Court to hear Bar's bid for JAC minutes in September
Published on: Wed, Jul 16, 2025
By: V Anbalagan, FMT Text Size: Syed Amir Syakib Arsalan Syed Ibrahim (left) with his lawyers Simrenjit Singh and Daniel Annamalai (right) outside the High Court after today's proceedings. Kuala Lumpur: The High Court has agreed to hear an application by the Malaysian Bar seeking the disclosure of the minutes of every meeting held by the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) since January 2023. The application is tied to an ongoing suit brought by lawyer Syed Amir Syakib Arsalan Syed Ibrahim in which the Bar appears as an intervener. In his suit, Syed Amir is challenging the constitutionality of the JAC Act 2009.
Advertisement At case management today, Justice Amarjeet Singh gave Syed Amir and the defendants – the government and the JAC – until July 30 to file their affidavits in reply. The judge also set Aug 30 as the deadline for all parties to tender their written submissions. The Bar's application, filed last week, contends that the JAC minutes must be sighted to resolve factual disputes raised in Syed Amir's amended originating summons. In an affidavit filed in support of the Bar's application, its secretary, Murshidah Mustafa, said the documents would assist the court in determining whether the case warrants referral to the Federal Court. Earlier, Syed Amir's counsel, Simrenjit Singh, urged Amarjeet to hear his client's reference application to the Federal Court first. 'The JAC members have an overreaching influence on the executive, which is not envisaged by the Federal Constitution,' said Simrenjit, who was assisted by Daniel Annamalai. That position was supported by senior federal counsel Ahmad Hanir Hambaly, appearing for the defendants. Counsel Christopher Leong, appearing for the Bar, however, called for the court to dispose of the discovery application first, pointing out that Syed Amir had in his affidavit alleged executive interference in the exercise by the JAC of its functions. 'Our application will become academic should the court allow the plaintiff's reference application,' said Leong, who appeared with B Anand Raj and Abdul Rashid Ismail. Lawyer Ramkarpal Singh, acting for Bersih – granted amicus curiae status in the proceedings – said the Bar's application should take precedence. 'The JAC Act is not unconstitutional and the plaintiff's 16 legal questions for reference are too general,' the MP and former deputy law minister said. Syed Amir filed his reference application on June 25. He is seeking a ruling as to whether the JAC Act 2009 contravenes the constitution, and whether judicial appointments made under the Act are rendered void as a result. His originating summons, filed in April, challenges the constitutionality of the JAC Act 2009, its alignment with the Federal Constitution, and the legitimacy of all judicial appointments made under its purview. He argues that the Act impinges on the supremacy of the constitution, as provided by Article 4, and that it is invalid as it violates Article 38(4), having been passed without the consent of the Conference of Rulers. Syed Amir further claims that the commission's powers breach the doctrine of separation of powers and the constitution's basic structure. He is seeking a mandamus order to compel strict adherence to Article 122B of the constitution, arguing that the prime minister has absolute discretion in advising the Yang di-Pertuan Agong on judicial appointments. The JAC is responsible for nominating judges to the superior courts and recommending candidates for top judicial roles, including chief justice and chief judges for Malaya and Sabah & Sarawak. Syed Amir contends that his legal questions are neither academic nor hypothetical, and that the outcome of the suit may affect all judicial appointments made since 2009. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available.
Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Express
2 hours ago
- Daily Express
Madius again raises 40pc entitlement: ‘Most of RM1.3 trillion debt used in peninsula'
Published on: Friday, August 08, 2025 Published on: Fri, Aug 08, 2025 Text Size: Madius also took the opportunity to ask about the status of projects proposed under the 12th Malaysia Plan (RMK-12) and questioned the government's lack of clarity on the Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) findings regarding undocumented migrants in Sabah. Kuala Lumpur: Datuk Seri Wilfred Madius Tangau, MP for Tuaran, again called on the Federal Government to honour Sabah's rightful entitlement to 40pc of the net revenue collected from the State, as outlined in the Federal Constitution. During the debate on the 13th Malaysia Plan (RMK-13) in the Dewan Rakyat, Madius reminded the government that the issue had already been discussed and agreed upon back in 1963, when Malaysia was formed. Advertisement 'We have the Malaysia Agreement 1963 in black and white. It's time to implement it. Why is this still being delayed?' he asked. Madius, who is also the Honorary President of Upko, said while Sabah contributes significantly to the national revenue, it receives far less in return. He expressed concern over the State's continuing struggle with poverty due to the lack of financial resources promised under the constitution. He further highlighted that more than 80pc of the national debt, over RM1.3 trillion, was spent in the peninsula, while Sabah's contributions have not been fairly distributed. Advertisement 'This isn't just about money, it's about the future of our people. If Sabah had its 40pc share of the revenue, we wouldn't need to beg for Federal funds to build basic infrastructure like roads or hospitals,' he said. The former Deputy Chief Minister also stressed that Malaysia's ambition to become the world's 30th largest economy won't be possible if Sabah continues to be sidelined. 'If Sabah moves forward, Malaysia moves forward. But ignoring Sabah's constitutional rights isn't just unjust, it undermines the very foundation of Malaysia itself,' he said. Madius also took the opportunity to ask about the status of projects proposed under the 12th Malaysia Plan (RMK-12) and questioned the government's lack of clarity on the Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) findings regarding undocumented migrants in Sabah. 'The people of Sabah deserve clear answers. These are issues that cannot be ignored any longer,' he added. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
