The 2 'Wild Cards' on Sean 'Diddy' Combs Jury, According to an Expert
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
Many of the jurors selected to hear Sean "Diddy" Combs' federal criminal case share common characteristics, but there are some that could be "wild cards," according to a jury consulting expert.
A jury was finalized in the case on Monday. Brittany Wooten, a senior litigation consultant at Magna Legal Services, said the chosen jurors could benefit the prosecution.
"This is a jury with a heart," Wooten told Newsweek. "They have social workers, caregivers, trauma-informed professionals who won't shy away from the emotional testimony. I think that's good from a prosecution standpoint."
Wooten said there are some "wild cards" on the jury, including juror number two, a 69-year-old man who is an actor and massage therapist.
"You have somebody who you really don't know is going to go one way or the other," Wooten said. "As an actor, you're going to be more emotionally attuned, but he could be also more liberal, more open-minded. But in massage therapy, and what I call a close proximity to body-related work, it could make him receptive or even desensitized to the non-traditional values."
Wooten also mentioned juror number 25, a 51-year-old man with a PhD in molecular biology and neuroscience, "who might turn out to be a leader, highly analytical, likely focused on logic over emotion."
Why It Matters
Combs is facing federal charges of sex trafficking, racketeering and transportation to engage in prostitution. He has pleaded not guilty to the charges and denies any wrongdoing.
Sean "Diddy" Combs at the 2009 Fragrance Foundation FiFi Awards held on May 27, 2009 in New York City.
Sean "Diddy" Combs at the 2009 Fragrance Foundation FiFi Awards held on May 27, 2009 in New York City.
zz/Raoul Gatchalian/STAR MAX/IPx
Opening statements were given and the first witnesses were called on Monday after jury selection concluded. The jury selection process began on May 5.
What To Know
Hiliary Remick, managing director of jury consulting at Magna Legal Services, said the jury is not "very unbalanced," but the prosecution might have a slight edge.
"There are some folks on there who might be appealing to the prosecution," Remick told Newsweek.
Wooten said there are some individuals who could lean in the defense's favor, including the investment analyst and the retired JP Morgan employee.
"The more logical and analytical the profession, the more likely they are to look carefully at what the accusations are, and that could help the defense," Wooten said.
The jury consists of eight men and four women. Wooten said there's "so much more to their backgrounds" than gender, but their experiences could play a role in how they evaluate the case.
"Men or women may interpret signals of consent or manipulation differently, just based on their life experiences or social conditioning," Wooten said.
Remick explained how the women on the jury might view the alleged abuse in this case.
"To the extent any of the four women on the jury have had particular experiences in their own life or with people close to them involving abuse or sexual abuse, that might be a very sensitive issue," Remick said.
What People Are Saying
Wooten, in an interview with Newsweek: "I think older jurors may be less swayed by the celebrity culture or emotional appeals, but more sensitive to the seriousness of the criminal allegations, especially if you believe the justice system is being misused or manipulated."
Remick, in an interview with Newsweek: "We will be very interested to see even simple signals like responsiveness, or leaning forward, or following, tracking with their eyes one particular presenter over another. That could tell us something."
What Happens Next
Combs' trial is expected to last eight to 10 weeks. Combs is facing a maximum sentence of life in prison if convicted.
