Andy Farrell is plumping for pedigree over form for the first Lions Test - but there is an uneasy, fingers-crossed feeling about it, writes CHRIS FOY
The visitors are set to rely on a side full of stellar reputations, but in several positions the players who have performed best are expected to miss out. That is certainly the case at No 8, where Ben Earl has made more of an impact than Jack Conan, but the Irish specialist is preferred.
There are various other examples, as the head coach is following the example of so many predecessors by trusting in players he knows best. James Lowe has been operating far below his usual, exalted standards on the left wing, but he is due to make the cut in the starting XV, partly due to the injury setbacks which have hampered back-three contenders Blair Kinghorn and Mack Hansen.
At scrum-half, Jamison Gibson-Park is another member of the dominant Leinster and Ireland contingent who will be deployed en masse, in the belief that he will soar to a performance peak when needed. Somehow, he was named Man of the Match in the win against the Brumbies in Canberra, but he had blown hot and cold in an unconvincing win in the Australian capital. Frankly, he has been eclipsed by stellar displays from Alex Mitchell and Ben White, but he is a Farrell favourite.
The pattern continues up front. Tom Curry has not reached his own familiar heights, but he will start at openside ahead of Jac Morgan, who has played the house down and been the Lions' pre-eminent jackal threat on the tour to date.
To complete the back-row doubts, Tadhg Beirne is seemingly set to start at blindside rather than Ollie Chessum, despite playing his best lately in the second row. Even the great Tadhg Furlong has just about located second gear - he is certainly not at full tilt.
But there are pockets of form. Ellis Genge and Dan Sheehan are on a thunderous roll in the front row. At lock, Maro Itoje and Joe McCarthy have both stood out with towering exploits. Finn Russell is in supreme form, as are Tommy Freeman and Huw Jones.
It is good to see common-sense should prevail as Jones is set to be unleashed alongside Scotland midfield partner Sione Tuipulotu. It makes perfect sense to tap into the established chemistry between those two and Russell.
So, all in all, this is not a form XV of Lions all going into the Test series with unstoppable momentum, far from it. There is an uneasy, fingers-crossed feeling about some of the marginal selections, but even allowing for the misgivings, this potential line-up should have far too much firepower for the vulnerable Australians.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Tadhg Beirne shows why he is Andy Farrell's prize poacher
S ky Sports are on to a winner with Dan Biggar and Ronan O'Gara. The two former fly halves have a natural rapport yet their easy banter never gets in the way of some searing insights. On one occasion yesterday, however, the TV execs must have been cursing Biggar for his honesty. As the Test match limped towards a conclusion, the Welshman admitted: 'It just feels a little bit flat, doesn't it? It doesn't feel like the end of a first Test at Suncorp at the beginning of a huge series.' It was left to others to scramble for reasons why the series might hold our attention for the next fortnight. Will Skelton and Rob Valetini may be ready for Melbourne. The Wallabies are wounded. They will be better next week. And so on.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
England face USA in Washington DC
Update: Date: 21:42 BST Title: Get Involved Content: #bbcrugby, WhatsApp 03301231826, text 81111 (UK only - texts will be charged at your standard message rate) As ever, do get in touch with your thoughts on tonight's game, England in general, or anything else. For starters, who has impressed you in the absence of the sizeable Lions contingent? Please remember to pop your name at the end of your message. Update: Date: 21:39 BST Title: England's absentees Content: USA v England (22:05 BST) Here's a reminder of all of the players currently absent from the England camp due to Lions duty... Ollie Chessum, Luke Cowan-Dickie, Tom Curry, Elliot Daly, Ben Earl, Owen Farrell, Tommy Freeman, Ellis Genge, Jamie George, Maro Itoje, Alex Mitchell, Henry Pollock, Fin Smith, Marcus Smith, and Will Stuart. Update: Date: 21:36 BST Title: Team news - USA Content: USA v England (22:05 BST) USA boss Scott Lawrence has handed debuts to prop Ezekiel Lindenmuth and Rufus McLean at right wing. Benjamin Bonasso, who has scored tries against Belgium and Spain this July, will captain the Eagles. USA XV: Storti; McLean, Besag, Pittman, Fricker; Hilsenbeck, De Haas; Lindenmuth, Geiger, Davis, Redelinghuys, Naqali, Bonasso (c), Daniel, Fa'Anana Schultz. Replacements: Klein, Iscaro, Kofe, Helu, Poidevin, Alikhan, Smith, Futi. Update: Date: 21:33 BST Title: Team news - England Content: USA v England (22:05 BST) Steve Borthwick has rung the changes for England's final Test of the summer, with only George Ford, Luke Northmore, and Alex Coles retained from the XV which started the second Test against Argentina. Immanuel Feyi-Waboso returns after missing the two Argentina Tests through suspension while Jack van Poortvliet starts at scrum-half after coming off the bench to score the match-winning try against Argentina last Saturday. There are debuts for Arthur Clark, Joe Carpenter, and Max Ojomoh while Gabriel Oghre, Charlie Atkinson, and Oscar Beard could earn their first caps off the bench. England XV: Carpenter; Feyi-Waboso, Northmore, Ojomoh, Murley; Ford (c), Van Poortvliet; Rood, Langdon, Opoku-Fordjour, Coles, Clark, Cunningham-South, Pepper, Dombrant. Replacements: Oghre, Baxter, Davison, Hill, B Curry, Randall, Atkinson, Beard. Update: Date: 21:29 BST Title: England going for seven in a row Content: USA v England (22:05 BST) Hello there! It's nearly time for England's final Test of the summer, against USA in Washington DC. Steve Borthwick's side are unbeaten in six matches - most recently completing a 2-0 series win over Argentina - and have only lost once in 2025. Can they make it seven wins in a row? Let's find out.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Lions start with promise but intensity drops off
