Boston Consulting Group quits Gaza humanitarian aid effort amid criticism
'They are actually making the wheels turn,' said one of the people of BCG's involvement.
Advertisement
A spokesperson for BCG stated that the firm had provided 'pro bono' support to the humanitarian operation and will not get paid for any of the work it has done on behalf of the foundation. Another person familiar with its operations contradicted the firm's account, saying that BCG had presented monthly invoices of more than $1 million.
Advertisement
The foundation said in an email early Tuesday that it had distributed more than 7 million meals during its first eight days of operations. 'It proves our model is functional and is an effective means to deliver lifesaving assistance to the Gazan people under emergency conditions,' wrote John Acree, named last week as the GHF's interim director.
Later Tuesday, the foundation announced a new executive director, Johnnie Moore, a Christian evangelical leader and public relations executive who is close to the Trump administration and was twice appointed during President Donald Trump's first term as a member of the US Commission on International Religious Freedom.
Since the war in Gaza began following the Hamas-led attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023 - which killed about 1,200 people and saw around 250 taken hostage - deliveries of
lifesaving humanitarian assistance
have been sporadic and woefully inadequate for the enclave's more than 2 million inhabitants. Israel, which has tightly controlled humanitarian access through its border crossings, has charged - without evidence - that much of the distribution by the U.N. and other aid organizations in the past has been seized by Hamas.
The architects of the GHF plan, including the Israeli government, private entrepreneurs,
consultants and some humanitarian actors, have said that the new aid mechanism was designed to protect against looting and seizures by the militant group. Armed US contractors have been hired to secure the aid convoys and oversee the distribution hubs.
The start of distribution followed an 11-week blockade, during which Israel prohibited any aid from entering Gaza. The government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has announced plans to relocate virtually all of Gaza's population to the southern part of the 141-square-mile enclave as it launches a new offensive in the north to eliminate Hamas's remaining fighters. So far, more than 54,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli attacks in the 19-month war, according to the Gaza Health Ministry, which does not distinguish between civilian and combatants.
Advertisement
Three out of four distribution hubs are now operating in the south, usually only for several hours in the morning until the day's packaged food deliveries have been exhausted.
No violent incidents have been reported inside the distribution hubs themselves, although Gazan health workers have reported dozens of people shot nearby.
On Tuesday, a spokesperson for the Israel Defense Forces said that they were investigating an incident resulting in casualties, in which Israeli troops fired on 'several suspects … deviating from the designated access routes' to the distribution sites.
Gaza's Health Ministry and the International Committee of the Red Cross said that 27 people were killed and dozens more injured near an aid distribution site in southern Gaza.
Previously, IDF spokesmen have said soldiers fired above the heads of crowds to disperse them but denied shooting directly at civilians, and they charged that reports of dead and wounded were Hamas disinformation. The IDF has distributed its own videos that it says show Hamas militants shooting at civilians.
In a statement Tuesday, the GHF said that 'while the aid distribution was conducted safely and without incident at our site today,' it was aware of the IDF investigation. The incident, the statement said, occurred in 'an area well beyond our secure distribution site and operations area. We recognize the difficult nature of the situation and advise all civilians to remain in the safe corridor when traveling to our … sites.'
Advertisement
The U.N. and other aid professionals, as well as some foreign aid donors, have long expressed concerns about the viability, morality and safety of the GHF's model, which confines food distribution to limited sites in the south
and leaves Israel in control of how much aid enters the enclave.
Nearly all major humanitarian organizations have refused to participate on the grounds that it violates their rules of neutrality and appears designed to further Israel's war aims. Even some senior Israeli defense officials have questioned the GHF model, anticipating that long lines could lead to stampedes, according to internal documents obtained by The Washington Post.
Calling the overall situation a 'tragedy,' the World Food Program's executive director, Cindy McCain, told ABC News on Sunday: 'What we need right now is an immediate ceasefire, complete, unfettered access, along with the safe … roads, every gate open, to feed people and stop this catastrophe from happening.'
Although Israel has allowed a limited number of U.N. aid convoys to enter Israel in the past week, the World Food Program has reported that desperate Gazans have stopped and looted them before they could reach WFP distribution points.
