Welfare rebellion not a confidence vote, PM says as he remains defiant over cuts
Some 108 backbenchers have signed an amendment that would halt the Government's proposed changes – enough to threaten the Prime Minister's majority.
But Sir Keir said on Tuesday he would 'press on' despite the prospect of a major revolt when the welfare Bill comes before the Commons in a vote set for July 1.
Speaking in the Hague, where he is attending the Nato summit with toher world leaders, Sir Keir told reporters there was a 'clear moral case' for reforming the system.
'It's not a confidence vote. It's a vote about reforming our welfare system,' he told Sky News.
'It isn't working. It doesn't help people into work. Quite the contrary, it actually makes it harder for people to go into work. I think most colleagues do accept the case for reform, we've got to get on and make that reform.'
Meanwhile Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall, who has already taken steps to soften the impact of the welfare Bill, is locked in talks with backbenchers as she seeks to win over those opposed to the plans.
The amendment was published on Tuesday's order paper and calls for a pause allowing for further scrutiny of the Bill and for support to be in place before any further cuts are made.
The size of the revolt is enough to defeat the Government's plans if opposition MPs sided with rebels, though Tory leader Kemi Badenoch had not revealed whether her party would vote for or against the proposals.
Asked whether he would consider pausing his plans in light of the rebellion, the Prime Minister told reporters travelling with him to the Netherlands: 'We were elected to change what is broken in our country.
'The welfare system is broken and that's why we will press ahead with our reforms.'
Today, I have co-signed an amendment with over 100 of my colleagues that would stop the welfare reform proposals from becoming law. I want to be clear this is not a decision I have taken lightly. In eight years as a councillor and almost a year as an MP, I have not broken the… pic.twitter.com/R7PyWQi6y9
— Josh Fenton-Glynn MP (@JoshFG) June 24, 2025
Sir Keir said: 'The additions to Pip each year are the equivalent of the population of a city the size of Leicester.
'That's not a system that can be left unreformed, not least because it's unsustainable and therefore you won't have a welfare system for those that need it in the future.'
The Prime Minister earlier told his Cabinet 'we will reform welfare' because the Government must take 'hard, honest choices,' according to Downing Street, which declined to say whether any minister had expressed concern over the Bill.
The Cabinet 'collectively' supports the Government's agenda, a Number 10 spokesman said.
Several Labour select committee chairs were among those who put their name to the amendment, including Treasury committee chairwoman Dame Meg Hillier and work and pensions committee chairwoman Debbie Abrahams.
Vicky Foxcroft, the former Government whip who resigned over the welfare plans, has also signed, while Labour London Mayor Sir Sadiq Khan added pressure by coming out against the plans on Tuesday afternoon.
The mayor said: 'Having looked at the analysis of the Government's plans, the impact on London will be substantial, and for too many disabled Londoners it will destroy their financial safety net.
'The Government must urgently think again.'
(1/2) With a heavy heart, I have written to the Prime Minister to tender my resignation as a whip.
Whilst I will continue to support the government in delivering the change the country so desperately needs, I cannot vote in favour of the proposed reforms to disability benefits. pic.twitter.com/GcOYNF6SLT
— Vicky Foxcroft 💙 (@vickyfoxcroft) June 19, 2025
Under the proposals in the Bill, eligibility for the personal independence payment (Pip), the main disability payment in England, will be limited along with the sickness-related element of universal credit (UC).
However, the legislation published last week will give existing claimants a 13-week phase-out period of financial support, in what was seen as a bid to head off opposition.
Ministers have previously said the reforms could save up to £5 billion-a-year.
Downing Street declined to explicitly rule out offering further concessions when asked on Tuesday what would be done to reassure uneasy backbenchers before a vote scheduled for next week.
'We'll talk to them over the next week but the Government believes this is a good package of reforms,' a Number 10 spokesman said.
'We hope that colleagues will engage positively over the next few days.'
Number 10 said the Government recognised the 'strength of feeling' surrounding the issue but rejected suggestions the plans were 'dead on arrival'.