Do you have a story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Diddy's ex, 'Jane,' is now his 2nd accuser to describe being sex-trafficked by violence
"Is this coercion?" Combs' ex said he asked her after leaving her covered with bruises last June. Combs' 2nd sex-trafficking accuser, "Jane" told a jury he then forced her to have sex with an escort. "Take this fucking pill," she said he demanded. "You're not going to ruin my fucking night." Sean "Diddy" Combs' ex told a federal jury Monday that the mogul once covered her face in bruises before posing a taunting question: "Is this coercion?" The rap mogul then demanded she put on makeup, pop an ecstasy pill, and have sex with a male escort, the woman, "Jane," testified, describing a June 2024 dinner date at her Los Angeles home. "Take this fucking pill. You're not going to ruin my fucking night," Jane, who is testifying under a pseudonym, said Combs demanded as she screamed, "I don't want to! I don't want to!" Through this harrowing testimony, Jane became the second of Combs' ex-girlfriends, after R&B star Cassie Ventura, to take the stand at his Manhattan trial and describe being sex trafficked through coercive violence. "He just looked at me, right in my face," from an inch away, his voice "forceful," Jane said, when lead prosecutor Maurene Comey asked her to describe how Combs appeared and sounded when he asked her, "Is this coercion?" It was the third day of testimony for Jane, who described herself as an OnlyFans lingerie model and the single mother of a child fathered by one of Combs' rap world rivals. She dated Combs between 2021 and 2024. Jane told the jury Monday that while she took the ecstasy pill on that violent night, she did not answer Combs' question about coercion. Instead, only three months later, federal prosecutors would answer the question for her. Combs would be indicted in September 2024 on racketeering and sex trafficking. Both Ventura and Jane were sex trafficked by means of Combs' false promises, violence, and coercion, according to the indictment. The legal definition of coercion includes any scheme or pattern that causes someone to fear serious harm. Defense lawyers argue that there was no coercion because the sex was consensual. They say that this is borne out by years of texts and emails in which Ventura and Jane display enthusiasm for these drug-fueled nights of sex with as many as three men, plus Combs himself. The racketeering allegations against Combs include bribery and witness tampering, and here Jane's testimony from Monday could also help prosecutors. Jane told the jury that in the days after Ventura filed her explosive November 2023 lawsuit, Combs threatened to send her sex tapes to the father of her child, offered her cash, and pleaded, "I need your friendship." "Charge me. Charge me, so we can just move on," Jane testified that a desperate-sounding Combs told her during a FaceTime call. "He was wanting me to come up with some sort of number," Jane told the jury, describing what she called a rejected offer to pay for her silence. The Ventura lawsuit quickly upended Combs' life and his multimillion-dollar music and lifestyle empire. In it, Ventura accused Combs of forcing her to have sex with male escorts while he watched, masturbated, and filmed. These so-called "freak off" performances involved heavy drug use and lasted for days, Ventura said in the suit, previewing her own testimony at the start of the trial. The lawsuit, which settled the next day for $20 million, was the catalyst for dozens of similar lawsuits and for the indictment itself. "I just reacted, like, I can't believe I'm reading my own story," Jane told the jury Monday, tearfully describing her reaction to reading Ventura's lawsuit for the first time. "I almost fainted," she told the jury. "In fact, I think I did." Combs' reaction to the lawsuit was more extreme than Jane's own, veering, in her description to the jury, from anger to accusation to fear. Before Ventura's lawsuit, Combs would react with scolding denials when she told him she wanted to stop what she called "hotel nights" and to enjoy romantic dinners and trips instead. "You're tripping," he would tell her, according to the texts shown in court. "Please, woman," and "You're fucking crazy," he'd tell her. "So, we're breaking up?" he'd threaten. But in the days after the Ventura lawsuit, Jane couldn't bring up "hotel nights" without Combs asking if she was out to get him. "You trying to set me up?" he asked her in one November 2024 phone call that was recorded by Combs, later recovered from the phone of his chief of staff, Kristina Khorram, and played Monday for the jury. "You recording my phone calls?" he demanded. Jane testified she was not — and that she had no idea that Combs was the one making a recording. In one of two recorded calls, Combs attempted to spin their nights together as "Just some kinky shit that I thought that we, you know, we both enjoyed." When Jane answers, "I just want you to know that's not how I saw things," Combs asks again, "Are you recording me?" Jane's cross-examination is set to begin on Tuesday and may last through Thursday. Read the original article on Business Insider
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
Diddy's ex, 'Jane,' is now his 2nd accuser to describe being sex-trafficked by violence
