logo
SIMMONS: Why don't Matthews and Marner have more Wendel and Gilmour in them?

SIMMONS: Why don't Matthews and Marner have more Wendel and Gilmour in them?

National Post12-05-2025

Article content
Wendel Clark doesn't really know how to explain it.
Article content
How he elevated his game at playoff time.
Article content
How his crazy intensity of regular-season hockey turned up more than a notch when the Stanley Cup playoffs began in Toronto.
Article content
As a teenaged rookie, Clark scored five goals in his first 10 Stanley Cup games. He followed that up with six in his second season. In between all that, he was hitting and fighting and doing all the Wendel things that made him so beloved in Toronto.
Article content
Article content
In the two magical Maple Leafs seasons still remembered so fondly, Clark scored 19 playoff goals in 39 games in 1993 and 1994, while smashing into anything around him and spending 75 minutes in the penalty box.
Article content
Article content
If only there was some Wendel Clark in Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner. If only those two Maple Leafs giants — in salary and regular-season numbers — had some of the qualities that made Wendel Clark, Wendel Clark.
Article content
Clark was built to play against — or for — the Florida Panthers. He was a more-dynamic Matthew Tkachuk, with a Matthews-Sam Reinhart kind of wrist shot and a body needing to engage in collision. He would have been the perfect Craig Berube player.
Article content
He wasn't the only Maple Leaf to grow come playoff time. Probably no one in Leafs history did it better than the rather tiny man himself, Doug Gilmour.
Article content
In the years in which Clark scored 19 goals, Gilmour had the two greatest individual playoff seasons in Leafs history. He had 63 points in 39 games in '93 and '94. No one will ever come close to that again.
Article content
And in doing so, Gilmour, more playmaker than the goal scorer and once traded for Berube, wound up with 16 post-season goals over those two years. Before that, he had scored 11 for the Flames in the only season Calgary won the Stanley Cup and he scored nine for St. Louis and led the playoffs in points without making it to the final with the Blues.
Article content
Gilmour never has completely been able to unpack what is was about him that made him so special in the biggest moments and the largest games. But he had it. In Toronto, in St. Louis, in Calgary, in Montreal — pretty much everywhere he played.
Article content
Article content
And they can't turn the better comparable of Marner, the ultimate playmaker, into Gilmour, the ultimate playmaker. It looked like it was there for Marner when he scored giant playoff points — 44 in 18 games — when playing junior for the London Knights.
Article content
His whole game is measured statistically and always will be. Not known for his goal scoring, Marner has scored at 16-goal pace in the post-season after scoring at 21-goal pace in the regular season.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Fans sad but supportive as Oilers lose Stanley Cup for 2nd year in a row: ‘Proud of our boys'
Fans sad but supportive as Oilers lose Stanley Cup for 2nd year in a row: ‘Proud of our boys'

Global News

timean hour ago

  • Global News

Fans sad but supportive as Oilers lose Stanley Cup for 2nd year in a row: ‘Proud of our boys'

They tried so hard and got so far, but in the end, the Edmonton Oilers and their fans were left with a sense of déjà vu. For the second year in a row, Edmonton lost in the Stanley Cup final to the Florida Panthers, extending Canada's three-decade long drought. The Panthers defeated the Oilers 5-1 on home ice, to secure their second Stanley Cup in franchise history. 'Lost to a really good team,' a muted Oilers captain Connor McDavid said after the Game 6 in Florida with a shrug of defeat. 'Nobody quit. Nobody threw the towel in… They're a heck of a team. 'They're Stanley Cup champions back to back for a reason.' Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "They're Stanley Cup champions back to back for a reason." Story continues below advertisement Some 4,100 kilometres away in downtown Edmonton, a hush fell over the packed crowd in the Moss Pit watch party outside Rogers Place arena, as the clocked ticked down and the score remained too far apart. Dejected fans who had placed such high hopes on their team patted each other on the back, consoled one another with hugs, and began clearing out early and quietly. 'We put it all on the ice. It was good,' said Taygen Mercier. Her friend Jordyn Soucy feels Edmonton ran out of gas early. 'I think we had more momentum last year – this year, we had a lot of ups and downs,' Soucy said. Regardless, both women said they are very proud of both the team and Edmontonians. 'It's our city — we're proud to live here, we're proud of our boys,' Mercier said. Soucy agreed. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'This is the best part of Edmonton, the best part about being in Alberta — the best time of the year by far. There's nothing like downtown in Edmonton in playoff season.' Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "This is the best part of Edmonton, the best part about being in Alberta — the best time of the year by far. There's nothing like downtown in Edmonton in playoff season." Post-game, it was a sombre scene in the Moss Pit after weeks of gatherings outside the arena brought together passionate fans from all walks of life, united by one common goal. Story continues below advertisement 'I think it's cool for the city — like, everybody's kind of tied together,' said fan Tyler Burns. 'Nobody cares about backgrounds or anything or where you're from, so it's a pretty cool, nice experience here.' Despite the loss, many fans saw the bright side to the marathon that is the quest to the Stanley Cup final. 'The city was so alive,' said fan Yasmine Soufli. 'This game, this playoffs really brought Edmonton together. 'All of us, it felt like a community, and I'm so proud of how connected this community became, it meant the world, and we should have gotten the cup. View full screen View full screen View full screen View full screen View full screen Previous Image Next Image Close Modal Gallery Fans far and wide tuned into the game. Story continues below advertisement 'Win or lose, each and every member of the Edmonton Oilers should hold their head high. Was one heck of run!' Alberta Premier Danielle Smith said on social media. 'Alberta is proud of you and you'll be back fighting for the Cup again soon!' Win or lose, each and every member of the @EdmontonOilers should hold their head high. Was one heck of run! Alberta is proud of you and you'll be back fighting for the Cup again soon! — Danielle Smith (@ABDanielleSmith) June 18, 2025 The Oilers are the first team to lose consecutive finals to the same team since the Boston Bruins fell to the Montreal Canadiens in both 1977 and 1978. The last time a Canadian team won hockey's most coveted trophy was in 1993, when the Montreal Canadiens brought it north of the 49th parallel. Canadian teams have had their chances at ending the curse. They have appeared in seven finals since 1993, including the Oilers previously in 2024 and 2006, but none have been able to end the country's lengthy Cup lockout. Story continues below advertisement Teams in the U.S. Sun Belt have won it five of the past six times — four of them in Florida. Burns and his friend Ben Hilliar suspect the loss of Zach Hyman, who dislocated his wrist in Game 4 of the Western Conference final and was done for the season, hurt the team in the finals. 'Losing him was horrible. We really needed him,' Hilliar said. 'Hyman was kind of the only physical player we had on the team for a while there, especially against Florida last year, he was the only one who could play their game and not get penalties,' Burns said. The Oilers will now go back to the drawing board and see if their talented cast, including superstars McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, can take another shot at leading Edmonton to its first title since their dynasty days led by Wayne Gretzky, Mark Messier and others. Edmonton took the Stanley Cup home five times between the 1983-84 and the 1989-90 seasons. 'I've been an Oilers fan for years and they had good efforts, they had good games during the season. I won't forget all those good moments and I still give them credit because they tried their best,' said fan Crystal Tremblay. Story continues below advertisement 'All we can do is hope for next year.' Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "All we can do is hope for next year." — With files from The Canadian Press

