Garda body accuses Drew Harris of leaving 'legacy of fear and distrust' at annual conference
DREW HARRIS HAS been accused of leaving a 'legacy of fear and distrust' among gardaí after his almost seven-year stint in the Garda Commissioner job, according to an officers' body.
The Garda Representatives Association (GRA) further accused of Commissioner Drew Harris of dismantling community policing thanks to reforms pushed through during his term overseeing the force.
The GRA kicked off its annual conference this week in Killarney, Co Kerry. At the outset it has outlined a belief that the role of a frontline garda has been diminished and degraded, with this year's conference carrying the theme 'It Was a Job Worth Doing'.
At the core of its criticism was the Operating Policing Model which was introduced in 2019. This has seen a restructuring at regional and divisional levels, with the ambition having been to improve community policing according to the needs of each local community.
But GRA General Secretary Ronan Slevin said that Harris has implemented a model of policing that 'isn't working', claiming that it has 'single handedly removed community policing' from Ireland.
The GRA, which represents over 11,000 officers, said that this was because Harris had has tried to implement a 'failed' UK model.
'If you were to analyze the commissioner's term, I suppose you'd have to say that he's implemented an operation policing model that isn't working. He has removed community policing from Ireland, which was the envy of Europe. The system we had, that's completely gone,' Slevin told reporters.
'He's had the biggest budget available to him over his career, over his term of office, yet we still have serious issues in relation to recruitment and retention within the force.
'I believe that the numbers we currently have are the same that were in the force when the Commissioner took up his role, even though the population has increased exponentially.'
Ronan Slevin at today's GRA conference
CONOR Ó MEARÁIN
CONOR Ó MEARÁIN
There is also much anger towards Harris because of a 'severe' discipline and suspension policy, Slevin said, further claiming this has hampered members when using force while policing.
He added that the number of gardaí currently serving is roughly the same as when Harris took up his role, despite promises to increase the number of officers.
Advertisement
Deputy GRA General Secretary James Morrisroe said that community policing is about 'frontline police knowing their communities while being visible and engaged in those communities', which he said allows these gardaí to develop respectful partnerships to solve problems and achieve community safety.
'That is not happening,' Morrisroe said, 'It's plain to see. And I think members of the public tell us on a daily basis, it's not happening.'
Quoting the
Commission on the Future of Policing
, the 2021 report outlining recommendations for the organisation, Morrisroe said that it noted that 'the culture should be one of a team of professionals working together, not a hierarchy where foot soldiers await instructions from above'.
Morrisroe added that the report said that communication should be 'personal interaction' and not written documents.
'We see that every single day in an Garda Síochána, where documents are posted on our portal and we're supposed to read them and train up on them. And that is not what the Commission of the Future of Policing recommended,' Morrisroe said.
'Employees should have the tools, training, uniform, vehicles and equipment needed to do their jobs. Well, we don't, so that's a failure.'
This was the latest edition of the conference where the Garda Commissioner was not invited.
Two years ago, the membership of the association voted overwhelmingly that they had no confidence in Harris and therefore did not invite him to attend.
This has seen the new Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan also not attend the annual gathering.
Contacted for comment, a Garda spokesperson said on behalf of the commissioner that he was happy to work with the GRA and gardaí on the issues raised.
'As he has done in the past, Commissioner Harris would have been more than happy to attend the GRA conference and engage with GRA delegates on important matters for all Gardaí at the GRA conference, as well as recognise the great work done by Gardaí every day in keeping people safe,' the spokesperson said.
'However, the GRA Central Executive Committee has not invited the Garda Commissioner to address and discuss such matters directly with Gardaí at the GRA's Conference.
