US judge dismisses some claims in Uber sexual assault lawsuits
U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer in San Francisco rejected some fraud and product liability claims on Tuesday.
His decision addressing 20 "bellwether" Uber cases could be a template for similar cases against the San Francisco-based ride-sharing company. A trial is scheduled for December 8.
Lawyers for passengers did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Wednesday. Uber and its lawyers did not immediately respond to similar requests.
Passengers said "Designated Driver" ads promoting Uber as a safe alternative to drunk driving should have disclosed that intoxicated people, especially women and especially late at night, faced an elevated risk of sexual assault by drivers.
The passengers also said app notifications containing Uber drivers' names, photos and "star ratings" should have disclosed drivers' prior misconduct and criminal histories.
In his 37-page decision, Breyer dismissed fraud claims based on ads saying "Don't drink and drive, call an Uber" and "Stay safe tonight. Use Uber."
The judge said reasonable consumers would view those ads merely as encouragement to use Uber, rather than drive drunk.
But he also said Uber's handling of app notifications "could form a deceptive scheme to obfuscate the risk of serious harm" when women accepted rides from drivers with histories of misconduct.
Uber said it did not intend to fraudulently withhold information, and no passengers claimed they relied on the app notifications.
Breyer also dismissed claims that Uber's app was defective because it failed to prevent high-risk pairings of drivers and passengers.
He refused to dismiss product liability claims based on the app's lacking a feature to match passengers with drivers of the same gender.
The judge previously dismissed some other claims in the bellwether cases.
In its U.S. safety report, opens new tab for 2021 and 2022, Uber said it received 2,717 reported incidents of the most serious categories of sexual assault and misconduct.
Uber also said only 0.1% of the more than 1.8 billion U.S. trips in those years had reported safety incidents, mainly about "minor" issues such as complaints about driving or verbal arguments.
The case is In re Uber Technologies Inc Passenger Sexual Assault Litigation, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, No. 23-03084.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Woman shot by Son of Sam receives chilling message from notorious serial killer during trip to library
A woman who was shot by the infamous 'Son of Sam' killer David Berkowitz was confronted by a friend of the killer earlier this week who delivered an eerie message. Wendy Savino had been inside the Valley Cottage Library in Long Island, on Wednesday when she was approached by Frank DeGennaro. The 88-year-old told The New York Post that DeGennaro approached her outside the building, claiming he told her 'David wants to talk to you'. She said: 'So I try to walk around him and he says, "you're Wendy Savino, aren't you?".' The man added: 'Well, I just want you to know David is very upset about what happened to you. David wants to talk to you. David wants you to know he didn't do it'. Following the strange comment, she asked DeGennaro to write down his name, her and her son Jason then took it to Clarkstown Police Department to file a report. She added: 'He had me backed into a corner. He's just talking and talking about the same thing, "David's a really good person".' DeGennaro told the outlet that he was called by the police but not charged, adding that he never intended to scare Savino. He said: 'I didn't corner her. I didn't stand in her way', adding that he became friends with Berkowitz after exchanging letters with the killer who remains behind bars. 'I realize now that it was probably the wrong thing to do, to even talk to her. This is getting blown out of proportion', he added. Savino was shot several times by Berkowitz - who admitted to killing six people - in her car on April 9, 1976. It was later determined that Savino was the first victim of Berkowitz in a series of violent murders that crippled the New York City. For 13 months from July 1976 to July 1977, the 'Son of Sam' carried out a killing rampage that claimed the lives of six and left seven other victims wounded. Armed with a Bulldog revolver, he hunted in the shadows, targeting mostly young couples in cars and on lovers' lanes across Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx. When he earned the nickname the .44 caliber killer in the press, the notorious murderer coined his own chilling moniker - the Son of Sam - in a letter taunting the police captain on his tail. The killer claimed that he was driven to kill by a 6,000-year-old demon named Sam which spoke to him through his neighbor's dog. The Son of Sam shootings took over the city's consciousness and filled pages and pages of the daily papers. Young women - noting a pattern of brown-haired victims - began dying theirs blonde or wearing wigs. Other New Yorkers avoided going out altogether. Then finally, on August 10, 1977, the Son of Sam - a 24-year-old postal worker from Yonkers by the name of David Berkowitz - was captured. Berkowitz was sentenced in 1978 to the maximum prison term of 25 years to life for each of the six slayings. He first became eligible for parole in 2002. He has since expressed remorse and said he is a born-again Christian. He is being held at Shawangunk Correctional Facility, a maximum-security prison in New York. Speaking with the Daily Mail last month, Berkowitz said t hat he was 'thankful to be alive, and by the grace of God do good things today with my life today.' 