Latest news with #Scholes
Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Sport
- Irish Daily Mirror
Roy Keane record set straight by Paul Scholes as he calls out problem he 'hates'
Despite forming a reputation as one of the Premier League's all-time enforcers, Roy Keane was that and a whole lot more. That's according to former Manchester United team-mate Paul Scholes, who has revealed the one Keane stereotype that really boils his blood. Keane, 53, arrived at Old Trafford in 1993 for what was then a British transfer record fee of £3.75million. The Cork man had already built up a renown for his tough-tackling methods at Nottingham Forest, leading some to believe he fitted the mould of a traditional defensive midfielder. But Scholes, who was part of the same United squad that won a historic treble in 1999, has jumped to his old comrade's defence. And the English legend has suggested nothing could be further from the truth, insisting that misconception has sprung from the more modern habit of wanting to pigeonhole players with certain labels. "People talk about this 'No. 6 role', don't they? The [Claude] Makelele role," he said on The Overlap Fan Debate. "And I think a lot of people see Roy as that a little bit. He was anything but that. "As a central midfielder for Manchester United, you couldn't just stay there [sitting deep] and let everybody else play. You had to be involved in everything. You had to be able to defend. You had to be able to attack. He [Keane] was unbelievable. A running machine, but with quality with it. "He'd do everything. He'd overlap his winger both sides. He'd sprint forward, he sprinted back, he led the team, almost in a Bryan Robson type of way. That's why I hate all this, 'He's a No. 8. He's a No. 6.' [It] gets on my nerves. Especially as a central midfield player, you should be able to do everything." It's easy to forget Mayfield-born Keane first earned Sir Alex Ferguson's attention as a much more attack-minded talent. The Republic of Ireland great scored 33 goals in 154 appearances for Forest, including a career-high 14 finishes during the 1991/92 campaign. He was perhaps shoehorned into a more defensive role while playing for the national team, more out of necessity than anything else. The long-time Republic of Ireland captain was widely viewed as the gem of the squad but had to take on more protective responsibilities than were required at United. Scholes, 50, went on to use Chelsea midfielder Moises Caicedo as a template for comparison against his former skipper. Caicedo played every league fixture for the Blues this season, but Scholes questioned whether his all-round impact made enough of a difference. "Was there much quality? Did he create a lot? Did he control loads of games for Chelsea? I don't remember that," he continued. "I think there's an era now, with midfield players especially, where you can go through seasons and games without really contributing a what Roy Keane did [contributed in all areas]. And he'd do it in this [current United] team as well." There's no telling what incumbent United boss Ruben Amorim might do for a player of Keane's profile today. The current United squad is crying out for leadership in all areas, not to mention top-tier footballers willing to give their utmost for the club. The Red Devils are in yet another transitional period as Amorim gets to work moulding his squad in his first summer transfer window with United. And the midfield is a particular area of focus, with current captain Bruno Fernandes among those being linked with the exit. A record low Premier League finish of 15th has left the club without European football next season and a general gloom around Old Trafford. And many fans are reminded of Keane's contributions across his 12-year stay at United as they yearn for another talent of that calibre.
Daily Record
7 hours ago
- Sport
- Daily Record
Man Utd 'world class genius' was teacher's pet but he took no s***
Fergie didn't suffer fools during his managerial career but had a soft spot for this player Former Man Utd No. 2 Rene Meulensteen has revealed how Paul Scholes was Sir Alex Ferguson 's 'teacher's pet'. And the Dutchman said it's simply because the England icon was 'a genius'. Scholes spent two trophy-laden decades at Old Trafford and even came out of retirement during a time of need for Ferguson. And asked who the biggest teacher's pet was during his time as assistant to Sir Alex, Meulensteen told Action Network: 'Paul Scholes because of the footballer he was, he was a genius, and I would rate him as one of the best world class midfielders ever. 'He was a genius and in training, if the bus was there and wasn't moving, he could hit it with a ball from 60 yards. 'I remember once, I was standing next to the manager with a cup of tea and Scholes wacked the ball from 40 yards. "I saw the ball coming and Scholes ran past me and said why did you move? 'We had a soft spot for him because everyone knew how important he was. "He was a no-nonsense player who took no s*** and was a really good trainer but also was at his best. 'He wasn't loud but when he said something, people would listen. Everyone respected him for how good of a player he was.' And despite Ferguson's reputation for giving players the famous "hairdryer" treatment, Meulensteen said he didn't see the legendary Scot lose the rag much. He said: "In all of my time as a first team coach, I can only remember when he raised his voice after West Ham when Nani got sent off towards the end of the season and basically, he did it to fire up all of the other players to say, you have to work double as hard to get us over the line. "He didn't want anyone to feel hard done by, but he was direct and tough with Nani but with a hidden message to all of the other players. "Other than that, I always felt he was spot on and never spoke for too long. He addressed things in two or three minutes at half time and that was it. "I was lucky to be there at a time when we won more than we lost so most of the time it was great. "If he did run into a defeat we didn't expect, even with a 6-1 defeat to Man City, you would think here we go. But the biggest thing that I took away from it was he was disappointed by the lack of players listening. "We got 1-0 down and Jonny Evans gets sent off and then go 3-0 down and we started going forward and Darren Fletcher scores to make it 3-1. It would've still been a hard struggle. Sir Alex was big on goal difference and losing 6-1, he said it cost us the league and it did by one goal."
