Borden-Carleton mayor concerned over MLA's public meeting about proposed gas station
Social Sharing
The mayor of Borden-Carleton is raising concerns about a public meeting to be held Monday by the area's MLA, Matt MacFarlane, about the planning of a fourth gas station in the town.
The proposed project, to be built by D.P. Murphy at the corner of the Trans-Canada Highway and the Dickie Road, would include a gas station, coffee shop and convenience store.
It's sparked discussion in the community in the past, with some residents and business owners saying the town of about 800 people is already "well served" by three other gas stations.
The proposal is under review by the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission, which is responsible for approving retail gas outlets on the Island.
In a letter to Housing, Land and Communities Minister Steven Myers, Borden-Carleton Mayor Randy Ahearn said MacFarlane's meeting could cause issues.
MLA's meeting 'undermines integrity of municipal planning process,' Borden-Carleton mayor warns
3 hours ago
Duration 2:14
Borden-Carleton officials are expressing concern about a public meeting being planned on a proposed gas station development. The district's Green MLA has organized it. The P.E.I. town's mayor says the meeting risks causing confusion about the planning process. Now the provincial minister involved, Steven Myers (shown), is weighing in. CBC's Wayne Thibodeau has the story.
"The MLA's decision to host a separate meeting — without any consultation with town council — undermines the integrity of the municipal planning process," he wrote.
"This is not an official part of the planning framework and risks creating confusion among residents, while signaling to potential investors that due process can be sidestepped for political purposes."
Ahearn said planning and developing are "core municipal responsibilities," adding: "When an MLA initiates parallel processes, it not only disrupts community trust — it may deter future developers who question whether their projects will be reviewed fairly and predictably under the planning act."
'These are my constituents too'
Myers said he doesn't think the project needs additional oversight in the form of MacFarlane's meeting.
"After I got the letter, I sought out legal advice to see what path we could chart to make sure the town not only felt that they were supported, but... have the room to operate without having to stickhandle a backbench MLA," Myers told CBC News on Tuesday.
"This is all well inside the governance framework that is set up by the provincial government so, you know, we don't feel like it needs extra oversight at this point, but for some reason Matt MacFarlane does."
IRAC's public hearing is scheduled for May 13.
In the meantime, MacFarlane said he doesn't see what's wrong with setting up a meeting with his constituents on a topic of public interest.
"This is an opportunity for people to speak on both sides of the issue if they want, and my intention is to make note of what I'm hearing, what people say and I'll send those comments along to IRAC as part of their deliberation process," he said.
This repeated pattern is deeply troubling. — Randy Ahearn, Borden-Carleton mayor
"I recognize they're a part of the town, but these are my constituents too, and they reach out to me and they... want to know what they can do to have their voices heard."
Ahearn said this isn't the first time MacFarlane has hosted a public meeting about an upcoming project in the town.
"A similar situation occurred during discussions around the Fabrication Yard Project. This repeated pattern is deeply troubling," he wrote in his letter to Myers.
For his part, MacFarlane said he wants to meet with town officials before the public meeting.
"I continue to communicate regularly with the town and their new CAO," he said. "If we can get a chance to get together before the public meeting, great. I'm hoping we can."
Statement sent from town
CBC News asked for an interview with Ahearn about his letter.
He was not available Wednesday, but the town sent a statement.
"The matter in question is currently before the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC), and it is essential that the established regulatory and planning process is respected and followed. It would be inappropriate for members of council to comment on an application that is currently being processed by IRAC," the statement reads.
