Pakistan loses plot as Munir gifts Sharif photo of 2017 Chinese drill, passing it off as Op Bunyanum
The dinner hosted Saturday was to pay tribute to the country's 'political leadership and the unwavering commitment of the Armed Forces'. Among the key attendees were President Asif Ali Zardari, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar, Chairman Senate Yousaf Raza Gilani, Speaker of the National Assembly Ayaz Sadiq, federal ministers, provincial governors and chief ministers.
However, the picture is actually from a Chinese military exercise in 2017 and not the Pakistani Army in action. The gaffe by the Army chief was quickly identified on social media where it was being likened to the Pakistan's Army's false declaration of a win and large scale destruction in India.
New Delhi: Pakistan Army Chief Field Marshal Asim Munir hosted a 'victory' dinner for the country's political brass and gave a framed picture of what was supposed to be his military in action against India under Operation Bunyanum Marsoos to Prime Minister Shahbaz Sharif.
After images of the high-profile dinner were shared on social media with pictures of both Munir and Sharif holding the picture, some users were quick to point out the discrepancies and soon mocked the Pakistani Army for sharing a fake photo.
'Apparently the Pakistan Army Chief has gifted PM Shehbaz Sharif a dated Chinese military photo as a souvenir to illustrate Pak Army attack against India. So not just a fake victory narrative but also a fake photo with it. What a joke @OfficialDGISPR,' Pakistani journalist Taha Siddiqui wrote on 'X'.
Senior leadership from major political parties, top government officials, and high-ranking officers from the Pakistan Army, Air Force, and Navy also participated in the event along with Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee and service chiefs, the state-run PTV reported.
The discovery of the Chinese-origin image has now undermined the credibility of the narrative and made the entire event a subject of public mockery.
'This is more than a meme-worthy blunder—it's a systemic tell. When Pakistan's top general gifts the Prime Minister a recycled Chinese artillery image as 'proof of success,; it reveals how disconnected their narrative machine is from operational truth…Either way, it shows one thing clearly: Pakistan's strategic signaling is now indistinguishable from parody. And even China's recycled firepower can't mask that,' another 'X' user pointed out.
Later, Siddiqui narrated to ThePrint how he found out the 'Chinese arms photo'.
'I saw the original photo being shared by local media in Pakistan and then saw other accounts sharing that it may be Chinese weaponry. Following which I did some reverse Google imaging and voila: It was indeed a Chinese arms photo from some years ago,' he said.
Pakistan has crafted a fake narrative of victory at home, so it is not surprising that it is using a fake photo to go along with it, he added.
'There is another angle but maybe more speculative: Using Chinese imagery to please the Chinese regime which has its own conflict with India. China is one of the main suppliers of weapons to Pakistan and this maybe a way to say thank you,' the exiled Pakistan journalist said.
(Edited by Tony Rai)
Also Read: Pakistan DG-ISPR echoes Hafiz Saeed in rant against India—'if you stop our water, we stop your breath'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
5 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Remaining S-400 defence system coming on time, says Russian envoy as he cites India-Pakistan conflict
Russian deputy ambassador Roman Babushkin to New India on Monday said India will receive the remaining regiments of the S-400 strategic air defence missile system by 2026, as scheduled. The S-400 missile system performed well in India's Operation Sindoor against Pakistan, intercepting Pakistani drones and missiles. There have been talks of an additional batch of the missile system. 'We heard that S-400 performed very efficiently during the situation between India and Pakistan,' Roman Babushkin told news agency PTI. Acknowledging that India and Russia have a long history of collaboration, Roman Babushkin said the air defence systems, 'according to what we are experiencing, the situation in Europe, here, this is one of the promising topics of our partnership in defence preparation in general'. "As far as my knowledge goes, the contract for the remaining S-400 units will be according to the schedule. We are open for a promotion of this partnership for the discussion of the expansion of dialogue on air defence system... I think it will be done in 2025, 2026," he added. India inked a $5.43 billion contract with Russia in 2018 for five regiments. Of the five, three have been deployed along the western and northern fronts, bordering Pakistan and China, respectively. India had received the first regiment in December 2021, while the second and third were delivered in April 2022 and October 2023, respectively. Re-christened as 'Sudarshan Chakra', the S-400 can detect, destroy hostile strategic bombers, jets, spy planes, missiles and drones at a range of 380 kilometres. Going by information shared by the Indian government, the acquisition was to be completed by 2023, The New Indian Express reported, citing unnamed sources. The S-400 system's delivery schedule got delayed due to the Russia-Ukraine conflict which affected supply chains and production, the report added. 'The S-400 Missile is a potent system in terms of its operational capability to provide a continuous and effective air defence system to a very large area. With the induction of this system, air defence capability of the nation will be significantly enhanced,' the ministry of defence had said in a statement in 2021. The S-400 system is capable of engaging multiple targets simultaneously, including aircraft, cruise missiles, and ballistic missiles, at varying ranges and altitudes. It consists of three main components: missile launchers, a powerful radar, and a command centre. It is capable of targeting aircraft, cruise missiles, and even high-speed intermediate-range ballistic missiles. The S-400 is seen as a major threat by NATO members due to its impressive long-range capabilities. It can engage almost all types of modern combat aircraft.
