Inside Economics: NZ recession risks on the rise ... again! Plus: the boy who cried ‘tariff' – Trump's threats lose their bite
Nobody wants to be talking about another recession; we're supposed to be recovering from the last one (or was that two ... or three?).
But sadly, there are some worrying signs that the fragile recovery petered out in the second quarter.
Both the Production of Services Index and the Production of Manufacturing Index contracted again in June.
These measures of business performance suggest that a large chunk of the economy is still in recession.
The Production of Services Index recorded its fifth successive contraction in June.
Apart from a positive bounce in January this year, it has been in contraction since March 2024.
That's a hell of a tough run and reflects the gloom we're hearing from hospitality, retail and professional services.
Meanwhile, manufacturing, which had started to pick up, faltered for the second month in a row in June.
That's prompted BNZ head of research Stephen Toplis to publish a very gloomy note, revising down his expectation for the second quarter GDP to -0.2%.
'The last few days have seen a number of high-frequency activity indicators support our view that not only did the economy stall in the June quarter, but it is also struggling to gain momentum going into [the third quarter],' Toplis writes.
'Indeed, so poor have these indicators been that we have lowered our expectation for Q2 GDP to -0.2%, from zero, and have made exactly the same adjustment for Q2 employment.'
Meanwhile, the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand (REINZ) Property Report for June showed the housing market remains subdued, with median house prices down again in Auckland.
Commentators have focused on the oversupply of properties on the market and a lack of demand from buyers because of job market insecurity.
We need the job market to improve to boost house prices, but we need house prices to improve and boost consumer confidence to improve the job market.
Likewise, housing market demand is suffering from the falling net migration rate, but that won't turn around until the job market improves.
The circuit-breaker might be more interest rate cuts from the Reserve Bank (RBNZ).
But the RBNZ hit pause last week because of short-term inflation concerns.
Of course, the recessionary conditions are meant to mean inflation will keep falling and the RBNZ will be able to cut further eventually.
For now, though, we're stuck in a frustrating deadlock that risks further undermining already-weak business confidence.
Lucky country?
What's worrying about the situation is just how bad it would be if the agricultural export sector weren't enjoying its biggest boom in years.
We don't have any control over export prices or agricultural production conditions, so you'd have to say we got lucky, although I suspect struggling retailers are feeling anything but.
What we desperately need is for the domestic economy to pick up before the export price cycle turns against us.
There is still hope, even though the wheels are turning painfully slow.
I think the elevated export earnings will eventually work their way through to the urban economy.
Economists also point out that the cuts the RBNZ has already made are still working their way through to consumers' pockets.
Core retail spending was up in June, although Westpac economist Satish Ranchhod notes that rising grocery prices probably counted for some of the extra spending in the consumables category.
More promising were increases in durables and apparel. Hospitality continued to struggle.
As Ranchhod notes in his analysis, retail spending isn't going to pick up rapidly.
But households with mortgages should see considerable relief in the coming six months.
'Compared to this time last year, fixed-term mortgage rates are around 170 to 200bps lower,' he said.
'The full impact of those declines is yet to be felt as most New Zealand mortgages are fixed for a period.'
Over the next six months, around half of all mortgages would come up for refixing, giving many borrowers the chance to secure a much lower rate, Ranchhod said.
'The related increases in disposable income levels will be a boost for sentiment, and that should support a gradual recovery in spending as we approach the end of the year.'
It feels like we've been saying that for two years now – but hang in there.
Something's got to give eventually.
Tariffs? What tariffs?
In my diary, August 1 looks to be looming fast. But Wall Street investors seem to have decided that the new tariff deadline imposed by Donald Trump is too far away to worry about.
Markets shrugged off his latest threats to impose 30% tariffs on the EU and Mexico, 35% on Canada and raise the base tariff for all countries from 10% to 20%.
Wall Street indexes continued to trade near record highs on Monday.
If the investors took these threats at face value, they would be extremely worrying, but I don't think anyone does anymore.
The story of The Boy Who Cried Wolf comes to mind.
Donald Trump's endless tariff threats are being treated as akin to one of Aesop's Fables.
