Tube station book swaps end over fire safety fears
A decision to end free book exchanges at London Underground stations on safety grounds has been branded "ridiculous" by a former fire chief.The benefits of these mini-libraries, which have operated in stations across London for years, outweigh the fire risks, according to former London Fire Brigade (LFB) borough commander Steve Dudeney who called the ban "overkill".LFB said "combustible material poses a fire safety risk", while Transport for London (TfL) said it would work "to see if book swaps can be reintroduced".Tian, who commutes from Oval Tube station in south London, said: "It's not a tragedy compared to other things happening in the world but it's disappointing for local residents."
'Legislation taken to the nth degree'
Section 7 of the Fire Precautions (Sub-surface Railway Stations) (England) Regulations 2009 states: "All parts of station premises must be kept clear of any accumulation of combustible refuse."Mr Dudeney said: "Bearing in mind those regulations have been in place for 16 years and there hasn't been a fire… I think it's a ridiculous application. It's overkill."If you've got a small bookshelf on a platform and in the upstairs area, the risk is there but it's negligible."Someone has taken the legislation to the nth degree without using experience and skill to use a proper assessment of the risk."
Tian added: "I'm obviously quite dismayed and disappointed."Firstly, it feels heavy-handed particularly because where the book exchange is is at the street level and, secondly, there are still the daily free newspapers in the station."It just felt very sudden and it wasn't really clear why it was a fire safety issue."
'More sustainable locations'
Kamal Shah, chair of North Harrow Community Library, said he "could see both sides".He said: "I can see why people are upset. It's unfortunate but I feel that TfL are not entirely to blame here."The biggest problem is people being inconsiderate; if people hadn't been vandalising them or dumping stuff around the shelving, TfL would have been happy to carry on the scheme"There are other places where [book swaps] happen which are more sustainable than stations."
An LFB spokesperson said: "We are working with TfL with regards to their responsibility to remove all book libraries from subsurface stations. "This is due to combustible material posing a fire safety risk if it is stored on these premises. "Non-subsurface stations have been asked to remove book libraries from display until they have the correct fire safety plans in place."A spokesperson for TfL said: "We work very closely with LFB and other emergency services to ensure our services run safely and, following guidance from the fire service, we have advised our staff to remove book swaps from stations. "We will also work with local communities to redistribute books to alternative local locations in the meantime."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
14 hours ago
- The Independent
New bus route to join London's 194km Superloop expansion
A new bus route named the 'Bakerloop' is set to improve transport connections in south- east London and will launch for passengers this autumn. The express bus service will connect Waterloo station to Elephant and Castle and Lewisham, and will run via Old Kent Road, Burgess Park and New Cross Gate. It is set to mirror the proposed Bakerloo tube line extension route, and is part of the Superloop network expansion, a 194km network of bus services that has improved transport in the city's suburbs. Consultation on the BL1 route closed on 14 March, with Transport for London (TfL) stating that it received mostly positive support from residents. Geoff Hobbs, TfL's director of public transport service planning, said: "It is great to see support for the 'Bakerloop' express bus running between Waterloo and Lewisham which would enable us to improve public transport connectivity and capacity between southeast London and central London by delivering some of the same benefits that the Bakerloo line extension would.' The BL1 is due to operate every 12 minutes during Monday to Saturday daytimes, and then every 15 minutes during Sundays, evenings and early mornings. Feedback from local stakeholders and residents found that 82 per cent agreed the route would be more convenient, and 79 per cent said it would result in a quicker bus journey time. The mayor of Lewisham Brenda Dacres said: "Lewisham welcomes the launch of the Bakerloop bus and thanks the Mayor and TfL for taking action to address the long-standing transport gap in south east London. 'But this must be just the beginning. With growing public support, we will continue to press for the Bakerloo Line Upgrade and Extension - a game-changing project that will mean faster journeys and new opportunities for our community as well as thousands of homes, jobs and economic growth unlocked for the UK." Three other routes have also been proposed, which would travel between Ealing Broadway and Hendon, Stratford and Chingford Hatch and Clapham Junction and Elham station. Consultations for all three are set to begin in autumn.
