Eight years on, Mulcahy Report into alleged planning corruption remains unpublished
The Department of Housing's position on publishing a report into accusations of planning corruption in Donegal has not changed — eight years since its completion.
The Mulcahy Report was completed in June 2017 but has still not been published despite changes in government due to concerns over the nature of the contents and fears that some may be defamatory.
Sources have said only a small number of copies of the report are in circulation.
In 2015, Rory Mulcahy SC was appointed to carry out a review into claims made by whistleblower Gerard Convie, alleging irregularities within the planning department of a local council during the early 2000s.
Rory Mulcahy SC, who was appointed in 2015 to carry out a review into claims made by whistleblower Gerard Convie. File picture: David Keane
Mr Convie had previously contested the findings of an internal review into his claims, which cast doubt on his motivations, by taking legal action in the High Court.
In 2013, the Department of the Environment was compelled to retract that internal review, reverse its conclusions, and issue an apology to Mr Convie.
He had submitted a dossier containing 20 sample cases to the government in 2010, which led then environment minister John Gormley to initiate an independent review.
However, that process was discontinued in 2011 following a change in government.
Mr Gormley's successor, Phil Hogan, instead commissioned an internal review. Completed in 2012, it found no evidence of wrongdoing and questioned Mr Convie's reasons for raising the allegations.
Mr Mulcahy completed his report in June 2017, but it has not yet been made public.
Asked this week if the report might be published, the Department of Housing said its position was unchanged. A statement said: 'The minister is considering the report and will bring this matter to Government for consideration in due course.
'The Attorney General's office has been consulted on both the content of the report and also on the issue of its potential publication and dissemination.
The review is a scoping report and as such it does not make findings as to the truth or otherwise of allegations that have been made by an individual against named persons.
'[T]his is a matter that requires careful consideration given that the scoping report details unproven allegations against named persons.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
16 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Frances Black ‘98pc sure' she won't run for presidency
The Independent senator was speaking as she announced details of a High Court action against the listing of Airbnb properties in the occupied Palestinian territories. Since tabling the Occupied Territories Bill she has been linked to running in the presidential election due to take place later this year. She has told the Irish Independent she is '98pc sure that I won't be running' but is leaving open the two per cent possibility 'because I have a responsibility – if people are coming to me – to consider that.' Asked if she was in discussions with parties of the left about being their agreed candidate, she said: 'Initially they came to me in February. I have had no conversations since. So it has just grown out of all proportion.' If she was to run under a left banner it would 'of course be all parties of the left,' she said, including Sinn Féin. The draft version of the Occupied Territories Bill – first tabled by Senator Black in 2018 to ban trade with Israeli entities based in the Occupied Palestinian Territories – is expected to be published this week. It will be referred to an Oireachtas committee which will hold three meetings to scrutinise it, before being voted on in the Oireachtas. It is unlikely that the current timeframe of being passed before the summer can be met. Ms Black said she is 'absolutely 100pc certain' that it is legally possible to include trade in goods in this Bill. She was speaking at the launch of a set of coordinated legal actions being taken in the US, UK and Ireland targeting Airbnb listings is Israel's illegal settlements in Occupied Palestinian territories. Airbnb has over 300 accommodations listed in illegal settlements and while it previously said they would be removed that decision was since reversed. A number of organisations including the Global Legal Action Network (GLAN) as well as the Ireland Palestine Alliance have launched a High Court action challenging 'the refusal of gardaí to investigate Airbnb Ireland and its senior executives for alleged criminal activity in Israeli settlements'. The group said: 'The acts of land appropriation, displacement and transfer of civilian population into occupied territory that facilitate the Israeli settlements are defined as war crimes and crimes against humanity under international law and related Irish legislation.'
Irish Independent
20 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Planned 63 housing scheme for Sligo placed on hold as Minister queries costs
The houses in Sligo were due to be built at Rathellen, Finisklin. Sligo is one of six areas affected in a total of 500 homes across the country. The social housing developments were understood to be near shovel-ready and were to be delivered under a public private partnership (PPP) scheme across six sites. Councillors have been forwarded a letter from the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage outlining how Dublin City Council were the lead local authority for PPP Bundle 3 which comprises 6 sites: Dublin (3) Sligo (1) Kildare (1) and Wicklow (1). The email from the DHLGH outlined how after careful evaluation of the costs associated with the 486 homes which were to be delivered under PPP Bundle 3, the Department has decided not to proceed with contract award It also states that the Department, the NDFA and the relevant Local Authorities remain fully committed to delivering the social housing that PPP Bundle 3. It said these social homes were very much needed and remain a priority for Government, the Department and the relevant Local Authorities. These 486 homes will instead be delivered by way of an alternative procurement and delivery strategy. Sligo County Council's Housing Capital Team are reviewing the options available for an alternative procurement and delivery strategy for the Rathellen site. This will require the agreement of the department. Housing Minister James Browne said: 'After careful evaluation of the costs associated with the 486 homes which were to be delivered under PPP Bundle 3, the Department has decided not to proceed with contract award on a value for money basis,' The decision by the Minister for Housing not to proceed with the project has been described as as a serious setback by the Cathaoirleach of the council, Cllr Declan Bree. 'There are in excess of 1,600 households on the Council's housing waiting list and in this context the delay in proceeding with the 63 units in Finisklin is unacceptable.' he said. ADVERTISEMENT The first phase of the project was to include 63 units including 18 Duplexes, 39 new houses, and 6 converted units in the existing Rathellen House. 'Given the failure of the Minister and his Department to deliver this public private partnership deal we now need to see the Minister and the Government provide the necessary funding directly to the County Council so as we can deliver the scheme in a speedy and efficient manner.' Cllr Bree said.
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Jurisdiction refused by district court in Louth ‘gun' case
Tommy Leddy, Moneymore, Drogheda, is accused of unauthorised possession of an unbranded 9mm Luger calibre semi-automatic pistol and unauthorised possession of 10 rounds of 9mm Luger calibre ammunition, at Moneymore, on March 4 last. Court presenter Sgt John O'Hehir said that DPP directions were not available. A ballistics report was awaited. Solicitor Paul Moore said that his client was in custody since March 5. Mr Leddy had been granted High Court bail but was unable to meet a cash lodgement condition. Judge Gráinne Malone said it was not a matter suitable for the district court and refused jurisdiction. The defendant was remanded in custody to June 23. A date of July 21 was reserved for service of a book of evidence. Judge Malone said that the DPP has had 'ample opportunity'. The accused was entitled to have matters expedited.
