logo
The 'Wuthering Heights' Casting Director Addressed The Jacob Elordi Backlash And Said The Movie Doesn't Need To Be 'Accurate' Because It's 'Just A Book' — And People Are Outraged

The 'Wuthering Heights' Casting Director Addressed The Jacob Elordi Backlash And Said The Movie Doesn't Need To Be 'Accurate' Because It's 'Just A Book' — And People Are Outraged

Buzz Feed29-04-2025

Last year, it was confirmed that Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie would star together in Emerald Fennell 's upcoming film adaptation of Wuthering Heights, the classic 1847 novel by Emily Brontë. The casting announcement did not go down well at the time, and it's fair to say it's still not sitting right with fans.
For context, many feel that 34-year-old Margot is too old to play 18-year-old Catherine Earnshaw, while Jacob is probably too white to play Heathcliff, the foster son of the Earnshaw family, who is described early in the book as 'dark-skinned.'
The exact details around Heathcliff's race and ethnicity are ambiguous in the novel. However, another character refers to him as 'a little Lascar,' which means a sailor from Southeast Asia, and in a later part of the text, he is described as a 'ragged, black-haired child… as dark almost as if it came from the devil.'
Despite this, Heathcliff has historically been portrayed by white actors, with the exception of the 2011 film, in which he was played by James Howson.
All in all, the consensus is that neither Jacob nor Margot, who are both Australian, are the right fit for the roles based on how they're described in the book. And now, off the back of the first batch of photographs of the pair together in costume on set, the film's casting director has weighed in on the widespread criticism.
Speaking at a Q&A session during the Sands Film Festival in Scotland over the weekend, Kharmel Cochrane — who notably worked with Jacob and Margot on Emerald's Saltburn in 2023 — argued that the actors don't need to look exactly how the characters are described in the original text because 'it's just a book.'
'If something is clearly written as white, for example, a script reads 'she tied her blonde hair back,' but there's no specific reason for it, I will just put people on tape,' she explained. 'And then it's almost like I dare someone to question why I've done it, and they don't. So then it just becomes normal. Years ago, I would get people saying, 'Did you read the brief?' And I'd say yeah, and this is my interpretation of it, just like when you can read a book.'
'There was one Instagram comment that said the casting director should be shot,' she said, talking about the backlash more specifically. 'But just wait till you see it, and then you can decide whether you want to shoot me or not. But you really don't need to be accurate. It's just a book. That is not based on real life. It's all art.'
Aside from the castings, Kharmel hinted at some potentially 'even more shocking' differences between the book and upcoming film, saying, 'there's definitely going to be some English Lit fans that are not going to be happy.' 'Wait until you see the set design because that is even more shocking,' she teased. 'And there may or may not be a dog collar in it.'
Well, as a former English Lit student, that was a liiiittle painful to hear — and it sounds like I'm not the only one feeling odd about Kharmel's latest comments. Many fans on X have pointed out that it's a bold choice to describe Wuthering Heights as 'just a book,' when you consider that it was Emily Brontë's only novel, published at a time when very few women's writing saw the light of day, and is widely lauded as a masterpiece.
On top of that, Kharmel's quips about the reactions of 'English Lit fans' are also bound to 'alienate' what will likely be the movie's primary audience of — you guessed it — English Lit fans.
Caro_LBF / X / Via x.com
I have to say, I'm with the people on this one. What do you think of her comments? Is it arrogance, or are they just enjoying pushing the boundaries of making a movie adaptation? LMK your thoughts.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

