
The 'Wuthering Heights' Casting Director Addressed The Jacob Elordi Backlash And Said The Movie Doesn't Need To Be 'Accurate' Because It's 'Just A Book' — And People Are Outraged
Last year, it was confirmed that Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie would star together in Emerald Fennell 's upcoming film adaptation of Wuthering Heights, the classic 1847 novel by Emily Brontë. The casting announcement did not go down well at the time, and it's fair to say it's still not sitting right with fans.
For context, many feel that 34-year-old Margot is too old to play 18-year-old Catherine Earnshaw, while Jacob is probably too white to play Heathcliff, the foster son of the Earnshaw family, who is described early in the book as 'dark-skinned.'
The exact details around Heathcliff's race and ethnicity are ambiguous in the novel. However, another character refers to him as 'a little Lascar,' which means a sailor from Southeast Asia, and in a later part of the text, he is described as a 'ragged, black-haired child… as dark almost as if it came from the devil.'
Despite this, Heathcliff has historically been portrayed by white actors, with the exception of the 2011 film, in which he was played by James Howson.
All in all, the consensus is that neither Jacob nor Margot, who are both Australian, are the right fit for the roles based on how they're described in the book. And now, off the back of the first batch of photographs of the pair together in costume on set, the film's casting director has weighed in on the widespread criticism.
Speaking at a Q&A session during the Sands Film Festival in Scotland over the weekend, Kharmel Cochrane — who notably worked with Jacob and Margot on Emerald's Saltburn in 2023 — argued that the actors don't need to look exactly how the characters are described in the original text because 'it's just a book.'
'If something is clearly written as white, for example, a script reads 'she tied her blonde hair back,' but there's no specific reason for it, I will just put people on tape,' she explained. 'And then it's almost like I dare someone to question why I've done it, and they don't. So then it just becomes normal. Years ago, I would get people saying, 'Did you read the brief?' And I'd say yeah, and this is my interpretation of it, just like when you can read a book.'
'There was one Instagram comment that said the casting director should be shot,' she said, talking about the backlash more specifically. 'But just wait till you see it, and then you can decide whether you want to shoot me or not. But you really don't need to be accurate. It's just a book. That is not based on real life. It's all art.'
Aside from the castings, Kharmel hinted at some potentially 'even more shocking' differences between the book and upcoming film, saying, 'there's definitely going to be some English Lit fans that are not going to be happy.' 'Wait until you see the set design because that is even more shocking,' she teased. 'And there may or may not be a dog collar in it.'
Well, as a former English Lit student, that was a liiiittle painful to hear — and it sounds like I'm not the only one feeling odd about Kharmel's latest comments. Many fans on X have pointed out that it's a bold choice to describe Wuthering Heights as 'just a book,' when you consider that it was Emily Brontë's only novel, published at a time when very few women's writing saw the light of day, and is widely lauded as a masterpiece.
On top of that, Kharmel's quips about the reactions of 'English Lit fans' are also bound to 'alienate' what will likely be the movie's primary audience of — you guessed it — English Lit fans.
