logo
Karachi power consumers denied big relief

Karachi power consumers denied big relief

Express Tribune16-02-2025

Listen to article
KARACHI:
Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) President Muhammad Jawed Bilwani, while strongly condemning the recent decision of the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) which deprives Karachi consumers of a significant relief in monthly tariff adjustment, has said that both Nepra and K-Electric (KE) have failed to provide promised benefits to the consumers.
He said Nepra's recent announcement of fuel price adjustment for November revealed a mere reduction of Rs1.23 per unit. "Although this reduction should be seen as a step in the right direction, it falls far short of expectation. Karachi consumers were expecting a much higher relief, given that KE had previously requested a reduction of up to Rs4.98 per unit for November."
He added, "What is even more concerning is the fact that despite the tariff cut being calculated at Rs5.0029 per unit, only Rs1.23 reduction was made for K-Electric consumers. This adjustment left pending a substantial benefit of Rs5.444 billion."
He said both Nepra and KE failed to uphold their commitment to providing consumers with a significant relief during current difficult times.
"Karachi consumers, already burdened by the high cost of living and doing business, are now being further victimised by this injustice. Nepra, which is responsible for protecting the rights of electricity consumers, has fallen short of its mandate by not ensuring that full benefit is passed on to consumers. KE, on the other hand, continues to benefit from these unjustified delays in tariff reduction," he lamented.
While expressing concern over the lack of transparency in the regulatory process, Bilwani said it was highly disturbing that Nepra, after a thorough analysis, failed to enforce the full tariff reduction.
"K-Electric's failure to provide the full benefit of Rs5.444 billion, which could have alleviated the financial burden on people, is nothing short of economic betrayal," he remarked.
He urged both Nepra and KE to take immediate corrective action and ensure that the full benefit of tariff adjustment was passed on to consumers without further delay.
He also called for greater accountability from both organisations to ensure that consumer rights were safeguarded, particularly in the current challenging economic conditions.
"We demand that Nepra and K-Electric not only correct this oversight but also ensure that any future adjustments are transparent, fair and directly benefit people. The business community and citizens of Karachi deserve something better and we will continue to fight for their rights," he said.
Meanwhile, he referred to the dissenting opinion expressed by Nepra Member (Tariff) Mathar Niaz Rana, seconded by Member (Technical) Rafiq Sheikh, who had opposed the limited relief provided to KE consumers.
In his dissent, Rana argued that consumers should have been granted the full benefit of November adjustment, amounting to a reduction of Rs5.0029 per unit, which would have resulted in a direct benefit of over Rs7.215 billion.
"The KCCI fully supports Mathar Niaz Rana's dissenting view. His position represents the voice of Karachi business community and consumers, who are being unfairly burdened," he said, adding that Rs8.7 billion was still under consideration by the authority and yet to be finalised. As of now, Nepra has put the decision on hold, "which is really unusual", he noted.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Budget: JI assails govt for ‘neglecting' Karachi
Budget: JI assails govt for ‘neglecting' Karachi

