Why suspended Labour MPs clearly hit a nerve with Starmer
Three newly-elected MPs, Neil Duncan-Jordan, MP for Poole, Brian Leishman, MP for the new Alloa and Grangemouth constituency, and Chris Hinchcliff, for North East Herefordshire, .
Rachael Maskell, MP for York Central, who was first elected a decade ago, is the fourth.
Politics latest:
They will all sit as independent MPs and will not be allowed to stand for Labour at the next election, unless readmitted. All appear to be surprised - and upset.
Three more have lost plum roles as trade enjoys - Dr Rosena Allin-Khan, Bell Ribeiro-Addy and Mohammed Yasin, all on the left of the party.
All were active in the rebellion against the government's welfare reforms, and voted against the changes even after a series of U-turns - but were among 47 Labour MPs who did so.
When MPs were told after the welfare vote that Number 10 was "fully committed to engaging with parliamentarians", this was not what they were expecting.
We're told the reasons for these particular suspensions go wider - over "persistent breaches of party discipline" - although most are not high profile.
In the scheme of things, Jeremy Corbyn and John McDonnell rebelled against the Labour whip hundreds of times under New Labour, without being suspended.
But these MPs' pointed criticism of the Starmer strategy has clearly hit a nerve.
Maskell - who was referred to, jokingly, in the House of Commons earlier this month by Tory MP Danny Kruger as "the real prime minister" - led the rebellion against cuts to winter fuel allowance which triggered a U-turn which she said would still leave pensioners in fuel poverty.
There was an attack on the government's values. Duncan-Jordan, a trade unionist who won the Poole seat by just 18 votes, led the welfare rebellion, telling Sky News the proposed cutbacks were "not a very Labour thing to do".
Hinchliff, who has also opposed the government's housebuilding strategy and plans to expand Luton airport,had told his local paper he was willing to lose the whip over welfare cuts if necessary. He also has a marginal seat, won by fewer than 2,000 votes.
Read more:
Leishman, a former pro golfer, has also been vocal about government plans to close the refinery in his Grangemouth constituency after promising to try and make it viable. They are MPs who the leadership fear are going for broke - and that's concerning as more tough decisions on spending are likely to come.
But after a poorly-handled welfare vote, in which MPs seemed to be in the driving seat forcing changes, will this instil a sense of discipline over the summer break?
While some MPs will see this as a deterrent to rebellion, for those whose chances of re-election are small, it may continue to be seen as a price worth paying.
To other Labour MPs, the move is confusing and may be counter-productive. One Labour MP on the left told me: "So, we're suspending people for winning an argument with the government?"
Another, in the centre, feared it looked divisive, saying: "We need to go into the summer focused on the opposition - not involved in our melodramas."
Number 10 wants to show rebelling comes at a price - but many Labour MPs with concerns about their political direction will want to know the prime minister is planning to listen to concerns before it gets to that point.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
At least 63 arrests at Palestine Action ban protests
Dozens of people have been arrested at protests across the UK against the decision to proscribe Palestine Action as a terror group. Arrests have been reported in London, Edinburgh, Manchester, Bristol and Truro, all places where demonstrations in support of the pro-Palestine action group took place on Saturday. The Met Police said 55 people were arrested on suspicion of terrorism offences in Westminster for displaying placards in support of Palestine Action. Eight were arrested in Truro in Cornwall. The government proscribed the group earlier this month under the Terrorism Act of 2000, making membership of or support for the group a criminal offence, following a break-in at an RAF base. Across the country, protesters held placards with the words: "I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action." In London, arrests were made near the Mahatma Gandhi statue in Parliament Square, where as many as 20 police vans attended. Officers moved in swiftly to arrest those holding the placards, many of whom appeared to be over the age of 60. One woman claimed to be in her 80s and was walking with a stick. Some were led away while others had to be carried. Devon and Cornwall Police said two men and six women were arrested on suspicion of terrorism offences after protesters gathered near Truro Cathedral. The force said around 30 people were involved in the peaceful demonstration, organised by campaign group Defend Our Juries. Earlier, the campaign group said that one of those arrested near the cathedral was an 81-year-old former magistrate. It also said 16 people were arrested in Manchester. Police forces in the other locations where protests took