'The past could never be undone. I wish it could, but it's not possible. So I just have to keep moving forward,' he said. 'I am also grateful for the friends I have in my life today. These are good law abiding individuals who love me for who I am today, not for who I was in the past when a [sic] let the devil rule my mind.' But, despite the apparent regret for his crimes, the Berkowitz suggested that he was simply a passive pawn being 'used' to do the devil's bidding.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
BREAKING NEWS Memphis guard Sincere Parker arrested after allegedly choking his girlfriend during attack
Memphis guard Sincere Parker was arrested Saturday on an aggravated assault charge for an attack on his girlfriend. The woman told police that he choked her and hit her, according to court documents. She also told police that the attack occurred on May 27 at the Memphis apartment the couple shared. She reported that Parker pushed her, slapped her in the face and choked her, leaving her bruised and bloodied, according to a police report. The woman also told police that Parker broke her cellphone because he didn't want her to have the digital key to the apartment. A warrant for Parker's arrest was issued Friday and the 22-year-old was booked into Shelby County Jail in Tennessee on Saturday. An arraignment was scheduled for Monday on charges of felony aggravated assault and misdemeanor vandalism. It was not immediately clear whether Parker had an attorney. The 6-foot-3 Parker transferred to Memphis after averaging 12.2 points last season for McNeese, helping the Cowboys and coach Will Wade reach the second round of the NCAA Tournament. He played his first two seasons for Saint Louis.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Sickening moment cop launches heinous attack on adorable animal... before vile threat to his colleague
A New Mexico police officer laughed as he fatally injured a tiny baby rabbit by throwing it at his vehicle, after threatening his colleague with a TASER. Grant County Sheriff's Deputy Alejandro Gomez, 27, was caught in cellphone video from August of last year horrifically injuring the animal. In the clip, Gomez can be seen demanding that an unnamed deputy hand over the animal that was found outside the town of Hachita, near the Mexican border. The deputy who found the small critter was holding the animal close, saying that he thought Gomez would kill it. Gomez swears on his kids he won't kill the animal. He only hands it over after Gomez threatens him with a stun gun, telling him: 'Give it to me right now'. Now holding the animal, Gomez then throws it against the side of their vehicle while smiling as fellow officers laugh. According to the Albuquerque Journal, the other deputy later told New Mexico State Police that the animal was fatally injured and had to be killed so 'it would not suffer'. Gomez has been placed on leave and is facing charges of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon upon a peace officer and one count of extreme cruelty to animals. The Grant County Sheriff's Office said that he would remain on leave until the case was resolved. State Police, who are probing the incident, said the sergeant and corporal who witnessed the cruelty 'failed to intervene as required by New Mexico Statute'. Neither of the two have been placed on leave and both are still employed at the office, the journal reported. Gomez's attorney Gary Mitchell told the outlet: 'We don't think he did anything wrong, obviously. 'We're waiting to see what evidence the state has. But it sounds like an inner-office situation that should not have turned into a criminal case.' An arrest affidavit says the group of officers stopped in the road after spotting the rabbit in the middle of the road. The deputy seen reluctantly handing over the animal said that he 'believed that if he just set the animal loose, Deputy Gomez would be able to pick it up and hurt it'. It added: 'Deputy Gomez threw the animal with such force that it fatally wounded the animal. A huge thud was heard as it struck the side of the patrol vehicle.' The deputy reported the incident and the Grant County Sheriff's Office conducted their own probe. The affidavit said that the internal investigation resulted in 'little or no action being taken against the deputies or supervisors involved'. It is also claimed that Gomez and the deputy had a run in days before the incident, after Gomez pointed his Taser at the deputy after having stole the deputy's phone. A few hour after the rabbit incident it is alleged that Gomez pointed his gun at the deputy behind his back and said he was 'only testing his duty-mounted light', it adds. The clip has surfaced on social media, sparking widespread outrage over Gomez's behavior. One person said: 'That's so inhumane and these are the people that are supposed to be protecting our community.'
