‘They're bombing us almost every single day': Windsor defence lawyer applauds restrictions to virtual courtroom
Criminal defence lawyer Patricia Brown said she has witnessed several inappropriate and offensive uses of the virtual platform in recent weeks.
'I just cannot believe this level of disruption that's happening,' Brown said. 'Before the last couple months, I've not experienced it.'
Brown has had hearings derailed by participants who unmute themselves and make offensive, racist, pornographic or homophobic comments.
'They're essentially kind of taking over the court. It's extremely distracting. It causes a lot of disruption,' Brown said.
Although she hasn't witnessed it personally, Brown said other courtrooms have also been derailed by a participant posting inappropriate images of swastikas or pornography in front of their camera.
'It is extremely offensive, to members of the public, staff, myself, and members of our community that are just trying to go about our business,' Brown said.
She thanked Justice Joseph Perfetto Thursday, for asking Zoom participants to identify themselves during a murder sentencing hearing.
Those who would not identify themselves Thursday were left in the waiting room and not given access to the Espinosa Montes proceedings.
The judge referenced a new memo circulated this week from the Ministry of the Solicitor General (MAG).
New rules for Zoom
So-called 'Zoom Bombing' is not a new problem.
It first arose at the start of the pandemic after the platform's usage skyrocketed as a way for everything from church to court to continue despite lockdowns.
Five years later, its such a problem, MAG has now restricted all public access to hearing links.
'Effective immediately, the Court has advised that the public will not be permitted to observe proceedings virtually. If the public would like to attend, they will be required to do so in-person,' Assistant Deputy Attorney General Katie Wood wrote in a memo to court staff dated July 16.
Wood said there has been a 'notable rise' in bombing incidents recently which she describes as 'deeply upsetting and unacceptable'.
Victims or complainants will have to receive approval and a link from either the Crown's office, or staff with the Victim/Witness Assistance Program.
The media must specifically request access from the Court Communications Officer and identify themselves before gaining access.
MAG has also updated its 'Reporting Zoom Bombings' tool, as a 'critical' part of the problem and to 'support justice security investigation efforts'.
MAG is also warning court staff to verify usernames even if they appear to be law enforcement, counsel, legal students or interpreters.
Brown doesn't believe the restriction on virtual links flies in the face of the 'open court' policy.
'The open court policy is still here for individuals to come down to the courthouse,' Brown said noting standing up in court and yelling profanities would see a person removed.
'When you are in a courtroom there are certain rules you have to adhere to.'
Eric Costaris, Crown Attorney for Windsor and Essex County deferred comment to MAG.
CTV News has reached out to Zoom for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
3 minutes ago
- National Post
Court ruling declaring removal of bike lanes unconstitutional is 'ridiculous': Doug Ford
THORNHILL — Ontario Premier Doug Ford teed off Wednesday on a court decision declaring his law to remove three Toronto bike lanes unconstitutional, calling it the 'most ridiculous' ruling he has ever seen. Article content Ford has already said his government plans to appeal, even as it works on a compromise with the city to both keep the bike lanes and add extra lanes for vehicle traffic. Article content Article content He said he has faith that the Court of Appeal will overturn the lower-court ruling, but in the event it does not, he did not rule out using the notwithstanding clause to save the law. Article content Article content 'Let's see what happens at the Court of Appeals, and then we'll go from there, but I have confidence in the courts,' Ford said at an unrelated transit announcement. Article content Ontario Superior Court Justice Paul Schabas ruled the lane removals would put people at an 'increased risk of harm and death' and violate the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Article content He noted that the government had received advice from experts, reports from Toronto officials and evidence from the city and elsewhere that removing bike lanes 'will not achieve the asserted goal' of the law, to reduce traffic. Article content Ford made the removal of bike lanes on Bloor Street, Yonge Street and University Avenue a campaign issue during the snap election he called and won in February, and he says the judge's ruling tramples on people's democratic rights. Article content Article content 'This is the most ridiculous decision I've ever seen,' he said. Article content Article content 'I've never seen a decision like this, that a judge overrules the people of Ontario because of ideology — not because of law — ideology, but we knew when they picked this judge where it was going anyway, so it's not a big surprise.' Article content It's not the first time Ford has called judges' integrity into question. In April he blasted judges he perceives as being soft on crime, and floated ideas such as electing judges and offering them payouts to retire early. Article content
Globe and Mail
3 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Alberta targets predatory tow-truck drivers with exclusion zones, fines
Alberta's government is creating fines and rules meant to curb predatory tow-truck drivers. Starting Friday, there will be 200-metre exclusion zones around accident scenes for tow-truck operators, who must stay back unless police or drivers involved say otherwise or face a $1,000 fine. At a Wednesday news conference, Transportation Minister Devin Dreeshen said the government has heard concerns about tow-truck drivers showing up at car accidents and pressuring those involved to unnecessarily accept their services. In some cases, he said, tow-truck drivers have charged excessive fees and withheld necessary information from those whose vehicles were towed. 'The last thing someone needs at a collision scene is to be harassed by dishonest tow-truck drivers, pressuring them to agree to towing services,' Dreeshen said. 'These changes penalize bad actors in the tow-truck industry and shield Albertans from unethical practices.' Edmonton police Insp. Angela Kemp, speaking alongside Dreeshen, said the force has been aware of predatory towing for years. Kemp said it has been difficult to assess the scale of the problem, as police rely on self-reporting, but there have been more reports of it in recent years as people become aware. She gave two examples of police charging tow-truck companies. Police arrest 18 in Greater Toronto tow truck bust Extortions, arsons targeting South Asian businesses on the rise, Edmonton police warn In October, a company was charged with theft over $5,000 for allegedly refusing to release a vehicle it had towed unless it received a fee from an insurance company. In May, the owners of 10 towing companies were charged with fraud, Kemp said. 'During this investigation, police discovered that numerous tow-truck companies in Edmonton were reportedly fraudulently billing insurance companies for services that were not provided,' she said. 'Police also learned that these companies were allegedly inflating bills, including charges to insurance companies of upwards of over $5,000 for basic collision tows.' The government's new rules are nearly identical to a bylaw passed earlier this year by Calgary city council, though the city's fine can be up to $10,000. Dreeshen said the province's fine is lower because the government is trying to set a basic standard to ensure Albertans have the same protection. He said the government's rules are a first step and further measures could be taken, such as following Ontario in developing a mandatory code of conduct and certification process for tow truck drivers. 'The government of Alberta will continue working with industry and other stakeholders to explore additional solutions.'
CTV News
3 minutes ago
- CTV News
IIO investigating after man injured during arrest in Nanaimo, B.C.
Investigators from B.C.'s Independent Investigations Office are seen in this file photo from the IIO. The B.C. police watchdog is asking witnesses to come forward after a man in Nanaimo was injured during an arrest earlier this year. According to a statement released by the Independent Investigations Office of BC, Nanaimo RCMP officers arrested a man near his home in the Sherwood Forest area at around 12:40 p.m. on April 20. 'There was an interaction between the man and police during the arrest, and the man sustained an injury that appears to have been self-inflicted while being taken into custody,' the statement said. The man was taken to hospital for treatment for the injury, which has since been deemed as one of serious harm. The investigation will determine what, if any, the connection is between that serious harm and the action or inaction of the officer, the statement said. The IIO is called in after any police-related incidents that result in death or serious injury, whether or not there are any allegations of wrongdoing. Any witnesses who have not already provided a statement, or who have video of the incident, are asked to contact the IIO at its Witness Line, toll-free at 1-855-446-8477, or via the contact form on the website.