Leading with a big, aggressive threat is clearly a negotiating tactic for Trump.
But each time he does it and then backtracks, he weakens his hand.
Trump knows the risk of pushing too hard is that he'll cop an ugly Wall Street sell-off or a bond market rally that pushes up interest rates.
His strategy has been to push to the limits of market tolerance and then pull back.
He hasn't managed to do that this time.
In the long run, Trump will likely achieve his goal of higher tariffs across the board. He'll have changed the global trade landscape and will be able to claim victory.
In the short term, though, he's struggling to deliver the big bang he promised in April.
No one really believes the big, scary numbers he plucks out of the air any more.
Eventually, markets will have to grapple with the reality of higher tariffs. For now, they seem comfortable treating Trump's big proclamations as entirely hypothetical.
The real measure of tariff impact
The real measure of tariff damage arrived this morning in the form of the latest US Consumer Price Index inflation data (for June).
By the time you read this, the numbers will be out already, and I'm loath to make any predictions.
But whether good, bad or ugly, markets are likely to take the data a lot more seriously than the latest pronouncements from the White House.
The inflation rate is a number that will have a direct bearing on the US Federal Reserve's plans for rate cuts (or lack of them).
Investors will be watching closely to see what impact the first round of tariffs has had on pricing.
Meanwhile, in New Zealand, we'll get our Consumers Price Index (CPI) data for the second quarter on Monday.
Economists expect it will remain higher than the RBNZ would like. BNZ is pencilling in 0.8% for the quarter (from 0.9% in the March quarter).
Butter Battles
Q: Hi, can you please explain the economics of a pound of butter made from milk acquired from cows in Waikato and processed nearby into a product on the supermarket shelf in Hamilton costing me the equivalent of the same product in London?
Various sources report the costs of transporting goods within New Zealand at 40% of a product's price, so I wonder how an economist can not account for the enormous expense of getting the pound of butter, the bottle of wine, the leg of lamb, the side of beef, the timber etc overseas.
Thanks for any explanation.
Regards,
Peter
A: Cheers, Peter.
The price of butter certainly continues to grate with many people, despite my best efforts to explain the ups and downs of international pricing.
Intuitively, it does seem strange that people on the other side of the world can be paying the same price as we do for a product made just down the road.
But I was surprised by your assumption that transportation accounts for 40% of butter costs.
Basically, by the time you stack a few tonnes on a truck, or many more tonnes on a boat, the transport cost per unit is actually very low.
I double-checked this with Fonterra. It confirmed that domestic transport costs are about 1% and international costs are about 3% of the final price.
So the transportation costs are marginal and don't have a big impact on the retail pricing.
If New Zealand butter is cheaper in international supermarkets than local supermarkets, I'd be looking at the margins being added by the retailer.
Ultimately, as I pointed out in a previous column, if we want a product such as butter to be cheaper than the market price then it has to be subsidised by someone.
I don't think the Government should be forcing farmers (or any other businesspeople) to charge lower prices than they can get elsewhere.
The Government could subsidise the price, of course. But they'd be doing that with taxpayer money. And it raises questions like: why butter?
The Greens and Labour occasionally talk about removing GST from some food products, which would be a form of subsidy. But the focus there tends to be healthy fresh produce, which they believe we all need to eat more of.
Products such as cheese and butter seem to hold special cultural importance to many Kiwis, given our history as a dairy-producing nation.
Perhaps a political party could run on a policy of subsidising them specifically; it might prove popular!
