Analysis: McKenzie question looms as biggest issue for All Blacks
Such is the determination of this group of All Blacks selectors to put their own stamp on the team 12 months into the job, it is probably foolish to predict what they will do for the second Test against France.
But with Sevu Reece out as he recovers from a head injury and Scott Barrett unlikely to play after hurting an Achilles – an announcement on the skipper will be made tomorrow, which sounds ominous – Scott Robertson and company may elect to keep other changes to a minimum.
The head coach today said the biggest area of improvement for the All Blacks this week after their 31-27 win in the first Test is their ability to finish opportunities.
'We broke 20 tackles and made 13 line breaks, so that's probably a reflection of what we created,' Robertson said.
ADVERTISEMENT
'It's just the finishing part… just the ability to keep trusting your instinct. The conditions this week might be a bit different. You expect everything here [in Wellington], so we'll have to adapt to that and have the same mindset around backing ourselves.'
Improving combinations will likely lift cohesion, which would make big changes more likely for the third Test in Hamilton than Saturday at the Cake Tin.
Waiting in the wings to replace Reece
The big question — one we'll address shortly — is what the selectors do with Damian McKenzie, who was on early in Dunedin and is a chance to start in Wellington but who may be better used as a pure impact player.
The inclusion of Patrick Tuipulotu to the starting line-up – and probably alongside impressive debutant Fabian Holland — may be the extent of the changes to the pack.
The selectors rolled the dice on playing Tupou Vaa'i at blindside flanker and that was, overall, a success. There will be no complaints about the All Blacks' set piece – their last-minute scrum penalty to help close out the game was a highlight – but they will want to pressure the French lineout a little more this week.
Beauden Barrett lines up a kick against France in Dunedin. (Source: Photosport)
ADVERTISEMENT
Centre Billy Proctor, in his third Test (and first at home), was caught out defending too narrowly in the build-up to France's first try in Dunedin and later threw a wayward pass as the All Blacks swept on to the attack. But he deserves another crack on his home pitch.
The biggest call for the selectors will be how to adjust to the withdrawal of Reece, who departed after just 57 seconds at the weekend.
McKenzie was a little uncertain under the high ball but virtually all his teammates were. This, and their defensive alignments, will be the team's two work-ons this week.
Overall, McKenzie did a solid job at fullback as Will Jordan shifted to the right wing, but the selectors may want him back on the bench to allow Jordan to play in his preferred position at the back and Beauden Barrett to have full reign as game controller.
If it is a straight swap for Reece, Caleb Clarke could come into the frame but so too could the uncapped Timoci Tavatavanawai. The Highlander's power game and breakdown excellence could add a new dimension to his team's attack and defence.
Possession is nine-tenths of the law
Otherwise, the All Blacks' inability to consistently retain possession will have disappointed the coaches.
ADVERTISEMENT
Forwards coach Jason Ryan said yesterday that part of the issue was the way his players carried the ball into contact but just as important will be supporting runners finding an extra urgency, and, after being reminded of the realities of Test rugby, the All Blacks should be better here second time around.
Beauden Barrett's accuracy off the tee (five out of five) – which proved crucial in the end – and key involvements in two of his team's three tries means he is a shoo-in to continue in the No.10 jersey.
Barrett told 1News today: 'We were probably a bit disappointed with the amount of errors we made in those conditions which are perfect for running rugby.
'That came from us being a little bit too flat at the line at times, putting our skills under pressure, but also we've got to give the French defence some compliments around the way they like to connect and work hard together.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
7 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Former All Black Kevin Mealamu joins Creative NZ board, shares health update
'I always thought I'd be illustrating a few more children's books, which I've been lucky enough to do. I think even governance, I don't think it's something that many people think about doing. I think I feel really very honoured and blessed and privileged to be able to do it.' Whilst navigating the complex ecosystems of governance, having joined the board of New Zealand Rugby too, Mealamu has also been on the mend after finding out he has a heart condition known as Atrial Fibrillation, which causes an irregular heartbeat. Keven Mealamu (right) with All Blacks teammate Jerome Kaino and the Webb Ellis trophy after winning the Rugby World Cup final in 2015. Photo / Photosport Last year, he shared footage on social media showing him collapsing at a gym. He found out he had the condition after two heavy training bouts in preparation for a charity boxing event in 2022. 'Sometimes when I look back, I think to myself, 'what was I thinking?' But it's probably that mentality of coming out of professional sports, just loving the opportunity to challenge yourself,' Mealamu tells Culture 101. Since then, he's undergone medical procedures and been in and out of hospital to treat it for the past three years. 'I had one done before Christmas and it had been in rhythm. But I found out a couple of weeks ago it's gone back into AFib again. 