NI water pollution: Farmers says Stormont proposals 'out of touch'
Farmers have said plans to reduce water pollution as a result of agricultural activity are "out of touch" with the reality of agriculture.Northern Ireland's long-overdue Nutrients Action Programme (NAP) for 2026-29 has been published for consultation.Many of the proposals are linked to the Lough Neagh Action Plan.Making low emission slurry spreading equipment (LESSE) mandatory and placing restrictions on the use of phosphorus fertiliser are among recommended revisions.
'Farmers are not shying away'
President of the Ulster Farmers' Union, William Irvine, said it was "deeply concerning" the proposals from the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (Daera) "lean heavily" towards enforcement and regulation rather than education, incentives or collaboration with farmers."Farmers are not shying away from their responsibilities," he said."For the last 20 years, since NAP was first introduced, we have been implementing practices to improve water quality."We fully recognise the need to protect and improve water quality, but it must be done in a way that's balanced, fair and grounded in the day-to-day realities of farming in NI."The proposals within NAP reflect a clear disconnect with local agriculture and fail to deliver what's truly needed."Daera said it was "widely recognised that the intensification of agricultural production has had negative impacts on the environment".
Why is the plan being introduced?
Daera Minister Andrew Muir said action was needed to improve water quality and meet legal obligations."This is why it is essential to review NAP and consider additional measures to reduce the overall phosphorus surplus in our agricultural system," he said."The main additional measures include further restrictions on use of chemical phosphorus fertiliser and a farm phosphorus balance limit for more intensive farms."He added that while 62% of the nutrient load in waterways could be traced back to to agriculture, other sources such as wastewater treatment and septic tank seepages also play a role.His department also wants to "enhance" the enforcement powers available to it, to apply fixed or variable monetary penalties for breaches of the NAP.
'Permission to pollute'
Speaking on BBC's The View, Muir said he recognised that the measures proposed in the NAP are "challenging" and the consultation is "very complex".He told the programme he will be extending the consultation period by four weeks."Ultimately we do need to change so we can improve our waterways and I don't want to consign Lough Neagh to the scenes we've seen in recent years," Muir said.He added that since NI Water was established in 2007 they have had a "permission to pollute".He added that he was "fed up" with the lack of investment in wastewater infrastructure, and that the Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins "needs to get her head out of the sand and needs to turn the situation around"."What I am being left with as the minister for agriculture, environment and rural affairs is the job of cleaning up the sewage that NI Water are pumping into our waterways."
Better ways of using slurry
Intensive farms – mostly dairy and some beef farms - can be granted a derogation for using slurry on their land, allowing them to apply up to 250kg nitrogen per hectare per year from grazing livestock manures, rather than 170kg.The number of farms that currently have a derogation is 427.The lower limit for nitrogen would be reduced to 150kg/N/ha/year, putting another 3,100 farms in the category.In total, the consultation document said, these farms account for 17% of all farms, yet produce some 50% of total manure nitrogen.They will also represent a significant proportion of surplus phosphorus because of their greater reliance on feed inputs.These farms would also be subject to a Phosphorus Balance Limit of 10kg/ha/year in 2027, reducing to 8kg in 2029.Other schemes seeking ways of better using slurry and the nutrients it contains include the sustainable use of livestock slurry and using slurry to generate biogas.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
6 hours ago
- Reuters
Return of Ukraine wheat and barley curbs gives small boost to EU farmers
PARIS/KYIV, June 6 (Reuters) - European farmers welcomed the European Union's re-introduction of quotas on Friday for Ukrainian wheat and barley as a small boost to their market, but they still face global price competition as Ukraine tries to export elsewhere. The European Union waived duties and quotas on Ukrainian agricultural products following Russia's full-scale invasion three years ago. It later capped volumes on some Ukrainian produce, including sugar, following an outcry from farmers over the price competition it posed. It did not limit volumes of wheat and barley, however, and more than 4 million metric tons of Ukrainian wheat were imported into the EU since the start of the 2024/25 season last July. Friday's expiry of the waivers means the EU has restored a pre-war regime of trade quotas, pending the conclusion of a new longer-term trade deal with Kyiv. The re-establishment of the quotas was "a crucial first step" towards rebalancing the market, French wheat farmers' union AGPB said in a statement. It reinstates a duty-free quota of 1 million tons annually for wheat and 350,000 tons for barley. Adjusted