Evanston teacher preps discrimination complaint as advocates say appeals for Palestinian human rights are squelched
Speakers with affiliations to Northwestern University and Evanston Township High School, community members and parents gathered at Lake Street Church to discuss several instances where they felt their voices had been suppressed when they spoke out advocating for Palestinian human rights.
One of the speakers, Evanston Township High School history teacher Andrew Ginsburg, spoke about how ETHS has sanctioned him twice: once for displaying an image calling for Jewish people to dissent when necessary, and once again for displaying a letter explaining that the first image was removed at the behest of the school district. The letter called the removal of the poster an act of censorship.
In response to the sanctions he has received, he said he plans to submit a federal civil rights complaint against the school.
Ginsberg, who is Jewish and advocates for Palestinians' human rights, told Pioneer Press that he has done no wrong, despite his job at the high school hanging in the balance after receiving the two warnings.
'[The district] has taught us to be relevant to the kids. They've taught us that you can't get the kids to share stuff about their lives if you don't share stuff about your life. I think I've been consistent with that, and I'm being punished for it,' Ginsberg said.
The original poster Ginsburg displayed was a drawing of a shiviti amulet that Jewish artist Liora Ostroff created for the magazine Jewish Currents. The drawing was influenced by an essay titled 'Dissent' by Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel, who wrote, according to several sources, 'Dissent is indigenous to Judaism.'
Ginsberg and his attorney, Rima Kapitan, plan to file a complaint to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, alleging that the school discriminated against him based on his religious identity.
'We feel that the school is violating his First Amendment right and also Title VII of the Civil Rights Act,' Kapitan said.
Though his situation has received some attention from Evanstonians, Ginsburg said it is not unique, and that other people in Evanston, including Jews, have also felt backlash and repercussions for advocating for Palestinian human rights.
'This has happened to other teachers. This is happening at Northwestern [and] all over the place. This is happening in the city,' Ginsberg said. 'We like to talk about how progressive we are up here, but when it comes to Palestine… all the institutions in the city have gone out of their way to silence everybody (who) wants to talk about Palestine.'
Speakers at the panel represented several Evanston institutions, including the Evanston Public Library, Northwestern University and Skokie/Evanston School District 65. 'You can't talk about Palestine in elementary school, you can't talk about Palestine in high school, and you can't talk about Palestine at college,' said co-host of the panel and former Evanston Librarian Lesley Williams.
Last October a student group at Northwestern University, Jewish Voice for Peace Northwestern, celebrated the Jewish holiday of Sukkot at Deering Meadow. The group set up a structure with banners that read, 'Gaza Solidarity Sukkah' and 'Stop Arming Israel.'
The group intended to celebrate the holiday for the entire week, but was ordered to leave after a few hours. Northwestern University's Vice President of Global Marketing and Communications Jon Yates told Pioneer Press then that Jewish Voice for Peace did not get its event application approved, and that the group's temporary structure did not follow the university's display policy.
But the university's efforts to enforce its own code of conduct and display policy went further than that night, according to Isabelle Butera, a member of the Northwestern chapter of the Jewish Voice for Peace.
'We tried again to do this in compliance with these new restrictions, and we were told again that this was in violation, that we could all be facing expulsion, and that it was very clearly implied to us that the reason we were in violation is because our sukkah had a banner on it that said, 'Stop arming Israel' and 'Gaza Solidarity Sukkah,'' she said.
'Since then, a number of us have been placed on disciplinary probation. I graduated in June, and my probation is not up until September… Our club was put on probation,' Butera said.
Shirin Vossoughi, a professor at the university, said Northwestern has a history of creating a 'repressive environment' when it comes to discussing Palestine, and it existed before Hamas' Oct. 7, 2023 attack against Israel. The university's practice of doing so was exacerbated after the university updated its code of conduct, she said.
'I think the fundamental question for me as an educator is, 'What does it mean for our educational institutions to contradict the mission of the university to such a degree?'' she said.