23 Life-Upgrading Finds From Black-Owned Businesses
23 Life-Upgrading Finds From Black-Owned Businesses

Buzz Feed

timean hour ago

  • Buzz Feed

23 Life-Upgrading Finds From Black-Owned Businesses

A pair of hammered glass martini glasses with gold rims because your fancy cocktail deserves more than a boring cup. The textured glass will catch the light like a dream, and it even comes with two gold picks so your olives or cherries can be a little extra. Sisterly Drinkware is a Black woman-owned small business that makes handmade glassware. Promising review: "These have been one of my favorite finds on Amazon. This set of martini glasses is not only gorgeous, but they're large and come with cute cocktail skewers. These glasses are a great way to elevate your cocktail gatherings!" —Arriana Get it from Amazon for $45.99 (available in three styles). Ghetto Gastro Sweet Potato Pancake & Waffle Mix your tastebuds deserve to try immediately — the reviews raving about the texture and perfect sweetness of the sweet potato flavor speak for themselves. Bread Beauty Supply's Hair Mask Creamy Deep Conditioner — it works on all hair types, but was really developed with curly and textured hair in mind! Australian Kakadu plum + starflower oil join forces to create a superrrr hydrating, but super lightweight formula. An iconic Telfar shopper in a medium puffer style that'll help you carry basically whatever you may need for the day. These bags are super sturdy, an IYKYK accessory, and come in several colors. If the name sounds a little familiar, it might be because Beyoncé wore a Telfar look on her Cowboy Carter tour at MetLife Stadium. Or simply because you've followed anything about fashion in the past decade or so! A fashion-forward Cincha travel belt that can accommodate most any carry-on as it expands to 45 inches. This way, when your summer travels have you here, there, and everywhere, you can stack your bags instead of juggling them. A pair of classic gold-dipped hoops that take ~literally~ no effort or know-how to style. While they're pretty substantial in size, they are unbelievably lightweight so you don't have to worry about saggy lobes. A variety pack of Partake cookies that are gluten-free, kosher, and vegan! They come in delish flavors like birthday cake, ginger snap, double chocolate brownie, and cookie butter. Touch Radiance's Sweet Like Mango Body Butter — it hydrates and smoothes skin with shea butter, vitamin E, and avocado and jojoba oils (among others). Best of all, it leaves you supple but not greasy! A waterproof, UPF 50 Kin Apparel satin-lined bucket hat from a brand that's perfected satin-lined clothes and accessories to help protect your hair and keep it smooth and frizz-free. Also, we could all use another bucket hat! A tube of Black Girl Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 30 that's a sunscreen and a moisturizer. This genius product was developed specifically for dark skin tones, and will leave no chalky residue on your skin after application. Black Girl Sunscreen is a Black woman-owned small business whose sunscreen is designed not to leave a white cast on melanated skin. It's ultra-sheer, water-resistant, and super nourishing. Plus, it's cruelty-free! Promising review: "I like that it doesn't have a strong sunscreen smell, which usually bothers me. Usually sunscreens make my skin look ashy and leave an odd color, but this one is great for dark skin tones. It leaves my skin glowing, feels lightweight, and doesn't cause breakouts like other face sunscreens I've used." —Sara BrodzinskiGet it from from Amazon for $9.99. A Dozen Cousins microwave beans variety pack might just become a pantry staple for you (they have for me!) once you realize how easily these microwavable mains will fit into your meal rotation. But that's just where the beans start! A 1,000-piece puzzle from Apostrophe Puzzles that'll give you and your roomies something to do with your hands while you watch all the drama go down on Love Island this season. It features a stunning take on Rosie the Riveter you'll absolutely want to frame when you've finished putting it together. A wall-mounted hat rack can take up *very* little room while helping maintain the shape of your caps. Each stores up to 20 baseball caps so you can finally get back some shelf space in your closet. (You may have seen this on Shark Tank!) A Speakeasy luxury candle so beloved by reviewers that many have made it the "signature scent" of their home. The blend of bourbon and palo alto is made all the more rich and complex by notes of cardamom, dark chocolate, and smoked incense, meant to "transport you to Harlem's clandestine nightclubs and secret lounges during the 1920s." A uniquely gorgeous watercolor art print to make a statement on your living room wall and give you something colorful to look forward to every day when you come home. Handmade linen dolls featuring a variety of hair textures and skin tones you might find yourself ordering for yourself even if you don't have a little one at home. The detailing on these beauties is truly incredible — they're better dressed than I am! A pair of merino wool crew socks from Shark Tank that'll wick away moisture, deter stinky odors with some comfy bells and whistles (meaning, 360-degree arch support, a flat toe seam, and extra heel cushioning). But the real kicker here is that these socks are made specifically for women's feet, which oftentimes have higher arches and narrower heels than men's feet. So you won't need to size down from a men's size to get the benefits of a superior sock. A customizable Buttah Skin kit to help you bring out your inner ~glow~, thanks to nurturing ingredients to help with dryness, discoloration, oiliness, and blemishes. If you're someone who needs a solid skincare routine, this is an excellent way to start a tried-and-true one! A concrete catch-all tray from Tara Jayne Designs because even your loose change deserves to rest on something gorgeous. Hand-poured and hand-painted with an eucalyptus branch motif, this sleek little tray brings serious artisan energy to your nightstand, vanity, or entryway. It's sealed with heat-resistant resin and finished with cork on the bottom, so it's both beautiful *and* furniture-friendly. Tara Jayne Designs is a Philadelphia-based Black woman-owned small business creating unique and functional concrete home review: "This tray is gorgeous! It is very well made and fits well in an array of decor styles. It is fairly large, so you can display/store quite a bit, and it is worth the price point. I will definitely order again!" —Kristina MitchellGet it from Tara Jayne Designs on Etsy for $30. A gorgeous ring from Adore Adorn you'll start planning all of your looks around — it comes in an array of stones and will look oh-so-fabulous alongside the baubles you already wear daily. Sugardoh's Ingrown Magic Wand made with a blend of sensitive-skin friendly blend of exfoliating and brightening acids both to help prevent the infection of ingrown hair, and to help with discoloration and hyperpigmentation caused by hair removal. A splurge-worthy iridescent cake stand from Estelle's Colored Glass you'll want to leave out on display at all times. It's not our fault if you *also* decide you need to whip up a delicious cake or muffins to plop on top of it weekly. A brass and crystal air plant mobile that'll turn your greenery into actual art. With eight shimmering prisms and space for four air plants, it's elegant, simple, and quietly show-offy in the best possible way. Hang it in a sunny window and let it do its thing.