place have not yet confirmed the number of arrests they made. Saturday's protests came ahead of a High Court hearing on Monday at which the co-founder of Palestine Action, Huda Ammori, will ask for permission to challenge the decision to ban the group. Last Saturday, 71 arrests were made across the UK at similar protests against the decision. Palestine Action has engaged in activities that have predominantly targeted arms companies since the start of the current war in Gaza. MPs voted to proscribe the group after activists broke into RAF Brize Norton in June, spraying two Voyager aircraft with red paint and causing £7m worth of damage. Palestine Action took responsibility for the incident at the time. Four people have since been remanded in custody, charged with conspiracy to commit criminal damage and conspiracy to enter a prohibited place knowingly for a purpose prejudicial to the safety or interests of the UK. The incident also prompted a security review across all UK military bases.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Dozens of Palestine Action protesters arrested across UK
Dozens of people have been arrested around the UK at protests in support of proscribed group Palestine Action. Demonstrations were held in London, Manchester, Edinburgh, Bristol and Truro on Saturday as part of a campaign coordinated by Defend Our Juries. Protesters wrote the message 'I oppose genocide I support Palestine Action' on placards before being surrounded by police officers at the Mahatma Gandhi statue in Parliament Square, London. Officers confiscated the placards and searched the bags of those arrested, with some protesters being carried away by police while others were led away in handcuffs. The Metropolitan Police said 55 people were arrested in Parliament Square under Section 13 of the Terrorism Act 2000 for displaying placards in support of Palestine Action. Eight people were arrested near Truro Cathedral in Cornwall after protesters gathered to show support for Palestine Action. Devon and Cornwall Police said in a statement that around 30 protesters were involved in the 'peaceful' Defend Our Juries demonstration. The force went on: 'A number of placards which were contrary to the law remained on display despite police advice. 'Eight people, two men and six women, were arrested on suspicion of offences under Section 13 of the Terrorism Act 2000. They remain in police custody.' A woman who was detained by police in Parliament Square said: 'We demand that Palestine Action is de-proscribed. 'Our government is not only arming a genocide, they are using terrorism laws to silence people who speak out. 'Palestine Action are campaigning for peace. They are dismantling weapons factories.' As he was carried away by police, a protester in London said: 'Freedom of speech is dead in this country, shame on the Metropolitan Police.' A small number of counter-protesters in Parliament Square held up placards which said 'there is no genocide but there are 50 hostages still captive'. It comes ahead of a High Court hearing on Monday in which the co-founder of Palestine Action, Huda Ammori, will ask for the green light to challenge the Home Secretary's decision to ban the group under anti-terror laws. The ban means that membership of, or support for, the direct action group is now a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison, under the Terrorism Act 2000. The Metropolitan Police said 70 people were arrested at similar demonstrations in Parliament Square over the past two weekends. The move to ban the organisation came after two Voyager aircraft were damaged at RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire on June 20, an incident claimed by Palestine Action, which police said caused about £7 million worth of damage. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper announced plans to proscribe Palestine Action three days later, saying that the vandalism of the planes was 'disgraceful' and the group had a 'long history of unacceptable criminal damage'.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Bombshell result in snap Aussie election
Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff will attempt to reform government after Labor suffered its worst vote in the state in more than 100 years. Flanked by his wife and daughter, Mr Rockliff admitted there was 'some way to go' with a minority government still very much in the offing. 