Huge ‘Jack & the Beanstalk' tree towers over our homes – it's grotesque & irresponsible… but council won't chop it down
TREE-FI-FO-FUM Huge 'Jack & the Beanstalk' tree towers over our homes – it's grotesque & irresponsible… but council won't chop it down
A GIANT "Jack and the beanstalk" tree is ruining locals' lives - but the council won't chop it down.
Residents in Winchester, Hants, slammed the "grotesquely irresponsible" and "ludicrous" 45 foot high oak.
9
A huge "Jack and the beanstalk" tree is ruining locals' lives - but the council won't chop it down
Credit: Solent
9
Locals called the council "grotesquely irresponsible"
Credit: Solent
9
The oak is under a protection order
Credit: Solent
They say the tree was planted around 50 years ago by a previous homeowner on Canon Street who just "wanted something to do".
But now it has branched into an "out of proportion" eyesore which overshadows the gardens of nearby properties - where the average house price is more than £600,000.
However, the council have refused to cut it down and placed it under a protection order.
The authorities said residents from a neighbouring street "appreciated" the tree.
The decision has sparked outrage among locals who are actually dealing with the daily repercussions of such an overwhelming tree.
Orla Williams, 40, moved into her terraced Grade II Listed home with her partner around two years ago.
The doctor said after moving in, several residents went to her about the oak.
She explained: "They were concerned that it is getting very large and that it could cause damage to their properties and potentially harm to people if it gets any larger, so they wanted it to be taken down.
"We applied to the council to have it removed and someone came to look at it.
"[The tree officer] said that they want to put a tree protection order on it."
The mum-of-two also told how an "awful lot of detritus" falls from the tree in autumn and winter.
She added: "We appreciate that the tree is beautiful but it's the wrong tree in the wrong place.
"It is quite sad to remove something like that but it is only going to get bigger and potentially cause damage to lots of properties which is the main concern.
"The council said they were concerned about removing it because it's one of the only trees in the area.
9
Orla Williams stood in her back garden with the tree
Credit: Solent
9
Residents fear the tree poses safety risks
Credit: Solent
9
Mark Pocock slammed the council's decision to protect the tree as "ludicrous"
Credit: Solent
"All of the local residents seem to be of the opinion that unfortunately, it's the wrong tree in the wrong place."
According to a council report, the tree officer visited Orla after receiving notice from the couple that it was due to be felled.
But he found the tree met the criteria for a provisional protection order, which was issued in February of this year.
A Winchester County Council meeting will take place next week to decide whether the tree status will change or not.
There are nine residents in total who have objected to the order.
Mark Pocock, a retired resident living on Canon Street, slammed the council's decision to protect the tree as "ludicrous".
He said: 'As trees grow older they become more brittle.
"If it were to fall and damage properties or persons, I would say the responsibility would be entirely with the council – not the owners of those properties.
"I think putting a tree protection order on is grotesquely irresponsible of the council.
'It could be a danger to property and life."
Nick Goff, 80, said he fears if the tree continues to grow, the roots underneath will damage a medieval wall in his garden, which was built in the Tudor era.
The retired British Airways pilot said: "The issue is that in 10 years time, that will be double the height and double the width.
'It put on six feet last year it it's going to put on another six feet this year."
He commissioned an independent report from a tree consultancy business.
The report stated while the tree, which is still a "teenager" is in "good physiological condition".
But the officer also found it is "a large sized tree in a very small area" and so the tree protection order is "unjustified".
The report also stated "the possibility of longer term damage to the retaining walls and footings of the adjacent properties as entirely foreseeable".
"Some guy planted this as something to do 40 years ago," Mr Goff continued "Now, we have got Jack and the Beanstalk.
"It's not a historic tree – it's a silly mistake."
However, the council report issued ahead of next week's meeting claimed these concerns were "speculative" and the tree "contributes meaningfully to local biodiversity and visual amenity".
It added: "It is also the last significant tree in an area of land between Canon Street and St Swithun's Street, enhancing the character of the conservation area."
Retired resident Graham Rule, 62, blasted the decision as "irresponsible".
He said: "We all love trees but that shouldn't be there.
"The people who want the protection order, they don't live here – its totally irresponsible."
Winchester County Council was contacted for comment.