Mint
5 days ago
- Business
- Mint
What sparks an investing revolution?
What prompts a revolution? When it comes to investing, no change has been as great as that which began with researchers at the University of Chicago in the 1960s. Their financial-theory revolution changed the way that almost everyone invests, and made speculators many trillions of dollars. The transformation is the subject of 'Tune Out the Noise", a documentary by Errol Morris, an Academy Award winner, which held its premiere in New York on March 6th. His film includes interviews with academics and investors, such as Eugene Fama, Myron Scholes and David Booth, who took ideas about market efficiency and diversification from the textbook and put them into practice in the markets. This led to a surge in the use of data and a disciplined focus on costs, in turn providing the foundation for modern passive investing. Mr Morris's film may, in theory, be about brilliant individuals, but its most powerful message is about the role played by chance. History, like markets, is affected by randomness, and luck brought together the right people at the right time. Each had to be present for the financial revolution to emerge. The University of Chicago's role is just about the only part of the story that happened by design. It had become the nexus for financial research owing to its reputation for excellence in economics. The Centre for Research in Security Prices was established there in 1960, and its wealth of data on the price of bonds and stocks over decades enabled the academics to do their work. Randomness is apparent just about everywhere else. Although Mr Fama, who would later win a Nobel prize for his work on asset pricing, completed a doctorate at Chicago in 1964, he almost never made it to the university. After completing an undergraduate education at Tufts University, he had to chase up his application to Chicago, discovering that it had never been received. On phoning the university, he reached the dean of students by chance, who told him about a scholarship for Tufts graduates, before offering it to him on the spot. It was a similar story for Mr Scholes, another future Nobel laureate. In the summer of 1963 he started a job as a computer programmer despite scant expertise. The six other programmers who were hired failed to show up for the job, leaving Mr Scholes alone to assist in the financial research of other academics. He took to the work, abandoning his plan to return to his family's book-publishing company, and was in time offered a place on the university's doctoral programme. Mr Booth, whose name now adorns Chicago's business school, and Rex Sinquefield, his business partner, put the academic ideas into practice by co-founding Dimensional Fund Advisors, a firm that today boasts $777bn in assets under management. In 1969 Mr Booth narrowly avoided being made to fight in the Vietnam war, when a lenient officer postponed his conscription since he planned to study for a PhD. Mr Sinquefield did serve in the armed forces during the war, but poor eyesight kept him from combat. A few twists of fate—an unanswered phone call, a prickly recruiting officer, more diligent computer programmers or better eyesight—would have prevented some of the men from reaching Chicago. Without the confluence of thought, investing might look very different today, making the world much poorer. Such happenstance is found elsewhere, too: other parts of economics and nuclear physics, for instance, relied upon the concentration of talent in America after geniuses, often Jewish, fled from the Nazis. In the 1950s Silicon Valley looked to be an unlikely home for the American tech industry, with corporate research mostly taking place on the east coast. That changed in large part because William Shockley, an inventor of transistor technology, set up his own firm in the San Francisco Bay Area. The company's employees went on to establish giants including Fairchild Semiconductor and Intel. Shockley had picked the area simply because he wanted to be close to his elderly mother. 'Tune Out the Noise" leaves viewers wondering where the next investing revolution will come from. Quantitative trading has speeded up market activity, which is not quite as transformative as the changes that emerged from the 1960s. Some fret that cryptocurrencies are the most significant newish innovation, and that they are the preserve of speculators and criminals. But, in time, more useful ideas could emerge from the industry. There is always a chance. Subscribers to The Economist can sign up to our Opinion newsletter, which brings together the best of our leaders, columns, guest essays and reader correspondence.
