Jane Austen's Bookshelf by Rebecca Romney review – the women behind the woman
It would be easy to mistake Rebecca Romney's Jane Austen's Bookshelf for one of the many books produced annually by the Jane Austen industrial-entertainment complex: Jane Austen at Home, Jane Austen: Her Homes & Her Friends, Jane Was Here: An illustrated Guide to Jane Austen's England. So much cultural real estate has been built off those six published books of Austen's, it's a wonder someone hasn't thought before to do a little detective work into the authors that influenced her: Ann Radcliffe, whose 1794 gothic thriller The Mysteries of Udolpho peppers every other conversation in Northanger Abbey; Elizabeth Inchbald, whose 1798 play Lovers' Vows is rehearsed by the characters in Mansfield Park; and Frances Burney, whose third novel, Camilla (1796), originated the phrase 'pride and prejudice'. 'There are two Traits in her Character which are pleasing,' Austen once wrote of a friend, 'namely she admires Camilla, & drinks no cream in her Tea.'
To her chagrin, Romney had not even heard of Burney, despite being a self-confessed Austen fanatic and a rare book dealer to boot, but she soon found she was not alone. Burney is not even mentioned on Austen's Wikipedia page and merits only dismissive mentions in most histories of the period, such as Ian Watt's The Rise of the Novel: Studies in Defoe, Richardson and Fielding (1957), which concluded, condescendingly, 'it was Jane Austen who completed the work that Fanny Burney had begun'. And this despite the Georgian era being the first time in English history more women published novels than men. It wasn't that Burney wasn't any good, it was that she wasn't as good as Austen, even though Richardson or Fielding are never asked to pass the same test. 'When Burney loses, that's it: she's off those canonical reading lists,' writes Romney, crisply. 'Between women writers, you have to beat the best or you don't get to play at all.'
Jane Austen's Bookshelf is brilliant stuff – a bold bit of canon jujitsu, sparked by the simplest of questions, leading to the most enraging of conclusions, but driven by the sheer pleasure that anyone who has ever read Burney's Evelina can attest to. From Burney, Romney moves on to Ann Radcliffe, whose The Mysteries of Udolpho still captivates like a waking dream, to bold, witty, Charlotte Lennox, whose The Female Quixote Romney finds 'far wittier than any of Austen's novels', to Elizabeth Inchbald, whose 'concise, ironic' style anticipates Austen's own. How are these writers not household names in a world where Austen stationery, Christmas decorations, coffee mugs and wallpaper all fly off the shelves at the gift shop at Jane Austen's house in Hampshire, where the author's 250th birthday celebrations are due to reach a climax this December?
Jane Austen's Bookshelf would not disappoint any reader who picked it up along with all their other Janeite merch but it's so much more. A worthy sequel to Dale Spender's Mothers of the Novel: 100 Good Women Writers Before Jane Austen, Romney's book is as sharp an examination of the 'great forgetting' of female writers as you could wish for, uncowed by big-name critics, buoyed instead by the instincts of a single reader trusting her honest enjoyment over dusty tradition. It also comes with a happy addendum: in addition to her book, Romney has built a small collection of the authors discussed at Indiana University's Lilly Library. The new canon starts here.