‘Do not let money guide policies'
G25: Commercialisation of public services can further divide society PETALING JAYA: The creeping commercialisation of public services in Malaysia under the guise of 'financial sustainability' is concerning, says civil society group G25. Citing rising foreign student intake in public universities and preferential treatment for paying patients in public hospitals, the group of prominent retired civil servants said such trends could deny deserving Malaysians access to essential services. The group warned that such policies risk deepening socio-economic divides and undermining constitutional guarantees of equality. 'This risks creating new socio-economic divides not based on race or religion, but between those who can afford access and those who cannot,' it said in a statement yesterday. It could also be a violation of the equality provisions as enshrined in Article 8 (equality before the law) and Article 12 (equality in the administration of education) of the Federal Constitution, it added. It said that the nation's ambition to become a high-income, innovation-driven economy hinges on consistent implementation of policies. 'Malaysia's ambition to become a high-income, innovation-driven economy must be underpinned by policies that develop and retain talent as well as avoid deepening socio-economic inequalities,' it said. The group also warned that economic advancement must be matched by improvements in governance and civil liberties. 'As the saying goes, when the stomach is full, people expect higher standards. 'Failure to meet these expectations could lead to resentment that could be exploited by extremist narratives,' it added. MCA president Datuk Seri Dr Wee Ka Siong, who first raised the issue, said he was not alone in his concerns about public university admissions. 'The G25 shares my apprehension about the commercialisation of these institutions, whereby the rich can just enrol in our public universities as long as they can afford the high tuition fees. 'This could impact access for less affluent Malaysian students, despite their academic excellence,' he said in a Facebook post yesterday. He noted that such practice was reminiscent of the Rakan KKM policy, where money allows one to skip the queue for medical treatment. 'Kudos to G25 for their courage in speaking the truth,' added Dr Wee. On Wednesday, Dr Wee reiterated his concerns about the sharp rise in foreign student enrolment at Malaysia's public universities which is outpacing that of local students, raising red flags about allocation of placements. Citing a recent study by the Institute of Strategic Analysis and Policy Research (Insap), he said the number of Malaysian students enrolling in public universities increased modestly from 172,719 in 2018 to 191,450 in 2024, reflecting a 10.8% rise and a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of mere 1.73%. In stark contrast, non-Malaysian enrolment surged from 10,003 in 2018 to 19,731 in 2024, marking a 97.3% increase and a CAGR of 11.99%. While not against the intake of international students, Dr Wee said it becomes an issue when their enrolment seems to be replacing spots meant for Malaysian students. 'We must ensure a balance that respects the educational needs of our own creme de la creme.' In response, Higher Education Minister Datuk Seri Dr Zambry Abdul Kadir denied the allegation, saying the government continued to prioritise Malaysians with no compromise on the quotas allocated for local students in public universities.
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
E-hailing driver charged with murdering son
JELEBU: An e-hailing driver was charged at the Magistrate's Court here with the murder of his six-year-old son. No plea was recorded from M. Arunkumar (pic), 36, after the charge was read to him before magistrate Norshazwani Ishak, as murder cases fall under the jurisdiction of the High Court. He was charged with murdering his son, Tishant, between 9.02am and 12.55pm on July 23 along KM25 Jalan Rompin in Bahau near here. Under Section 302 of the Penal Code, the accused can be sentenced to death or jailed between 30 and 40 years and whipped, upon being found guilty. The court fixed Sept 10 for mention at the Seremban High Court. It was earlier reported that the suspect had lodged a report on his son's disappearance in Johor Baru on July 24, claiming that the boy had gone missing near a coffee shop in Taman Bukit Indah. Arunkumar was subsequently arrested to assist in the investigation. Four days later, police reportedly found the boy's remains buried in a secluded spot near a railway line along Jalan Rompin. On Sunday, Johor police said that the accused will also be charged later on with multiple offences, including domestic violence and assault. The suspect's wife had lodged a report on July 22 claiming she was physically abused by the suspect, who also took their only child away.