It refused to say whether it was confident that the Bill would make its way through Parliament when asked by reporters on Tuesday.
'We are focused on delivering last week's Bill and engaging, talking to colleagues … as to why this reform is so important,' the spokesman said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
28 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
PM to announce ‘biggest strengthening of UK nuclear posture in a generation'
The jets, a variant of the F35Bs the UK already uses, can carry conventional weapons, but can also be equipped with nuclear bombs. Sir Keir said: 'In an era of radical uncertainty we can no longer take peace for granted, which is why my government is investing in our national security, ensuring our armed forces have the equipment they need and communities up and down the country reap the benefits from our defence dividend.' The decision represents a victory for the Royal Air Force, which has long pushed for a return of its nuclear capabilities since the last British air-dropped nuclear weapon was withdrawn from service after the end of the Cold War. Sir Keir Starmer has travelled to The Hague for a Nato conference, where leaders are expected to commit to spending 5% of GDP on defence and security. (Ben Stansall/PA) Since then, the UK's nuclear deterrent has been carried exclusively by the Royal Navy's submarines, which the Government has also promised to invest in renewing with four new vessels. Sir Keir added: 'Supporting 100 businesses across the country and more than 20,000 jobs, these F35 dual capable aircraft will herald a new era for our world-leading Royal Air Force and deter hostile threats that threaten the UK and our Allies.' Defence Secretary John Healey said the decision followed a strategic defence review that 'confirmed we face new nuclear risks, with other states increasing, modernising and diversifying their nuclear arsenals'. The review, published earlier this month, recommended beginning discussions with the US and Nato on 'enhanced UK participation' in the alliance's nuclear mission, and raised the possibility of acquiring F35As. Nato's nuclear mission involves allied aircraft being equipped with American B61 bombs stockpiled in Europe. Nato secretary general Mark Rutte welcomed the announcement as 'yet another robust contribution' from the UK to the alliance. (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Seven nations currently contribute so-called 'dual capability aircraft' to Nato's nuclear mission, but a the use of nuclear weapons would require the authorisation of the alliance's nuclear planning group as well as the US president and British prime minister. The alliance's secretary-general Mark Rutte welcomed the announcement, saying it was 'yet another robust British contribution to Nato'. Alongside the nuclear announcement, the UK is set to provide 350 air defence missiles to Ukraine as Sir Keir and Mr Healey push for Nato to provide Kyiv with further support. The delivery will be funded by £70 million raised from the interest on seized Russian assets. Sir Keir said: 'Russia, not Ukraine, should pay the price for Putin's barbaric and illegal war, so it is only right we use the proceeds from seized Russian assets to ensure Ukraine has the air defence it needs.' Wednesday is also expected to see Nato allies formally sign up to a target of spending 5% of the GDP on defence and security. The figure includes 3.5% on 'core' defence spending, with another 1.5% being spent on wider security and resilience measures such as critical infrastructure, border security and intelligence. On Tuesday, the UK committed to reaching the new 5% target from 2035, but the Prime Minister declined to say how the Government would pay for the increase from its current target of spending 2.5% of GDP on defence from 2027.
