logo
The 'Wuthering Heights' Casting Director Addressed The Jacob Elordi Backlash And Said The Movie Doesn't Need To Be 'Accurate' Because It's 'Just A Book' — And People Are Outraged

The 'Wuthering Heights' Casting Director Addressed The Jacob Elordi Backlash And Said The Movie Doesn't Need To Be 'Accurate' Because It's 'Just A Book' — And People Are Outraged

Buzz Feed29-04-2025

Last year, it was confirmed that Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie would star together in Emerald Fennell 's upcoming film adaptation of Wuthering Heights, the classic 1847 novel by Emily Brontë. The casting announcement did not go down well at the time, and it's fair to say it's still not sitting right with fans.
For context, many feel that 34-year-old Margot is too old to play 18-year-old Catherine Earnshaw, while Jacob is probably too white to play Heathcliff, the foster son of the Earnshaw family, who is described early in the book as 'dark-skinned.'
The exact details around Heathcliff's race and ethnicity are ambiguous in the novel. However, another character refers to him as 'a little Lascar,' which means a sailor from Southeast Asia, and in a later part of the text, he is described as a 'ragged, black-haired child… as dark almost as if it came from the devil.'
Despite this, Heathcliff has historically been portrayed by white actors, with the exception of the 2011 film, in which he was played by James Howson.
All in all, the consensus is that neither Jacob nor Margot, who are both Australian, are the right fit for the roles based on how they're described in the book. And now, off the back of the first batch of photographs of the pair together in costume on set, the film's casting director has weighed in on the widespread criticism.
Speaking at a Q&A session during the Sands Film Festival in Scotland over the weekend, Kharmel Cochrane — who notably worked with Jacob and Margot on Emerald's Saltburn in 2023 — argued that the actors don't need to look exactly how the characters are described in the original text because 'it's just a book.'
'If something is clearly written as white, for example, a script reads 'she tied her blonde hair back,' but there's no specific reason for it, I will just put people on tape,' she explained. 'And then it's almost like I dare someone to question why I've done it, and they don't. So then it just becomes normal. Years ago, I would get people saying, 'Did you read the brief?' And I'd say yeah, and this is my interpretation of it, just like when you can read a book.'
'There was one Instagram comment that said the casting director should be shot,' she said, talking about the backlash more specifically. 'But just wait till you see it, and then you can decide whether you want to shoot me or not. But you really don't need to be accurate. It's just a book. That is not based on real life. It's all art.'
Aside from the castings, Kharmel hinted at some potentially 'even more shocking' differences between the book and upcoming film, saying, 'there's definitely going to be some English Lit fans that are not going to be happy.' 'Wait until you see the set design because that is even more shocking,' she teased. 'And there may or may not be a dog collar in it.'
Well, as a former English Lit student, that was a liiiittle painful to hear — and it sounds like I'm not the only one feeling odd about Kharmel's latest comments. Many fans on X have pointed out that it's a bold choice to describe Wuthering Heights as 'just a book,' when you consider that it was Emily Brontë's only novel, published at a time when very few women's writing saw the light of day, and is widely lauded as a masterpiece.
On top of that, Kharmel's quips about the reactions of 'English Lit fans' are also bound to 'alienate' what will likely be the movie's primary audience of — you guessed it — English Lit fans.
Caro_LBF / X / Via x.com
I have to say, I'm with the people on this one. What do you think of her comments? Is it arrogance, or are they just enjoying pushing the boundaries of making a movie adaptation? LMK your thoughts.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

EXCLUSIVE: Hugh Jackman Lists NYC Penthouse for $39 Million—Amid Divorce From Deborra-Lee Furness
EXCLUSIVE: Hugh Jackman Lists NYC Penthouse for $39 Million—Amid Divorce From Deborra-Lee Furness

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

EXCLUSIVE: Hugh Jackman Lists NYC Penthouse for $39 Million—Amid Divorce From Deborra-Lee Furness

