With new decree, Trump seeks to cow the legal profession

Boston Globe

23-03-2025

Vanita Gupta, who as a civil rights lawyer and a former Justice Department official has both sued the government and defended it in court, said Trump's memo 'attacks the very foundations of our legal system by threatening and intimidating litigants who aim to hold our government accountable to the law and the Constitution.'
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
The president has long complained that Democratic-leaning lawyers and law firms have pursued what he calls 'lawfare' in the form of investigations and lawsuits against him and his allies that he claims are motivated by politics. Since being sworn into office, he has targeted three firms, but the new memo seems to threaten similar punishment for any firm that raises his ire or any lawyer who does.
Advertisement
Trump's memo argues that the steps are necessary to ensure 'accountability' in the legal profession.
After Trump issued an order suspending security clearances for Paul Weiss lawyers and sharply limiting their employees from entering government buildings or getting government jobs, the firm agreed to a series of commitments to get the president to cancel the order.
As part of the deal, the firm said it would provide $40 million in legal services to causes Trump has championed, including his task force to combat antisemitism.
Perkins Coie, another firm targeted by Trump, chose a different tack — suing him in federal court and getting a temporary restraining order against the president.
Trump's attacks on law firms, and Paul Weiss's decision to sue for peace rather than fight it out in court, have sent shock waves through the legal community. The sweeping nature of Trump's latest demand comes as he has also stepped up his public attacks on judges and the notion that the courts can tell him what to do or not do.
Advertisement
The executive branch 'should neither fear nor punish those who challenge it and should not be the arbiter of what is frivolous. There are protections in place to address that,' Gupta said. 'This moment calls for courage and collective action, not capitulation, among lawyers and the legal profession.'
It also comes amid a showdown between a federal judge in Washington and the administration over Trump's invocation a week ago of the Alien Enemies Act, which he used to immediately send more than 100 Venezuelan migrants he said were gang members to a large prison complex in El Salvador.
Civil rights activists say the deportations violated the law and that the administration's refusal to give clear answers on its conduct flouts the very premise of the US court system.
One law firm that is suing the administration over its policies said it would not back down in the face of threats from the White House.
The leaders of Keker, Van Nest & Peters, a San Francisco firm that has sued the Trump administration over its immigration raids, called Trump's latest memo 'inexcusable and despicable.'
'Our liberties depend on lawyers' willingness to represent unpopular people and causes, including in matters adverse to the federal government,' the firm said in a statement. 'Our profession owes every client zealous legal representation without fear of retribution, regardless of their political affiliation or ability to pay.'
Advertisement
The firm also encouraged other lawyers to join a nationwide effort to submit a 'friend of the court' brief in the Perkins Coie lawsuit against Trump.
Trump's Friday night memo, titled 'Preventing Abuses of the Legal System and the Federal Court,' complains that lawyers have long engaged in unethical conduct in opposing him or deportations. The memo also suggests that the Trump administration will make disciplinary referrals against lawyers who pursue cases without merit, 'particularly in cases that implicate national security, homeland security, public safety or election integrity.'
Trump also used the announcement to attack one particular lawyer by name, Marc Elias.
Elias previously worked at Perkins Coie and has long represented Democrats. Trump blames Elias, among others, for a dossier of unsubstantiated allegations about his links to Russia that was investigated by the FBI in 2016 and 2017.
'President Trump's goal is clear. He wants lawyers and law firms to capitulate and cower until there is no one left to oppose his administration in court,' Elias said in a written statement. 'There will be no negotiation with this White House about the clients we represent or the lawsuits we bring on their behalf.'
This article originally appeared in