Should Feinberg-Mngomezulu or Pollard be Springbok flyhalf in All Blacks Eden Park Test?
Ashfak Mohamed | Published 15 minutes ago
Ruck&Maul Column
I was honestly worried about Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu's injury situation earlier this season.
He just didn't seem like he could put a few matches together before breaking down. The collarbone injury sustained against the Sharks in December was the latest problem.
In fact, in the two previous games against the Sharks and Lions, Feinberg-Mngomezulu went off with concussion and hip issues, respectively.
That of course all happened after a knee injury against the All Blacks saw him ruled out of the Springbok November tour as well.
After earning the SA Rugby Young Player of the Year award, Feinberg-Mngomezulu said the 'injury layoff served me well', and that 'I don't take any opportunity for granted. I've had injuries, and understand that game-time is never given'.
He made his belated return against the Scarlets in Wales on March 22, and inspired his team to a 29-17 win.
There was a bit of 'red mist' in the 38-34 loss to Ulster in Belfast, but Feinberg-Mngomezulu was back at his irresistible best in last weekend's 34-29 win over Connacht in Cape Town.
The 23-year-old flyhalf showcased his full array of skills – pace, panache, power, little chips, dummy passes, long passes... you name it.
A sensational 25-minute hat-trick from the Bishops product set the platform for the win, although the Stormers' leaky defence nearly blew it on the day – with only an obstruction in the final move stopping Connacht from pulling off a win.
But now the big question remains: should Feinberg-Mngomezulu start ahead of Handré Pollard against the All Blacks at Eden Park on September 6?
Yes, there are lots of Tests before and afterwards, but that is surely the biggest Test of the year for Rassie Erasmus' team – at least until the South Africans square off against Ireland in Dublin on November 22.
Some fans will point to the French Test at the Stade de France in Paris on November 8 as another massive one, but for me, New Zealand at Eden Park and Ireland at the Aviva Stadium are even more important.
The All Blacks haven't lost at the famous Auckland venue in 50 matches since 1994 – when they incidentally drew 18-18 against the Boks in a 'dead-rubber Test' after already winning the series 2-0 in the first two games.
New Zealand have won 48 and drawn two over the last 30 years, with the other stalemate the 15-15 score-line against the 2017 British and Irish Lions.
So, while Erasmus experimented with combinations last year and will continue to do so in 2025 in the name of growing depth for the 2027 World Cup, the best team must play against the All Blacks at Eden Park.
Who's it going to be at flyhalf: Feinberg-Mngomezulu or Pollard?
The latter is currently finishing off his stint at Leicester Tigers in England before heading home to join the Bulls on July 1.
Pollard doesn't have to prove his worth as a player or leader to Erasmus, but he would need to display the necessary form to wear the No 10 jersey in Auckland on September 6.
There are Tests against Italy, Georgia and Australia for Erasmus to run the rule over his two main pivots – and Manie Libbok will hopefully also be back from injury by then – before the Boks travel to New Zealand. But I would go for Feinberg-Mngomezulu, and the reason is two-fold.
He has shown that he can handle the big occasion by starring against the Kiwis and Wallabies last season, and is currently in outstanding form.
His vast repertoire ties in with what assistant coach Tony Brown is trying to do with the evolution of the Bok attack heading towards 2027 – that the world champions are so much more than just a forward-based side who can only score tries off scrums and mauls.
Feinberg-Mngomezulu also needs to experience starting a Test match in New Zealand. He has shone at Twickenham as well, but the All Blacks are the ultimate test for the Bok team.
Can he go toe-to-toe with a Richie Mo'unga, Beauden Barrett or Damian McKenzie in a high-stakes Rugby Championship showdown?
Feinberg-Mngomezulu can only benefit from that situation, and it may provide Erasmus with a few answers before the 2027 World Cup.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
7 hours ago
- eNCA
England's Tuchel impatient for improvement after dire Andorra display
Thomas Tuchel said he is impatient to see improvement from his England side and believes there is no need to "sugarcoat" criticism after an underwhelming 1-0 victory over minnows Andorra on Saturday. The Three Lions came under fire for their sloppy performance in the World Cup qualifier in Barcelona, where Harry Kane scored the only goal early in the second half. They were booed after struggling to break down a team ranked 173rd in the world even though they extended Tuchel's winning start to three games. "I'm impatient and want to do better," the former Chelsea and Paris Saint-Germain boss said ahead of Tuesday's friendly against Senegal in Nottingham. "We are thinking about giving the players a little bit more freedom in the structure -- let's see. "Tomorrow we face a more physical and demanding team. On paper it might not look as offensive as we were against Andorra but will give the players more freedom to express themselves and hopefully we see that on Tuesday." A serial winner of major titles, Tuchel was appointed as the third foreign coach of England to great fanfare, but he has so far failed to deliver on the exciting brand of football he promised. His reign began with a 2-0 win over Albania and 3-0 victory against Latvia in March. England captain Kane conceded the Euro 2024 finalists had "got away with one" given their lacklustre performance in front of a small crowd at Espanyol's RCDE Stadium. "I think there was commonsense straight after in the dressing room," said Tuchel. "We underperformed clearly in the physical input in the game which you could see on the sideline and the data. We didn't run enough." The German said he believed in brutal honesty. "I protect my players, I said no names of players," he said. "We as a team didn't match our standards. "I didn't like the last 10 minutes, I felt on the sidelines. We didn't play seriously enough to win it in the end and what we needed to do in a World Cup qualifier. "Everything I say here I say to the players, why should I sugarcoat? There is no harm done, we can have criticism and I believe a group of players in football can speak honestly to each other.