"Is this coercion?" Combs' ex said he asked her after leaving her covered with bruises last June. Combs' 2nd sex-trafficking accuser, "Jane" told a jury he then forced her to have sex with an escort. "Take this fucking pill," she said he demanded. "You're not going to ruin my fucking night." Sean "Diddy" Combs' ex told a federal jury Monday that the mogul once covered her face in bruises before posing a taunting question: "Is this coercion?" The rap mogul then demanded she put on makeup, pop an ecstasy pill, and have sex with a male escort, the woman, "Jane," testified, describing a June 2024 dinner date at her Los Angeles home. "Take this fucking pill. You're not going to ruin my fucking night," Jane, who is testifying under a pseudonym, said Combs demanded as she screamed, "I don't want to! I don't want to!" Through this harrowing testimony, Jane became the second of Combs' ex-girlfriends, after R&B star Cassie Ventura, to take the stand at his Manhattan trial and describe being sex trafficked through coercive violence. "He just looked at me, right in my face," from an inch away, his voice "forceful," Jane said, when lead prosecutor Maurene Comey asked her to describe how Combs appeared and sounded when he asked her, "Is this coercion?" It was the third day of testimony for Jane, who described herself as an OnlyFans lingerie model and the single mother of a child fathered by one of Combs' rap world rivals. She dated Combs between 2021 and 2024. Jane told the jury Monday that while she took the ecstasy pill on that violent night, she did not answer Combs' question about coercion. Instead, only three months later, federal prosecutors would answer the question for her. Combs would be indicted in September 2024 on racketeering and sex trafficking. Both Ventura and Jane were sex trafficked by means of Combs' false promises, violence, and coercion, according to the indictment. The legal definition of coercion includes any scheme or pattern that causes someone to fear serious harm. Defense lawyers argue that there was no coercion because the sex was consensual. They say that this is borne out by years of texts and emails in which Ventura and Jane display enthusiasm for these drug-fueled nights of sex with as many as three men, plus Combs himself. The racketeering allegations against Combs include bribery and witness tampering, and here Jane's testimony from Monday could also help prosecutors. Jane told the jury that in the days after Ventura filed her explosive November 2023 lawsuit, Combs threatened to send her sex tapes to the father of her child, offered her cash, and pleaded, "I need your friendship." "Charge me. Charge me, so we can just move on," Jane testified that a desperate-sounding Combs told her during a FaceTime call. "He was wanting me to come up with some sort of number," Jane told the jury, describing what she called a rejected offer to pay for her silence. The Ventura lawsuit quickly upended Combs' life and his multimillion-dollar music and lifestyle empire. In it, Ventura accused Combs of forcing her to have sex with male escorts while he watched, masturbated, and filmed. These so-called "freak off" performances involved heavy drug use and lasted for days, Ventura said in the suit, previewing her own testimony at the start of the trial. The lawsuit, which settled the next day for $20 million, was the catalyst for dozens of similar lawsuits and for the indictment itself. "I just reacted, like, I can't believe I'm reading my own story," Jane told the jury Monday, tearfully describing her reaction to reading Ventura's lawsuit for the first time. "I almost fainted," she told the jury. "In fact, I think I did." Combs' reaction to the lawsuit was more extreme than Jane's own, veering, in her description to the jury, from anger to accusation to fear. Before Ventura's lawsuit, Combs would react with scolding denials when she told him she wanted to stop what she called "hotel nights" and to enjoy romantic dinners and trips instead. "You're tripping," he would tell her, according to the texts shown in court. "Please, woman," and "You're fucking crazy," he'd tell her. "So, we're breaking up?" he'd threaten. But in the days after the Ventura lawsuit, Jane couldn't bring up "hotel nights" without Combs asking if she was out to get him. "You trying to set me up?" he asked her in one November 2024 phone call that was recorded by Combs, later recovered from the phone of his chief of staff, Kristina Khorram, and played Monday for the jury. "You recording my phone calls?" he demanded. Jane testified she was not — and that she had no idea that Combs was the one making a recording. In one of two recorded calls, Combs attempted to spin their nights together as "Just some kinky shit that I thought that we, you know, we both enjoyed." When Jane answers, "I just want you to know that's not how I saw things," Combs asks again, "Are you recording me?" Jane's cross-examination is set to begin on Tuesday and may last through Thursday.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Diddy's Ex Passed Out After Reading Cassie's Lawsuit Describing 'Freak-Off' Orgies
