Abrego Garcia's return should not end Trump contempt probe, lawyers say
*
Maryland man was wrongly deported to his native El Salvador
*
Abrego Garcia indicted for migrant smuggling, lawyer calls charges 'fantastical'
*
Trump administration says courts are intruding on foreign policy
NEW YORK, - The return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia to the U.S. last Friday after his wrongful deportation to El Salvador in March should not end a judge's investigation into whether Trump administration officials should be held in contempt for violating a court order, Abrego Garcia's lawyers said.
In a court filing on Sunday, Abrego Garcia's lawyers disputed the administration's assertion that it was in compliance with Greenbelt, Maryland-based U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis' order to facilitate his return from El Salvador because it had brought him back to face criminal charges of migrant smuggling in Tennessee.
"Until the Government is held accountable for its blatant, willful, and persistent violations of court orders at excruciating cost to Abrego Garcia and his family, this case is not over," Abrego Garcia's lawyers wrote. "The executive branch's wanton disregard for the judicial branch has left a stain on the Constitution."
Spokespeople for the White House, the Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Abrego Garcia's March 15 deportation to his native El Salvador, despite a 2019 immigration court ruling that he not be sent there because he could be persecuted by gangs, has emerged as a flashpoint for Republican President Donald Trump's aggressive immigration policies.
Trump critics say the deportation of Garcia, a 29-year-old who had a work permit and whose wife and young child in Maryland are U.S. citizens, was a sign that the administration was disregarding civil liberties in its push to step up deportations.
Critics also said the administration's failure to bring him back, even after the U.S. Supreme Court upheld Xinis' order that it facilitate his return, suggested the Trump administration was willing to defy unfavorable court rulings even though the judiciary is a co-equal branch of government under the U.S. Constitution.
Xinis on April 15 demanded U.S. officials provide documents and answer questions under oath about what it had done to facilitate Abrego Garcia's return, in an investigation that could result in officials being held in contempt.
Trump administration officials have accused the judiciary of overstepping and interfering with the executive branch's ability to conduct foreign policy. They also alleged Abrego Garcia was a member of the MS-13 gang, though he had not been charged with a crime at the time of his deportation.
Officials on Friday portrayed Abrego Garcia's criminal indictment as vindication for their approach to deportations. A grand jury in Nashville, Tennessee, on May 21 indicted him on charges of transporting undocumented migrants from the U.S.-Mexico border to locations around the country.
Abrego Garcia has not yet entered a plea and is detained pending his next court hearing on Friday. His lawyer has called the criminal charges "fantastical."
In their filing on Sunday, Abrego Garcia's lawyers said his immigration case would need to be handled as it would have been if he were not deported in order for the administration to be in compliance with Xinis' order.
It was not immediately clear when Xinis would rule.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
No trace of newlywed Pratapgarh couple on honeymoon trip to Sikkim
Prayagraj: It has been 13 days since the newlywed couple from Pratapgarh district - Kaushlendra (29) and Ankita (26) – went missing after the tourist vehicle in which they were travelling with 10 other passengers plunged into the swollen Teesta River in Mangan district of Sikkim and the family of the couple are yet to hear from the authorities about the two. After tying the nuptial knot in May, the couple went to Sikkim for their honeymoon on May 24. They went missing from May 29 onwards. It was later established that the mini-bus they boarded along with other tourists had fallen into Teesta River. Though authorities roped in divers and rescuers but there has been no trace of the couple since. The couple, Kaushalendra Pratap Singh (29) and Ankita Singh (26) got married just 25 days ago had gone to Sikkim on their honeymoon on May 24. A group of four family members, who returned home on Tuesday empty-handed from Sikkim, are in a state of shock and continuously shedding tears. They shared their experience with top police and administrative officials of Pratapgarh and even explained the horrific view of the Teesta river and the accident site to them. Talking to TOI, SP (Pratapgarh) Dr Anil Kumar said, "Four of the family members of the couple who rushed to the spot soon after the incident returned home on family members met with senior police and administrative authorities in Gangtok and also narrated the extensive search operation being carried out by the authorities concerned." The search operation was carried out by removing the rocks and debris of the Teesta river flowing in a ravine of thousands of feet. Teams are still searching till Chungthang, about eight km from the accident site. SP, meanwhile, said, "Even as the flow of the river has now become normal, it is not easy to search among the debris. No belongings related to the Pratapgarh-based couple have been found so far. The family members have returned on the assurance of the officers. " Sher Bahadur, who reached Gangtok in search of his son and daughter-in-law, kept searching for the couple along with his relatives and family members. They also met the two tourists who survived the accident . Sher Bahadur told Pratapgarh police officials that the two surviving tourists identified the Pratapgarh couple by looking at their photos as they were travelling in the vehicle. The vehicle was carrying 11 tourists and a driver and was returning from Chungthang to Gangtok when it lost control around 9 pm due to heavy rainfall. Eight tourists, including Kaushalendra and Ankita, remain untraceable till now. The unfortunate news has devastated both the Pratapgarh couple's families. The families of both are still living under uncertainty. Ankita worked in the medicine department at Medanta Hospital in Lucknow. Kaushalendra, his parents' only child, was preparing for the civil services examination in Delhi. Their honeymoon plans were finalised on a whim after their waitlisted train tickets were confirmed on May 22.