Time of India
12 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Even China, Turkey Unwilling To Pay Us': Pak PM Sharif's Candid 'Begging Bowl' Admission
'Even China, Turkey Unwilling To Pay Us': Pak PM Sharif's Candid 'Begging Bowl' Admission Source: Pakistan Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has issued a blunt call for national self-reliance, declaring that the era of approaching allies with a "begging bowl" must end. Speaking to military officers in Quetta, Sharif acknowledged that nations like China, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey now expect partnerships built on trade and innovation, not aid. Stressing economic reform and resource development, he vowed—alongside Field Marshal Asim Munir—to stop carrying the weight of past dependencies. Despite decades of financial struggle, Sharif expressed hope in Pakistan's strategic ties and future potential.#pakistan #shehbazsharif #china #imf #pakistanarmy
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
22 minutes ago
- Business Standard
China accuses US of violating trade truce over chip curbs, vows retaliation
China has accused the United States of breaching the terms of a recent trade agreement, escalating tensions between the world's two largest economies just weeks after a temporary truce brought hope for renewed dialogue. The Chinese Ministry of Commerce on Monday issued a statement rejecting US President Donald Trump's claims that Beijing had violated the trade consensus reached in Geneva last month. The ministry denounced a series of fresh US trade measures as "discriminatory", warning that China would take "resolute and forceful measures" to protect its interests if the US continued on its current path. Beijing cited Washington's unilateral actions, including new export restrictions on advanced AI chip technologies and chip design software, as well as the revocation of Chinese student visas, as evidence of the US breaching the agreement. The ministry also referenced an earlier understanding between Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping on January 17, suggesting the latest US moves violated that accord as well. 'If the US insists on its own way and continues to damage China's interests, China will continue to take resolute and forceful measures to safeguard its legitimate rights and interests,' the ministry said. Trump accuses China of trade violations, threatens fresh tariffs On Friday, Trump claimed via a post on his Truth Social platform that China had 'TOTALLY VIOLATED ITS AGREEMENT WITH US", accusing Beijing of backsliding on its trade promises without specifying details. Trump declared the US would double tariffs on both steel and aluminium imports from China, to 50 per cent from 25 per cent, beginning next week. Although China is the world's largest steel exporter, it has sent minimal volumes to the US since Trump imposed 25 per cent tariffs in 2018. However, China is currently the third-largest supplier of aluminium to the US. Trump also alleged that the temporary May deal to ease triple-digit tariffs for 90 days had been made to save China from what he called 'a devastating situation' of factory shutdowns and civil unrest. The brief tariff rollback, hailed by markets at the time, had reduced the effective US tariff rate to the mid-teens, down from around 25 per cent earlier this year. Did China violate US trade agreement? While Trump did not specify how China had allegedly violated the trade agreement made in Geneva, US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer accused China of failing to accelerate exports of critical minerals essential for advanced electronics. Greer told CNBC that China was 'slow-rolling their compliance', calling Beijing's approach 'completely unacceptable'. He added that the US would need to address the issue, though he did not elaborate on what actions may be taken. The Geneva agreement in mid-May included a 90-day pause on sweeping tariffs. Are US-China trade talks in limbo again? Earlier last week, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent acknowledged that talks with China were 'a bit stalled' and indicated that direct intervention from both Trump and Xi might be necessary to break the deadlock. 'Getting a deal over the finish line will likely need the direct involvement of Trump and Xi,' he said in an interview with Fox News. White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett had also earlier said a phone call between the leaders was likely this week, but no confirmation has come from Beijing. Despite the rising political rhetoric, US stock markets ended last week relatively flat. Trump's renewed complaints came just two days after he was reportedly angered by a journalist's reference to Wall Street's new acronym 'TACO', short for 'Trump Always Chickens Out', used to describe expectations that he will ultimately soften on aggressive trade actions.
