Govt under fire from opposition, allies over telco data handover demand
THE Malaysian government is facing mounting criticism over an alleged directive requiring all telecommunications companies (telcos) to hand over comprehensive mobile user data, including call records, internet usage, and GPS location history.
MCA President Datuk Seri Dr Wee Ka Siong has voiced serious concern over the move, warning that it poses a significant threat to citizens' privacy and could lead to the misuse of personal information.
He rejected the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission's (MCMC) claim that the data had been 'de-identified,' arguing that metadata, such as GPS coordinates, call logs, and IP addresses, could still be easily traced back to individuals, especially when cross-referenced with other digital sources.
He believed MCMC is trying to downplay the issue by saying, :Don't worry, the data has been de-identified and contains no personal details that can identify individuals.'
'But I want to ask, de-identified, really? Don't try to fool us. If you're collecting data on who we call, when we call, how long we talk, our IP address, and our GPS coordinates, the exact latitude and longitude, time and day, anyone with access to this data can easily match it back to our identities. Especially now, with e-wallets, CCTV, Touch 'n Go, and banking records, it's incredibly easy to pinpoint someone's identity,' he said in a video posted to Facebook on Saturday.
From the opposition, Pejuang raised similar concerns. Pejuang information chief, Muhammad Rafique Rashid Ali, criticised the move as unjustified and questioned the true motive behind collecting such intrusive data.
'What exactly does MCMC intend to do with this data? Their excuse is to promote local tourism? But what is the real motive?' he said.
'Not only is this a privacy issue, but there is also the risk of this data being misused or leaked to other parties,' Rafique added.
'MCMC should stop trying to cover up a huge scandal with a tiny sieve,' he said via Facebook on Sunday.
Both Pejuang and MCA, despite being on opposing sides of the political spectrum, are united in calling for greater transparency and accountability from the government on this issue.
Their joint concern marks a rare moment of bipartisan unity in defending Malaysians' right to privacy and democratic safeguards. —June 8, 2025
Main image: Securiti
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
25 minutes ago
- New Straits Times
Make sure you've done your research before pointing fingers, Wee tells Armizan
KUALA LUMPUR: MCA president Datuk Seri Dr Wee Ka Siong has called on Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Minister Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali to provide evidence supporting his claim that Wee was involved in approving the Control of Supplies (Amendment) Regulations 2021. In a video posted on Facebook today, Wee strongly refuted Armizan's statement and demanded proof for the allegation. "I have reviewed the parliamentary Hansard and the relevant bill to confirm which section mentions that a permit is required for using more than three cylinders of subsidised gas. "Furthermore, are food and beverage businesses actually prohibited from using subsidised liquefied petroleum gas (LPG)?" he asked. Previously, the media reported that Armizan had reminded Wee to review the regulations that were enacted when the former transport minister was in the cabinet. Armizan was quoted as saying that the Control of Supplies (Amendment) Regulations 2021 — which stipulate that any party using more than 42kg of LPG is required to apply for a Scheduled Controlled Goods Permit — had already been enforced since Oct 15, 2021, under the previous administration when Wee was a member of the cabinet. Wee demanded that Armizan issue an apology for alleging his involvement in approving regulations related to supply control while he was in the cabinet in 2021. The Ayer Hitam member of parliament said that based on a review of the 2021 parliamentary Hansard, the amendment at the time was solely aimed at granting broader enforcement powers to officers of the then Domestic Trade and Consumer Affairs Ministry. He said the amendment to the Control of Supplies Act (Amendment) 2021 was never intended to regulate the use of subsidised LPG. "I reviewed every line in the Hansard of the Dewan Rakyat during the debate, where MPs from constituencies such as Jempol, Bayan Baru, Pasir Gudang, Jelutong, Kota Melaka, Bukit Bendera, Pokok Sena, and Sepang presented their arguments. "However, not a single MP at the time raised the issue of requiring a permit for three cylinders of subsidised LPG, nor did anyone discuss the commercial use of LPG by food outlets," he said. He said then Domestic Trade and Consumer Affairs Minister Datuk Seri Alexander Nanta Linggi, in his reply in parliament in March 2022, also made no mention of any regulation concerning subsidised gas cylinders. "Datuk Armizan, why fabricate stories and make baseless accusations against me? "You weren't even in the Dewan Rakyat at the time, but you can always check the Hansard. "Do your homework before accusing me. "You're being unfair to me, you know? Or at the very least, just call Nanta to get confirmation. "Surely you have his phone number? If not, I can give it to you," he said. Wee said Armizan should not have accused him of being involved in the amendment related to the requirement for storing more than three cylinders of subsidised LPG and questioned the accuracy of the minister's source of information. He said the regulation concerning the use of subsidised LPG cylinders not exceeding 42kg might merely be an internal directive or administrative instruction from the ministry, and not part of the 2021 amendment. Wee said the law was never enforced until it was first implemented under the Pakatan Harapan 1.0 administration in 2019, before being revived again through Op Gasak this year. He said Armizan should issue an apology for the confusion and the allegations made against him. "You (Armizan) owe me an apology for your mistake.