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Trump won't allow mob rule in America, says White House amid LA unrest
US President Donald Trump 'will never allow mob rule to prevail in America,' the White House said on Wednesday, following escalating protests in Los Angeles sparked by the administration's aggressive immigration enforcement House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt, speaking at a press briefing, said President Trump remains firmly committed to upholding law and order in the face of what she described as organized unrest. 'The most basic duty of government is to preserve law and order, and this administration embraces that sacred responsibility,' she said, as images of burning vehicles and masked demonstrators were displayed during the unrest follows a series of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids carried out in Los Angeles last week, a city governed by Democrats, which has long opposed Trump's immigration agenda. Though many protests were peaceful, several incidents of violence, including the torching of self-driving taxis and clashes with police, prompted a militarized gas and other non-lethal methods were deployed, and President Trump authorized the National Guard to intervene, a rare move in recent Gavin Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass sharply criticized the deployment, calling it excessive and politically motivated. In response, Leavitt accused both leaders of dereliction of duty. 'Governor Gavin Newsom and Mayor Karen Bass shamefully failed to meet their sworn obligations to their citizens,' she said, also alleging that Newsom had 'fanned the flames and demonized our brave ICE officers.'advertisementPresident Trump, speaking Tuesday at Fort Bragg military base, promised to 'liberate' Los Angeles, intensifying tensions with California's Democratic administration has also raised concerns about the organization behind the protests. Trump referred to some demonstrators as 'paid insurrectionists' equipped with professional anti-riot gear, a claim Leavitt said is under investigation. 'It's a good question the president is raising, and one we are looking into, about who is funding these insurrectionists,' she told news agency backlash is intensifying as the fast-growing 'No Kings' protest movement prepares for a massive, coordinated demonstration on June 14, coinciding with both a pro-Trump parade in Washington, DC, and the president's 79th birthday. Organizers estimate that nearly 3 million people could flood streets in cities across the country in what they describe as a unified stand against response, the White House remains defiant. 'President Trump will never allow mobs to take over the United States,' Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said, signaling no intention to yield to mounting public inputs from agenciesTune InMust Watch
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Pete Hegseth confirmed Iran working towards nuclear weapon, claims US senator
US senator from Arkansas Tom Cotton on Thursday claimed that defence secretary Pete Hegseth had confirmed that Iran was working towards building a nuclear weapon amid a stalled nuclear deal between the countries. In a post on X, Tom Cotton said, 'Today @SecDef confirmed that Iran's terrorist regime is actively working towards a nuclear weapon. For the sake of our national security, the security of our allies, and millions of civilians in the region this cannot be allowed to happen.' Also Read: Israel preparing strike on Iran's nuclear facilities, suggests US intelligence: Report The US and Iran have been negotiating a nuclear deal for around two months, with Oman mediating. They have held five rounds of talks. US President Donald Trump, after being elected for his second term, had said he wants a deal that curbs Iran's atomic activities and that the US could strike Iran if the talks break down. Also Read: Trump travel ban shows 'deep hostility' towards Iranians, Muslims, says Iran Israel, which believes a nuclear-armed Iran would pose an existential threat has also threatened to attack Tehran, with or without US help. Iran has long denied having plans to build a nuclear weapon, although it has been enriching uranium to a higher point than required for civilian purposes, leading to wariness from the US and other western countries. Earlier this week, Trump said he was "much less confident of a deal being made. 'They seem to be delaying, and I think that's a shame," he told the New York Post. Also Read: A thaw in Iran-Canada ties? Tehran says 'ready for talks' to restart relations Iran has warned of retaliation against US military assets in the Middle East if the talks collapse and the Islamic Republic is attacked. 'I sincerely hope it won't come to that and that the talks reach a resolution,' Iran's Defense Minister Aziz Nasirzadeh said. 'But if they don't, and conflict is imposed on us, the other side will undoubtedly suffer greater losses. We will target all US bases in host countries without hesitation," he added.