'I don't have the symptoms where some people find it really hard to walk or [it] just comes on really spontaneously. But I'm able to control mine.' Bringing a lens that connects people Mealamu's ultimate dream to be an All Black was always a clear vision in his head. But he knew he couldn't just sit and wait around – someone had to pay the bills, he says. So while chasing a professional rugby career, he took on an apprenticeship opportunity that came via his school coach: signwriting. To get to his workplace, he remembers he would bike from Māngere to Ōtara, which he considered part of his training as well. 'I can't remember how many times I'd get a flatty and have to be shamefully walking my bike all the way home. So when I had the opportunity to go into rugby, it was probably one of the cool things. I was like, 'yes, I don't have to bike to work anymore'.' Keven Mealamu thanks his supporters after his last game for the Blues at Eden Park, Auckland on June 12, 2015. Photo / Photosport Now he sees how the two fields – art and sport – align in that they can both have an impact on the community. 'You can feel the passion in what both art and sport do. You can feel the passion in who's presenting it,' Mealamu says. 'You look at one of the most influential rugby players around in the world at the moment, Ardie Savea, and just the way he expresses himself and the way he carries himself, there's a strong cultural bit to him as well.' Being at the helm is a big part of who he is, he says, having captained the All Blacks three times and remaining a key part of the leadership group for more than a decade. 'I think what I do bring to the [Creative New Zealand] board is an authentic Pacific Island New Zealander leader. So that lens, I think, is really important. A lens that has been through community all the way to the very top of my sport but also work[s] well with other leaders and community.' But if there's something he's wistful about, it's the fact he didn't join earlier. 'I just wish I was on earlier to be able to share that moment with my Mum, because as proud as I am being able to have both my parents around as I became an All Black, this one also would have been something that she would have been really proud of as well.' – RNZ
NZ Herald
8 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Scott Robertson's All Blacks: The promising signs from series win
Banishing the second-half blues Down 19-17 at halftime, the All Blacks saved their best for the last 40 minutes. The confidence in the team grew as the game went on. Even captain Ardie Savea was slightly out of sorts in the first quarter, but by the end of the match he was providing the sort of inspirational leadership he did for Moana Pasifika in Super Rugby Pacific. And if you wanted a perfect example of how confidence can grow even in the cauldron of a test, it was provided by hooker Brodie McAlister in his international debut. His first three throws to the lineout were stolen by the French. But he and the jumpers settled, the combinations started working and in the 76th minute, McAlister had the dream moment for a new All Black. The hooker slid across the damp grass for a try in his first test, pushing his side out to an unbeatable 27-19 lead. Damian McKenzie converted to seal the match. No, it's not the All (Red And) Blacks If anything, Robertson and his selectors were tough on Crusaders during this series. Crusaders captain David Havili missed out in a crowded midfield selection and Ethan Blackadder, the pick of the loose forwards from both teams when the Crusaders beat the Chiefs in the Super final, will hopefully get the shot he deserves before the year is out. Star of the series Step up Fabian Holland, the 22-year-old lock who showed in three stellar performances that he has the mental hardness to go with his range of huge physical gifts and impressive skills. At their best, All Blacks World Cup teams have had outstanding locks ranging from Gary Whetton and Murray Pierce in 1987 to Brad Thorn and Sam Whitelock in 2011 and Whitelock and Brodie Retallick in 2015. At the risk of putting far too much pressure on a young man at the start of his international career, Holland is surely a player around whom they can build the pack for the 2027 World Cup. Fabian Holland has been impressive for the All Blacks in the series against France. Photo / Photosport Welcome back Jordie Barrett didn't enter the contest in Hamilton until the 54th minute, but his impact at second five-eighths was dramatic. It's not completely out of the question to say he possibly saved the match with terrific cover defence, and then sealed it with a startling moment on attack. First, with just 22 minutes to go, he managed to haul the quicksilver French wing Émilien Gailleton over the sideline and save a try that would have put the visitors ahead 24-22. That touch of defensive brilliance was matched offensively when Barrett sent McAlister over for the try that sealed things for New Zealand. It can be easy to forget how big and strong Barrett is. Before slipping the perfect pass to McAllister, he fended off the 135kg French lock, Romain Taofifénua, with the ease of someone swatting away a pesky fly at a picnic. The All Blacks have Quinn Tupaea offering huge physicality, the promise demonstrated by Timoci Tavatavanawai and, in the background, the great rugby intelligence of David Havili. If there's one position in the side that suddenly feels well resourced it's second five-eighths. Why the ref was right A minor controversy has arisen over the massive cross-field pass by Will Jordan to Sevu Reece that ultimately led to the try on the stroke of halftime by Anton Leinert-Brown. Replays show that where Reece received the ball he was well in front of where Jordan was when he threw the pass. Quite correctly the pass was not called forward by referee Angus Gardiner. Why? Because for several years