Actor Hugh Jackman has put his sprawling New York City penthouse on the market for $38.9 million—just days after agreeing to split the money from the property with his former spouse, Deborra-Lee Furness, amid their ongoing divorce. Jackman, 56, and Furness, 69, originally snapped up the dwelling in 2008 for a cool $21 million but in recent years have bee renting out the opulent unit—which was last on the market for $125,000 a month. However, in September 2023, the former couple announced that their marriage was over after 'almost three decades together as husband and wife,' with Furness officially filing for divorce in May 2025. In legal documents seen by People, Furness' lawyers indicated that the terms of her divorce from Jackman—who has since moved on with actress Sutton Foster—were not going to be contested and that the paperwork simply required a judge's sign-off in order to be made official. Then, on June 5, it was revealed that steps had been taken to divide up the couple's shared assets, with The Real Deal reporting that the couple had filed paperwork to split an extravagant penthouse apartment that the duo shares in Manhattan's Chelsea neighborhood. While that dwelling has yet to be listed, Jackman and Furness are moving ahead with the sale of one of their other New York City properties, a stunning five-bedroom penthouse located in the West Village. The extraordinary abode is spread across three floors and boasts 11,000 square feet of living space, including a 'dramatic double-height great room with walls of windows,' a private workout studio, a luxurious sauna, and a library. Designed by acclaimed architect Richard Meier, the property is described in its listing as a 'modernist masterpiece' that boasts a wealth of amenities, including dazzling views across the Hudson River. Jackman and Furness have previously tried to offload the property—listing it in 2022 for the exact same price that it has now been put on the market for. However, back in 2022, they hit pause on their plans to sell, instead putting it on the rental market in 2023. It is unclear whether Jackman and Furness plan to split the money from the sale of this apartment, which was not mentioned in the court filing that confirmed their decision to split their other New York abode. The listed apartment is currently still registered to an LLC through which the couple bought both units, however the Chelsea abode has since been transferred to a different shell company with ties to Furness, according to The Real Deal. has contacted Jackman's spokesperson for comment. Interestingly, the property's listing comes just days after Australian publication New Idea reported that Foster and Jackman had moved into one of his New York City penthouse together, with an anonymous insider claiming to the publication that Furness was upset that another woman was making herself at home in the dwelling that she had 'poured her soul into.' It's unclear which of the former couple's penthouses Jackman is currently living in—however he has spent the past six months based in Manhattan while doing a series of live shows at iconic New York venue Radio City Music Hall. Though Furness has not publicly commented on her former husband's romance with Foster, she hinted at the 'betrayal' she felt after their split, issuing an emotional statement to the Daily Mail after filing for divorce. 'My heart and compassion goes out to everyone who has traversed the traumatic journey of betrayal. It's a profound wound that cuts deep, however I believe in a higher power and that God/the universe, whatever you relate to as your guidance, is always working FOR us,' she said. 'This belief has helped me navigate the breakdown of an almost three-decade marriage. I have gained much knowledge and wisdom through this experience. Even when we are presented with apparent adversity, it is leading us to our greatest good, our true purpose. 'It can hurt, but in the long run, returning to yourself and living within your own integrity, values and boundaries is liberation and freedom.' In addition to their New York City properties, Jackman and Furness also own a 2.5-acre estate in East Hampton, NY, which they picked up for $3.5 million in 2015—before spending six years renovating it into their perfect weekend escape. Situated by the water, the property boasts three bedrooms, five bathrooms, and a guesthouse with a bedroom and two bathrooms. It measures 7,300 square feet and features floor-to-ceiling glass doors and a stunning swimming pool. A year after purchasing their East Hampton home, the couple splashed out $5.9 million on a property in Australia. It is believed that Jackman will take over the three-bed, two-bath, six-balcony home following their divorce. Hand Surgeon's $60 Million Seaside Santa Barbara Playground Skims to the Top of the Week's Most Expensive Homes List 16 States That Exempt Senior Citizens From Property Taxes—and 7 More That Are Working on It This State Is Where Young People Prefer To Buy Property the Most

