Google settles antitrust case with CCI over smart TV practices, to pay ₹20 crore
New Delhi: Google has become the first company to utilize India's newly-enacted settlement framework, receiving a settlement order to pay ₹ 20 crore to resolve an antitrust investigation by the Competition Commission of India (CCI) into allegations of its anti-competitive behaviour in the smart TV market, the watchdog said in a statement.
The resolution marks a significant shift in the regulatory landscape and compels the tech giant to unbundle its Play Store and Play Services on Android TVs in the country.
Mint was the first to report on 2 October 2024 that Google offered to settle the antitrust case after an investigation found the technology giant's agreements with smart TV makers violated provisions of India's competition law, making it the first company to invoke the brand-new settlement route enacted in 2023.
As per the settlement deal, Google will have to pay a settlement amount of ₹ 20 crore, after a 15% discount that comes with the scheme.
Queries emailed to Google on Monday seeking comments for the story remained unanswered till press time.
CCI's move to settle the case with Google comes at a time its EU counterpart is reportedly contemplating action against Big Tech if EU's trade talks with the US, after President Trump's sweeping tariffs, fails.
The gist of the allegation against Google LLC, Google India Private Limited and two others was that Google misused its dominant position by enforcing restrictive agreements on original equipment manufacturers (OEMs), including compulsory bundling of the Play Store with Android TV operating system and preventing the use or creation of rival forked Android versions through its Anti-Fragmentation Agreements.
CCI said in a statement on Monday that its investigation had found that Google's agreements—Television App Distribution Agreement (TADA) and Android Compatibility Commitments (ACC)—executed together, allegedly imposed unfair terms by requiring the pre-installation of its full app bundle Google TV Services, preventing television makers from developing or using Android forks, and hindering innovation.
The regulator said it had invited objections and suggestions from 45 parties on Google's settlement application.
'The Commission considered the settlement proposal and observed that under the 'New India Agreement,' Google will provide a standalone license for the Play Store and Play Services for Android smart TVs in India, thereby removing the requirement to bundle these services or impose default placement conditions,' CCI said.
'By waiving the need for a valid ACC for devices shipped into India that do not include Google apps, OEMs can now sell and develop incompatible Android devices without violating the TADA,' CCI said.
The competition watchdog said that considering the material on record, an assessment of the settlement proposal as well as the nature, gravity, and impact of the alleged contraventions, it agreed to the settlement proposal.
'The final settlement amount, after applying a settlement discount of 15%, is ₹ 20.24 crore,' CCI said.
First Published: 21 Apr 2025, 11:33 PM IST
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
22 minutes ago
- Mint
Elon Musk's daughter mocks father's feud with Trump: ‘Love being proven right'
Elon Musk's daughter appeared to mock her father's highly publicised feud with US President Donald Trump on Friday, expressing satisfaction over the situation on social media. Vivian Wilson, 21 — who previously vowed to leave the US after Trump's election — shared an Instagram post that hinted at amusement over the clash. The Instagram post of Elon Musk's daughter. 'I love being proven right,' she wrote, followed by uncontrollable laughter and a refusal to comment further, according to a report by the New York Post. The conflict between Musk and Trump escalated Thursday when Musk criticized one of Trump's policies, prompting Trump to question whether their relationship could ever be repaired. Trump said on Friday that Elon Musk had "lost his mind" but added that he was ready to move past their heated fallout. The dramatic rift between the world's richest man and the most powerful political figure has sparked concerns, carrying both political and economic implications. "Honestly I've been so busy working on China, working on Russia, working on Iran... I'm not thinking about Elon Musk, I just wish him well," Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One en route to his New Jersey golf club late Friday, as reported by AFP. After Elon Musk slammed Trump's spending bill as an 'abomination' on Tuesday, the former president responded sharply from the Oval Office on Thursday, expressing he was 'very disappointed' in the billionaire entrepreneur. I love being proven right. The controversial bill is expected to face stiff resistance in Congress, as it significantly increases the U.S. deficit. Critics also warn that it could slash healthcare coverage for millions of low-income Americans. (With inputs from agencies) Key Takeaways Public feuds can have significant political and economic ramifications. Family dynamics can add complexity to high-profile conflicts. Social media serves as a platform for personal opinions on public matters.