'We want our students to interpret evidence. We want our students to stand up against moral injustices… They're [the students] punished, and I feel like what we've done essentially is sacrifice some of our education principles and mission in order to protect a state that is enacting genocide,' Vossoughi said.
Northwestern University President Michael Schill is slated to appear for a second time before a congressional committee over alleged antisemitism on campus, according to a June 30 Chicago Tribune article.
The committee chair, U.S. Rep. Tim Walberg, a Michigan Republican, accused Northwestern of failing to fulfill its commitment to protect Jewish students.
Reine Hanna, Evanston Township High School District 202's director of communications, told Pioneer Press the district does not comment on matters related to personnel. Yates, of Northwestern, did not respond to a request for comment after Sunday's event.
As of last month, upwards of 55,000 Palestinians had been killed in the Israel-Hamas war, according to Chicago Tribune sources. The war began when Hamas-led fighters killed around 1,200 people, mostly Jewish civilians, in the Oct. 7, 2023 attack and abducted 251 hostages, according to sources.
Israel says 58 hostages remain in captivity, with about 23 of them said to be alive, according to previously published reporting.
The U.N. human rights office says it has recorded 613 Palestinians killed within a month in Gaza while trying to obtain food, according to Tribune sources. Previously, international humanitarian nonprofits oversaw food distribution, but the Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation has taken over.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
9 hours ago
- New York Post
Voters' Zohran Mamdani fears: Letters to the Editor — July 19, 2025
The Issue: New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani's socialist, anti-police, antisemitic record. Zohran Mamdani is like an old-time politician: One who panders to voters by saying he will do one thing while he has talked, for years, about doing just the opposite ('Zohran tells rich to Grin & $hare it,' July 16). He has already fooled that idiot Rep. Jerrold Nadler into endorsing him. Next he will get Sen. Chuck Schumer — who is looking to save his seat from Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez — to tell us that he, too, is endorsing Mamdani and that Mamdani is a friend of Israel. They are all phonies and liars of the first degree. You simply cannot believe a word that comes out of their mouths. The next thing they say will be that Mamdani really loves the Jewish people and that he is going to convert to Judaism. The problem is that some Jews in New York City would probably believe it. Alan Brooks Brooklyn If Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries endorse mayoral candidate Mamdani, then there needs to be a vote on the floor to change the 'Democratic Party' to the 'Socialist Party.' Robert Neglia The Bronx It's ironic that Mamdani is campaigning against unaffordable housing, high grocery prices, poor education and high costs of living when all those things are the result of Democrats' policies. They have employed a huge number of unnecessary, unproductive bureaucrats, who have produced destructive regulation, thus creating corruption, costly delays for business and high taxes. They also created the most expensive failed education system in the world. Mamdani is selling 'snake oil,' claiming he can solve the unaffordable housing crisis by simply repeating the Democratic failed system of regulation, high taxes, unaffordable housing and pushing out the city's productive, wealthy taxpayers. In addition to that, Mamdani and much of the left essentially support Hamas and its antisemitic policies. Anton Loew Manhattan We're about 100 days out from the election and the talking heads act like the New York City mayoral election has been called and Mamdani has won. After the last few presidential elections, I do not know how anyone is confident about a pick right now. The city appropriately has a wide field coupled with a frustrated electorate — it's anyone's game. Deirdre Harvey Valley Stream Democrats should be worried about Mamdani. He's like a snake-oil salesman: full of charm but his platform is for the radical left. Defunding the police appeals to insurrectionists, lawbreakers and those who lack common sense. And that's just one of his off-the-wall ideas. He talks about the rich like they're dirt. Well, to clue him in, that's who will be paying for his giveaways. Brenda Hodgkiss Atlantic Highlands, NJ To everyone wondering if Mamdani is a communist, there's an old, old saying: If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck. Bruce Collins Middletown, NJ Mamdani the commie is right: Businesses will not leave New York City if he is elected mayor. To make a terrible comparison, businesses are like a domestic-abuse victim who keeps returning to an abusive spouse, hoping to be treated better. It's not going to happen. Brien Hollowood Saratoga Springs To understand who Mamdani is, one needs to look no further than at the people who tripped over each other to greet him in Washington, DC ('AOC's party favor for her fellow lefty,' July 17). The usual lefty lunatics: AOC, Bernie Sanders, Nadler, Pramila Jayapal, Ayanna Pressley and others are on the socialist bandwagon, swooning over him. That should be all you need to know to conclude that Mamdani is a bad choice for New York City. Bo Madden Jupiter, Fla. It's time to get serious, New York; this lunatic Mamdani must and can be defeated. Several hundred thousand voted for him, but there are millions who didn't vote at all. They must mobilize against him. Sharon Wylie Westport, Conn. Want to weigh in on today's stories? Send your thoughts (along with your full name and city of residence) to letters@ Letters are subject to editing for clarity, length, accuracy, and style.