In 2013, the final moments of the British and Irish Lions' first Test win against Australia had the entire Suncorp Stadium Kurtley Beale slipped, when attempting to convert a match-winning penalty, and the Lions escaped to lead the series Excitement. Edge-of-your-seat stuff. It is what makes the Lions so forward 12 years and Andy Farrell's side also delivered at Suncorp Stadium with a 27-19 victory - the Lions' ninth straight win in result was the same but the feeling was Lions were so dominant in the first 50 minutes that the outcome was never in side raced out of the blocks to lead 17-5 at half-time after tries by Sione Tuipulotu and Tom Curry. A 12-point lead did not do justice to their Russell at his mercurial best was dominating his head to head with rookie Australia fly-half Tom Lynagh and, in partnership with scrum-half Jamison Gibson-Park, was running the Tom Curry and Tadgh Beirne, both of whom responded to questions over whether their form warranted a starting spot, were bossing the physical Ellis Genge and hooker Dan Sheehan were battering Australia's defensive line."The Lions looked battle-hardened, ready and a lot of the clunky stuff in the warm-ups had gone," former Lion Tom Shanklin told the BBC. "They looked sharp in attack, they knew what they were doing and Australia ran out of options."Finn Russell and Gibson-Park were quality. The way they pull the strings, the time they have on the ball, their decision-making makes everyone's jobs so much easier."Andy Nicol, a Lions tourist in Australia in 2001, heaped praise on Curry and Beirne."Tom Curry was off the scale," he told the BBC's Rugby Union Weekly. "He smashed players in contact and his metres after contact was amazing as well."Beirne was man of the match and played the full game, Curry played 57 minutes and I would happily have given it to him. He was outstanding, so was Maro Itoje." 'I want the series to be competitive' When Dan Sheehan added a third try early in the second half, the Lions surpassing their record score against Australia (31-0 in 1966) looked on the cards. This much-anticipated series opener was almost too one-sided."As a former Lion, I wanted the Lions to win but I want the series to be competitive," said Nicol. "At that point [24-5 up] there was a chance that it wasn't going to be."But as the Lions brought on their replacements, their performance dropped. They lost momentum and cohesion, giving Australia the chance to play themselves into some replacements Carlo Tizzano and Tate McDermott crossed for late tries to nearly bring the hosts back within touching Joe Schmidt's side showing heart to come back into the game, it was too late to ignite the crowd in Brisbane. The Lions' lead was never seriously noticed some Australian fans not watching the game as their attention wandered with the Lions seemingly cruising to victory."Ten to 15 minutes into the second half, a lot of the corporate boxes were full of Aussie fans standing talking to each other and not watching the game," he told BBC's Rugby Union Weekly."They had switched off and almost chucked the game, thinking it wasn't going to happen. That would not have been good for the series."The atmosphere was great in the first half."But the second half had nothing and there was no atmosphere in the stadium at all, even the Wallabies try... they weren't really celebrating. It was relief around me." 'The Lions would have gone up a gear' Former Ireland head coach Schmidt has come up with numerous masterplans over the years to defeat the world's best. However, his side failed to properly assert themselves until the final quarter against the England wing Chris Ashton said Schmidt had made a mistake in not releasing his players to face the Lions in their warm-up games. "If you have not faced them, even for 10, 15 minutes, how are you meant to expect the level or have some understanding what a Lions Test is about in the first 20 minutes?" he told BBC Sport. "You're not. And after 20 minutes, the game was almost over."In order to help spark an epic Test series, former Scotland captain John Barclay even found himself hoping Australia would score before half-time."I felt that if Australia had got close, the Lions would have gone up a gear," he told Rugby Union Weekly. "Australia did well off the bench but the Lions had so much in the tank."I expected a lot more from Australia. Joe Schmidt always brings a lot of detail to how his players can play the game but it looked like all the detail was missing."I think they will be much better next week, they have to be, but the Lions have so many more levels they can go up."The difference in class between the nines and 10s is night and day."His fellow Scot Nicol also feels the Lions can take their game to another level."If the Lions play for a full 80 minutes next week, I think there is a 20-to-30 point gap between these two sides," he will tell if these two dance partners are suited to produce a Lions series for the Cricket Ground is expected to have more than 90,000 people in attendance for the second Test next is a venue worthy of an epic.