Mint
31 minutes ago
- Mint
Apple's growing list of problems clouds AI reboot
It says something about Apple's current status that its trailing position in artificial intelligence isn't the company's biggest problem. It might seem to be next week, though. Investors are glum ahead of Apple's Worldwide Developers Conference that kicks off Monday. The stock has slid 20% since the first of the year, which is the worst run the shares have experienced ahead of the company's WWDC event since at least 2010. Apple's big tech peers now use their own annual developer events almost exclusively to tout their progress in AI. But Apple's conference this year is expected to mainly demonstrate how far behind the company is in what is considered a once-in-a-generation technological shift. The Apple Intelligence service introduced at last year's conference is still a work in progress, and the Siri digital assistant is still awaiting a promised AI makeover. That won't be coming next week, at least based on a rare admission Apple made three months ago that its planned Siri upgrade was taking longer than expected. 'Apple will be much more cautious about overpromising and will refrain from showing features that aren't yet ready for prime time," Craig Moffett of MoffettNathanson predicted in a report Thursday. But AI is only one of the significant problems Apple is facing now. Tariffs threaten the profit margins of the company's hardware business. And the president of the U.S. is openly pressuring Apple to effectively undo its two-decade-old business model of exclusively producing its devices overseas. Then there is services, which drive an outsize portion of Apple's bottom line. Legal challenges hang over the fees the company earns from app developers, as well as the payments it receives from Google to make the search engine the default option on Apple's devices. Those fees and payments together comprise a substantial part of Apple's services arm that generates annual gross profit margins of 74%—twice the margins the company's device business commands. 'We caution that Apple has material risks to its revenue growth, margins, and valuation multiple," Needham analyst Laura Martin wrote in a report on Wednesday, where she downgraded the stock to a 'hold" rating. Against the risk of tariffs, App Store fee reductions and the loss of Google payments, Apple's slow start in AI seems almost a minor worry. The company hasn't been marketing Apple Intelligence as a premium service that would cost users extra—a notable contrast to the approach of Microsoft and Alphabet's Google, which are charging money for most of the generative AI tools sold to their customers. But Apple needs to give customers more reasons to buy its devices, and upgrade them more frequently. Its flagship iPhone business has been in a rut, with revenue growth relatively flat over the past two years and expected to be flat again for the current fiscal year ending in September. The lack of new AI offerings is expected to weigh on the next cycle as well, with Wall Street expecting iPhone revenue growth of only 3% in fiscal 2026, according to FactSet estimates. 'We believe that, for this stock to work, it must have the catalyst of an iPhone replacement cycle, which we do not foresee in the next 12 months," Needham's Martin wrote in her report. Apple has a lot of very loyal customers—more than 2.35 billion active devices make up its installed base—who won't necessarily bail over a single piece of missing software. But the company that disrupted the smartphone market could be disrupted itself if generative AI creates a new class of devices that obviate the need for a touch screen slab in everyone's pocket. OpenAI just nabbed Jony Ive, the famed Apple designer who crafted the original versions of most of Apple's current product line, as part of an ambition to eventually ship 100 million 'AI companions." The first devices are expected to come out next year. The famously secretive Apple could very well spring some of its own surprises by then. But it will have to do so while juggling its global supply chain and deftly navigating the legal challenges to its App Store fees and Google payments. Apple isn't even officially a party to the Google case, which might limit its options to shape the outcome. Apple's slow start in AI is a problem, but compared to its other challenges, at least it is more under its control.
Time of India
32 minutes ago
- Time of India
Fed likely to leave rates unchanged as US job market cools but doesn't crumble
Federal Reserve policymakers have already signaled they are in no rush to cut interest rates , and a government report on Friday showing the labor market is far from crumbling amid big trade policy changes only cements that stance. The Labor Department 's monthly employment report showed the unemployment rate held steady at 4.2% last month. Employers added 139,000 jobs, which combined with downward revisions to prior months' estimates showed a cooling in labor demand but nothing abrupt; by comparison, job gains averaged 160,000 last year. U.S. President Donald Trump ratcheted up his calls for rate cuts. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The Killer New Honda CR-V Is Utter Perfection (Take A Look) SneakerToast Undo "Go for a full point, Rocket Fuel," Trump said in a post on Truth Social that urged the Fed to lower rates by 100 basis points. The president added that the Fed could simply increase rates again if inflation reignited. But the latest job growth reading is already giving Fed policymakers more comfort about holding the U.S. central bank's policy rate steady as they watch to see how higher import tariffs affect the economy. Live Events It "was a solid report and I was pleased with it," Philadelphia Fed President Patrick Harker told CNBC, adding that now was the time for the Fed to hold policy steady. Fed officials have telegraphed that they intend to do just that at their June 17-18 policy meeting. Financial markets have been betting the Fed will wait until September to cut rates and will deliver a second reduction in borrowing costs by December; after the jobs report they trimmed their bets on a possible third rate cut by the end of this year. "Continued strength in the jobs number provides further support for the Fed's patience," said Scott Helfstein, Global X's head of investment strategy. "The Fed is likely to remain on hold through the end of summer to see how tariff negotiations proceed and ensure prices are stabilizing." Analysts said they expect more softening ahead in the labor market as higher import levies and government policy uncertainty strain economic growth. Job gains in May were concentrated in a narrowing range of industries, including healthcare, and manufacturing lost jobs in its worst showing since January, the employment report showed. The workforce shrank by the most in 17 months. Fed policymakers, however, have signaled they are disinclined to act preemptively to cushion any emerging weakness in jobs, especially with higher tariffs seen likely to also push up prices and potentially reignite inflationary pressures. The takeaway on the labor market for the Fed, said Krishna Guha, vice chairman of Evercore ISI, is that, "given the lack of any serious cracks to date, the risk of waiting several more months to learn more with policy in a modestly restrictive posture looks low."