'An Garda Síochána continues to meet with all Garda Associations, collectively, and separately on a wide range of issues.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
39 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Kinahans at large ‘should be worried' of ‘perilous position' amid ‘huge global effort' to nail boss Daniel & associates
THE Garda Commissioner says the remaining Kinahan cartel members at large "should be worried" and insisted: "We are fixed on bringing them all to justice." Drew Harris told how the global organised crime group are in a "perilous position" as international law enforcement are cooperating with the force to 5 Daniel Kinahan remains living openly in the Middle East 5 Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said the crime group are in a 'perilous position' Credit: Garrett White/PA Wire 5 Harris said the force's work with authorities in Dubai continues Credit: Getty Images But he also reminded lower ranking members of the gang that Harris was speaking a week and a half on from Kinahan's right-hand man Sean McGovern, 39, becoming the first ever Irishman to be extradited out of the McGovern, who had left for But gang leader READ MORE IN NEWS Commissioner Harris insisted the force's work with authorities in Dubai continues. Harris said: "They should be worried, but they should have been worried now for a number of years, because this huge investigative effort, an international effort, has gone into the investigation of the overall "A lot of things which were said couldn't be done, have been done. "So following on from the sanctions, the work that we've undertaken with the UAE, and the work that specifically we've undertaken then with the police in Dubai, has been very fruitful. Most read in The Irish Sun "They have been very active partners with us in terms of investigation, providing us information, and obviously then UAE authorities have worked to support the extradition, and we see an individual then extradited back to Ireland to face justice here, and that's the correct thing to do." US authorities issued a $15million bounty on the heads of Daniel, his father Christy, 68, and brother Christopher Jnr, 44, to provide crucial information to bring them down three years ago. Harris added: "The sanctions and the rewards still stand. There's $15 million there of reward money through the federal law enforcement authorities of the US. So that is still in play as well. "I just want to remind others in the Kinahan organised crime gang of the perilous position that they're now in, that ourselves and other law enforcement are fixed on them, and we are fixed on bringing them all to justice. "So all of them should be worried, and they should be thinking about the choices, serious life choices that are now ahead of them, in respect of what to do over the coming months. "Our work with the Dubai police obviously carries on." WARNING TO OTHER GANGS Deputy Commissioner Justin Kelly told how the events of the past week and a half highlighted how gardai are relentless in their pursuit of some of these transnational OCGs. Kelly said: "I think it's really important as well that everybody knows that there's other transnational organised crime groups outside the Kinahan OCG. "It's exactly the same for those, it doesn't matter where in the world they are, if there are charges here we will seek to have them extradited back to Ireland. "So extradition agreements, all the work by the Department of Justice, Department of Foreign Affairs are really important to our organisation." Kelly also explained that the work in relation to the Kinahan cartel and the Hutch OCG should serve as a warning to others involved in organised crime. He added: "We have absolutely dismantled two of the organised crime groups here in Dublin. "At one stage we had 47 members of one group in jail. "So if you make those life choices and you want to become involved in this, what is the reality facing you is the full force of the state against you, and investigations by specialist investigators, prosecutions, many of these cases are in the Special Criminal Court." BEHIND BARS He continued: "There've been numerous lengthy sentences handed out for possession of drugs, firearms. "Now we have substantial legislation around organised crime, directing and facilitating organised crime. "So there's a huge range of powers we have, and even beyond that, we can see people who are convicted, their houses are now being subject to Criminal Assets Bureau orders. "So before people get involved, this is the type of thing they need to look at." 5 Sean McGovern was extradited back to Ireland last month Credit: Crispin Rodwell - The Sun Dublin 5 Harris said the sanctions and the rewards still stand Credit: James Treacy
Irish Independent
43 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Drew Harris says two new water cannons to be used in ‘extreme scenarios'