9
Nick Goff said "it's not a historic tree – it's a silly mistake"
Credit: Solent
9
A decision will be made over the protection order at a meeting next week
Credit: Solent
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
09-08-2025
- Daily Mail
Six-bedroom 17th century manor with walled gardens on sale for just £150,000 - but there's a BIG catch
A sprawling six-bedroom 17th century manor has hit the market for a remarkably low £150,000 because it needs 'unprecedented' levels of repair work. Grade II listed, oak-timber framed manor house, Burghill Lodge, is nestled in the middle of Hereford's idyllic countryside and presents a remarkable opportunity for prospective buyers. The building was listed in 1952 and when resurveyed in 1986, was described as being in a 'ruinous condition' as only some sections of masonry and the timber frame remained. More than 30 years after it was denounced as being in desperate need of some handy work, it then was listed on the market for £450,000. However, the condition of the building has deteriorated so much in the near decade since that the property's value has been slashed by a whopping two thirds - meaning it is available to buy for around the average price of a one-bedroom home in the UK. It is believed to have been the manor for one of the largest dairy farms in Europe but it has not been lived in for more than 100 years. However, the house was abandoned when the family who owned it built a larger 12-bedroom property nearby. This project allowed Burghill Lodge to fall into disrepair and its condition has continued to worsen over time. The Grade II listed building presents the opportunity for a prospective buyer to bring the property back to its former glory. Above (left) is the current state of Burghill Lodge side by side with how it would look after renovations (right) Now, it is being advertised as a 'unique' and 'prized' opportunity for those looking to undertake a significant restoration project. Listing agent Glasshouse said planning consent was in place for work to commence to create a huge six-bedroom home in the diminutive village of Canon Pyon. The property's listing reads: 'Burghill Lodge offers an unprecedented opportunity to undertake the restoration of the grand oak frame Manor House, creating an extraordinary family home of approx. 6000 sq. ft, with proposed six double bedrooms, four en-suites and orientated to overlook part-walled private gardens. 'Currently, the house is a shell, with its stunning oak timber frame stripped back, treated and supported by a scaffolding cover - ready for year-round work to commence, with planning consent. 'Enjoying a slightly elevated position, the Manor dominates its rural surroundings, set in the triple village parish of Burghill, Tillington and Canon Pyon; combining to offer local stores with post office, primary schools, golf club and gastropubs. While the full city amenities of Hereford are five miles or the market town of Leominster ten miles.' Burghill House hitting the market comes just days after another listed building, this time a spectacular Grade I, 175ft tall tower, was put on sale for £2.78million. Hadlow Tower - or 'May's Folly' as locals call it - is the tallest Gothic folly in the world and boasts four bedrooms over five floors. The tower, which underwent a £4.2m restoration in 2013, is 6ft taller than Nelson's Column and surrounded by private gardens, woodlands and even a picturesque lake. It also boasts a parapet with stunning 360-degree views of quaint Hadlow village in Tonbridge, Kent. Despite giving the appearance of having come straight from the pages of a fantasy novel, the historic tower has all the features of a modern family home. Once part of a Romantic Gothic style 18th-century castle, the tower is accessed through a triple-arched entrance on the village high street. The tower's current owner explained that though he and his family had been privileged to live at Hadlow Tower for the past few years, his work was taking him abroad, meaning he'd have to part ways with the home. The first floor features an octagonal dining room, a unique arched recess and sculptured oak doors from the original castle He said: 'My family and I have thoroughly enjoyed our time here, including the peaceful and tranquil environment. Although where we are is private and peaceful, Hadlow high street is at the end of the lane. 'This charming village is in a Conservation area and includes many attractive period properties and a variety of shops, pubs, hairdresser, restaurant, church, library and a medical centre. 'For the more energetic, there are cricket and bowls clubs as well as a good primary school and the renowned Hadlow College of Agriculture and Horticulture that includes the Broadview Gardens complex that has a tearoom and florist and where you can enjoy wandering around the grounds. 'Other facilities are available in nearby Tonbridge, including excellent grammar and private schools, independent shops and high street stores, pubs, restaurants, a theatre and the station - where trains to London take around 30 to 40 minutes. 'There is also the Tonbridge School leisure club, while for golfing enthusiasts there are numerous golf clubs and courses within a radius of nine miles around Hadlow, including the local Poult Wood Public Golf Centre.'