Tkachuk, Barkov and Reinhart play through significant injuries to help Panthers win Stanley Cup
Tkachuk, Barkov and Reinhart play through significant injuries to help Panthers win Stanley Cup

Winnipeg Free Press

timean hour ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

Tkachuk, Barkov and Reinhart play through significant injuries to help Panthers win Stanley Cup

SUNRISE, Fla. (AP) — Some top Florida Panthers players gutted through significant injuries to help them repeat as Stanley Cup champions, most notably Matthew Tkachuk dealing with a sports hernia and torn adductor muscle on the same side. 'He was a mess,' coach Paul Maurice said. 'That's the medical term: He was a mess.' Maurice said Aleksander Barkov's point production in the final was affected by one of the captain's hands being cut open and that Sam Reinhart returned from a Grade 2 MCL sprain in the Eastern Conference final. 'In Game 1, Sasha split the palm of his hand open,' Maurice said. 'He had those sutures torn out twice 'til he just glued it together.' Reinhart came back to score four goals in the clinching Game 6 against Edmonton. No player has done that since Maurice 'Rocket Richard' in 1957. Tkachuk scored what turned out to be the Cup-winning goal, four months after getting injured playing for the U.S. in the 4 Nations Face-Off. He missed the second half of the regular season. 'I was really not hopeful at the start that he would survive the first round,' Maurice said. 'We just didn't think he could do it.' Smiling ear to ear on the ice after hoisting the Cup, Tkachuk beamed about the medical treatment that made him able to play. 'I wouldn't be here without the trainers and the doctors and those people, and that's what makes this Cup more special for me is how hard it was just to be out there and to get to the point of playing,' Tkachuk said. 'I owe — this Cup is because of them for me. I'm so lucky.' Perry comes up short Corey Perry became the first player in NHL history to lose in the final five times in six years with four different teams. Perry was also with the Oilers last year and before that lost in 2022 with Tampa Bay, 2021 with Montreal and 2020 with Dallas. Had Edmonton won, Perry would have broken the record for the longest gap between Cup championships. He won it with the Anaheim Ducks in 2007. Cup handout surprise Barkov did not hand the Stanley Cup to a longtime teammate like Aaron Ekblad or Sergei Bobrovsky. It went to newcomer and third-pairing defenseman Nate Schmidt, who won it for the first time in his career. 'He just looked at me and he gave me the 'Cap' death stare,' Schmidt said. 'You don't turn those eyes away. No, I didn't know. It was awesome.' Schmidt then handed it to Seth Jones, who gave it to Tomas Nosek to Vitek Vanecek to A.J. Greer and on to all the other players who hadn't hoisted the Cup before. Jones, a trade acquisition from Chicago late in the season, later celebrated on the ice with his father, retired NBA player Popeye Jones. '(Barkov) looked me and he said, 'Hey, the guys that haven't done it before, we're going to take a back seat to you guys,'' Schmidt said. 'It means a lot.' Dynasty talks Thursdays Keep up to date on sports with Mike McIntyre's weekly newsletter. There are a few teams that people point to when the word dynasty comes up. Michael Jordan's Chicago Bulls. The Tom Brady-led New England Patriots. After successfully defending their title, should this Panthers team be added to that list? 'Hell yeah,' Matthew Tkachuk said. 'Absolutely.' The dynasty talk started before the series even began, when it became clear that the Florida Panthers would play in their third straight Stanley Cup Final. They've played more hockey games than any other team in the NHL over the past three years, which obviously means they've done a lot of winning. ___ AP NHL playoffs: and

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store