#ManCrushMonday: 15 Black Actors Who Are Sexy & Under 30
#ManCrushMonday: 15 Black Actors Who Are Sexy & Under 30

Black America Web

time2 hours ago

  • Black America Web

#ManCrushMonday: 15 Black Actors Who Are Sexy & Under 30

Source: Arnold Turner / Getty The entertainment industry thrives on the energy and innovation that fresh talent brings. Among its dynamic contributors are young Black actors under 40, whose rising stardom is redefining Hollywood. These actors are not only captivating audiences with their performances but are also instrumental in shaping a more inclusive and diverse entertainment landscape. Jacob Latimore exemplifies this new wave of talent. Known for his role in the Showtime series The Chi , Latimore effortlessly balances his career as both a singer and an actor. His versatility sets him apart, showcasing his ability to connect deeply with audiences across genres. Michael Rainey Jr. has also made a remarkable impact, starring in the hit series Power Book II: Ghost . With his impeccable acting chops and a growing fan base, Rainey continues to elevate the stories told on-screen. Meanwhile, rising stars like Miles Brown and Marcus Scribner have become household names, portraying relatable and inspirational characters that resonate with younger generations. Actors like Jharrel Jerome, who won an Emmy for his role in When They See Us , and Caleb McLaughlin, a standout in Stranger Things , demonstrate how talent and dedication can create iconic moments on screen. Each contribution they make strengthens their role as leaders in a Hollywood that is evolving for the better. From performances that spark conversations to breaking barriers in casting, these actors are setting the stage for a future where stories reflect a wide range of voices and experiences. Through their passion, they are not just entertainers but powerful role models for aspiring actors worldwide. Also Check Out: Black Actors Under 40 We Should Be Paying Attention To #ManCrushMonday: 15 Black Actors Who Are Sexy & Under 30 was originally published on Source:Getty Jacob Latimore is a multi-faceted talent who balances acting and music with ease. Best known for his role as Emmett in the Showtime series The Chi , Jacob brings depth and relatability to his characters. His on-screen charm has earned him a loyal fanbase, while his music career showcases his versatility as an entertainer. From rom-coms like The Last Summer to sci-fi thrillers such as Sleight , Jacob's diverse portfolio demonstrates his ability to excel in different genres. A shining example of a modern artist, Jacob uses his craft to connect with audiences while continuing to grow as a performer. Michael Rainey Jr. rose to fame with his standout role as Tariq in the hit series Power Book II: Ghost . Known for his natural charisma and nuanced acting, Michael has captivated viewers with his portrayal of a morally complex character navigating a turbulent world. His talent has garnered accolades, making him a rising star in Hollywood. Beyond acting, Michael is admired for staying humble and engaging with fans. He exemplifies promise and dedication, with a career trajectory that hints at larger roles in the future. Michael's influence continues to grow as he becomes a leading figure in young Black Hollywood. Miles Brown, best known for his role as Jack Johnson on ABC's Black-ish , has charmed audiences with his comedic timing and warm personality. Starting his career as a dancer, Miles transitioned effortlessly into acting, earning accolades for his performance in the series. Beyond television, he has showcased his talent in film, music, and even activism, championing causes that inspire younger generations. With his creative endeavors and down-to-earth charisma, Miles is seen as a role model for aspiring artists. At such a young age, he has already developed an impressive resume, confidently paving the way for a long-lasting career in entertainment. Bursting onto the scene with When They See Us , Asante Blackk quickly proved himself a force to be reckoned with. His Emmy-nominated portrayal of Kevin Richardson in Ava DuVernay's series brought attention to his exceptional talent and ability to embody emotionally charged roles. He later joined the cast of This Is Us , receiving praise for his portrayal of Malik, a young father balancing life's challenges. Beyond acting, Asante uses his platform to advocate for equality and representation in the industry. With his thoughtful performances and grounded approach, this rising star is redefining what it means to be young and influential in Hollywood. Marcus Scribner became a household name with his role as Andre Johnson Jr., or 'Junior,' on ABC's Black-ish . His comedic and heartfelt performance earned him admiration and established him as a voice for socially conscious narratives. Off-screen, Marcus is an advocate for environmental causes and social justice, proving his commitment to using his platform responsibly. He expanded his career with roles in animated projects, including the lead voice in She-Ra and the Princesses of Power . Marcus continues to capture attention with his craft and activism, solidifying himself as a well-rounded talent and an important figure in the entertainment industry. Jharrel Jerome captured hearts and critical acclaim with his powerful, Emmy-winning performance in Ava DuVernay's When They See Us . His portrayal of Korey Wise, one of the Exonerated Five, remains one of the most moving performances in modern TV history. Jharrel followed up with impressive roles in Moonlight and Concrete Cowboy , further showcasing his tremendous range. He is lauded for his ability to bring authenticity and emotional depth to every project he undertakes. Jharrel's success continues to inspire others, proving that talent and dedication can break barriers and shift perceptions