‘Inside' Review: Guy Pearce Delivers Another Incredible Supporting Performance in Australian Prison Drama That Cuts Through All the Bull
‘Inside' Review: Guy Pearce Delivers Another Incredible Supporting Performance in Australian Prison Drama That Cuts Through All the Bull

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

‘Inside' Review: Guy Pearce Delivers Another Incredible Supporting Performance in Australian Prison Drama That Cuts Through All the Bull

The lower-security prisoners in Charles Williams' difficult but deeply penetrating 'Inside' sometimes pass the time by playing the trivia games that are printed on the packaging of their sweets. 'WHO AM I?' the text asks, before offering a series of clues about, say, a Brooklyn-born musician who got his first break when Bette Midler hired him as a pianist. Most of the characters in this decidedly grounded Australian prison drama are too young — and too many worlds removed — to know who Barry Manilow is, let alone guess his identity based on a handful of factoids. But that doesn't stop these men from trying, even if they spend every day of their sentences trying to separate their souls from the bullet points of their own biographies. Are they more than what they've done? The people they've hurt? The situations they were born into? We know they are. Not because they're human, and we have the natural grace to extend these murderers the courtesy of that recognition, but rather because this film wouldn't have any reason to exist if the answer to any of those questions was 'no.' The abundant power of Williams' debut feature — which stems from his experience growing up in an economically dispossessed Victoria town whose jail was like a second home for several of the men in his family — is rooted in the fact that 'Inside' never pretends otherwise. More from IndieWire Zoe Saldaña Says Her 'Emilia Pérez' Oscar Is 'Trans': The Statue 'Goes by They/Them' Two Lost Exploitation Films from Trash-Cult Favorite Andy Milligan Will 'Re-Premiere' at Tribeca This is not a story that labors to earn its prisoners their humanity. On the contrary, it's a story about how their clear and inextinguishable humanity is liable to become a prison unto itself. In the borrowed words of long-time inmate Warren Murfett (a bushy and brilliant Guy Pearce): 'The worst of men have a little bit of good in them, and that'll be their undoing.' Warren is quoting another inmate at the same time as he's mocking the way that some of his fellow convicts try to protect themselves with aphorisms, but some pearls of wisdom are worth carrying around in your pocket like a shiv at the ready. For a man with blood on his hands like Warren, it's that last mote of humanity that might prove to be his doom — the stubborn part of himself that still yearns for redemption, hopes for healing, and strives to make something more of himself before there's nothing left. It's the part of himself that 17-year-old Mel Blight (puppy-eyed newcomer Vincent Miller, wrenchingly credible in his first movie role) is already trying to stamp out by the time Williams' film begins to take shape around him. In his opening voiceover, which floats above the sort of glassy synth music that's meant to numb our judgment, Mel informs us that he was conceived during a conjugal visit when his father was in prison, and that his dad once told him that he was destined to wind up back behind bars. 'And he was right.' A broken home gave way to juvenile detention, and the violence that followed him there saw Mel transferred to general population — not unheard of in a country where kids as young as 10 can be locked away indefinitely. Now that he's inching toward parole, Mel's doing everything in his power to fuck it up. 'They want me to make a story out of it and pretend I've changed,' he says when asked to write a letter of contrition to the boy he beat to death in juvie. 'But I haven't changed. No one does, especially inside.' By 'inside' he means prison, but Williams' delicate script obviously intends for us to recognize that he means inside himself as well. If this film is able to afford such an explicit double entendre, that's because of how truthfully it grapples with the nuances of rehabilitation — with the crooked path these men are meant to walk from sin to salvation, and with the practical realities of returning to a world that may no longer have a place for them in it. Like so many of the people he meets in prison, Mel doesn't think he's worthy of being released. 