Daily Mirror
29 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
UK will buy nuclear-capable fighter jets as Brits told to 'prepare for war'
Keir Starmer has said that the UK will buy at least 12 F35A fighter jets, capable of firing both nukes and conventional weapons, as the country bolsters its nuclear deterrent Britain will buy fighter jets capable of firing nuclear missiles for the first time since the Cold War as the public were told to "actively prepare" for war on home soil. In the major bolstering of the UK's nuclear deterrent, Keir Starmer said Britain will purchase at least 12 F35A fighter jets, capable of firing both nukes and conventional weapons. The new fighter jets will be armed with American B61 gravity bombs. Britain is the only major nuclear power that has just one platform to unleash its arsenal - the Trident submarines which provide the continuous at-sea deterrent. France has both air and sea capability, while the US can launch nukes from air, land and sea. The Government warned the public today that they must "actively prepare" for war on British soil "for the first time in many years". The long-awaited National Security Strategy said tackling the danger of nuclear weapons will be "more complex than it was even in the Cold War". Major powers like China and Russia are seeking to gain an upper hand in "outer space, cyberspace, the deep sea, and at the Arctic and Antarctic poles", it said. And the report also warned that hostile states may join forces with terror groups and criminals to carry out attacks on these shores. It states: "For the first time in many years, we have to actively prepare for the possibility of the UK homeland coming under direct threat, potentially in a wartime scenario." The document said the years ahead will test the nation - with a World War Two-style spirit needed to deal with growing threats. The Prime Minister revealed plans to bolster Britain's nuclear capabilities as he arrived in the Netherlands on Tuesday for a high-stakes NATO summit. He joined members of the 32-strog Western defensive alliance in committing to hike defence and security spending up to 5% by 2035. The UK will buy American-made fast jets, which will be based at RAF Marham, in Norfolk, and will deploy them as part of NATO's nuclear mission. The Government expected to procure 138 F35s over the lifetime of the programme. Unveiling the plans, the PM said: 'In an era of radical uncertainty we can no longer take peace for granted, which is why my government is investing in our national security, ensuring our Armed Forces have the equipment they need and communities up and down the country reap the benefits from our defence dividend. "Supporting 100 businesses across the country and more than 20,000 jobs, these F35 dual capable aircraft will herald a new era for our world-leading Royal Air Force and deter hostile threats that threaten the UK and our Allies. "The UK's commitment to NATO is unquestionable, as is the Alliance's contribution to keeping the UK safe and secure, but we must all step up to protect the Euro-Atlantic area for generations to come.' Defence Secretary John Healey said: 'The Strategic Defence Review confirmed we face new nuclear risks, with other states increasing, modernising and diversifying their nuclear arsenals. And it recommended a new UK role in our collective defence and deterrence through a NATO-first approach. 'This commitment is an embodiment of NATO first, strengthening the alliance while at the same time using defence as an engine for growth to create jobs across the UK.' NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said: 'The UK has declared its nuclear deterrent to NATO for many decades, and I strongly welcome today's announcement that the UK will now also join NATO's nuclear mission and procure the F-35A. This is yet another robust British contribution to NATO'. The National Security Strategy yesterday(TUES) laid bare the threats facing this country in a more dangerous world. Warning of hostile states acting within the UK, Mr Starmer said the country is in a period of "radical uncertainty". He has pledged to spend 5% of GDP on national security within a decade - a move the strategy says will draw together civilian and military priorities "in a way not seen since 1945". The document said: "The years ahead will test the United Kingdom... The direction it takes – and the decisions we take – will reverberate through the decades. We will need agility and courage to succeed, but we should be optimistic. We remain a resolute country, rich in history, values and in our capabilities. "But most of all, there is the determination of the British people themselves. After all, we do not need to look too far into our history for an example of a whole-of-society effort, motivated by a collective will to keep each other safe. We can mobilise that spirit again and use it both for our national security and the rebuilding of our country." The wide-ranging dossier said AI, social media and attacks on key infrastructure pose growing threats in the coming years. It warned arms control measures had failed to keep up with the spread of nuclear weapons - highlighted by alarm over Iran's nuclear weapons programme. The UK is "directly threatened" by hostile activities including assassination, intimidation, espionage, sabotage, cyber attacks and other forms of democratic interference, it added. Critical national infrastructure such as undersea cables, energy pipelines, transportation and logistics hubs are also a target. "It may become more difficult to identify hostile state activity as they make use of terrorist and criminal groups as their proxies," the report stated. Referencing North Korea's support for Russian forces in Ukraine, the strategy said hostile nations are more willing to work together. "As our adversaries and competitors engage in further military modernisation, issues like technology transfer and sanctions enforcement are going to become increasingly important," the strategy states. Speaking in the Commons, Cabinet Office Minister Pat McFadden said the Government needs to be "clear-eyed and hard-edged". Mr McFadden said ministers would work on protecting security at home by bolstering borders and making the UK "more resilient to future threats". He said more would need to be done with international allies to defend collective security - especially in the UK's relations with major powers like China. The strategy warned that "instances of China's espionage, interference in our democracy and the undermining of our economic security have increased in recent years". Mr McFadden also set out the UK's priority to rebuild its defence industries and build "advantages in new frontier technologies" like AI. "All of this will make us a stronger and more resilient country," he added.
