'AI music curation is harming UK festivals - here's how we can fight back'

Metro

2 days ago

The UK is famous for its music festivals.
Hundreds of thousands attend festival giant Glastonbury every year while newer events like All Points East have become calendar events in London.
But since 2019, 192 music festivals across the UK have disappeared. Last year alone, 60 festivals were cancelled or postponed.
What's to blame? For Will Page, the former Chief Economist of Spotify, and Nico Perez, CEO of Mixcloud, it's artificial intelligence.
Specifically, AI curation of playlists.
If you have Spotify, you've already seen AI at work on a popular music platform. Those 'daily mixes' and the personal DJ are forms of the technology at work, catering to users' every need.
But just how far will AI go in the music world – and could it be the death blow to music festivals?
At SXSW London, Will and Nico sat down to chat about how AI has reshaped how we discover, personalise and consume music.
Ticketing app DICE has put together a list of their 25 grassroots artists you need to see in London over the next six months.
With tickets ranging from free to £27.50, these shows will ensure a great night to suit all tastes and budgets.
Click HERE to catch the full list.
There are a number of reasons why festivals have faced hardship in the past few years.
A pandemic, inflation, the cost-of-living, and what Will and Nico call a lack of connection.
Will pointed out: 'I'm not seeing any 'sold out' stickers on festival posters in May, like they normally are.
'Our music 'Venn diagrams' are not crossing. When you look at a festival lineup now, to many, it looks like a playlist made for someone else.'
In recent years, many festival-goers have opted to buy one-day tickets to see one or two artists they care about – a sharp contrast from festival culture just ten or fifteen years ago.
'No one wants to take a risk on day two or three. We don't take risks anymore when it comes to music,' Will added.
How can we fight back against this lack of risk-taking, which is, as Nico and Will point out, threatening festivals?
Nico observed: 'I always say, nobody will wait in line for an AI DJ in the rain.'
'We have to remember it's important not to seek those million subscribers, or a large number. There's been such a focus on views and ratings, and in that process, we've lost sight of – are these quality artists?'
'Form small communities. Stay connected with people. Oftentimes, these are focused around local radio stations or local music,' Will said.
Personalised playlists using AI offer a wide selection of genres, artists and decades – but they're not foolproof when it comes to expanding one's horizons.
A quick look at Metro reporter Sarah Hooper's Spotify, when she asked it to make a 'Rainy Day' AI playlist, offered 50 songs.
When she asked for a 'Love Song' mix, the same songs and artists on the 'Rainy Day' playlist were featured – again. With a noticeable lack of new music.
Nico explained: 'What you'll often find with these AI recommendations is that there's a lack of serendipity that you lose in the process.'
Long gone are the days of spending hours burning CD Mixes of your favourite tunes for a loved one, or personalised cassettes. More Trending
AI curation has allowed people to listen to their own echo chamber, Nico says.
'If every single person is listening to their own echo chamber, we don't have any backgrounds or shared experiences in the music world.
'Over the long term, this ends up making us more isolated,' he said.
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at [e-mail].
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: King Charles serenaded by Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's wedding singers at SXSW London
MORE: Fyre Festival launches tropical hotel this summer with $1,500 stays
MORE: SXSW: 'The creative eyes of the world will be on London'