'Whether we like it or not, Israel is calling the shots in Gaza right now. We can either posture and be outraged, or accept it: Aid will never be provided in a neutral manner because of the heavy hand of the Israelis,' said one aid professional who was approached to assume a leading role in the GHF but ultimately declined to join the foundation.
Advertisement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
11 minutes ago
- CBS News
Trump's travel ban is set to begin Monday. Here's what to know.
What to know about President Trump's travel ban on nationals from 12 countries What to know about Trump's new travel ban What to know about Trump's new travel ban Washington — President Trump signed a proclamation late Wednesday barring travelers and immigrants from a dozen countries and restricting the entry of nationals from seven other nations. With the move, the White House cited concerns about national security. The president said the recent attack at a march supporting Israeli hostages in Boulder, Colorado, had "underscored the extreme dangers posed to our country by the entry of foreign nationals who are not properly vetted, as well as those who come here as temporary visitors and overstay their visas." "We don't want them," Mr. Trump said. Here's what to know about the travel bans: Who does the ban apply to? With some exceptions, the proclamation bans the entry of foreigners from 12 countries who are seeking to come to the U.S. permanently as legal immigrants, as well as those with temporary visas, including tourists: Afghanistan Myanmar Chad The Republic of the Congo Equatorial Guinea Eritrea Haiti Iran Libya Somalia Sudan Yemen President Trump announced that the U.S. would bar entry to nationals from these 12 countries, with few exceptions, citing national security concerns. CBS News The proclamation also partially suspends the entry of travelers and immigrants from another seven countries. This restriction applies to legal immigrants seeking to move to the U.S. and certain temporary visa holders who hail from the following countries: Burundi Cuba Laos Sierra Leone Togo Turkmenistan Venezuela When does the ban take effect? The ban is set to take effect at 12:01 a.m. on Monday, June 9. Why were the countries selected? On the first day of his second administration, Mr. Trump directed officials to perform a security review of high-risk regions and make recommendations for where immigration and travel restrictions should be imposed. The president said the factors considered were "the largescale presence of terrorists, failure to cooperate on visa security, inability to verify travelers' identities, inadequate record keeping of criminal histories and persistently high rates of illegal visa overstays, and other things." "Very simply, we cannot have open migration from any country where we cannot safely and reliably vet and screen those who seek to enter the United States," Mr. Trump said. The president cited the recent attack in Boulder, where an Egyptian national was charged, as part of the justification for the bans. Egypt is not among the countries on the White House's list. But the proclamation directed officials to assess the "adequacy" of Egypt's vetting policies "in light of recent events." Are there exceptions to the new travel ban? The president's decree contains certain exemptions, including for U.S. permanent residents and the spouses and children of U.S. citizens who have "clear and convincing evidence of identity and family relationship." The proclamation also outlines exemptions for Afghans who assisted American forces and have special visas; diplomats, athletes coming to the U.S. for the World Cup, the Olympics and other major sporting events; dual nationals with a passport from a country not listed in the president's decree; and for adoptions. Mr. Trump said the list could be revised if countries make "material improvements," and new countries could be added "as threats emerge around the world." Did Trump do this before? The president's actions follow a series of travel bans issued during his first administration that initially targeted predominantly Muslim countries. Like those orders, his latest proclamation could be subject to lawsuits, although the Supreme Court ultimately upheld the revised ban from his first term, which the White House noted in a fact sheet outlining his second-term bans. The president touted his first-term travel bans in his video statement released Wednesday. "In my first term, my powerful travel restrictions were one of our most successful policies, and they were a key part of preventing major foreign terror attacks on American soil," Mr. Trump said. In January 2017, Mr. Trump signed a travel ban restricting the entry of most citizens of Iran, Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen. The ban sparked widespread outcry, creating chaos at airports and prompting legal challenges, as opponents argued the ban was discriminatory. Then in March 2017, Mr. Trump removed Iraq from the list and added Chad, Venezuela and North Korea. The president expanded the ban in 2020, adding immigration restrictions for nationals of Nigeria, Eritrea, Sudan, Tanzania, Myanmar and Kyrgyzstan. Chad was later removed from the list. The third iteration of the president's first-term ban was upheld by the Supreme Court in the summer of 2018. At the time, conservative justices cited the president's broad authority to restrict the entry of foreigners on national security grounds. When President Joe Biden took office, he scrapped that ban.