in the competitive landscape of Hollywood. Caleb McLaughlin skyrocketed to fame as Lucas Sinclair in Netflix's global hit Stranger Things . Known for his grounded performance, Caleb has carved out a niche as a relatable and versatile actor. Beyond acting, Caleb made history as the first Black youth ambassador for Dior's Sauvage fragrance line, signaling his rising star in fashion and culture. He also appeared in Concrete Cowboy , solidifying his role in diverse storytelling. Caleb regularly mentors youth about self-confidence, using his platform to inspire. At just 23, Caleb is a dynamic talent influencing Hollywood and proving himself as a positive force in the entertainment world. Chosen Jacobs is a rising actor making his mark with roles that showcase his unique charm and commitment to the craft. Best known for his role as Mike Hanlon in Stephen King's It adaptation, he effortlessly brought sincerity and depth to the coming-of-age horror classic. Chosen continued to build his career with projects like Castle Rock and the Disney+ musical Sneakerella , further highlighting his versatility. Off-screen, Chosen has a passion for music and philanthropy, often sharing songs with his fans. With charisma and determination, he's establishing himself as a promising talent poised to leave a lasting impact on Hollywood. Jabari Banks burst onto the scene as Will in Peacock's Bel-Air , a reimagining of the iconic sitcom The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air . His fresh take on the role introduced him to a new generation of fans while paying homage to the original series. Jabari's energy and heartfelt performance won praise from audiences and critics alike, signaling a bright future ahead. Stepping into big shoes for his debut role, he proved himself capable of carrying a series, showcasing both dramatic and comedic skills. With his impressive entry into the industry, Jabari Banks is making his presence known in Hollywood. Niles Fitch is best known for his heartwarming performance as teenage Randall Pearson in NBC's hit drama This Is Us . Through emotional depth and authenticity, he added layers of complexity to his character, earning recognition from both fans and critics. He has also appeared in Disney+'s Secret Society of Second-Born Royals , further demonstrating his versatility as an actor. Beyond his roles, Niles is celebrated for his dedication to representation in Hollywood, ensuring diverse stories are told. With exceptional talent and a bright outlook, Niles has positioned himself as one of the most promising young actors in the entertainment industry. Myles Truitt gained attention with his role in Kin , a sci-fi thriller that highlighted his ability to lead a complex narrative. He's also appeared in notable television series like Black Lightning , where he portrayed Issa Williams, and Euphoria , showcasing his versatility in different genres. Myles's captivating performances continue to draw audiences, with each role reflecting his growth as an actor. Despite his young age, he remains grounded and focused on honing his craft. His dedication has cemented his status as a rising talent in Hollywood, with fans eagerly awaiting what future projects he'll take on. Known for his breakout role in Kicks , Jahking Guillory brought authenticity and raw emotion to his portrayal of a teenager navigating life in Oakland. He has since appeared in projects like On My Block and Black Lightning , earning praise for his gripping performances. Jahking often channels personal experiences to bring depth to his roles, connecting with audiences on an emotional level. Off-screen, he's an advocate for mental health awareness, often engaging with fans on social platforms. His talent and advocacy make him one of the most promising young actors today, poised to make significant strides in the industry. Michael Epps is best known for playing Jake Taylor on Showtime's The Chi . With his natural talent and relatable demeanor, Michael has captivated viewers as a young actor on the rise. He portrays a character navigating challenges in his community, offering an authentic reflection of adolescent struggles. Off-screen, Michael remains focused on his craft while maintaining a grounded personality that resonates with fans. His passion for storytelling and dedication to representation make him a standout talent in the industry. At such a young age, Michael continues to build a career marked by impressive performances and growing influence. Alex Hibbert first gained recognition for his poignant portrayal of young Chiron in the Academy Award-winning film Moonlight . His deeply emotional performance earned widespread acclaim, establishing him as an actor to watch. Transitioning to television, Alex joined Showtime's The Chi , delivering similarly compelling work. Despite his youth, Alex approaches each role with maturity and thoughtfulness, bringing nuanced perspectives to the characters he plays. Off-screen, he's an advocate for diversity and positive youth representation. With his grounded approach to fame and natural talent, Alex continues to prove himself as a vital voice in young Black Hollywood. Martin Bobb-Semple has earned recognition for his performances in The CW's Pandora and Netflix's Free Rein . His roles often showcase his ability to portray complex emotions, bringing depth and authenticity to his characters. A native of London, Martin has quickly adapted to Hollywood's demanding landscape, gaining fans around the globe. Alongside his acting career, Martin is passionate about wellness and personal growth, often sharing motivational messages with his audience. With a strong presence both on and off-screen, he embodies the qualities of a modern entertainer. Martin's commitment to his craft makes him a promising force in the industry. Black America Web Featured Video CLOSE