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
I want to know what's in the Epstein files. But there could be a price.
I was watching the Benny Johnson show the other day, which I often do for my job, not my pleasure, when I caught an interview with Mike Benz, the former alt-right vlogger–turned–GOP conspiracy theory constructor. He'd been brought on the show to make sense of the bomb that had just been dropped on the MAGA base by Trump's Justice Department: The long-promised Epstein files weren't coming. There was no client list, the DOJ had announced in a memo a day earlier. Further, it said, Epstein had not blackmailed anyone and there was nothing suspicious about his death, case closed. Benz, like the rest of his MAGA cohort, was livid. 'Where's our WikiLeaks? Where's our Twitter Files?' Benz demanded. It was a telling admission — and offered a kind of warning about what might ultimately come from the release of thousands of pages of records, documents, and audio and video recordings related to the Epstein investigation and indictment. There's currently a strange moment of agreement between MAGA influencers like Benz, Democratic lawmakers and much of the mainstream public over publishing the Epstein files, but what each faction wants from them — and what they'll do next should they be published as a bipartisan group of lawmakers are calling for, on a 'publicly accessible website' — will probably ignite a whole new wave of conspiracy-mongering. For many on the far right and far left, it won't matter what's actually in those files. What will matter is what people want to find in them, and how fast they can spin it into content. The most red-pilled in the MAGA base want proof of a secret world order: one run by powerful (and often, in these fever dreams, progressive, Jewish) elites who prey on — and in the internet's worst corners, literally feed on — children. In this version, Epstein wasn't just a predator, he was a secret agent in a global blackmail network controlled by billionaires, the media and the so-called deep state. At the Turning Point USA summit last week, after an earlier Q&A included MAGA activists openly criticizing Trump over the handling of the Epstein files, Steve Bannon appealed to these conspiracy theorists when he told an uncharacteristically riled-up crowd that the release would answer a 'very simple' question: 'Who governs this country? The American people or the deep state?' Conspiracy theorists on the left, branded 'BlueAnon' by critics, have their own false fixations. Among them, an allegation — stemming from a now-dismissed lawsuit against the president — that he raped a girl procured by Epstein. (There is no evidence to support such a claim, and the story behind that 2016 allegation is more complicated.) This is the crowd of bipartisan conspiracy consumers that MAGA influencers like Benz are speaking to. And it's an audience researchers say can never be satisfied. Stephen Prochaska, a doctoral candidate who studies what's known in academia as collective sensemaking at the University of Washington's Center for an Informed Public, told me how it works: Conspiracy theories in the digital age thrive on a process where communities collaborate to interpret ambiguous evidence and create narratives. Sometimes known as participatory misinformation, the goal isn't necessarily to uncover truths, but to create content that resonates with the community's existing beliefs and to transform complex, sometimes totally unrelated information into pertinent, digestible and often misleading lines that can move the story along. To gut-check my unease with a public repository of the Epstein files, I called Joan Donovan, a researcher at Boston University who researches conspiracy theories and media manipulation. 'There will never be enough information to satiate the need for more clues for the next episode of this online conspiracy theory,' Donovan said. And we've seen how that ends. WikiLeaks published hacked emails from the Democratic National Committee in 2016 on a searchable website, which conspiracy consumers and opportunistic online creators mined to fuel a narrative that birthed 'Pizzagate,' the false belief that a pedophile ring was being run out of a Washington, D.C., pizza joint, and ultimately led to QAnon, a mass delusion that posited that these pedophiles ruled the world and that Donald Trump would stop them — a theory linked to multiple murders, kidnappings and various attempts to overthrow the government. With the Twitter Files, internal documents were selectively framed to stoke an irrational panic over censorship that sparked harassment campaigns against