: 'The DNC's post-election review is not a finger-pointing exercise, it's about bringing together Democrats across the ecosystem to adopt an actionable playbook to win, not just for 2026 and 2028, but to dominate for cycles to come. 'Democrats are clear-eyed about the challenges facing the party—many of which are rooted well before the 2024 cycle—and it requires all of us to make structural changes in how we run campaigns.' The review was started in March and has not yet been finalized, it is expected to be released this fall. After Trump won the election and made his return to the White House, Biden has continued to face questions over his mental decline while in office. The 82-year-old is facing a Republican led investigation probing the extent of the Democratic president's decline was understood by his top staffers. The investigation has focused on former staffers who would be privy to the most sensitive presidential discussions and his use of an autopen to sign documents. Biden has denied the claims being pushed by Trump that he did not have the focus to make decision as president. He told The Times: 'I understand why Trump would think that, because obviously, I guess, he doesn't focus much. Anyway, so - yes, I made every decision.' While being questioned by lawmakers, Biden's personal physician, Dr. Kevin O'Connor, and Jill Biden's longtime aide Anthony Bernal, have all pleaded the fifth amendment protections in recent weeks. Oversight Chairman James Comer noted that there's a pattern beginning to emerge after Biden's former deputy chief of staff and senior adviser Annie Tomasini also pleaded the fifth this week. 'There is now a pattern of key Biden confidants seeking to shield themselves from criminal liability for this potential conspiracy,' Comer wrote. 'Annie Tomasini, former Assistant to the President and Deputy Director of Oval Office Operations, pleaded the Fifth when asked if Joe Biden, a member of his family, or anyone at the White House instructed her to lie regarding his health at any time.' She also pleaded the fifth when asked about classified documents being found in Biden's garage, if the former president instructed anyone to destroy or conceal classified documents at the Democrat's home or if she's conspired with anyone to hide information on the Biden family's business affairs, Comer shared. The Kentucky Republican said this is a 'historical scandal.'
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
US justice department asks to unseal grand jury transcripts in Epstein case
The US Department of Justice asked a federal court on Friday to unseal grand jury transcripts in Jeffrey Epstein's case at the direction of Donald Trump amid a firestorm over the administration's handling of records related to the wealthy financier. The move – coming a day after a Wall Street Journal story put a spotlight on Trump's relationship with Epstein – seeks to contain a growing controversy that has engulfed the administration since it announced that it would not be releasing more government files from Epstein's sex trafficking case. Todd Blanche, the US deputy attorney general, filed motions urging the court to unseal the Epstein transcripts as well as those in the case against British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell, who was convicted of luring teenage girls to be sexually abused by Epstein. Epstein killed himself in 2019 shortly after his arrest while awaiting trial. The justice department's announcement that it would not be making public any more Epstein files enraged parts of Trump's base in part because members of his own administration had hyped the expected release and stoked conspiracies around the well-connected financier. Trump's demand to release the grand jury transcripts came after the Wall Street Journal reported Thursday on a sexually suggestive letter that the newspaper says bore Trump's name and was included in a 2003 album for Epstein's 50th birthday. The letter bearing Trump's name includes text framed by the outline of what appears to be a hand-drawn naked woman and ends with, 'Happy Birthday – and may every day be another wonderful secret,' according to the newspaper. The outlet described the contents of the letter but did not publish a photo showing it entirely. Trump denied writing the letter, calling it 'false, malicious, and defamatory' and promised to sue. Trump said he spoke to both to the paper's owner, Rupert Murdoch, and its top editor, Emma Tucker, and told them the letter was 'fake'. 'These are not my words, not the way I talk. Also, I don't draw pictures,' the president wrote on social media. The justice department said in the court filings that it will work with with prosecutors in New York to make appropriate redactions of victim-related information and other personally identifying information before transcripts are released. 'Transparency in this process will not be at the expense of our obligation under the law to protect victims,' Blanche wrote. But despite the new push to release the grand jury transcripts, the administration has not announced plans to reverse course and release other evidence in its possession. Pam Bondi, the US attorney general, had hyped the release of more materials after the first Epstein files disclosure in February sparked outrage because it contained no new revelations. A judge would have to approve the release of the grand jury transcripts, and it's likely to be a lengthy process to decide what can become public and to make redactions to protect sensitive witness and victim information. The records would show testimony of witnesses and other evidence that was presented by prosecutions during the secret grand jury proceedings, when a panel decides whether there is enough evidence to bring an indictment, or a formal criminal charge.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Trump once hosted party for ‘young women' where Epstein was the only guest, says report
Donald Trump once hosted a party with 'young women' where the disgraced late pedophile Jeffrey Epstein"was the only other guest,' according to a report. The president is under pressure to release all files relating to the Epstein case, which he has so far refused to do despite a 2024 election promise. The anecdote was part of a New York Times piece on Saturday entitled 'Inside the Long Friendship Between Trump and Epstein.' It states that 'For nearly 15 years, the two men socialized together in Manhattan and Palm Beach, Fla., before a falling out that preceded Mr. Epstein's first arrest.' The piece goes on to describe Trump hosting 'a party at Mar-a-Lago for young women in a so-called calendar girl competition, Mr. Epstein was the only other guest.' It states that the party was organized by Florida businessman George Houraney. 'Mr. Houraney recalled being surprised that Mr. Epstein was the only other person on the guest list,' it states. 'I said, 'Donald, this is supposed to be a party with V.I.P.s,' Mr. Houraney told the newspaper about the party in 2019. 'You're telling me it's you and Epstein?'' It comes just days after a bombshell report by The Wall Street Journal, which a bawdy message and doodle from Trump among an album of letters celebrating Epstein's 50th birthday. The president has denied that the drawing or letter was his doing and is now suing the Journal, News Corp, Rupert Murdoch, and two journalists. On Friday, Attorney General Pam Bondi filed a motion in New York 'to release grand jury transcripts associated with' the Epstein case.