'I intend to visit the governor and ask her to recommission my government so we can get on with the job for Tasmania,' Mr Rockliff. But Labor challenger Dean Winter has refused to admit defeat and declared Tasmainas were not 'happy with politics as usual'. But he has said another election was 'not an option'. Shortly before 10pm, it was clear the Liberal Party would emerge as the largest party in Tasmanian parliament. The Premier said he was committed to 'working in the best interest of all Tasmanians' and that the result showed that despite the leader of the opposition successfully passing a no-confidence motion in Mr Rockliff's leadership, the state instead showed that in relation to Mr Winter, the state shows they 'do not have confidence in him'. The Premier became emotional in his address, thanking the state Liberal Party for showing confidence in his leadership in what he called 'a very difficult time'. Mr Rockliff pointed to Tasmania having the 'strongest economy in the country' and the 'lowest unemployment rate' and highlighted investments in health and education as key achievements of his government. Someone in the ballroom interjected to ask 'who is going to pay for it' to cheers and applause from Tally Room onlookers. About 30 vocal supporters were at Hobart's Grand Chancellor Hotel ballroom with blue placards to show their support for the Premier. Labor's Mr Winter was hoping to unseat Mr Rockliff after a shock vote of no-confidence earlier this year. Mr Rockliff has held the position of premier since 2022, but faced a no-confidence vote over claims by Mr Winter of rising debt, delayed ferries, and previous privatisation plans. Labor does not admit defeat Striking a sombre tone, Mr Winter addressed his supporters shortly after 10.30pm 'Tonight, the Tasmanian people have spoken and they have delivered another hung parliament and, with it, a resounding message that they want their politicians to work together more collaboratively. 'They aren't happy with politics as usual and they want to see things done differently.' Mr Winter said he had 'fundamental and real concerns with the direction state is moving in', but acknowledged his opponent as someone who 'cares deeply'. 'The Premier's speech earlier tonight showed some of the same approach that he took on election night some 16 months ago, and we know that hasn't worked,' he said. 'That isn't what Tasmanians have just voted for.' Mr Winter did not concede the election, but said he 'is listening to the will of the Tasmanians'. 'Tasmanians can be assured over the message they have sent and we will play my part in making this parliament work in the best interests of our state. 'It seems likely that the three major parties in the state will end up with more or less the same number of seats as they did in the last parliament. Another election 'not an option' 'Another election is not an option, which means that we need to figure this out. 'This will take leadership, it will take maturity, and it will take a willingness to work and seek common ground.' While no one party had a majority, the parliament would 'highly likely to be progressive in majority', Mr Winter said. The mood had been grim among Labor supports earlier in the evening, describing the result earlier in the evening as 'terrible' and 'a disaster'. Greens message to Labor Greens leader Rosalie Woodruff earlier addressed her supporters, telling supporters voters had again 'rejected majority government'. In a pointed message to Mr Winter, Ms Woodruff said the Greens were 'ready to work collaboratively in the best interest of Tasmanians 'Dean, I hope you put them first this time,' she said. She accused Mr Winter of not taking up their 'offer of a conversation about working together to avoid this election'. 'Now, Tasmanians have chosen the next parliament this conversation needs to be had stopped. 'Representing our communities is not a game. Yes, there are differences, but the Greens and Labor have a lot in common too.' Ms Woodruff opened her address referring to the 'violent dispossession' of Tasmania's local Aboriginal community and referring to the Israel/Gaza conflict. Ms Woodruff said 'things are looking very good for the Greens' and that as well as holding their current five seats, she expects further gains including a possible gain in the seat of Braddon where they currently have no incumbent MPs. She said elections were made up of 'people driven by values' and thanks those who supported the Greens in what she called a 'cold campaign' referring to perhaps more than the weather. The Greens leader has vowed to continue to fight to end native forest logging and opposing the construction of the Macquarie Point Stadium among other policy goals. Read more below for earlier for updates. Labor vote the 'worst it's been' Labor is one track for its worst vote in Tasmania in more than 100 years after it's own no-confidence vote triggered a snap election. The Liberals were on track to win the largest percentage of the vote by 9pm on Saturday night, however who gets a swing at forming government still remained uncertain as candidates battle others from their own parties in the state's peculiar Harre Clark system. Labor, on the other hand, looks almost certain for another term in opposition with the ABC projecting its worst result in history. As of 9pm, Labor's vote share is sitting at 25.4 per cent with the Liberals on 38.2 per cent. 