researchers and congressional show trials. In 2022, Elon Musk handed cherry-picked emails and records from his newly acquired company to ideologically aligned writers, who twisted internal debates over content moderation into claims of widespread censorship. As The Atlantic's Charlie Warzel noted, the result was 'a drawn-out, continuously teased social-media spectacle framed as a series of smoking guns.' Ultimately, the Twitter Files led to the shuttering of academic institutions that tracked misinformation and to a flood of harassment and threats directed at researchers who studied the phenomenon. Within both WikiLeaks and the Twitter Files, there was newsworthy content. They revealed a real plot against then-presidential candidate Bernie Sanders and the messy inner workings of a social media platform grappling with how to govern in an age of misinformation. But the actual facts got lost in a flood of conspiracy theories, fermented by a group project of people digging through documents, finding crumbs and spinning them into whatever story they wanted. Real people were hurt by these conspiracy theories, which traveled further and have remained in the public consciousness longer than any of the factual reporting. Similarly the Epstein files could address real questions in the public interest. About the source of Epstein's wealth (Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., has been investigating these financial records for the last three years). About the full scope of Epstein's social circle — made somewhat public by Gawker's 2015 publication of his little black book — and what they knew. About the 'poor judgment' that led to a sweetheart deal by federal prosecutors that treated Epstein's victims as an afterthought. About how, exactly, a man in federal custody managed to kill himself in a facility so plagued by security failures that it was eventually shut down. For those late to the story: In 2008, Epstein struck a now-infamous nonprosecution agreement with then-U.S. Attorney Alexander Acosta. With it, Epstein avoided federal charges and served just 13 months in a Florida jail on the charge of soliciting a minor for prostitution, with a work-release arrangement that allowed him to leave six days a week. More than a decade later, after dogged Miami Herald reporter Julie Brown renewed scrutiny in the case and fresh federal charges for sex trafficking and conspiracy followed, Epstein was arrested in New York. But before he could face trial, Epstein hanged himself in his Manhattan jail cell. It's likely Epstein would have been convicted; prosecutors secured a 20-year sentence for Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein's longtime girlfriend and co-conspirator, on sex trafficking charges for her part in a kind of pyramid scheme in which Epstein allegedly paid minors to perform sexual massages and recruit ever-younger girls to do the same. (Maxwell's petition to vacate her sentence is currently pending before the Supreme Court.) The facts of the case were already fertile ground for conspiracy theories, but Epstein's death supercharged them. Over that weekend, Twitter lit up with claims that Epstein had become the latest entry on the infamous 'Clinton Body Count' list — an evidence-free allegation amplified by Trump himself, who reposted speculation that Epstein was murdered because 'he had information on Bill Clinton.' Now, six years later, we're in another frenzy over Epstein, this time sparked by the DOJ and FBI's 'case closed' memo and the administration's ham-fisted attempt to tamp things down. Trump has offered a dizzying set of reactions, including saying he didn't want the kind of supporters who fixate on Epstein or the files, which he now calls 'a big hoax that's perpetrated by the Democrats, and some stupid Republicans and foolish Republicans fall into the net.' After a report Thursday in the Wall Street Journal detailing a cryptic 2003 birthday card to Epstein bearing Trump's name, the president is calling on the Justice Department to seek the unsealing of 'all pertinent' grand jury testimony in Epstein's sex trafficking case. (Earlier in the week, Trump had used the qualifier 'all credible' to describe the kind of files he'd be OK with Attorney General Pam Bondi releasing.) But this won't quiet anyone down. Democrats, joined by a few Republicans who've built followings off conspiratorial clout-chasing, are still demanding a vote to publish the Epstein files. And maybe, just maybe, the files contain disturbing, disqualifying or even criminal revelations about the people in Epstein's orbit. Maybe, as some Democrats, Musk and a growing chorus of once-MAGA