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
I mentioned 'A' but Dr Wee referred to 'Z', says Armizan
Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Minister Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali. – Bernama PETALING JAYA: Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Minister Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali says he was referring to another law which differs from what MCA president Datuk Seri Dr Wee Ka Siong quoted earlier on Sunday (June 8). In the war of words between the two, Armizan said in his press conference on June 5, he clearly stated that his ministry was enforcing Ops Gasak under the Control of Supplies (Amendment) Regulations 2021 to combat the smuggling of subsidised liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), among others. "The MCA president was referring to the Control of Supplies (Amendment) Act 2021. "It is of course impossible to find the legal provisions I was referring to because I mentioned 'A' but he was referring to 'Z'," he said in a Facebook post. Armizan said in 2021, the then-domestic trade and consumer affairs ministry drafted amendments to the Control of Supplies (Amendment) Regulations 2021. "It was enforced on Oct 15, 2021, and at the same time, gazetted for public access," he said. Armizan said he was unfazed by Dr Wee accusing him as a liar but urged him not to confuse the people by quoting another law. Armizan also addressed Dr Wee's comments that he is a greenhorn MP, saying that even with lesser experience, he still respects the legal process. He had previously said this regulation was enforced during the former administration when Dr Wee served as a minister. Previously, Armizan had said Ops Gasak is being carried out under three existing laws – the Control of Supplies Act 1961, the Price Control and Anti-Profiteering Act 2011 and the Control of Supplies (Amendment) Regulations 2021. Earlier on Sunday, Dr Wee had said though he served as a minister in 2021, he was never involved in approving such regulations. "The government has the discretion to decide whether or not to enforce such policies," said Dr Wee. The Control of Supplies (Amendment) Regulations 2021, which came into force on Oct 15, 2021, limits the use of subsidised LPG to a maximum of 42kg at any one time for commercial purposes. Any shop exceeding this limit must obtain a permit and switch to non-subsidised LPG. On Thursday (June 5), Armizan said small and micro-scale food and beverage operators would be exempted from enforcement under Ops Gasak. Armizan said the Cabinet agreed to review the regulations on the use of subsidised LPG cylinders by such traders, after recommendations submitted by the Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry. Ops Gasak, which began on May 1 until Oct 31, is meant to curb illegal activities such as decanting (transferring gas from subsidised LPG cylinders to non-subsidised ones), smuggling and the misuse of subsidised LPG by medium and large-scale industrial sectors. Dr Wee had said the Ops Gasak should have focused on large-scale operations and at the borders and not on petty traders and hawkers.