Metro
6 days ago
- Entertainment
- Metro
Chelsea issue telling response after Scholes makes bold Caicedo claim
Chelsea issued a telling response after Paul Scholes' comments about midfielder Moises Caicedo caused a stir on social media. After a mixed first season at Stamford Bridge, Caicedo has grown into his role at Chelsea, featuring in all 38 Premier League games and thriving in Enzo Maresca's side. The Ecuadorian international was deservedly crowned Chelsea's Player of the Year, having helped guide the club back to the Champions League as well as scoring in the final of their Conference League win over Real Betis. But not everyone was convinced with Caicedo's impact for the Blues this season, most notably former Manchester United midfielder Scholes. Speaking on the latest episode of The Overlap with SkyBet, Scholes said: 'I think a lot of people talk about Caicedo. 'He's played 38 games'. Brilliant, what an achievement. Wake up to find news on your club in your inbox every morning with Metro's Football Newsletter. Sign up to our newsletter and then select your team in the link we'll send you so we can get football news tailored to you. 'But was there much quality? Did he create a lot? Did he control a lot of games for Chelsea? I don't remember that. 'I think there's an era now, with midfielders especially, where you can go through seasons and games without really contributing.' Many fans on social media were surprised by Scholes' comments, and it appears even Chelsea were keen to issue a rebuttal. Posting on the club's X account, the Blues posted a thread of statistics highlighting that Caicedo had made the most appearances (38) and won the most tackles (114) of any Chelsea player in the Premier League last season. — Chelsea FC (@ChelseaFC) June 3, 2025 Only four players made more tackles than Caicedo in the league last campaign, with Marc Cucurella the next best in a Chelsea shirt with 67. Some fans on social media were less cryptic with their rebutals towards Scholes for his comments. 'This is genuinely one of the worst bits of punditry I've ever seen. And if Paul Scholes has said this he quite simply doesn't watch much football,' one user wrote on X. More Trending Another added: 'You can't watch Chelsea's games, and do even a 30-second stat check, and think Moises Caicedo that was a star for Brighton, and now Chelsea doesn't 'contribute a lot'. The eye test doesn't lie. The stats don't lie. He's wrong'. Even Caicedo's fellow teammates have been vocal with their praise about his consistent levels of performance this season. 'He's a machine. From the start of the season, he has been our best player,' Cole Palmer told Sky Sports last month. 'Wins the ball back all the time. Always 100 per cent everyday. Humble, nice to everyone and everyone loves him.' For more stories like this, check our sport page. Follow Metro Sport for the latest news on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. MORE: John Obi Mikel backs Chelsea to sign two Man Utd stars and build Europe's best young squad MORE: Chelsea respond to AC Milan transfer request for Mike Maignan MORE: Ian Wright says he 'would love' Arsenal to sign £22m former Everton midfielder
Scottish Sun
6 days ago
- Entertainment
- Scottish Sun
‘Worst punditry I've ever seen' – Paul Scholes slammed for comments about Premier League giants' player of the season
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) PAUL SCHOLES has upset Chelsea supporters by admitting that he's been underwhelmed by Moises Caicedo's performances. The former Brighton midfielder, 23, was recently named the Blues' Player of the Season and Players' Player of the Season. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 Paul Scholes appeared on The Overlap Fan Debate Credit: The Overlap 4 Moises Caicedo has impressed Chelsea fans this term Credit: Getty Caicedo started all 38 Prem games for Enzo Maresca's side, contributing the most passes of any midfielder in the league while being the fifth top tackler. Despite the Ecuadorian's popularity at Stamford Bridge, Scholes is yet to be fully convinced. Speaking on The Overlap Fan Debate, the Manchester United legend, 50, said: "I think a lot of people talk about Caicedo. 'He's played 38 games'. Brilliant, what an achievement. "But was there much quality? Did he create a lot? Did he control a lot of games for Chelsea? I don't remember that. READ MORE IN FOOTBALL COUPLE GOALS Declan Rice and Wag make rare public appearance after abuse from cruel trolls "I think there's an era now, with midfielders especially, where you can go through seasons and games without really contributing." Scholes' comments received little backlash from his fellow panellists during the programme. But Blues fans online were not happy at all with the former England star's assessment. One blasted on X: "This is genuinely one of the worst bits of punditry I've ever seen. And if Paul Scholes has said this he quite simply doesn't watch much football. BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK 4 "Saying Caicedo is 'not contributing much' is absolutely outrageous." While a second fumed: "Respect to Scholesy and his career but he clearly doesn't watch much football anymore. Jadon Sancho shares his Chelsea highlights reel as he says goodbye to fans ahead of Man Utd return "We're talking about not only Chelsea POTY but probably the best DM in league last season." Referencing Scholes' brief stint in charge of Oldham, a third wrote: "This is why he only coach a team for two weeks and got sacked the next morning since then no team wanted him in the lower division." Although another did add: "In the wider conversation what Scholes said made sense. Chill out." 'FLOGGED TO DEATH' The ex-midfielder also called on Man Utd to stick with struggling forward Rasmus Hojlund. Scholes said: "I'd keep Hojlund. I know he's not been great, but he's a 22-year-old kid who has been asked to play centre-forward for Manchester United on his own for the last two years. "He's had to play every week. He's the only one there, and he's a 22-year-old kid. "With the way they play, Man United should have at least three top centre-forwards, and I'd bring him into that group. "Get [Victor] Osimhen and [Viktor] Gyokeres. Hojlund has struggled - like mad of late especially but he's not had the chance to sit down and watch. "If a striker is lacking confidence the manager should sit him down and say, 'Have a look, get a bit of hunger back, a bit of feeling back for the game'. "We all know he has centre-forward qualities — we've seen it. Not enough, I know that. But if he had experience around him. Say he had Andy Cole and Dwight Yorke around him, it would bring him on so much. He's been absolutely flogged to death." 4 TRANSFER NEWS LIVE: ALL THE LATEST FROM THE SUMMER WINDOW