Liam Dann is business editor-at-large for the New Zealand Herald. He is a senior writer and columnist, and also presents and produces videos and podcasts. He joined the Herald in 2003. To sign up to his weekly newsletter, click on your user profile at nzherald.co.nz and select 'My newsletters'. For a step-by-step guide, click here. If you have a burning question about the quirks or intricacies of economics, send it to liam.dann@nzherald.co.nz or leave a message in the comments section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
an hour ago
- Otago Daily Times
Inflation predicted to hit 12-month high
By Gyles Beckford of RNZ Inflation is expected to hit a 12-month high, as surging food prices and power costs put the squeeze on household budgets. Consumer prices for the three months ended June are expected to have risen 0.6 percent, pushing the annual rate to 2.8 percent from 2.5 percent in March. ANZ senior economist Miles Workman said there would be familiar domestic drivers of the latest numbers. "The main drivers of quarterly inflation are expected to come from the food and housing-related groups - accelerating electricity inflation, but slowing rents and construction." High export prices for meat and dairy products have driven local food prices, and thus stoked inflation, but at the same time, they are delivering strong export returns that have supported the economy. ASB senior economist Mark Smith said the spike in inflation was expected to push the annual rate above three percent in the September quarter, but should prove to be temporary. "We expect the period of three percent-plus inflation to be short-lived. Forthcoming inflation expectations surveys will be critical for ascertaining whether team transitory or team persistence will win the inflation tug-o-war. "Our core judgement is that the deteriorating global outlook and the large margin of spare capacity will dampen the medium-term outlook for inflation." RBNZ discomfort Workman said the higher inflation numbers would be uncomfortable reading for the Reserve Bank (RBNZ), which would have to balance between controlling inflation and helping the economy. "The RBNZ will need to balance any upside surprise in the CPI against the signal from the high-frequency data, which is currently pointing to a stalling recovery and therefore downside risks to the medium-term inflation outlook." In its most recent monetary review, the RBNZ acknowledged the speed-up in inflation, but also gave a strong hint of a further rate cut at the end of August. "If medium-term inflation pressures continue to ease as projected, the committee expects to lower the official cash rate further," the RBNZ statement said. Kiwibank economists said the issue for the RBNZ and interest rate policy was underlying inflation trends. "Encouragingly, core inflation has been trending south since hitting the 6.7 percent peak at the end of 2022. In the year to March 2025, core inflation fell to 2.6 percent." They said the economy needed lower rates and they expected another 25 basis-point cut in August. At this stage, Workman picked the cuts in August, November and early next year would take the cash rate to a low of 2.5 percent.
NZ Herald
4 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Rising prices a risk to Reserve Bank's effort to avoid inflation danger zone
'The balance of the volatile monthly prices came in a touch stronger than our assumptions for the month, although not enough to alter our pick.' BNZ is picking a 0.8% rise for the quarter for an annual rate of 2.9%. 'This is stronger than the RBNZ's May forecast of 0.5% [quarter on quarter] and 2.6% [year on year],' Toplis said. 'The RBNZ openly acknowledged near-term inflation upside in its July MPR [Monetary Policy Review], noting that 'inflation is expected to increase further in the June and September quarters toward the top of the MPC's inflation target band'. And the bank still confirmed an easing bias,' he said. 'So higher near-term inflation remains a risk to monitor but need not necessarily derail further reduction in the OCR if the RBNZ continues to look through the near-term pressure and focus on a subdued medium-term outlook.' Despite the risks, inflation would need to come in much worse than expected to prevent another OCR cut in August, said ANZ senior economist Miles Workman. 'The RBNZ will need to balance any upside surprise in the CPI against the signal from the high-frequency data, which is currently pointing to a stalling recovery and therefore downside risks to the medium-term inflation outlook,' he said. 'Given this, we think it would take a sizable upside surprise in the CPI to take an August cut off the table.' Westpac's Satish Ranchhod highlighted the contrasting trends for tradable inflation (internationally priced goods like petrol and food) and non-tradable inflation (domestically priced goods and services like rents and labour costs). 'In terms of the big CPI groups, we expect that domestically oriented non-tradables prices will rise 0.7% over the quarter,' he said. 'That would see annual non-tradables inflation slowing to 3.8%, down from 4% last quarter and continuing the gradual easing that we've seen over the past couple of years.' Non-tradable inflation traditionally runs higher than tradable inflation. 'Underlying that easing in domestic inflation has been softness in economic activity, which has seen muted growth in wages and service sector prices,' Ranchhod said. 'We've also seen very limited increases in both rents and the cost of new housing (the latter reflecting the more general softness in the housing market).' But even with that softness in domestic activity, overall non-tradables inflation was easing only gradually because of lingering strength in administered prices, like electricity charges, he said. Those increases meant domestic inflation is lingering above historic averages, and that would be a key concern for the RBNZ. 'On the imported front, we expect tradable prices will rise by 0.3% in the June quarter,' he said. 'That would see annual tradables inflation rising to 1.2% – a stark change from the past year when tradable prices had been flat or falling.' For the Reserve Bank, the focus would go to core inflation, which tracks underlying trends by stripping out volatile goods like petrol and food. 'Core inflation measures have been trending down in recent months and have drifted back towards or inside the RBNZ's target band,' Ranchhod said. 'We expect that core inflation will continue to gradually ease in June but will linger above 2%.' The main uncertainty around forecasts would be prices for discretionary household items, with the risks here on both sides, he said. Those items are mostly imported and include products like apparel, furnishings and other durable items. 'Household spending has been subdued in recent months, and that could have an even larger dampening impact on prices than we had assumed. However, prices for some items, like cars, can have sizeable swings on a quarter-to-quarter basis.' Liam Dann is business editor-at-large for the New Zealand Herald. He is a senior writer and columnist, and also presents and produces videos and podcasts. He joined the Herald in 2003.