'Labor's vote the worst it's been in Tasmania since the Hare-Clark system in 1903,' Casey Briggs told ABC viewers. Eric Abetz, meanwhile, will return to parliament, with a likely increase to the size of the crossbench. Peter George was declared by the ABC to have been elected in the seat of Franklin, while Craig Garland will be returned in Braddon. Elsewhere, the Nationals attempt to enter parliament looks set to fail, while the Shooters, Fishers, and Farmers (SFF) remain in the hunt for a shock seat pick up in Lyons with Carlo Di Falco currently on 0.61 of a quota. Labor leader's election gamble in doubt Labor's Dean Winter's election gamble, triggered by his motion of no-confidence in Premier Jeremy Rockliff, does not look like it is paying off, with the Labor leader trailing in his own seat of Franklin. Across the rest of the state, things aren't looking much better. While figures are early, Labor's primary vote is down nearly seven per cent while the Liberal vote is up five per cent. Early results in Franklin indicate Peter George, who came close to winning the seat at the last Federal election, leads in the count, with the Liberals second and Labor third. Labor needs to make serious ground and win four seats in Franklin if they are any chance to form majority government, currently the results show they would win only two. Meanwhile in Braddon, another ex-Liberal federal MP is set to make the successful switch to state politics with the former federal member for Braddon, Gavin Pearce, on track to win a seat in the state parliament. Shortly after 8pm, ABC analyst Casey Briggs said the national broadcaster would be calling the Liberals as the largest party in the next parliament. The ABC projected the Liberals would finish with about 39 per cent of the vote, Labor with 23.5 per cent, the independents on 19 per cent, and the Greens on 16 per cent. Meanwhile, Labor operatives are not optimistic about improving its parliamentary numbers with MLC Sarah Lowell on ABC saying scrutineers are hopeful of at least two Labor MPs being returned in each electorate which would result in only 10 Labor MPs being returned, resulting in a status quo result for the Party and a Labor minority even being unlikely. Defeated pollie's return in Tassie poll Figures are slowly trickling in from Tasmania's second state election in 16 months and it looks like Bridget Archer is set to return to frontline politics a little more than two months after vacating their federal seats. Ms Archer is on course to easily be elected as one of seven candidates in Bass just two months after being shown the door by voters in the federal poll, with the maverick Liberal leading in the vote count with almost double the number of her nearest competitor incumbent Michael Ferguson. The ABC has now declared Archer as one of the MPs elected in Bass. Meanwhile in Lyons, the Liberals are on track to increase their vote while the return to politics of former Federal member Brian Mitchell looks uncertain. In Braddon, Incumbent Premier Jeremy Rockliff will be returned as an MP in the next parliament the ABC projects. Early result unlikely in Tassie poll An early outcome in Tasmania's snap election is unlikely with tens of thousands of additional pre-poll votes, the state's election commissioner has revealed. The state's election tsar told the ABC it was likely voters would have to wait 'the period' in the 2025 election, the second in 16 months. About 100,000 pre-poll votes have reportedly been cast in the election, about 20,000 more than in last year's ballot. The school holidays were blamed for the trend, with many people voting before leaving to go overseas. Bookies favourite Despite polls showing the Liberals the likely largest party (although short of a majority) Sportsbet has Labor at $1.43 favourites to be the party sworn into government following today's poll. The Liberals are paying $2.85, with the Greens at $36.00 'Thousands' rally in favour of Macquarie Point Stadium With the stadium issue dominating both the past state election campaign as well as this one, proponents have organised a march and rally to show their support for the proposal on election day. An estimated 3000 Tasmanians took to the streets to show their support for the proposed Macquarie Point stadium, with organisers saying the 'silent majority' is finally making its voice heard. Despite growing opposition from the Greens and most Independents likely to hold the balance of power after tonight's election, both major parties have said they support the stadium which the AFL says is a pre requisite for the Tasmanian devils team to enter the completion, with the women's team due to enter the AFLW in the 2027 season and the men's in 2028. Tasmania heads to the polls Tasmanians are today heading to the polls for the second state election in 16 months, after the state was plunged into political chaos by a no-confidence motion in Premier Jeremy Rockliff. Saturday's election is the fourth in just over a year for many Tasmanians. The last state election was held in March 2024, voters returned on May 3 for the federal election, and May 24 as a number of legislative council seats were contested. With key projects on the line, a unique electoral system and the risk of a fifth election for voters in the near future if Saturday's poll does not return a clear result, this election will have major impacts on the state's future.