'There's something broken inside of us,' he writes in one of his letters, and it's easier for him to own that spiritual dysfunction than to risk the heartache of failing to overcome it. That's a big part of the initial reason why Warren takes Mel under his wing: The kid is the perfect candidate to kill the most hated man in prison, whose bounty would be enough to pay off Warren's dire gambling debt. The target's name is Mark Shepard (a slack-jawed Cosmo Jarvis, who continues to be one of the most gifted chameleons in modern cinema), he became a national sensation when he was convicted for the rape and murder of a young girl when he was only 13 years old himself, and — after earning a transfer out of maximum security — he happens to be Mel's new cellmate. What separates Mark from the other two characters in this movie's core triangle is that he's evangelically convinced of his own absolution, to the point that he delivers Pentecostal sermons to the world's most hostile congregation. He even ropes Mel into playing the prayer room keyboard as he preaches. It's a little detail, but also one emblematic of the irreconcilable tension that 'Inside' would rather articulate than resolve; Williams often lingers on the image of Mel sitting focused at the piano, forcing us to guess whether the kid is starting to entertain the possibility of self-deliverance, or whether he's plotting how to stab the man at the pulpit. Of course, Mel's dilemma isn't so black-and-white, especially because offing a 'monster' of Mark's caliber might be the shortest possible route to getting right with God. 'Inside' eventually builds to a clear moment of choice for the sake of its own climax, but the vast majority of this movie is spent complicating its characters' logic rather than framing their choices as some moral binary. Not only do Williams and Jarvis conspire to rescue a mottled innocence from the recesses of Mark's tortured mind (a process that hinges on a truly shocking reveal), but Pearce's layered and wrenchingly humane performance eventually reveals Warren to be the heart of the film. That isn't because Warren evolves from the diabolical manipulator that he seems to be at the start of this story, but rather because we bear witness to how the character reframes himself as his greatest mark. He might tell Mel that breaking their cycles of violence is as foolish as thinking a different song might come on when you replay a tape, but some of his actions suggest otherwise, and the surrogate father role Warren assumes while coaching Mel towards another murder starts to affect the older man after he suffers a disastrous visit with his actual son during a brief furlough ('Babyteeth' breakout Toby Wallace is outstanding in the crucial one-scene role). The Joker-like shot of Warren sticking his head out of a car window on the way back to jail, his beard blasting against his face in the wind, is an unforgettably poignant snapshot of a man who's free from everything but himself. 'Inside' is a small and constrained prison drama, even by the inflexible standards of its genre, and yet Williams' debut is so replete with such moments of raw compassion that it almost invisibly accumulates a deep well of emotion — one that allows the film to feel much bigger than it looks by the time it arrives at its absolute knockout of a final scene. There are a few small cheats along the way, but 'Inside' is averse to didacticism and neoliberal heart-softening when it counts, and the power it achieves in the end is inextricable from the honesty with which it's earned. 'Who Am I?' is a mystery that none of these characters may ever be able to solve for themselves, at least not with the certainty of a trivia game on the back of a candy wrapper, but to watch them look for the answers in each other is enough to convince us that the question is always worth asking. 'Inside' screened at the 2025 Tribeca Festival. Quiver Distribution will release it in theaters on Friday, June 20. Want to stay up to date on IndieWire's film and critical thoughts? to our newly launched newsletter, In Review by David Ehrlich, in which our Chief Film Critic and Head Reviews Editor rounds up the best new reviews and streaming picks along with some exclusive musings — all only available to subscribers. Best of IndieWire The 25 Best Alfred Hitchcock Movies, Ranked Every IndieWire TV Review from 2020, Ranked by Grade from Best to Worst

