Bengaluru stampede sparks ‘Kumbh vs Chinnaswamy' debate over crowd chaos: 'No resignations, no accountability'
The tragic stampede outside Bengaluru's M Chinnaswamy Stadium that killed 11 people and injured dozens has triggered a political and public debate, with comparisons being drawn to past crowd disasters, including the Kumbh Mela stampede.
The debate was sparked after Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, responding to criticism over the RCB victory celebration tragedy, said, 'Such incidents happened in many places; I am not going to defend it by comparing them and saying that it happened here and there... 50-60 people died in Kumbh Mela. I did not criticise. If Congress criticises, then that is a different matter. Did I or the Karnataka government criticise?'
(Also Read: 'Stampede was state-orchestrated': Bengaluru MP Tejasvi Surya slams Siddaramaiah government)
Union Minister Pralhad Joshi strongly objected to this comparison. 'Kumbh and this incident are totally incomparable. People died, but you (Karnataka CM) continued to celebrate. Why did your Deputy CM go to receive the team? A judicial inquiry should be conducted into the incident. When police denied permission, who forced them to allow the event?' he said, demanding accountability from the state leadership.
Over 50 people lost their lives in stampedes across the country this year, at temples, railway stations, the Maha Kumbh, and now at Bengaluru's Chinnaswamy Stadium.
On January 29, during the Maha Kumbh, a stampede at the Sangam area claimed the lives of 30 people and left 60 injured. The tragedy occurred as millions of pilgrims jostled for space to take a holy dip on the auspicious occasion of Mauni Amavasya.
On social media, the tragedy ignited emotional reactions. Industrialist Harsh Goenka wrote on X, formerly Twitter, 'Delhi station stampede. Kumbh stampede. Bangalore IPL stampede. Dozens die. No resignations. No accountability. No lessons. In India, the life of a common man isn't priceless it's worthless. Cheaper than a cup of chai! Business will go on as usual. Nothing will change.'
Political content creator Arpit Sharma added, 'If you were defending Yogi during Kumbh stampede, you don't have any moral right to question Chinnaswamy stampede.'
Adding context to the comparisons, an advocate on X pointed out stark differences in crowd volumes, 'Maha Kumbh Mela 2025 saw approximately 663 million (66.3 crore) visits. The Chinnaswamy Stadium has a seating capacity of 35,000, but was overwhelmed by an estimated 2 to 3 lakh people. These are entirely different scales and require different levels of preparation.'
(Also Read: Bengaluru Police denied permission, RCB victory parade took place amid confusion)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
27 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Lift ban on issue of arms licences: BJP MLA to CM
First-time BJP MLA from the Kalapipal seat of Shajapur district, Ghanshyam Chandravanshi, has written to CM Mohan Yadav, urging him to lift the ban on the issuance of new arms licences in the state. In his letter to the CM, the legislator has emphasised the need to allow fresh armed licences in view of Operation Sindoor. 'Patriotism is reigning supreme, and the people of the state, particularly women, need to be trained in the use of firearms for self-defence,' he stressed, adding, 'To that end, the issue of fresh arms licences must resume.' The state, which has over 2.5 lakh arms licence holders, hasn't issued a fresh licence since October 2023. MP's Pachmarhi to host 3-day BJP training camp A three-day special training camp will be organised by the BJP for its lawmakers (MPs and MLAs) from June 14 at the state's lone hill station, Pachmarhi. Union Home Minister Amit Shah is likely to address the gathering on the inaugural day. As part of the camp, the lawmakers will be asked to refrain from making comments on sensitive issues without the permission of the party leadership. This comes in the backdrop of highly controversial remarks made by state Deputy CM Jagdish Devda, Cabinet minister Vijay Shah and seventh-time MP Faggan Singh Kulaste on Operation Sindoor. State receives Rs 1,929-cr investment proposals The state government received investment proposals worth a whopping Rs 1,929 crore at the day-long spiritual and wellness summit held in Ujjain on Thursday. During the event, CM Mohan Yadav held 14 one-on-one meetings with investors from the wellness and hospitality sectors, during which they discussed ground-level requirements, investment-friendly policies and priority areas. An MoU was inked between the National Institute of Pharmaceutical Education and Research-Ahmedabad and MP Industrial Development Corporation on the occasion under which the Ujjain Medical Device Park will receive technical and academic support. Anuraag singh Our correspondent in Madhya Pradesh