Daily Mail
01-08-2025
- Daily Mail
Is YOUR name going extinct? Find out with our search tool
The names Jack, Harry and Emily are dying out, according to data that shows how monikers common in the 90s are going out of fashion. Jack, which sat atop the boys' names popularity list every year between 1996 and 2008, last year ranked 22nd, with just 1,711 babies being given the name. This is a fall of more than 4,000 (70 per cent) compared with 10 years ago, marking the biggest decrease of all 6,000-plus boy names. Harry, also once top of the charts, has had tumbled by 3,600 (67 per cent) and now sits 20th, with a continuing downward trajectory. For girls, Emily and Jessica saw the biggest falls in the past 10 years, from 3,991 to 1,170 (-70 per cent) and 2,995 to just 483 (-84 per cent), respectively. Both names were among the most common in the 1990s. The Daily Mail has built a new search tool which shows how your name has risen or plummeted in popularity over the last few decades. To use our interactive below, first select your gender, then search for your name in the box and select it from the dropdown menu. It will then tell you how many babies of your sex and name were born this year and how popular it is, how it has changed from its heyday, and in what years the name reached its peak position in the charts. You can then compare your name against up to five more names of any gender. Our tool comes as official data yesterday crowned Muhammad as the most popular boys' name in England and Wales for the second year running. More than 5,700 boys were given the name in 2024, according to the Office for National Statistics (ONS). This represents a significant 23 per cent rise since the year before – the first time it topped the list – when around 4,660 boys were named after the Islamic prophet. It tops our biggest risers list. In 1996, just 441 baby boys were given the name Muhammad. Mohammed entered the top 100 boys' names for England and Wales 101 years ago, debuting at 91st in 1924. Its prevalence dropped considerably in the lead up to and during WW2 but began to rise in the 1960s. That particular iteration of the name was the only one to appear in the ONS' top 100 data from 1924 until Mohammad joined in the early 1980s. Muhammad, now the most popular of the trio, first broke into the top 100 in the mid-1980s and has seen the fastest growth of all three iterations since – seeing a 12-fold increase in the past three decades. Another popular name rising the charts is Arlo, an old English word for 'fortified hill' which saw a rise from 397 in 2014 to 2,220 in 2024 for a total change of 1,823 (459 per cent). Olivia held onto the top spot for girls for the ninth year running, with 2,761 girls being given the name by their parents last year. Despite still being top pick, the name is falling fastly out of fashion – down by 1,963 since 2014 (-42 per cent). Amelia (2,448) also held on to the second spot for the third year in a row, but Isla (2,056) dropped out of the top three after being replaced by Lily (2,185). Names inspired by pop culture have proved popular, with Maeve – which surged in popularity after the 2019 debut of Netflix's Sex Education, starring Emma Mackey as the fiercely intelligent Maeve Wiley – growing the most of all girls' names. Just 61 infants were given the name in 2014, compared to 1,264 last year, a rise of 1,204 – or 1,974 per cent. Otis, the lead from the same show played by Asa Butterfield also saw a rise in popularity at the same time, from 164 in 2014 to 762 in 2024. Hollywood is also a popular inspiration, with Margot (1,243) – a name shared Australian Barbie actress Margot Robbie – has seen steady rises in popularity over the past few years, peaking this year in 28th place, a rise from 44th in 2023. Meanwhile, the Prime Minister appears to have killed off his own name for good. Keir did not appear in the list of names last year. This could mean it has gone extinct completely, although the ONS hides actual figures for names with fewer than three instances.
BBC News
29-07-2025
- BBC News
Maryport Christ Church window damage delays museum opening
Damage to the windows of a Grade II listed church have been blamed for yet another delay in its Church in Maryport, Cumbria, is undergoing major renovation to reopen as the town's Maritime was initially expected to finish in spring 2024, but Cumberland Council, which is behind the project, said the museum would now open in autumn authority said some of the building's windows were more damaged than initially thought, leading to delays in repairing and replacing them. "Our priority for Christ Church is to preserve and protect a building which is part of the fabric of Maryport and give it a long and successful future," said Mark Fryer, the Labour council's said working on old buildings was "never an exact science" and it was difficult to know what materials had been used in the initial construction and how they had been treated over time."While it is frustrating that the restoration has proved complicated, we are determined to get it right," he council said the issue did not affect the stained windows of the church, just those containing leaded Church is more than 150 years old and the local authority said the building had "suffered decades of deterioration" before it was bought in 2020. Follow BBC Cumbria on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