Forbes
41 minutes ago
- Forbes
Supreme Court Expands Tax Exemptions For Religious Charities
The Supreme Court expanded when religious organizations can qualify for tax exemptions as it ruled Thursday in favor of a charity in Wisconsin—potentially setting off a slew of organizations seeking new exemptions, which critics warn could harm federal and state tax revenues. Dan Bezley, 63, of Northville, MI, carries a cedar cross in front of the US Supreme Court in ... More Washington D.C. on Jan. Catholic Charities, a social charity that's part of Roman Catholic dioceses in Wisconsin, asked the state to be exempted from the its unemployment tax under the carveout for religious groups, but the state denied the request because the group's actual activities—providing services to people of all faiths who have disabilities—are not religious. The Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled in the state's favor against the organization being granted the exemption, but Catholic Charities argued to the Supreme Court that being denied the exemption violated the First Amendment's prohibition on the government interfering with the free exercise of religion, claiming Wisconsin is trying to 'pick and choose among religious groups.' Justices ruled unanimously in favor of Catholic Charities, finding the Wisconsin Supreme Court's decision violated the First Amendment. This story is breaking and will be updated. While it wasn't a party in the case, the Trump administration filed a brief urging the court to rule in favor of Catholic Charities being granted the tax exemption. The federal government claimed the Wisconsin Supreme Court's ruling was based on a 'misunderstanding' of the law, and the exemption applies for any organization that conducts its activities 'primarily for sincere religious motivations,' even if the activities it conducts aren't directly religious acts like proselytizing. The Trump administration also suggested it has an interest in the case because any ruling could also affect federal rules on tax exemptions for religious groups, noting the language of Wisconsin's law 'mirrors' the Federal Unemployment Tax Act. The Supreme Court's ruling is the latest in a string of decisions the high court has made regarding religious liberty, which have typically come out in favor of broadening parties' religious rights. The 6-3 conservative court has ruled in recent terms to rule in favor of letting religious adoption agencies refuse to work with same-sex couples, a high school football coach who prayed on the field, a Christian group who wanted to fly a flag at Boston City Hall, a web designer who wanted to deny services to same-sex couples and that a state-funded school voucher program in Maine can be used to pay for religious school tuition, among other cases. Justices did issue a notable ruling in May against a proposed religious charter school in Oklahoma, splitting 4-4, which meant the lower court's ruling against the school will stay in place. The court could still take up other cases in the future on religious charter schools, however.
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Chinese researchers charged with smuggling
Chinese researchers charged with smuggling Two Chinese researchers have been charged with smuggling a "potential agroterrorism weapon" into the US in a wad of tissues, according to an FBI affidavit. CNN's Max Foster explains how laboratory testing discovered a sample containing a DNA sequence with the potential to cause a fungal disease that could decimate crops, and impact human health. 01:10 - Source: CNN Record rain floods Mexico City, traps people Mexico City was hit with record rainfall that didn't relent for more than five hours Monday night, marking the heaviest rain since 2017, according to water management officials. CNN's Valeria León walks a flooded avenue of the nation's capital after emergency crews worked through the night to rescue several trapped drivers. 00:43 - Source: CNN Gaza aid distribution turns deadly for third consecutive day For a third consecutive day, Palestinians came under fire while trying to receive aid from a distribution site in Gaza. According to the Palestinian Ministry of Health and Nasser hospital, at least 27 people were killed and dozens injured on June 3. 00:56 - Source: CNN Analysis: Why Ukraine's drone attack on Russia just changed the world CNN's Jim Sciutto explains why Ukraine's large-scale drone attack on Russian air bases thousands of miles behind the front lines struck fear into the heart of every global superpower 01:05 - Source: CNN Tomatoes fly at Colombia's largest food fight Around 20,000 revellers gathered in Sutamarchán, Colombia, to throw over 45 tonnes of tomatoes at each other. The Gran Tomatina festival, now in its 15th year, is hosted to celebrate the economy of Sutamarchán, which is centred around tomato production. Mayor Miguel Andrés Rodríguez said "between 70 and 80 percent of families [in Sutamarchán] live off tomatoes. This is a tribute to them." The festival uses tomatoes which are overripe, or otherwise not suitable for consumption. 