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Asean News Headlines at 10pm on Sunday (June 8, 2025)
Malaysia: * No travel ban for Fahmi Reza, confirms IGP / PM wants Deputy IGP to look into travel ban on Fahmi Reza * 'My freedom to travel was restricted', says Fahmi Reza, threatens to sue govt * MetMalaysia issues thunderstorm warning for eight states * Sukuk misuse case: Tan Sri to be quizzed soon following hospital discharge, says Azam * DAP backs judicial review on NFA over Teoh Beng Hock case * Nearly RM800mil allocated to states for water supply projects to address monsoon impact * Klang boat capsize: Victim's mother breaks down when identifying body * MCMC call data request from telcos to improve network, not invade privacy, says Fahmi * Telcos assure customer privacy in MCMC data initiative * Check before making further decision, Higher Education Ministry urges Harvard-bound Malaysians * Bursa Malaysia seen trading between the 1,500 and 1,530 level this week, pending fresh catalysts * Ringgit to continue its positive trend against US dollar this week, keen eyes on US economic data report * Badminton: Cheers to Wei Chong-Kai Wun for fighting on despite hostile atmosphere * Badminton: Pearly-Thinaah stretch China's world No. 1 pair before going down in final * Faster by train, not plane -- A train can never move faster than a plane, but a train ride can be faster than a flight Secretary of State Marco Rubio (right) meets with Singaporean Foreign Minister Vivian Balakrishnan at the State Department in Washington.-- AP Photo/Kevin Wolf Singapore: * My husband arranged for five men to rape me. I have to live for my children: Victim in Singapore wife-rape ring case * 'I want women to know that this kind of thing really happens': Wife-rape survivor in Singapore on telling her story * Man who let snakes bite him 200 times spurs new antivenom hope * Singapore to send delegation led by Foreign Affairs Minister Vivian Balakrishnan to UN Ocean Conference * Over 20,000 devotees attend Sri Sivan Temple consecration in Singapore, crowd almost breaks through barricades * 15 people in Singapore to be charged with theft; food, medicine, clothing among items stolen from shops * Mum of six who juggles three jobs starts free breakfast club for children in Ang Mo Kio, Singapore * Woman arrested at Changi Airport check-in area for abusing public servant * Megan, half-Singaporean member of Katseye, comes out as bisexual * Who is Megan Skiendiel? Katseye's half-Singaporean teen member in the limelight for being bisexual but she also loves her laksa Indonesia: * Indonesia and Russia are among the major economies with lowest dependence on exports, as according to calculations * Five nabbed for murder of Indonesian in Kluang * Indonesia and EU are close to finalising major trade pact * Badminton: Dane Antonsen ends bane of being second best at Indonesian Open * Former Indonesian president Jokowi signals interest in leading PSI over PPP * Indonesian National Police Commission urges sanctioning Makassar officers for alleged extortion, assault * Prabowo sends Gerindra officials to meet Megawati, deliver confidential message Volunteers pick up trash during a coastal clean-up drive ahead of World Oceans Day, in Pasay City, Metro Manila, Philippines. -- Photo: REUTERS/Lisa Marie David Thailand: * Thai and Cambodian forces to resume previous positions on border, Thailand says * Thailand cuts border crossing hours with Cambodia over security * Embassy hosts Aidiladha celebration for Malaysians in Bangkok * Thai DPM Phumtham cancels Paris trip to monitor three key developments * Thai authorities seize 346 tonnes of smuggled chicken feet amid bird flu concerns * Thailand enforces border controls to safeguard communities amidst rising tensions Philippines: * UN Ocean Conference sets sail in France on World Oceans Day * Philippine and Singapore expand cooperation in prioritised areas * Chinese ship runs aground off Philippines-occupied island in the disputed South China Sea * Mass actions pressing for Sara Duterte trial set for June 9 to June 11 * Philippine Bureau of Investigation nabs yakuza boss in Angeles * Marcos, Machiavelli, and martial arts A saleswoman uses her phone as she waits for customers at a home appliance store in Hanoi on June 6, 2025. Vietnam's exports rose sharply last month, official figures showed June 