Jane Austen's Bookshelf: The Women Writers Who Shaped a Legend by Rebecca Romney is published by Ithaka (£25). To support the Guardian and Observer order your copy at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time Out
2 days ago
- Time Out
Beloved literary icon Jane Austen is celebrated at this new exhibit in NYC
Anybody who has taken a high school English class is likely familiar with the name Jane Austen, but that wasn't the case when Austen was alive. Instead, she published her works—even the famed Pride and Prejudice —anonymously. It wasn't until after her death in 1817 that Austen's name became famous as one of the great English novelists. That interesting legacy, as well as much more Austen lore, is part of a new exhibition at The Morgan Library & Museum titled " A Lively Mind: Jane Austen at 250." It features first-edition copies of her novels, corresponding artworks, personal letters, historical documents and artifacts from Jane Austen's House in Chawton, England. This major exhibition celebrating Austen's 250th birthday is now open through September 14, 2025. "Our aim in the show is to welcome every visitor—regardless of their prior knowledge of Jane Austen, level of interest in Jane Austen, possible prejudices against Jane Austen," Juliette Wells, co-curator of the exhibition and Professor of Literary Studies at Goucher College, said at a preview event for the exhibit. To that end, the exhibition takes a chronological approach, starting with Austen's younger years when her father helped to buoy her love of the written word. Her father, a reverend, owned 500 books, a large personal collection for that era. Also rare for the time, he allowed his daughters to read whatever they wanted whether that was from his collection, borrowed from friends or obtained from a library. Unfortunately, her father's death dealt a blow to the ambitious young writer, who then struggled through unsettled years with a tight budget. Much of the story is told through Austen's letters to her sister and lifelong confidante Cassandra. Being able to see Austen's handwriting and read her words helps the late author tell her own story. Eventually, Austen found professional success, writing about heroines who value happiness, trust their own judgment and love wholeheartedly. That success continued from 1809 until her death at the age of 41. In Austen's time, only her family and friends knew she was the writer of popular works including Emma, Persuasion and Sense and Sensibility. Even Austen's tombstone says nothing about her authorship. It's impossible to know why Austen chose to publish anonymously, Wells said, especially when her early letters demonstrate an interest in fame. It seems Austen wanted her books to sell well, but she didn't want to be personally identified, Wells explained. Meaning she wanted people to devour her writing, but she didn't want them to come up to her on the street. Plus, The Morgan's Dale Stinchcomb added, publishing for a single woman was still unusual at that time. If she was married, it may have been a different story. "'A Lively Mind' examines how it was possible for Austen to publish her now-beloved novels when women generally were not permitted to become writers, much less encouraged to be," said Stinchcomb, Drue Heinz Curator of Literary and Historical Manuscripts at the Morgan Library & Museum. We also don't know why she chose to use "By a Lady" as her literary nom de plume, though that wasn't an uncommon phrase for authors at that time. Even if they didn't know who she was, Americans were reading Austen in her lifetime—and continue to do so today. American readers, in particular, played a major role in securing Austen's place as one of the great English novelists. Austen's fandom has grown increasingly diverse and global over the decades. The exhibition ends with a nod to that trend by featuring a painting by Amy Sherald titled "A Single Man in Possession of a Good Fortune," which is a reference to the opening line of Pride and Prejudice. For even more of Sherald's artwork, check out this full exhibit of her work at The Whitney.
The Guardian
3 days ago
- The Guardian
Geoff Dyer: ‘I don't go to books for comfort; I have a memory foam pillow for that'
My earliest reading memory Beatrix Potter when I was having my tonsils out. No point saying how much I loved her books because everyone does, but Roberto Calasso makes a brilliant point in The Celestial Hunter by pairing 'two great moments in the Victorian age' when Darwin 'linked human beings to primates' and Potter 'distributed human behaviour among a certain number of small domestic and rural animals'. My favourite book growing up The Guns of Navarone. My first Alistair MacLean, the first of about 20 before I grew out of him at the age of 15. They were thrilling and addictive and it was possible, while reading, to visualise every scene so clearly (helped in part by the scene-enacting photos on the covers of the Fontana editions). The book that changed me as a teenager I was being changed on a weekly basis by what I was reading from O-levels onwards. I could single out Jane Austen's Emma as the starting point, but more important than any particular book or writer was the acquired habit