Karnataka HC directs Centre to ban encrypted email service ‘Proton Mail'
The Karnataka high court on Tuesday directed the Union government to block 'Proton Mail,' an encrypted email service, based in Switzerland and available in India.
The court's direction came on a petition filed by a Bengaluru based firm, M Moser Design, seeking a direction to the Union Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology to ban proton mail after its employees and clients received several emails through Proton Mail IDs with morphed pictures, AI generated deepfake images, and sexually explicit content.
Before reserving its orders on Moser Design's petition, justice Nagaprasanna had gone through some of such emails received by the firm and remarked that the content was akin to 'porn' and said since the issue was a serious one, the centre must be directed to take appropriate steps.
At the time, the court had also asked the Union government why it cannot block all such instant messaging services and Virtual Private Networks (VPN)that do not have physical servers in India and are not amenable to Indian laws.
The petitioner firm also told the court that in the past, Proton mail had been used to send bomb threats to some schools in India. It said that while the local police was already investigating into the matter, it was yet to identify the accused since, Proton had refused to give details of the sender of such emails.
The petitioner firm's counsel, Jatin Sehgal told the court that on its website, Proton mail even guided users on how to bypass monitoring by authorities in India and that it declared that it had removed physical VPNs from India in 2022 after the union government made it mandatory for VPN providers with servers in India to store user data.
Additional Solicitor General of India, Aravind Kamath, who appeared for the Centre, however, said at the time that while India has a 'mutual legal assistance treaty' with Switzerland, since a criminal investigation into the petitioner firm's police complaint was already on, the investigating officer will now have to follow provisions of the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita and request the magistrate court to issue a 'Letter Rogatory,' which is a formal, written request to a court in another country to seek judicial assistance.
Kamath however, added that if the high court issued specific directions for blocking, the government will comply. The court then said it was inclined to exercise its jurisdiction under Article 482 of the CrPC and pass orders.
A detailed order of the High court is awaited.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
26 minutes ago
- Time of India
Rules set by Centre to deal with human-animal conflict ridiculous: min
T'puram: Forest minister A K Saseendran has said that if a tiger or leopard enters a populated area, the central rules cannot be followed, and the conditions set by the Centre are ridiculous. The minister, while responding to the reported claims by Union minister Bhupendra Yadav regarding the state's powers to kill wild animals and the electrocution of a teen in a wild boar trap at Nilambur, said the rules proposed by the Centre are impractical and cannot be followed to handle human-animal conflict. The Centre's stance on the human-animal conflict in the state was unacceptable, he said. The state govt had been asking the Union govt to permit it to declare wild boar as vermin and to remove bonnet macaque from Schedule I and II. The Union minister said that the Centre has issued guidelines to the state to implement a few measures, including giving powers to the panchayats to kill the animals if they posed a threat to human life and crops. Yadav had said that the boy's death was due to the negligence of the state govt. Saseendran termed the reported claims by the Union minister "half-truths" and "baseless". He said the Union minister was merely reiterating the allegations of the opposition with regard to the boy's death. He denied any negligence on the part of the state govt. Saseendran also said that while the chief wildlife warden (CWC) has powers to order killing of a wild animal which causes loss of life or property in populated areas, a standard operating procedure (SOP) has to be followed before issuing any such directive. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Buy Brass Idols - Handmade Brass Statues for Home & Gifting Luxeartisanship Buy Now Undo One of the requirements under the SOP is to constitute a local area committee which shall also include a representative of the National Tiger Conservation Authority, the minister said. He said that there are similar impractical requirements in the SOP which hamper the decision to be taken by the CWC. "We sent a letter requesting the central govt to give relaxations with regard to such requirements in the SOP. However, there is no response yet on that and the Union minister was silent about it when he spoke to the media," Saseendran said. He claimed that such "double standards" of the Centre were responsible for the sufferings of the people living in the hilly regions of the state.
Indian Express
28 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Newark airport videos: Delhi formally takes up matter with US Embassy
The Ministry of External Affairs has formally raised the matter with the US Embassy in New Delhi in the wake of social media videos purportedly showing an Indian national being handcuffed and pinned to the ground at the Newark airport. The Indian Consulate in New York has also been in touch with the US authorities to ascertain the details of the incident, as per sources. Posted on X by Indian-American entrepreneur Kunal Jain, the videos and photographs showed an unidentified young man being restrained by officers from the Port Authority Police Department (PAPD), the agency responsible for law enforcement across major transport hubs in New York and New Jersey Sunday night. Jain had tagged the Indian Embassy in Washington DC and External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar in his series of posts. During a call from The Indian Express to Port Authority Police Department at Newark International Airport, an officer said that 'the PAPD doesn't get involved in deportations'. 'The Ministry has formally raised the matter with the US Embassy in New Delhi. Our Embassy in Washington DC and the Indian Consulate in New York have also been in touch with the US authorities to ascertain the details,' sources in the Ministry said. 'We have so far have not received any details about the incident or the circumstances under which he was restrained, the flight he had to board or boarded and his final destination,' sources said, adding that the ministry will continue to follow up on the matter. There is still no information if the person has left Newark or has arrived in India, as per those aware of the matter.
The Hindu
32 minutes ago
- The Hindu
BJP leaders in Jharkhand, Bihar laud Modi govt.
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Smriti Irani in Jharkhand and Union Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal in Bihar listed out the achievements to commemorate the 11 years of the Narendra Modi-led government at the Centre. Addressing a press conference at the BJP office in Patna, Mr. Meghwal said the scale and speed of the schemes have changed under the Prime Minister's leadership. He cites an example that earlier also there was a plan to build houses but the amount was less and it took more time. 'But when the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana was launched by the Modi government, the amount increased, the scale increased and the time of its completion also decreased,' Mr. Meghwal said in the presence of Bihar BJP president Dilip Kumar Jaiswal. In Ranchi, a professional meet was organised by the BJP's Ranchi Rural District wing. Speaking as the chief guest, Ms. Irani said, 'The BJP government under the leadership of Modiji is not hungry for power but to serve the poor farmers and women in villages.' The Jharkhand Mukti Morcha termed the celebration a 'mockery of people's pain and unanswered questions'. Party spokesperson Tanuj Khatri said the ground reality here does not reflect the grand celebrations. 'It echoes with the cries of the people, their struggles,' he said.