faithful suggest, the files contain details that would ensnare the president. Whatever the Epstein files end up being, as a journalist, I want them. But I also know what happens when a big, messy cache of information gets dropped into the middle of a post-fact attention economy. And I'm not excited. I'm nervous. The details of the Epstein case have always attracted conspiracy theorists: a rich man, powerful friends, real crimes, a sweetheart deal and a suicide. But the files aren't just evidence, they're ammunition. Depending on which citizen researcher mines them or which influencers frame what they find, the files will be used in equal measure to 'prove' Trump's innocence or guilt in all things, to confirm a liberal cabal and a conservative cover-up. Who gets caught up in the theories that follow — or the real threats those stories might inspire — is impossible to predict. If the past is any predictor, it's not Epstein (he's dead) or Trump (he's Teflon) who will be caught up in the new round of conspiracy theories. It's regular, innocent people. Prochaska, from the University of Washington, put it this way: 'What we think we're going to see may not be what we get.' This article was originally published on Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
Dem House leader Hakeem Jeffries still withholds endorsement after meeting with Zohran Mamdani
After meeting with leading New York City mayoral contender Zohran Mamdani, Minority Leader Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., issued a lukewarm statement through a spokesperson about the meeting and did not endorse his party's nominee. Mamdani, a New York state assemblyman and self-proclaimed socialist who has promised to overhaul New York City and launch massive new government programs, has been endorsed by progressive politicians like Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., and Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt. Despite winning the Democratic Party's nomination over former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo by a wide margin, Mamdani has yet to be endorsed by the party's top leaders, Jeffries and Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. Jeffries and Mamdani met in New York City for about an hour Friday. After the meeting, Politico reporter Nicholas Wu posted a statement from Jeffries spokesperson Justin Chermol that called it "constructive" but did not include any mention of an endorsement. Aoc Welcomes Socialist Mamdani To Nation's Capital As Dem Leaders Withhold Endorsements Read On The Fox News App Chermol said "the meeting between Leader Jeffries and Assemblyman Mamdani was constructive, candid and community-centered, with particular focus on affordability. "Leader Jeffries and Assemblyman Mamdani discussed a variety of other important issues, including public safety, rising antisemitism, gentrification and the importance of taking back the House in 2026." According to Chermol's statement, the two "agreed to reconvene shortly, alongside other members of the New York City congressional delegation and a few high-level community leaders." Mamdani Sparks Social Media Frenzy With Viral Clip Discussing What Happens If He Runs Out Of Money Mamdani is seen by many as a controversial candidate, partially due to his socialist policy proposals and heavy criticism of the state of Israel. Mamdani, who is Muslim, has declined to say whether Israel has the right to exist as a Jewish state and his initial refusal to condemn the phrase "globalize the intifada." However, he recently began distancing himself from the phrase. On Thursday, Jeffries told reporters "as has been the case with every single high-profile endorsement decision that I've made in the past, I have a sit-down conversation, and then I take it from there." The meeting with Jeffries comes after Mamdani's recent visit to Washington, D.C., where he attended a breakfast hosted by Ocasio-Cortez and mingled with some of the party's most powerful players. Since then, he secured the endorsement of Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., who serves as the ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee. Bipartisan House Resolution Aims To Condemn Phrase That's Created Firestorm For Zohran Mamdani Mamdani is running to unseat the current mayor of New York City, Eric Adams, who is running for re-election as an independent. He is also facing off against Cuomo, who is running as an independent, and activist Curtis Sliwa, who is the Republican Party article source: Dem House leader Hakeem Jeffries still withholds endorsement after meeting with Zohran Mamdani Solve the daily Crossword