Hans India
35 minutes ago
- Hans India
Bengaluru stampede: Sidda's political secretary sacked
Bengaluru: The political secretary of Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah, K Govindraju, has been sacked, and the state intelligence department head, Hemant Nimbalkar, has been transferred over the Bengaluru stampede that claimed 11 lives. Govindraju is also the head of the state Olympic association and the key person who pressured the Chief Minister to hold the RCB victory event at Vidhana Soudha. The Karnataka government has taken several steps in the wake of the unfortunate incident, including the filing of FIRs against the representatives of Royal Challengers Bangalore (RCB). A political row has also erupted in the state with the BJP accusing the Congress-led state government of making the police a 'scapegoat" in the incident. Hitting back, Siddaramaiah on Friday criticised the saffron regiment for politicising the stampede at Bengaluru's M Chinnaswamy Stadium. The CM stated that action was taken against officials who were found to be 'visibly responsible" and 'negligent in their duty." 'They are doing it for politics. I don't do politics. We have taken action against those who were visibly responsible and found to be negligent in their duty," he said.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
U.S. lawmaker tells Pakistan delegation to eliminate ‘vile' terror group Jaish-e-Mohammed
A senior American lawmaker has told a visiting Pakistani delegation, led by Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, that the country should do "all it can' to eliminate the 'vile' terrorist group Jaish-e-Mohammed as well as ensure protection of religious minorities. The Pakistani delegation met Congressman Brad Sherman on Thursday (June 5) , timing their visit to the U.S. capital around the same time as a multi-party delegation of Indian parliamentarians led by Congress MP Shashi Tharoor is in Washington DC. The all-party delegation is briefing key interlocutors about Operation Sindoor in the wake of the Pahalgam terror attack and India's strong resolve to fight terrorism emanating from Pakistan. In a post on X, Sherman said that he 'emphasised to the Pakistani delegation the importance of combatting terrorism, and in particular, the group Jaish-e-Mohammed, who murdered my constituent Daniel Pearl in 2002'. During my discussion with the #Pakistan delegation yesterday, I raised the critical issue of water for Sindh. The Indus River is the lifeline for tens of millions of Pakistanis, and protecting that water resource is vital. I am also very concerned to hear of unrest in the city… — Congressman Brad Sherman (@BradSherman) June 6, 2025 Terrorist Omar Saeed Sheikh was convicted of orchestrating the 2002 kidnapping and murder of Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl. Mr. Sherman said Pearl's family continues to live in his district and 'Pakistan should do all it can to eliminate this vile group and combat terrorism in the region'. Mr. Bhutto also landed in the U.S. at the same time as the Tharoor-led delegation. Mr. Bhutto met UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres with his delegation as well as Security Council Ambassadors in New York, and later travelled to Washington in Pakistan's bid to internationalise the conflict with India as well as the Kashmir issue but instead got instructed to deal with terrorism emanating from its soil. The U.S. lawmaker also told the Pakistani delegation that the protection of religious minorities in Pakistan remains an important issue. "Christians, Hindus and Ahmadiyya Muslims living in Pakistan must be allowed to practice their faith and participate in the democratic system without fear of violence, persecution, discrimination, or an unequal justice system.' Sherman further urged the Pakistani delegation to relay to their government the need to free Dr Shakil Afridi, who continues to languish in prison for helping the United States kill Osama bin Laden. 'Freeing Dr Afridi represents an important step in bringing closure for victims of 9/11,' he said. Afridi is a Pakistani physician who helped the CIA run a polio vaccination programme in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province to collect DNA samples of bin Laden's family. Afridi was arrested by Pakistani authorities shortly after the American raid on bin Laden's compound in Abbottabad in May 2011. In 2012, a Pakistani court sentenced Afridi to 33 years in prison.