6, as the communist country tries to negotiate relief from swingeing tariffs threatened by US President Donald Trump. -- Photo by Nhac NGUYEN / AFP Vietnam * Many opportunities for Asean amidst US' tariff tantrum, says Asean-BAC head * Vietnam PM attends Blue Economy and Finance Forum in Monaco; event aims to help countries tackle financial challenges * US imposes anti-dumping duty on Vietnamese shrimp exporters * Vietnam exports up as US tariff threat lingers * Vietnam inks deals to buy US$3 Billion US products before talks * Smaller families still in favour for Vietnam young couples Myanmar: * US cuts Chinese medicine purchases threefold in April, according to customs data * Trump's travel ban on 12 countries goes into effect early Monday; Myanmar among countries on top of list * One minor, two micro earthquakes hit Myanmar on Sunday morning * China urges citizens to flee Myanmar conflict zone * Junta protests UN labour violations resolution South Korea's Kim Won-ho and Seo Seung-jae celebrate on the podium following their victory against Indonesia's Sabar Karyaman Gutama and Moh Reza Pahlevi Isfahani during their men's doubles final match at the Indonesia Open badminton tournament at Istora Senayan in Jakarta on Sunday, June 8, 2025. -- Photo by BAY ISMOYO / AFP Cambodia: * Thailand reduces opening days for major border crossings with Cambodia; chaos at border gate as workers rush to go across * United Nations and Asean urge global community to protect oceans under threat * Chinese banana group expands Cambodian operations by 50% * Cambodia, Thailand hope for peaceful settlement of border dispute Laos: * Lao central bank governor, ministers reshuffled in major cabinet overhaul * Laos seeks to improve health system resilience * Road accidents claim 70 lives in Laos in May Brunei: * Bruneian on mission to conquer seven Central Java mountains * Fact-checking platform set to strengthen Brunei response to fake news, digital scams * QuickCheck: Can Singapore dollars be used in Brunei and vice versa? People walk on the sea promenade ahead of the UN Ocean Conference in Nice, French Riviera. -- AP Photo/Laurent Cipriani AseanPlus: * Kerala woman, accused of marrying 10 men and duping them, arrested before latest wedding * China committed to building South China Sea into sea of peace, friendship and cooperation, says report * K-pop sensation BTS' new single 'On' surpasses 500 million streams on Spotify * US to resume processing Harvard visas * Japan flexes its military muscle at China, and Trump * A classical music festival is giving historic Melaka a fresh dose of culture * China vice premier to meet US delegation for trade talks: Beijing * Australia seeks stronger trade ties after unjustified US tariffs * Foreign politicians urged to stop interfering in Hong Kong affairs * Japan, EU to form Competitiveness Alliance to strengthen trade ties * Secret Russian intelligence document shows deep suspicion of China * A Brazilian medal for a Japanese princess * Restive Indian state orders curfew after fresh violence * With G7 on horizon, Lee Jae-myung races to fill key posts in South Korea * Chinese man defies demolition orders to build madcap rural home * Naver to establish US subsidiary for investment in local startups * Civilians in Gaza face heavy attacks while seeking food at aid centres, says UN agency * Paid less than unskilled labourers, community health workers in India go on strike * Taiwan scholars mark 80th anniversary of victory in war against Japanese aggression * UK and India discuss 'counter-terrorism' cooperation after Pakistan ceasefire * Faulty prostate cancer tests leave 406 Hong Kong patients with nervy wait * Is China's Tiandu-1 first to enter resonant Earth-moon orbit? US raises doubts * Why Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area is a must-watch for global businesses * Leo, the first US pope, criticises nationalist politics at Sunday Mass * Still starving in Gaza -- When can Palestinians get any food aid? * Is China's Tiandu-1 first to enter resonant Earth-moon orbit? US raises doubts * Cricket-Australia's Hazlewood does not want to miss WTC final again * Aidiladha joy for muay thai exponent Nor Iman in ONE C'ship * Tennis-Gauff continues American renaissance by stunning Sabalenka for French Open glory * Swimming - Canadian teen McIntosh shatters 400 metres freestyle record