NZ Herald
5 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Mortgage rates drop, but further relief unlikely as OCR stabilises
At 5.1%, unemployment is the highest since 2016 (excluding the Covid-era) and it's expected to increase a little further before stabilising. This level of labour market slack usually keeps a lid on domestic inflation pressures. The RBNZ isn't done with cutting rates just yet, but an important insight borrowers should take from last week's decision is that we are nearing the end of the easing cycle. Of the big four Australian banks and Kiwibank, forecasts for where the OCR troughs range from 2.50% to 3%. The most recent RBNZ projections imply a floor of either 3% or 2.75%, with the odds slightly tilted towards the latter. Whoever you choose to believe, it's clear the bottom is getting closer. For most of us, this matters because of what it means for borrowing costs and the household budget. Mortgage rates have already fallen a long way. The two-year rate is 5% right now, down from 7% at the end of 2023. It's important to understand that your mortgage rate isn't driven solely by moves in the OCR. Global economic conditions, wholesale interest rates, bank funding costs and competition among lenders can also have a big influence. There's still a strong relationship though, especially for the shorter mortgage terms. In the past six months the gap between the OCR and the two-year rate has been about 1.5%, well below the average since 2017 of 2.2%. That tight spread could mean there's less room for mortgage rates to fall, even if we do see another OCR cut or three. The outlook could change if we experienced a global economic shock, or if inflation proved more persistent than expected. However, right now, the base case points to limited further relief. As our biggest lender, ANZ likely has some useful insights about the mortgage market. Its latest monthly property report suggests the two-year mortgage rate will bottom at 4.9% later this year, only marginally below current levels. It has the one-year slightly lower at 4.7%, while the three- and five-year rates don't dip below 5% in its projections. This conservative outlook is notable, given ANZ (with Kiwibank) sees the OCR falling to 2.50%. The upshot here is that most of the downward move in mortgage rates is behind us. I wouldn't say this is 'as good as it gets' for borrowers, but we're much closer to that point than many think. The next OCR decision is due in late August and importantly, this one will also see the release of a new forecast set. This is the natural opportunity for the next cut, but there are a few things to monitor between now and then. Next week's June quarter consumer price index (CPI) report is one, while the labour force report on August 7 will also be crucial. Assuming those are close to RBNZ projections, there's a decent chance we see a 0.25% cut at that time. That would take the OCR to 3%, close to neutral and where it sat comfortably for six years from 2010 to 2015. The focus will then shift to whether that's as low as it goes this cycle. With mortgage spreads already compressed relative to recent years and the OCR within neutral territory, borrowers hoping for much lower rates will be left disappointed. Mark Lister is Investment Director at Craigs Investment Partners. The information in this article is provided for information only, is intended to be general in nature, and does not take into account your financial situation, objectives, goals, or risk tolerance. Before making any investment decision Craigs Investment Partners recommends you contact an investment adviser.