"In the interest of due process of integrity, we trust that all parties — including the MLA in question — will allow the IRAC process and the town's planning framework to proceed without undue influence or parallel initiatives."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
13 hours ago
- CBC
Matt MacFarlane chosen as leader of P.E.I. Green Party
Matt MacFarlane has been elected leader of the P.E.I. Green Party. The Borden-Kinkora MLA got 507 of the 647 votes cast. He was running against former Green Party MLA Hannah Bell. The leadership convention took place at Bluefield High School in North Wiltshire Saturday. It was originally scheduled for a smaller venue, but was relocated after the party's membership quadrupled to 800 in the lead-up to the vote. The Greens have been without a leader since Peter Bevan-Baker left the position after the 2023 provincial general election. That vote saw the party tumble from Official Opposition status. Their eight seats were cut to two — Bevan-Baker and Karla Bernard, who stepped up as interim leader. The Greens added a third seat in the legislature after MacFarlane won a February 2024 byelection in Borden-Kinkora. That was triggered by the resignation of former Progressive Conservative MLA Jamie Fox, who stepped down to run for the federal Conservatives. Byelections are set to be called before the end of the summer in Charlottetown-Hillsborough Park and Brackley-Hunter River. Those seats were left vacant when former PC cabinet minister Natalie Jameson stepped down to run in the federal election for the Conservatives, and Dennis King stepped down as premier and MLA. The Greens and the P.E.I. Liberal Party each have three seats in the legislature, so the upcoming byelections could decide which party becomes the Official Opposition.
CTV News
2 days ago
- CTV News
Toronto receives $67M from province for meeting housing targets
Video Premier Doug Ford presented Mayor Olivia Chow with a $67M cheque as part of Ontario's Building Faster Fund, rewarding Toronto for surpassing 80 per cent of its housing goal.
CBC
2 days ago
- CBC
Toronto gets $67.2M housing cheque as Ontario housing numbers falter
The Ontario government has awarded Toronto $67.2 million in funding after the city came close to hitting its housing starts target last year — but provincial officials say they'll be handing out fewer such cheques in 2025 as not as many cities are hitting their goals. "You have certain mayors in certain towns and cities that absolutely refuse to build. They aren't building a doghouse," Premier Doug Ford said at a news conference at Toronto City Hall Friday, flanked by Mayor Olivia Chow. "They aren't building a garage, and we all know it. "And then you have great cities, and great mayors like Mayor Chow here that's saying, 'We're going to build, we're going to build as quickly as possible because we need the housing.'" This is the second round of funding from the province's Building Faster Fund, which provides funding to municipalities that hit at least 80 per cent of their provincially designated housing targets. Announced in 2023, it promised to provide $1.2 billion over a three-year period to municipalities that achieve annual targets for new home construction starts. Toronto broke ground on 20,999 new homes last year, the province said in a news release, which works out to be 88 per cent of its 2024 housing target. Municipalities missing housing targets Though Toronto appears to be on the right track, it's now increasingly unlikely that Ford's government will achieve its stated target of 1.5 million new homes by 2031. The latest Ontario budget forecasts 71,800 housing starts in 2025, followed by 74,800 next year and 82,500 in 2027. WATCH | Fewer homes expected to be built in Ontario this year: Ontario budget forecasts fewer housing starts in 2025 22 days ago Duration 3:57 There have been 260,000 actual housing starts in the three years since the target was set. So if you add in the projections for 2025 and 2026, the province would only be about one-quarter of the way toward its goal at the end of next year, which is the halfway point of the target timeline. The province distributed only $280 million from the fund in its first year after more than half of Ontario's municipalities failed to hit the housing start targets in 2023. The government hasn't updated its housing start tracker since October 2024. As of that point, nine months through the year, only 11 of 50 municipalities had reached their annual benchmark. Country facing housing 'crisis,' housing minister says When asked by CBC News at Friday's news conference why the provincial government is no longer showing the numbers for what each municipality is building, Housing Minister Rob Flack said that he would "have to get back to you." "Housing starts are down. We know that," Flack said. "There's a crisis, a major crisis in this country. We're going to hand out some nice Building Faster Fund cheques — not as many and not for as much this year as we did last year." Flack went on to say that's why the government introduced Bill 17, which is intended to accelerate permit issuance and streamline zoning rules. It also defers the collection of development charges until occupancy, which the province says will provide greater cash flow flexibility. "We know the numbers are down, but if we don't make the changes like we did in Bill 17, we're never going to hit our targets," Flack said. Speaking at the news conference, Chow said that the provincial funding will help build homes in the city faster. "At the end of the day we have a housing crisis, we need to build, whether through deferring development charges, exempting development charges, building the missing middle," she said. "We need to build, build, build a lot of housing, especially affordable housing."