The most recent ex-girlfriend of Sean 'Diddy' Combs testified further at his sex trafficking and racketeering trial in New York on Monday, detailing the deterioration of their relationship over the last few years, fainting from shock upon reading Cassie Ventura's civil lawsuit against him and a savage beating at his hands months before the fallen mogul's September arrest. As prosecutors near the end of their witness list and get ready to rest their case, the victim, using the pseudonym Jane Doe to protect her anonymity, shared her experiences with the defendant over the back half of their three-year relationship. Last week, she told the court that about 90 percent of their time together revolved around 'freak-offs' or what she referred to as 'hotel nights,' which were drug-fueled orgies where she was allegedly coerced and blackmailed into having marathon sex sessions orchestrated and filmed by Combs as he looked on. More from The Hollywood Reporter Sly Stone, Funk-Rock Pioneer, Dies at 82 Taylor Swift's 'Reputation' Album Surges Back to Top Five on Charts Following Masters Purchase 'Outer Banks' Actor Jonathan Daviss to Star as Snoop Dogg in Universal Biopic This came after the defense team made a second motion for a mistrial, citing what they called 'prosecutorial misconduct.' In a letter to the judge overseeing the case, Combs' attorneys wrote that federal prosecutors knew that testimony from Ventura's friend Bryana Bongolan, who told the court last week that she was dangled by Combs over Ventura's balcony in 2016, was false but allowed her to testify before the jury anyway. Judge Arun Subramanian has said he will respond to the letter on Tuesday. From the witness stand on Monday, Jane testified further to the court of the alleged coercion to participate in hotel nights she claims to have experienced from Combs, who paid for her apartment and still does today; she said her housing felt contingent on keeping Combs happy, which she has said was always her goal in their ultimately orgy-centered relationship. '[It was] like the home was being used as leverage,' she said, and added that she felt 'guilt-trippy things' about living in a home paid for by Combs. Jane told the court that this 'made me feel like I had to perform' sex for housing. She expressed this to him in a text that described her feeling 'disgusted' with herself. On two separate occasions, she told the court, a hotel night involved a man dressed as a cowboy while wearing high-heeled shoes and another involved three men, which led to her vomiting. Combs went to check on her afterward but quickly ushered her back to the 'party,' she said. Jane also alleged that Combs blackmailed her with sex tapes he made of her and male sex workers at the hotel nights, telling her that he would release them in December 2023 and show them to her baby's father. This was amid a series of fights the couple had, she told the court, as their relationship was deteriorating as she began to show more agency and tell the wealthy business leader that she did not want to have sex with other men for his pleasure. Her mental health deteriorated during this time, she said, as she began to recognize the alleged gaslighting tactics Combs used on her; at a point, she began to have suicidal ideation, she said. Jane also described a time she vomited during a session involving three men and shared her thoughts after viewing footage of her at a hotel night. 'I saw me being high. I was following a pattern, the pattern that I thought he wanted to see,' she testified. 'It was like a show over and over again.' A man named Cabral, who appeared with her in a sex video, asked for $10,000 for the footage, which Combs had shot on the sex worker's phone. It was eventually sold to an undisclosed publishing company, she said. The turning point for Jane seems to have been when she read Ventura's 2023 legal filing against Combs, which was famously settled out of court the following day. Three pages of that complaint struck her sharply, she said. Jane also told the court that upon reading the suit, she fainted. 'I feel like I'm reading about my own sexual trauma,' she said. Combs asked for her emotional and spiritual support in a taped phone call from the time that was played in court. 'I just needed to tell you I need your friendship; you know you ain't gotta worry about anything else, baby, please pray for me,' the mogul told her. 'I will be praying for you; I need your friendship.' Jane finally described on Monday a harrowing story, mentioned in the prosecution's opening statement, of being physically attacked by Combs amid an argument they'd had after he was photographed with a woman 25 years younger than him. Jane said she referred to him as a 'pedophile' and slammed his head into a marble kitchen counter. This allegedly enraged Combs, who stalked her around the apartment, kicking in four doors as she tried to flee from his attacks. Describing the terror she felt on that day in June 2024, Jane said she escaped the home and lingered in the neighborhood for hours, waiting for Combs to leave. Jane Doe's testimony will resume when court is back in session on Tuesday. Best of The Hollywood Reporter Most Anticipated Concert Tours of 2025: Beyoncé, Billie Eilish, Kendrick Lamar & SZA, Sabrina Carpenter and More Hollywood's Most Notable Deaths of 2025 Hollywood's Highest-Profile Harris Endorsements: Taylor Swift, George Clooney, Bruce Springsteen and More