Bianca Censori Seemingly Launches New Business Amid Kanye West Drama
Bianca Censori Seemingly Launches New Business Amid Kanye West Drama

Yahoo

time4 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Bianca Censori Seemingly Launches New Business Amid Kanye West Drama

Bianca Censori has reportedly made a new business move in her career amid the drama surrounding her husband, , who now goes by Ye. As reported by the U.S. Sun, the Australian designer has launched her first-ever, self-named company, Bianca Censori Inc., in the United States. Amid the online controversies and speculation involving Kanye West, his wife, Bianca Censori, allegedly set up her own U.S. company. The U.S. Sun reported that the brand-new business by the designer has been named Bianca Censori Inc. and that the company was registered in the state of California last month. She has also registered her full name, Bianca Censori, as an Australian firm. The base of the firm is reportedly in Alphington, a prosperous suburb in Melbourne where Censori's parents reside at present. The designer has also allegedly listed herself as the new firm's CEO and secretary. As for the nature of the firm, there is a chance that it may be a beauty brand. Although Censori has not confirmed anything yet, Hussein Lalani has been listed as the chief financial officer of the firm. Lalani is notable for specializing in cosmetic treatments. He founded the brand, Zensa, which sells tattoo and piercing kits, DIY Brazilian wax kits, various nourishing creams, microblading, and other beauty procedures. It reportedly appears that Censori and West came across Lalani at the luxury West Hollywood condo. Last year, the couple used to live in that neighborhood in a $10,000-a-month two-bedroom apartment. The U.S. Sun reported that on Bianca Censori Inc.'s corporate statement of information, Lalani is listed with that particular address. Moreover, he has reportedly been touted as the Yeezy CFO. On the other hand, Bianca Censori used to work for her now-husband, Kanye West, as an architect at Yeezy in 2020. The two tied the knot two years later following the rapper's divorce from Kim Kardashian, with whom he shares four children. The post Bianca Censori Seemingly Launches New Business Amid Kanye West Drama appeared first on Reality Tea.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store