now the key issue in the rules is whether the ball was travelling backwards when it left the passer's hands. That judgment is usually made by checking whether the passer's fingers are pointing towards his or her own goal-line. Both of Jordan's hands are pointing at the New Zealand line. Conspiracy corner Given that conspiracy theories are dominating world political headlines it was perhaps inevitable that rugby in the past couple of weeks has had its share. French coach Fabien Galthié didn't hold back with the French media after the second test was lost in Wellington. He claimed incorrect refereeing cost the French two penalty tries. The weird touch was that he then swore he was actually 'not complaining', and I think he probably meant it. For me it was a wonderful reminder that the French, in rugby and life, look at the world very differently from us. I still have memories of the salacious delight my schoolmates and I took from a story in the Herald by the great Terry McLean when the French first toured here in 1961. In Nelson, at the first training session a forward needed to relieve himself. He didn't seek out the privacy of a toilet, McLean reported, but instead strolled to the nearest goal post and peed on it. Vive la difference, as they say. France head coach Fabien Galthié said he was "not complaining" about the referees. Photo / Photosport No complaints On the other hand there can be no real complaints from the New Zealand under-20 side about their 23-15 loss to South Africa in the final of the world tournament in Italy. It was still a terrific effort by the Kiwi side to make the final, having to overcome a potent French side 26-24 in their semifinal. It was the first time since 2017 New Zealand had reached the final. France in particular have benefitted at test level from under-20 graduates. Hopefully we may soon do the same. Phil Gifford is a Contributing Sports Writer for NZME. He is one of the most-respected voices in New Zealand sports journalism.
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Du'Plessis Kirifi keen to add to All Blacks openside legacy
Du'Plessis Kirifi didn't have much time to think about his first All Blacks start. He was thrust into the run on side moments before kickoff in the third and final test against France in Hamilton after Luke Jacobson was a late withdrawal. Kirifi would start at openside, with captain Ardie Savea switching to No.8. "To play any game for the All Blacks is special, but to be told you're starting out of the blue, you don't have enough time to really react," Kirifi said. "But when you get a moment in the changing room before you run out, I think it starts to sink in that you're going to be wearing the No.7 jersey for the All Blacks." Du'Plessis Kirifi scores against France. Photo: Brett Phibbs / Openside flanker is one of the most scrutinised positions in the All Blacks and whoever wears the No.7 jersey will inevitably be compared to the likes of Richie McCaw and Sir Michael Jones. "Then there's a little pressure of who has gone before and who has worn that jersey in the past," Kirifi said. "I hope that tonight in the tinniest way possible that I could help out and benefit the (All Blacks) No.7 legacy." Kirifi insisted he wasn't overwhelmed by the late call up to the starting XV, though he said it was always bittersweet when it was because of an injury to another player. "We're all professionals and we're all prepared to play. In the first test Damian McKenzie came on one minute into the game. You're always prepared for that situation. Whether or not it happens is another question. "Obviously I'm gutted for Luke (Jacobson). He's worked extremely hard to get back into the environment and into the starting jersey." Du'Plessis Kirifi celebrates with Ruben Love. Photo: Brett Phibbs / Kirifi said you had to prepare as if you were going to play 80 minutes. "Physically, you're still getting the work done throughout the week. Mentally, I think if you let yourself fall into the trap of 'I'm only going to come on for 10 or 20 minutes', then when something like tonight happens, you're caught out," Kirifi said. "As we've seen throughout the week we've had multiple injuries in our back line. So Will Jordan, who wasn't even supposed to be playing, is now starting (late replacement for Rieko Ioane). That's the reality of contact sport. Prepare to play and if the time comes you're ready." Kirifi not only made his first test start but also scored a try in the All Blacks come from behind 29-19 win, which sealed a 3-nil series sweep . "Obviously it's pretty cool to get your first test try for the All Blacks," Kirifi said. "A pretty typical No.7 try. A bit opportunistic there at the end of a loose ball... I was just extremely lucky on the back of a good kick and a good chase. "A cool moment getting the first meat pie (try), but I was just really glad that the pressure we were applying throughout that second half found a way to turn into points." Du'Plessis Kirifi of New Zealand celebrates his try, New Zealand All Blacks v France. Photo: Brett Phibbs/ Kirifi and the All Blacks will have a small break before turning their attention to the Rugby Championship. The squad is named early next month, with the All Blacks first game in Argentina on 17 August. Kirifi was honest in his assessment about how much he had learned after three weeks of test rugby. "I'm not going to lie. Not a lot," Kirifi said. "You always know it's a step up and you try to prepare as best as possible. Whether or not you're prepared is another question. "I've always been aware of the intensity, the physicality and the level up that it is. My job and the challenge for me is to just continue to keep growing and trying to reach that intensity and that level accurately." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