eNCA
7 hours ago
- eNCA
Injured Scotland prop Fagerson out of Lions tour
Scotland prop Zander Fagerson has been ruled out of the British and Irish Lions' tour to Australia with a calf injury, head coach Andy Farrell announced on Monday. The Glasgow Warriors tighthead will be replaced in the squad by Ireland international Finlay Bealham. The squad, minus those involved in next weekend's Premiership Rugby and United Rugby Championship finals, are due to fly to Portugal for a training camp on Tuesday. England pair Jamie George and Asher Opoku-Fordjour will also join the group. "It's tough on Zander to miss out so close to the tour, but now Finlay gets an opportunity to come in and add to the group," said Farrell. "This is unfortunately part and parcel of the game, so we always have to be prepared for that. "But it's great to be finally at the stage where we can get onto the training ground and get to work with these players." The Lions, captained by England skipper Maro Itoje, face Argentina in Dublin on June 20 before starting their tour of Australia, which includes three Tests against the Wallabies.
IOL News
9 hours ago
- IOL News
Lord's will be humming when the WTC final gets underway, says Proteas coach Shukri Conrad
Proteas coach Shukri Conrad ahead of the World Test Championship final at Lord's. Photo: Zaahier Adams Independent Media Image: Zaahier Adams Independent Media LONDON: Embrace the grandeur of the occasion. That's Shukri Conrad's message to his young Proteas team as they prepare to face Australia in the World Test Championship final at Lord's. An 'ordinary' Test at Lord's – if such a thing exists – is customarily associated by pomp or splendour. The Members Pavillion is adorned with males in navy blue blazers with gold buttons with their necks held up by red and yellow ties – affectionately known as egg and bacon in these parts – that smells of opulence and inheritance. And the rest of the stands from the Mount to the Tavern are filled with London's most swanky sipping French champagne in crystal glasses. It's a far cry from wearing shorts and plakkies whilst finishing off a boerie and beer on the Centurion grass banks. ALL ROADS LEAD TO LORD'S .... Feel it, it is here ... just a couple more days before the Proteas go head-to-head with Australia in the World Test Championship final at the Home of Cricket...@IOLsport @IOL @ProteasMenCSA @ICC — Zaahier Adams (@ZaahierAdams) June 9, 2025 Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading 'It is a huge occasion. We can't wish it away,' Conrad told the media, at the Thomas Lord Suite on Tuesday. 'It's difficult not to get the place out of your system. We've almost taken the, 'let's embrace it, whatever comes with it' approach. It's going to be humming, well, two days' time. 'We'll probably be enjoying the majority of the support. I think all the English will be supporting us as well. And just to really embrace the occasion. 'There are going to be nerves. The excitement levels are starting to ramp up, as you well aware. So, yeah, it's a great occasion, and I'd rather be part of it than not.' There are few individuals that have experienced the Lord's spectacle more than former England fast bowler Stuart Broad. Furthermore, Broad was a prime antagonist of the Aussies in hey day too, and it may just have been another Conrad masterstroke to rope in 'Broady' – even if it was just to get under the skin of Pat Cummins' men. 'It was enlightening (the dinner with Broad),' Conrad said. 'We met last night, the coaching group with Broadie. 'It was just a casual chat. And if I didn't call time at 10.30, I think he'd probably still be sitting there chatting to us. Independent Media's Zaahier Adams will be at Lord's for the World Test Championship bringing you all the news, videos and podcasts. Picture: Independent Media Image: Independent Media 'Some of the conversations that we had last night, you know, (was about) taking it in, just making sure you settle yourself down. And, yeah, rather than wish it away, we talked through these things. 'So, really enlightening, really casual. And everybody walked away there like, yeah, that was great, Broadie included.' Conrad steered away from his customary penchant of naming the team his team in the media prior to the start of the Test, indicating that there is still plenty of thought going into getting the starting XI just right for the conditions. The clouds have hovered over the famous old ground all week, whilst the Father Time weathervane overlooking the ground has been swivelling due to a blustery wind. However, the forecast does predict temperatures touching the 30-degree mark for the majority of the Test which may bring the spinners more into the equation as the Test draws on. 'Obviously the new ball is critical. But then also, there's been a lot of talk about when the lacquer comes off the ball. Talking around over 10 maybe,' Conrad explained. 'And you obviously still need guys that are as effective with that ball when the lacquer comes off and it tends to swing a little bit more. So that will be a consideration. The bounce here with the older ball can be a little bit inconsistent, can be a bit slower. 'Than what we're normally accustomed to. So those would be the considerations. Obviously not a venue where spin is a massive factor in terms of wickets taken. 'But it's shown that spinners can play a role here. Both as wicket-takers and doing an important holding role as well for your seamers to be effective. 'So I think those are pretty much the conversations that have happened. And based on all of that, we'll structure our bowling attack accordingly.'