of reading, the solace of interiority. The writer who changed my mind The big revelations and re-evaluations, respectively, took place in my 20s with Marx and Nietzsche. Freud, by contrast, seemed daft and cultish. The book that made me want to be a writer I never particularly wanted to be one; being a writer was one of many possibilities simmering away and this is the one that happened to come to the boil. Very different from Walt Whitman, who said he was simmering, simmering, and Emerson brought him to the boil. The book I came back to I've reread The Names by Don DeLillo more than any other book. It remains a high point, not just in DeLillo's career but in the history of the postwar novel. The book I could never read again Under the Volcano by Malcolm Lowry. I tried a couple of years ago, not because I'd loved it first time around, in my early 20s, but because I hadn't really liked it then. Second time around it seemed complete tripe. I'm often struck by the consistency of my feelings about books. The book I discovered later in life Everything by Elizabeth Taylor. If I had to choose one it would be A Game of Hide and Seek but her 12 novels and the hefty volume of short stories lit up my mid-60s. Also, the first 12 novels by Anita Brookner, a subtle and quietly pathological writer. When someone writes essentially the same book over and over you're in receipt of an enacted philosophical consciousness. Having said that, Brookner's persistent and gradually shrinking sameness led me to pause at about the halfway mark: 12 down, a dozen to go. The book I am currently reading Rosamond Lehmann's The Weather in the Streets. One of those perennially bubbling-under modern classics – too good for the Championship, unable to sustain a place in the Premier league – which turns out to be way better than some of the canonical stalwarts permanently installed in the top flight. Sign up to Inside Saturday The only way to get a look behind the scenes of the Saturday magazine. Sign up to get the inside story from our top writers as well as all the must-read articles and columns, delivered to your inbox every weekend. after newsletter promotion My comfort read Tessa Hadley's Clever Girl – except it's not comforting at all because although it seems to contain an easy-to-understand guide to writing fiction it turns out to be impossible to extract the necessary skills from the pages in which they are so abundantly and discreetly revealed. So the open secret remains as mysteriously elusive as ever. Which is fine because I don't go to books for comfort; I have a much-loved memory foam pillow for that. Geoff Dyer's memoir Homework is published by Canongate. To support the Guardian order your copy at Delivery charges may apply.
Glasgow Times
3 days ago
- Glasgow Times
Queen opens new stand named in her honour at ‘beautiful racecourse'
She was at the privately-owned Hexham Racecourse – Northumberland's only track – to open the Queen Camilla Stand. The Queen was shown around the venue, 600ft above the town, which boasts views across the county and an undulating jump track which sits in a natural amphitheatre. Camilla, under a photograph of the late Queen's horse No Trumps, which won a race at the course in 2019, said she hoped to come back with a runner one day. The Queen used a clear umbrella at times as showers passed over (Owen Humphreys/PA) She wore a pale-blue Bruce Oldfield outfit and a horseshoe broach marked Minoru, which was a horse owned by Edward VII. The Queen used a clear umbrella at times as showers passed over. After officially opening the stand, she said: 'How thrilled I am to be here in Hexham. 'I haven't been here, I am ashamed to say, before but it really is the most beautiful racecourse. 'It has the most wonderful views. 'Unfortunately, I didn't bring the weather with me, I can imagine what it is like on a sunny day because it looks pretty good on a day like this. 'Next time, I hope to come back with a runner. Hopefully it emulates No Trumps.' The Queen spoke to racing industry figures including trainer Charlie Brooks, who said afterwards: 'She is very engaged in racing issues and, without putting words in her mouth, is understanding of the challenges – she knows her stuff.' Robert Whitelock, racecourse manager, showed the Queen around the site and said afterwards: 'It is wonderful that she came up here and I think she is delighted about the stand being named in her honour.' Racing has been held in Hexham since 1670 and National Hunt Racing started at the current site in 1890. Camilla also visited Hexham Abbey during her visit to Northumberland (Owen Humphreys/PA) The Queen, like her late mother-in-law before her, is a long-standing supporter of horse racing and has loved horses since she was a girl. She once told ITV Racing: 'I could probably ride before I could walk.' A follower of jump racing from her teenage years, Camilla recognised the odds were against being a winning racehorse owner. Speaking to the channel in 2021, she said: 'I think people go into racing who don't know a lot about it and think 'Oh, we will buy a horse and it will win a race', but it's terribly difficult to win any race anywhere. 'The odds are actually stacked against winning, aren't they?'