BTS reunion nearing, almost all members done with military service
BTS reunion nearing, almost all members done with military service

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

BTS reunion nearing, almost all members done with military service

(NewsNation) — BTS fans could soon see the band reunite as four of its members are released from their mandatory military service in South Korea. RM, 30, and V, 29, were discharged on Tuesday, and Jimin and Jungkook were released on Wednesday. Only one more member, Suga, is still in service. He is set to be discharged on June 21, and the BTS fan base, called ARMY, is excited for the upcoming reunion. Macklemore's home invaded with kids inside, nanny bear-sprayed: Report NewsNation's Paula Froelich exclusively reported in March that the band would be recording an album this summer once all members were released from their military service. The group, which has seven members, had to put their music career on hold in 2022 when Jin started his mandatory service in December. In South Korea, all able-bodied men between 18 and 28 years old are required to spend anywhere from 18 to 21 months in the military. Jungkook spoke with journalists and fans on Wednesday as he and Jimin were discharged. He said, 'Actually, it's been so long since I've been in front of cameras, and I didn't even put on makeup, so I'm a bit embarrassed… I don't know what to say.' RM and V saluted their fans on Tuesday, who were crowded near the band's agency's office as they returned in their army uniforms. PEOPLE reported that V said his time in the army gave him 'time for me to reset both physically and mentally.' V addressed the crowd, saying, 'To all the ARMYs who have waited for us in the military, I want to say I am truly, truly grateful. Please wait just a little longer, and we will return with a really cool performance.' RM played the sax for his fans at the military base before saying, '(Members) would feel the same, but stage performance, I want to perform the most. I'll work hard to make an album soon and come back to the stage.' What is 'Call Her Daddy' host Alex Cooper's net worth? He also said, 'Now, I'm ready to hit the ground running again as RM of BTS. Thank you to everyone who waited and looked after us.' Fans from around the world came to see the members released, with Philip Darbyshire, a 72-year-old Australian fan, saying, 'It is just absolutely joyful… It is just wonderful.' According to the Associated Press, members of the ARMY fanbase were aware there could be backlash, as the band's label had discouraged fans from showing up for safety reasons. However, some fans, like Anaesi, who is from Portugal, said the trip to Yeoncheon, South Korea, was worth it. Justin Baldoni continuing legal fight against Blake Lively after dismissal 'Portugal is a small country, but inside of Portugal, BTS is a king,' she explained. Anaesi had found BTS on YouTube and said that the group had saved her from depression. 'So for me, BTS is my angel,' she said. Jin and J-Hope were discharged from the military last year and have been performing solo while waiting for their fellow bandmates. 'After pursuing our own little ventures, we are now coming back together, and I love that for us,' J-Hope told a magazine outlet. 'The Pitt's' Noah Wyle to make push for health care workers at Capitol The entertainment group that manages BTS, HYBE, is planning an event called BTS FESTA so fans can celebrate the band's 12th anniversary. Jin attended the event last year, but it isn't known if members will be attending this year's fest. BTS became a band in 2013 and has been nominated for five Grammy Awards since then, according to PEOPLE. Six of their songs have been on the Billboard Hot 100 list. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store