00:30 - Source: CNN Palestinians shot dead near Gaza aid hub The Palestinian health ministry, hospital officials and multiple eyewitnesses say deadly gunfire killed dozens of Palestinians near an aid distribution site in Gaza on Sunday, with Israel's military denying that its troops fired 'within or near' the aid site. CNN Jerusalem correspondent Jeremy Diamond brings you up to speed on what we know about the weekend chaos. 02:31 - Source: CNN Palestinians describe deadly shooting near aid center in Gaza CNN spoke to multiple witnesses who recounted the deadly chaos that unfolded near a US-backed aid center in southern Gaza after more than 30 Palestinians were killed and dozens injured on Sunday, according to the Palestinian Ministry of Health. The health ministry blamed the Israeli military for the deaths while other witnesses claimed that local security personnel had also opened fire. Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which runs the aid center, said there had been no gunfire at the site and Israel Defense Forces denied firing on civilians at or close to the site, calling such accusations 'false reports.' 00:55 - Source: CNN Palestinian UN envoy breaks down talking about Gaza's children The Palestinian ambassador to the UN made an emotional address, saying more than 1,300 children have been killed in Gaza since Israel ended the ceasefire in March. 01:19 - Source: CNN Political candidate wears body armor daily CNN's David Culver met César Gutiérrez Priego as he was readying to campaign for office in Mexico City. Gutiérrez Priego, who is running for a seat on the Supreme Court in Mexico, shows Culver the safety precautions he takes with political violence in Mexico at an all-time high. See Culver's full reporting on CNN. 00:53 - Source: CNN Harvard students and faculty speak out against Trump Harvard students and faculty spoke to CNN ahead of commencement as Donald Trump said the university should cap foreign enrollment. The Trump administration has recently sought to cancel $100 million in contracts with the school. 02:03 - Source: CNN Palestinians desperate for food rush US-backed aid site Scores of people rushed over fencing and through barricades in southern Gaza on the first day a US-Israeli-backed aid site was opened. CNN's Jeremy Diamond explains the desperate humanitarian situation that remains in the region. 01:22 - Source: CNN Journalists spit on at Jerusalem Day flag march Ultra-nationalist Israeli Jews chanted anti-Arab slogans as they marched through Jerusalem's Old City to mark Jerusalem Day. CNN's Oren Liebermann describes heavy police presence on the ground. Members of the crowd were seen spitting on journalists, including a CNN producer. 01:50 - Source: CNN Finland's president responds to Russian military activity along border CNN's Erin Burnett speaks with Finland's President Alexander Stubb about his country ramping up its military to deter potential Russian aggression. 02:16 - Source: CNN King Charles stresses Canada's 'self determination' amid pressure from US King Charles III delivered the ceremonial Speech from the Throne in the Canadian Senate. The address marks only the second time in Canadian history that the reigning sovereign has opened parliament, and the third time that the British monarch has delivered the address. 00:42 - Source: CNN Huge ship refloated after nearly crashing into house A larger container ship has been refloated after nearly crashing into a house in Norway. According to local police, the navigator had fallen asleep at the helm. 00:42 - Source: CNN Vehicle plows into crowd in Liverpool Police in the United Kingdom say a man has been arrested after a car plowed into Liverpool fans celebrating during the soccer club's Premier League trophy parade. 01:14 - Source: CNN Iran's Foreign Ministry on progress of Iran-US talks Iran's Foreign Ministry spokesperson Esmaeil Baqaei gave an exclusive interview to CNN's Fred Pleitgen on the progress of continuing nuclear talks with the US. Baqaei told CNN that any attempt by the Trump administration to 'deprive' Iranians of their right to nuclear energy would be 'very problematic'. But he also said that there were many ways to come to a compromise. Iran and the United States concluded a fifth round of talks in Rome on Friday. 01:16 - Source: CNN Video of President Macron's wife 'pushing' him goes viral A video of French President Macron's wife pushing him as they disembarked a flight has caught the attention of Russian trolls after going viral. While Macron himself tried to downplay the video saying it merely showed a couple 'bickering,' it's not the first time Russian troll accounts and state media outlets have tried to use videos of the French president to spread disinformation. CNN's Saskya Vandoorne has more. 01:35 - Source: CNN