Caro_LBF / X / Via x.com
I have to say, I'm with the people on this one. What do you think of her comments? Is it arrogance, or are they just enjoying pushing the boundaries of making a movie adaptation? LMK your thoughts.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Cardi B Embraces Reptilian Inspiration in Nicol & Ford Strapless Dress for ASCAP Rhythm & Soul Awards 2025
Cardi B was honored at the ASCAP Rhythm & Soul Awards 2025 on Sunday in Los Angeles. The Grammy Award-winning rapper received the Voice of the Culture Award at the event, styling a look with sensual, reptilian inspiration. Cardi wore a strapless dress courtesy of Australian fashion label Nicol & Ford. The dress featured a corseted bodice with a plunging neckline and reptilian fabric. The skirt of the dress featured a contrasting reptile print, paired with a flowing silhouette and draped fabric at the drop waist. More from WWD From Cole Escola's Glittery Eyes to Cynthia Erivo's Stiletto Nails, a Look at the Best Beauty Moments at the 2025 Tony Awards Addison Rae Debuts Armani Beauty Product in a Behind-the-scenes Look at Her 'Times Like These' Music Video Paris Jackson Styles Botanical Whimsy in Fendi for 2025 Tribeca Film Festival Cardi accessorized with bold statement, cherub ribbon earrings by Phoebe Hyles, crafted for Nicol & Ford's fall 2024 collection. The 'I Like It' rapper's look was curated by stylist Kollin Carter, who's collaborated with Cardi B on several previous occasions. Carter has also collaborated with notable artists such as Victoria Monet and Kelly Rowland, among others. Nicol & Ford was founded by Katie-Louise Nicol-Ford and Lilian Nicol-Ford. Launched in 2014, the label rebranded in 2017 with the name it has today. The label's fall 2024 collection, titled 'Thorn,' featured a bevy of animal prints, fabric draping and sensual styling. While Nicol & Ford's profile has risen thanks in part to Cardi B's latest styling of one of the label's designs, so too has the rapper's reach within the fashion industry. In April, Cardi joined forces with Revolve Group, the California-based fashion and lifestyle retailer, on an exclusive multicategory venture. The partnership will include beauty and fashion brands. 'People have been expecting both from me. My beauty line, people have been expecting that, like an album,' the rapper told WWD in an interview. 'I personally believe that I put a lot of people on a lot of trends. It's not even about getting paid, but it's not appreciated. I gotta do this for me because I don't get thank yous. If I don't have a good year, I don't get, 'How have you been?' Nobody does that. It's time for me to do s–t for my own self, not for everybody else,' she said. View Gallery Launch Gallery: Cardi B in Slashed Body-con Dress and More Star Style at Coachella 2025's Pizzaslime x Revolve Afterparty Powered by Casamigos, Photos Best of WWD Mia Threapleton's Red Carpet Style Through the Years [PHOTOS] Princess Charlene of Monaco's Grand Prix Style Through the Years: Louis Vuitton, Akris and More, Photos Princess Charlene's Monaco Grand Prix Style Evolution at Full Speed: Shades of Blue in Louis Vuitton, Playful Patterning in Akris and More
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Paramount to cut 3.5% of its workforce amid economic, media challenges
Paramount Global said Tuesday that the entertainment and media company is cutting 3.5% of its workforce, citing challenges in the broader U.S. economy and in the linear television business. It's the latest round of layoffs at the media company — which owns the CBS broadcast network as well as cable channels, such as MTV and Nickelodeon — as it prepares to merge with movie studio Skydance Media. In a memo sent Tuesday morning to employees from the company's three co-CEOs — George Cheeks, Chris McCarthy and Brian Robbins — Paramount said the layoffs would affect U.S. workers, with "the majority of impacted staff being notified today." Some employees outside the U.S. could later be impacted, according to the memo. Paramount had about 18,600 full- and part-time workers in 32 countries at the end of 2024, according to a regulatory filing. As consumers shift to streaming media and viewership declines for traditional TV and cable networks, Paramount has put more resources into its streaming business, Paramount+. It's also banking on its merger with Skydance, an entertainment business launched by David Ellison, son of Oracle founder Larry Ellison, to help revive its fortunes. "As we navigate the continued industrywide linear declines and dynamic macro-economic environment, while prioritizing investments in our growing streaming business, we are taking the hard, but necessary steps to further streamline our organization starting this week," the co-CEOs wrote in the memo. A spokesman for Paramount said the company declined further comment. The latest cuts come after the media giant slashed about 15% of its workforce last year, part of an effort to trim costs by $500 million and return the company to profitability. For the first three months of the year, Paramount reported net earnings of $152 million on revenue of $7.1 billion, compared with a loss of $563 million on revenue of $7.6 billion in the year-ago period. Paramount and Skydance are awaiting regulatory approval for the merger amid a lawsuit filed by President Trump against the network. The suit claims that CBS' "60 Minutes" program intentionally misled the public in its editing of an October 2024 interview with then-Vice President Kamala Harris about her presidential candidacy. The network has repeatedly said the claims are "completely without merit." Legal experts have said they view the lawsuit as "frivolous" and an infringement on First Amendment rights. Mediation between Paramount and Mr. Trump's legal team is ongoing. Australian reporter covering Los Angeles protests shot with rubber bullet by police officer LAPD chief speaks out about deployment of military forces to anti-ICE protests Can Trump deploy National Guard without governor's approval?