South Wales Guardian
33 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Starmer: No tax rises on working people to reach 5% defence spending pledge
The Prime Minister is meeting leaders of other Nato member countries in The Hague, where they are expected to formally agree the target, made up of 3.5% on 'core defence' and another 1.5% on 'resilience and security'. He rejected that tax rises would be needed to pay for higher defence spending. 'Every time we've set out our defence spending commitments, so when we went to 2.5% in 2027/28, we set out precisely how we would pay for it, that didn't involve tax rises. 'Clearly we've got commitments in our manifesto about not making tax rises on working people and we will stick to our manifesto commitments,' the Prime Minister told reporters in the Netherlands. He said the current commitment to get defence spending up to 2.5% of GDP by 2027/8 was not coming at the expense of welfare, but rather from cuts to overseas development aid. 'So, it's a misdescription to suggest that the defence spending commitment we've made is at the expense of money on welfare.' Donald Trump is among the world leaders at the summit, and told reporters on the way to the Netherlands that it would depend 'on your definition' when asked if he would commit to Nato's Article 5, which requires members to defend each other from attack. At a Cabinet meeting on Tuesday morning, Sir Keir underscored that national security is the 'first duty' of Government. His trip comes as the Government publishes its national security strategy, setting out plans to make the UK 'more resilient to future threats'. Downing Street has described the 5% goal as 'a projected target' that allies will review in 2029 when Nato carries out its next capability assessment. It is a significant jump from the current 2% Nato target, and from the UK Government's aim of spending 2.5% of gross domestic product (GDP) on defence from 2027 and 3% at some point after the next election. But the figure is in line with the demands of US President Donald Trump, who has called for Nato allies to shoulder more of the burden of European defence. The Government expects to spend 1.5% of GDP on resilience and security by 2027. The details of what counts towards that target are due to be set out during this week's summit, but it is likely to include spending on energy and border security as well as intelligence agencies. But increasing core defence spending to 3.5% will not happen until 2035, with at least two elections likely to take place before then. The Institute for Fiscal Studies estimates that an increase in core defence spending from 2.6% to 3.5% would cost around £30 billion more a year. It noted however that the plans concern spending far in the future – due in 10 years' time – and therefore may not affect the Government's spending review or autumn budget decisions, but prompt the chancellor to revise plans at the 2027 spending review. Spending 3.5% of national income on defence is 'certainly not unprecedented' but much more is now spent on health than in the past, IFS researcher Bee Boileau noted. Shadow foreign secretary Dame Priti Patel said the Government had not been clear enough about how it would reach the core defence spending goal, claiming ministers had only offered 'smoke and mirrors'. She added: 'So, when will he actually deliver a plan to get to 2%, and why won't he heed our calls to hit 3% by the end of this Parliament, which would be vital, and a vital stepping stone on the way to that higher defence spending that he is seeking.' The Nato gathering comes amid the backdrop of escalating Middle East tensions and the ongoing war in Ukraine. Sir Keir has urged Israel and Iran to get back to the fragile ceasefire brokered by Donald Trump. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is expected to attend the summit, but not take part in the main discussions of the North Atlantic Council. Nato secretary-general Mark Rutte described the move to spend more on defence as a 'quantum leap' that would make the organisation 'a stronger, a fairer and a more lethal alliance'. But it was reported on Sunday that Spain had reached a deal that would see it exempted from the 5% target. Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez said that Spain would be able to keep its commitments to the 32-nation military alliance by spending 2.1% of GDP on defence needs.