Gardaí are also planning to increase the capacity at Templemore so that 1,000 recruits can be attested every year. Commissioner Drew Harris was speaking today at the launch of a report into how An Garda Síochána has transformed in the seven years under his leadership. The report states that the number of garda staff has increased by 51pc while 700 body worn cameras are now used by gardaí on a pilot basis. It says an 'information led' approach has also resulted in almost 15,000 mobility devices being issued to gardaí, The organisations vehicle fleet is at its highest ever level after spending €75m in the last five years with more than 3,600 cars, armed support vehicles and public order vans, as well as two water cannons now available. The water cannon trucks have not yet been deployed but were on standby during a recent large demonstration in Dublin city centre. Each vehicle has two mounted water cannons and are operated by trained gardaí from the public order unit, while they also have a self-extinguishing water system if they are petrol bombed. Mr Harris said that they will be deployed in 'extreme scenarios' and, referring to the Dublin Riots and Coolock Riots, noted 'very violent incidents' that had occurred in recent years. He also said that Ireland holds the EU Presidency in 2026 and that they have to be prepared for 'any public order threats that might arise' during that. 'In a very violent situation, we need to make sure that we're not suffering members being injured, as opposed to having the vehicles and the equipment, including water cannons, which can probably deal with very violent disorder. So that's what they're there for,' he said. ADVERTISEMENT 'They're there for pretty extreme scenarios, but they're there to protect the public. They're there to protect members of An Garda Síochána who are engaged in public order policing. So, it is essential that we have them ourselves.' He also said it was important that the vehicles are adaptive for the streets around Dublin and elsewhere in Ireland where they might be used. The 'Transforming An Garda Síochána 2018-2024' report was compiled to provide an organisational account of the implementation of the 'A Policing Service for Our Future' programme. It notes that Garda staff have increased by 51pc since 2018, but that the number of attested gardaí between 2019 and 2024 has reduced from 14,307 to 14,125. The Garda Commissioner has said that they plan to increase the capacity of the Garda Training College in Templemore to ensure that 1,000 gardaí can graduate every year. 'How we're going to achieve that is really then back to our actual recruitment process. We've revamped all of our processes, to try and speed them up and try and bring people through the process quicker and actually make it more related to the vocation that it is.' So far 700 gardaí have piloted new body worn cameras which frontline personnel have described as the 'most important and invaluable' adaption to their personnel protective equipment in recent years. Gardaí have received a report on the pilot phase and will begin the process of rolling out the body worn cameras across the organisation by the end of this year. Mr Harris said that anecdotally there has been evidence of them reducing threats to frontline members while also acting as an investigative tool. 'I think it makes a difference in terms of just taking the temperature out of a situation when people are told that a camera is on, and those who have any sense at all realise their actions are being recorded, but some don't,' she said. 'And then this is very useful evidence, very appropriate evidence then, to bring before the courts. It gives the unvarnished, unalloyed description and representation of their behaviour at the scene. 'So that does make a difference. And we believe that it's really significant for us in terms of just speeding up criminal justice cases, but also helping on the ground and on the street-based situations.' A significant change has been the rollout of the operating model which has moved from localised focus at district level to larger autonomous divisions. Mr Harris rejected collective criticism of the model from policing representative bodies, and said they don't speak about the successes delivered under it. He said this included each division having a Detective Superintendent to oversee serious criminal investigations and Divisional Protective Services Unit to investigate sexual offences and domestic violence, as well as increasing the number of garda staff to free up attested garda members.
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Man, 50s, arrested on suspicion of human trafficking
A man has been arrested in Co Monaghan on suspicion of human trafficking. As part of an ongoing probe into trafficking for the purpose of sexual exploitation and forced criminality, gardaí undertook an operation on Monday morning. Officers attached to the human trafficking investigation and co-ordination unit arrested a man in his 50s. He is currently detained under Section 50 of the Criminal Justice Act, 1984. Gardaí have made an appeal to anyone who may be the victim of human trafficking for sexual exploitation to come forward and speak with them at any Garda station in person or by phone, or by calling the freephone Garda Confidential Line: 1800 666 111. Anyone who has information related to human trafficking for sexual or labour exploitation is encouraged to contact gardaí. Read More Former Cork prison could become new 300-bed facility under plan to tackle overcrowding