Buzz Feed
4 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
26 Extremely Rare And Fascinating Pictures From History That Will Completely And Totally Change Your Perspective On The Past
Before airplanes were pressurized for commercial use, flyers had to wear oxygen masks at higher altitudes: This picture is from 1939 and taken while 20,000 feet in the air. During World War II, the USS Trigger got close enough to Japan on patrol to take a picture through its periscope of Mount Fuji: This is from 1943. Fascinating stuff! The Michelin Man not only used to be absolutely terrifying, but he used to run with a gang of several other musically inclined Michelin men: Chet Baker is shaking. Tourists in Egypt used to be able to climb on top of the Great Pyramid all willy-nilly: Let's be thankful there are some stricter rules about visiting the landmark. These gigantic contraptions are apparently one of the first life preservers ever made: They're made out of mattresses but something tells me they aren't comfortable. This picture, taken in 1942, shows a New York Times employee creating that day's layout of the Sports page: "Boy, this Mort Cooper guy can really slang it." This is selection of prosthetic face parts designed for World War I veterans: Here's what one of those prosthetics looked like in action: This is Australian javelin thrower Reg Spiers, best known for literally mailing himself in a big giant box from London to Australia in the 1960s: Spiers was broke and needed to figure out a way home to his family, so he did what any person would have done: he posted himself. This is the 5x3x2.5 foot box Spiers mailed himself in: The journey took over two days. Spiers stuffed himself in the box with some "tinned food, a torch, a blanket and a pillow, plus two plastic bottles - one for water, one for urine." You can read more about the whole ordeal here. This is frogman Courtney Brown towing a 55 scale model of the Titanic during the filming of the movie Raise The Titanic: The movie was, well, about raising the Titanic from the ocean floor. Interestingly enough, because the movie was made in 1980, the wreck of the ship had yet to be found. That's why "the wreck" is in one big piece here. Here's what the wreck of the model of the wreck of the Titanic looks like today: Slightly worse than the one in the Atlantic, I'd say. This is Robert Earl Hughes, the one-time world's heaviest man and his pet dog: At his heaviest, Robert weighed over 1,000 pounds. Eleven days in October had to be skipped after the Gregorian calendar was adopted in 1582: A wise person on Reddit hipped the internet to the fact that if you scroll back in your phone long enough, you can see it for yourself. Here's what gorilla's fingerprint looks like compared to a human's: Gorillas: they're just like us. This is what a whole bunch of wind turbines look like from way above: Like they're floating! This is a replica of what was apparently the world's largest polar bear, standing tall at 12 feet and weighing over 2,200 pounds: That, and I don't say this lightly, is one big bear. This is the crew of the USS Hunchback, taken in Virginia at the end of the Civil War. Unlike the army, the Union's navy was actually integrated: I think I would have also been the banjo player during the Civil War. This is what British World War I victory medal looks like: Too bad there would be another Great War for civilization less than two decades later. This is the first computer Apple ever developed: It looks nothing like an apple. Not even like an orange. This is a Corinthian helmet and the skull that wore it from the Battle of Marathon in 490 BC: Chilling stuff. This is what a pick-up truck from 1985 looks like compared to the behemoths that are modern pick-up trucks: Poor l'il guy. Owls have big ol' long legs: Check out the gams on Birdie. This is a list of the causes of death of everyone who died in London in 1632: Me, personally? I'm dying from "Planet." This was the scene aboard the ship The Queen Elizabeth as it brought soldiers back home to New York after World War II ended: I hate to say it... but imagine having to use the bathroom? Nightmare. And, finally, this is what Nicolas Cages' father, August Coppola, looked like: Incredible stuff.