Business Recorder

timean hour ago

  • Business Recorder

Budget: JI assails govt for ‘neglecting' Karachi

KARACHI: Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) Karachi Chief, Monem Zafar Khan has strongly criticised the budget 2025-26, claiming it demonstrated a clear neglect of Karachi — the economic hub of the country. Speaking at a press conference held at Idara Noor-e-Haq, he said that Karachi was conspicuously missing from the list of federal priorities. Flanked by several town chairmen, Monem Zafar Khan demanded an allocation of Rs 500 billion for Karachi's development, along with Rs 2 billion for each town and Rs 2.5 million for every Union Council (UC), in order to address the city's pressing issues. Highlighting the severe water crisis in Karachi, he said the K-IV water supply project — vital for the city's future — appears to have been sidelined by the federal government. Although Rs 40 billion were requested, the budget allocates just Rs 3.2 billion for the project, despite its scheduled completion by June 2026. He pointed out that while the Water Resources Division was allocated Rs 133 billion, the K-IV project's share amounts to only 2.5 percent of that total. The JI Karachi chief denounced the federal budget as a 'jigsaw puzzle of statistics' that ignores the city's core issues. He noted that the Karachi IT Park, launched in 2022 and expected to complete by 2026, received only Rs6 billion — a figure he described as 'peanuts' in relation to the scale and importance of the project. He further criticised the reduction in the Higher Education Commission's budget from Rs 65 billion to Rs 39.5 billion, and condemned the 18 percent tax imposed on the solar energy sector, calling it a severe blow to an emerging industry. Monem Zafar Khan lambasted the federal government for failing to complete several critical transport projects in the city, including the Green Line Bus, 20-bus Orange Line, and the Red Line. He stressed that Karachi has long been deprived of its fair share in resources, despite being the financial lifeline of Pakistan. Referring to historical trends, he said that while Sindh received Rs 178 billion from the federal government in 2007-08, the allocation has now increased to Rs 1,853 billion. Yet, the provincial government continues to centralise power, ignoring the urgent need for administrative and fiscal devolution. Monem Zafar Khan also turned his attention to what he described as rampant corruption and poor governance in solid waste management, particularly under the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP). He accused the Sindh government of outsourcing Karachi's waste management to inefficient and corrupt contractors, leading to severe issues during Eid-ul-Azha. He shared specific examples, including the case of a JI-run town that submitted its Eid waste management plan well in advance. The Solid Waste Management Board (SWMB) responded only two days before Eid, disregarding all local recommendations and issuing outdated instructions. In another case, while the SWMB committed to sending 15 pickup vehicles, only 10 were dispatched on the day — raising questions about the misuse of funds allocated for vehicles, staff, and fuel. The JI leader also narrated an incident where a town chairman lodged a complaint with the mayor about waste management failures. Instead of holding the contractor accountable, the mayor suspended the town's Deputy Director of Solid Waste, he said. In a scathing indictment, Monem Zafar Khan also accused the MQM, PPP, and PML-N of complicity in a 'fake census', which, according to him, cut Karachi's population in half. This undercounting, he said, has serious consequences for resource allocation and representation. He also highlighted the disparity between the government's treatment of the poor and lawmakers. 'On one hand, 100 million Pakistanis live below the poverty line. On the other, the government has approved a six hundred percent increase in the speaker's allowances and over 140 percent salary hikes for lawmakers,' he stated. Monem Zafar Khan urged the federal government to revise its approach and recognise Karachi's pivotal role in the national economy. He called for transparent governance, fair distribution of resources, and greater autonomy for local administrations to ensure the city's problems are addressed effectively. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

April FCA: KE seeks Rs4.69/unit negative adjustment
April FCA: KE seeks Rs4.69/unit negative adjustment

Business Recorder

time2 hours ago

  • Business Recorder

April FCA: KE seeks Rs4.69/unit negative adjustment

ISLAMABAD: K-Electric has sought negative adjustment of Rs 4.69 per unit to refund Rs 7.173 billion to its consumers under the FCA mechanism for the April 2025. However, pursuant to determination of Generation Tariff of Power plants of KE for the period post June 2023, KE has submitted the required partial load, open cycle and degradation curves along with Startup Cost for approval and an amount of Rs.16 billion for the period July 2023 to April 2025 is accordingly pending for adjustment. In addition, BQPS-III and KCCP heat rate adjustment for previous MYT amounting to Rs. 0.6 billion and Rs. 0.2 billion are also pending out of which Authority has set aside Rs.15.2 billion in KE's FCA decisions for November 2024 to March 2025. March FCA: KE seeks Rs5.02 interim negative adjustment KE has requested the Authority to also consider the remaining adjustment of accumulated actualization of fuel cost so that the recovery can be made from the negative fuel cost variation of March 2025 and April 2025 to ensure consumers are not burdened at a later stage. In this regard, Nepra is scheduled to conduct a public hearing on June 19, 2025 to consider the proposed adjustment. For deliberation during the hearing, following issues have been framed which are as (i) whether the requested FCA is justified; (ii) whether KE has followed the merit order while giving dispatch to its power plants as well as power purchases from external sources; and (iii) whether the request of KE to consider adjustment of accumulated actualization of fuel cost on account of partial load, open cycle and degradation curves along with startup cost from July to Dec. 2024, from the negative fuel cost variation is justified. All the interested/affected parties are invited to submit written/oral comments or objections as permissible under the law at the hearing. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

Govt set to lift surcharge cap on electricity bills
Govt set to lift surcharge cap on electricity bills

Express Tribune

time3 hours ago

  • Express Tribune

Govt set to lift surcharge cap on electricity bills

The federal government is planning to impose additional surcharges on electricity consumers by amending the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) Act, a move that would allow it to unilaterally increase electricity bills, sources said on Wednesday. According to official sources, the proposed amendment to the NEPRA Act will empower the government to exceed the current 10% cap on electricity surcharges, paving the way for higher charges on consumer bills. Sources said the government was preparing to remove the existing 10% limit on surcharges levied through power bills, with the new legal framework granting it broader authority to determine tariff hikes on a case-by-case basis and for specified durations. A proposal is also under consideration to charge consumers an additional Rs3.23 per unit as a surcharge. However, a final decision regarding the increase has not yet been made, sources clarified. In the past, surcharges collected from electricity bills were primarily used to pay interest on the growing circular debt. The government is now aiming to eliminate the circular debt altogether by borrowing Rs1,275 billion from commercial banks.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store