for the seven months left in 2025, that represents about 583,000 tons of wheat and 204,000 tons of barley available for the rest of the year. European farmers, also concerned by a planned EU deal with South America's Mercosur bloc, blame Ukrainian competition for pushing prices below their production costs, which have also been inflated by higher energy and fertiliser bills since the war. The quotas should shift Ukraine's exports away from Europe and keep more EU wheat at home, though the price benefit for farmers may be limited, traders said. One trader, speaking on condition of anonymity, said Ukrainian grain that is not shipped into the EU will still find its way to the global market. Reduced access to the massive EU market was a setback for Ukraine, but it should be able to pivot more towards North Africa and Southeast Asia, First Deputy Farm Minister Taras Vysotskiy told reporters. "We were there in 2021, and logistically it is not difficult. The question is the price," he said. The EU and Ukraine, meanwhile, are working on a broader trade accord. The EU's agriculture commissioner told Reuters the future deal would set quotas somewhere between current levels and the waivers. Ukraine's trade representative Taras Kachka flagged the risk of market tensions. "There will be no problems with corn supplies, but there are issues with wheat and barley, but we hope to reach acceptable volumes," he told a grain conference in Kyiv on Friday. Ukrainian corn (maize) is subject to a pre-war 650,000 ton annual quota from Friday. But unlike wheat and barley, no impact is expected since the EU has a general zero tariff on corn.
Reuters
7 hours ago
- Reuters
Brazil's Lula bets on agriculture to drive higher growth in 2025
June 6 (Reuters) - Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva said on Friday that growth in the agriculture sector may allow Latin America's largest economy to defy current projections and expand this year more than in 2024, when it notched growth of 3.4%. Lula's optimistic remarks diverge from his own government's forecast, as the Finance Ministry sees Brazil's gross domestic product (GDP) growth slowing to 2.4% in 2025 amid tight monetary conditions. The comments followed the publication of Brazil's first-quarter GDP figures last week, which showed year-on-year growth of 2.9% fueled by a jump in agricultural activity thanks to a bumper harvest of soybeans, the country's top farm export. The South American country is the world's largest exporter of soy, coffee, cotton, sugar, beef and chicken, as well as a top supplier of corn and pork. "Our first-quarter growth demonstrates that we can once again surprise the world and grow above the global average," Lula told an event in Paris, where the country was recognized as free of foot-and-mouth disease without vaccination. "If last year we grew 3.4% with agriculture not expanding as much as we expected, I think agriculture growth this year can allow us to think about growing a bit more," the leftist leader added. Private economists polled on a weekly basis by the central bank expect Brazil's GDP to grow 2.13% this year.
BBC News
9 hours ago
- BBC News
Trump's trade tariffs 'to hit NI growth and jobs'
A US tariff of 10% on UK goods could cost the Northern Ireland economy £85m and 800 jobs over the next 15 years, a Department for the Economy study has does not mean the economy will shrink in absolute terms, rather it will be smaller than it would have been if the tariffs had not been study only considers the direct effects on Northern Ireland exports rather than any secondary impact would rise to a £110m loss of potential economic output if US President Donald Trump was to impose a 20% tariff on pharmaceuticals. Pharmaceuticals is the part of the Northern Ireland economy which is most exposed to Trump tariffs as almost half of the sector's export sales go to the study suggests a 20% tariff would mean pharmaceutical sector output would be around 5% lower compared to a no tariff are effectively a tax on imported goods and are a major part of Trump's economic policy. Since re-entering office in January, he has raised tariffs on specific items such as steel, aluminium, and cars and imposed a blanket 10% levy on most goods from trading partners around the had briefly targeted some countries' exports with even higher tariff rates, only to suspend those measures for 90 days to allow for talks.A US trade court has ruled that an emergency law invoked by Trump did not give him the unilateral authority to impose the blanket 10% those tariffs are still being collected while the Trump administration appeals the administration is also conducting a national security investigation into pharmaceutical imports, a process which would provide a more solid legal basis to impose tariffs on that sector. 'A significant headwind' The study concludes that tariffs will "adversely affect local businesses and represent a significant headwind for businesses when trying to grow exports over the longer term"."It is also likely that many of the businesses impacted will be in specific geographic areas e.g. Mid Ulster and Armagh, Banbridge and Craigavon council areas," it says."This is due to the importance of the manufacturing and pharmaceutical industries to these areas, which will have implications for the regional balance agenda being taken forward by the department."