BBC News
20 hours ago
- BBC News
Waterloo to Lewisham 'Bakerloop' bus route to launch in autumn
A new bus route named the Bakerloop is set to launch in autumn to connect stations and areas in south-east for London (TfL) said the BL1 express bus service will run between Waterloo and Lewisham and is part of the Superloop network areas the bus will mirror the proposed Bakerloo Tube line extension route covering stops such as Old Kent Road and Burgess consultation on the BL1 route closed on 14 March and received mostly positive support from residents and local stakeholders, TfL said. 'Just the beginning' A bus stop that was proposed on Station Road towards Waterloo has been removed to allow a "quicker and more direct route" for the Bakerloop when leaving of Lewisham, Brenda Dacres said: "Lewisham welcomes the launch of the Bakerloop bus and thanks the mayor and TfL for taking action to address the long-standing transport gap in southeast London. But this must be just the beginning."TfL's director of Public Transport Service Planning said that they will monitor all bus services to accurately reflect customer demand in the area. The BL1 will operate between 05:00 and 00:30 every 12 minutes during the daytime from Monday to Saturday and every 15 minutes in the evenings and on has also revealed new plans for three further routes - consultations on these proposals are set to begin this autumn.
Metro
a day ago
- Metro
Londoners take graffiti covered Tube trains into their own hands
A group of people took Tube graffiti into their own hands by giving carriages a scrub themselves. Recent months have seen a dramatic increase in defaced carriages, with Underground trains frequently seen covered with graffiti both on the inside and outside. Joe Reeve, from Looking for Growth, led a team to spruce up trains on Sunday morning. He told Metro: 'We are seeing this [graffiti] every single day. I take the Bakerloo Line every day. I see someone push through the barriers, and then every carriage is covered in graffiti. 'It's one of the those things that bugs people.' He added: 'Londoners are fed up and the cavalry is here. We are not going away.' His team used an environmentally friendly water-based graffiti remover to clear the writing plastered all over the carriages, including on the doors, floors and ceilings. But he explained that while some stains came off on the first wipe, others took far longer to remove, suggesting they had been left for weeks. He said: 'It comes off in the first wipe if it's under a week. When the graffiti's older it sticks more. By not dealing with it right away, it makes it much harder and more expensive to remove it later.' They're hoping to return to the fleet on Tuesday, and this time Joe hopes they will cover a full carriage every 30 minutes. In the last few months, graffiti has become a common sight on the Tube in recent months, specifically on the Bakerloo and Central lines. Both happen to have some of the oldest rolling stock on the network, with Bakerloo line trains having been continuously in service since 1970 – the oldest fleet still operating in Britain today. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video But the problem has spread onto other lines and newer trains, with even the brand new Piccadilly Line stock, which has yet to begin service, covered in artwork on arrival from Germany last year. Many commuters have said the graffiti reminds them of the New York Subway in the 1980s, when the system was well-know for being hotspot for crime and tagging. London Assembly member Bassam Mahfouz said that as well as making trains look a 'complete eyesore' the artwork was making passengers feel less safe. He said: 'If it is removed within a reasonable period of time, then that minimises the number of people who see it and therefore, there is no point putting even the sliver of effort to my artwork if it's not going to be seen, and I'll move somewhere else. Last month, TfL explained that a faulty automatic train washer was partly responsible for the uptick in graffiti visible on trains, but later clarified that the problem had been rectified. However commuters are increasingly convinced the problem is a symptom of the network's ageing rolling stock, with some suggesting that a shortage of trains on both lines means TfL is unable to take sets out of service to rid them of graffiti. One user commented on Reddit: 'TfL's current budget constraints means less money is being spent on low-level maintenance requirements such as graffiti removal, so it's not being removed much, and more graffiti is encouraging more graffiti and so on.' Another factor is the lack of CCTV coverage on both lines, with the exception of some refurbished Central Line trains, so vandals are rarely caught on camera. More Trending Joe blames a combination of poor procurement and management at the top, in particular the Mayor of London Sadiq Khan. TfL said that it works to remove graffiti quickly, but added that where it cannot be wiped down easily it is covered wherever possible before being attended to during engineering hours, in order to keep trains in service. Siwan Hayward, director of security, policing and enforcement said: 'The safety of our customers and staff is our top priority. We are working closely with the police to prevent crime and anti-social behaviour on the network, with over 2,500 police and police community support officers and 500 TfL enforcement staff patrolling the network at all times. 'We work hard to ensure that our customers and staff feel safe when travelling on the network and continue to strengthen our capability to deter and detect fare evaders and ensure our trains and stations remain a pleasant and clean environment for passengers.' Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: The real reason behind 'Stop Hiring Humans' ads appearing on the Tube MORE: 'Stupid' Apple Pay prank plagues commuters on London Tube MORE: Fare dodger barges his way through barriers – and straight into arms of police
