Eight years on, Mulcahy Report into alleged planning corruption remains unpublished
The Department of Housing's position on publishing a report into accusations of planning corruption in Donegal has not changed — eight years since its completion.
The Mulcahy Report was completed in June 2017 but has still not been published despite changes in government due to concerns over the nature of the contents and fears that some may be defamatory.
Sources have said only a small number of copies of the report are in circulation.
In 2015, Rory Mulcahy SC was appointed to carry out a review into claims made by whistleblower Gerard Convie, alleging irregularities within the planning department of a local council during the early 2000s.
Rory Mulcahy SC, who was appointed in 2015 to carry out a review into claims made by whistleblower Gerard Convie. File picture: David Keane
Mr Convie had previously contested the findings of an internal review into his claims, which cast doubt on his motivations, by taking legal action in the High Court.
In 2013, the Department of the Environment was compelled to retract that internal review, reverse its conclusions, and issue an apology to Mr Convie.
He had submitted a dossier containing 20 sample cases to the government in 2010, which led then environment minister John Gormley to initiate an independent review.
However, that process was discontinued in 2011 following a change in government.
Mr Gormley's successor, Phil Hogan, instead commissioned an internal review. Completed in 2012, it found no evidence of wrongdoing and questioned Mr Convie's reasons for raising the allegations.
Mr Mulcahy completed his report in June 2017, but it has not yet been made public.
Asked this week if the report might be published, the Department of Housing said its position was unchanged. A statement said: 'The minister is considering the report and will bring this matter to Government for consideration in due course.
'The Attorney General's office has been consulted on both the content of the report and also on the issue of its potential publication and dissemination.
The review is a scoping report and as such it does not make findings as to the truth or otherwise of allegations that have been made by an individual against named persons.
'[T]his is a matter that requires careful consideration given that the scoping report details unproven allegations against named persons.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Irish woman 'in fear' ahead of release of main suspect in Madeleine McCann probe
An Irishwoman who alleged she was raped at knifepoint by the main suspect in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann fears he will seek her out after his release from prison. Christian Brueckner, 48, is due to be freed from a German jail in September after serving his sentence for the rape of a 72-year-old woman in Portugal in 2005. Hazel Behan, 41, who has waived her right to anonymity, said: 'His sentence may be ending but mine never did. I have lived with fear every day for 21 years. 'Fear I'll see him. Fear he'll find out where I live and hunt me down. I also have fear that he'll do to someone else what he did to me. 'I wouldn't put anything past a person like him. A leopard doesn't change his spots.' Brueckner was acquitted by a German court over the violent rape of Ms Behan at her apartment in Praia da Rocha in Portugal. Later this year she will discover the outcome of her German High Court appeal against his acquittal for raping her, another woman and a girl in Portugal in 2004. Ms Behan accused the Portuguese authorities of 'inaction' in identifying and prosecuting Bruckner. In April, she lodged an application to the European Court of Human Rights against over their handling of her attack. Ms Behan also expressed her sympathy and support for Madeleine's family. Maddie was just three years old went missing in Praia da Luz while on holiday with her family in 2007. Ms Behan said: 'I cannot begin to imagine what they continue to go through every day.' German and Portuguese police and firefighters carried out a three-day search of an area near Praia da Luz last week in the latest fruitless efforts to find out what happened to the missing child. Ms Behan also spoke about Brueckner's impending release in an exclusive interview with this newspaper earlier this year. She said 'He knows who I am. Well, he always knew who I was, I just didn't know who he was. 'But I suppose now, at this stage, he knows me a lot better as this person that I am now. But I can't live in that fear, if you know what I mean? 'I have to remind myself all the time that, you know, I am not that kind of person. 'I don't live that kind of lifestyle at all like, in fact, quite the opposite, thankfully. 'But I can't allow for him to take any more from me than he already has and I'm not going to give him that. 'Like, is there a fear in the back of my mind? 100 per cent. But my fear isn't just, as I said, about me. It's bigger than that. I mean, if he wants to come at me again, he better put his boxing gloves on because I'm ready for him this time. I'm not 20 anymore. I'm not a baby and I will kick ten shades of sh*te out of him if he came near me again. But, on a real human level and not to be funny or anything, but yeah he terrifies me.' The court ultimately acquitted Brueckner in October of raping Ms Behan - ruling that there was insufficient evidence to find the convicted rapist and child abuser guilty. Ms Behan also spoke in detail about the trauma she suffered as a result of the horrific crime in 2004 - and how it continues to affect her to this day. 'You're very much stuck there. Not by choice. It's like something is just imprinted on you. The sad thing about it is I didn't choose that. This is something that, not to sound dramatic, but it murders the person that you were. You're gone,' she said. Speaking about living with that trauma, Ms Behan said she is still constantly battling with the horror she suffered 20 years on. 'Nothing is ever going to take away the fact that that happened. So for me, I think the hardest part of that was the control I felt he still had in my life, and still does have and I hate admitting that,' she told us. 'I have developed, you know, different quirks in my life, like I won't travel on holidays without, like, a portable door lock because of him. My family has suffered because of him. My friends have suffered. Like this is all because of him.'
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Eight years on, Mulcahy Report into alleged planning corruption remains unpublished
The Department of Housing's position on publishing a report into accusations of planning corruption in Donegal has not changed — eight years since its completion. The Mulcahy Report was completed in June 2017 but has still not been published despite changes in government due to concerns over the nature of the contents and fears that some may be defamatory. Sources have said only a small number of copies of the report are in circulation. In 2015, Rory Mulcahy SC was appointed to carry out a review into claims made by whistleblower Gerard Convie, alleging irregularities within the planning department of a local council during the early 2000s. Rory Mulcahy SC, who was appointed in 2015 to carry out a review into claims made by whistleblower Gerard Convie. File picture: David Keane Mr Convie had previously contested the findings of an internal review into his claims, which cast doubt on his motivations, by taking legal action in the High Court. In 2013, the Department of the Environment was compelled to retract that internal review, reverse its conclusions, and issue an apology to Mr Convie. He had submitted a dossier containing 20 sample cases to the government in 2010, which led then environment minister John Gormley to initiate an independent review. However, that process was discontinued in 2011 following a change in government. Mr Gormley's successor, Phil Hogan, instead commissioned an internal review. Completed in 2012, it found no evidence of wrongdoing and questioned Mr Convie's reasons for raising the allegations. Mr Mulcahy completed his report in June 2017, but it has not yet been made public. Asked this week if the report might be published, the Department of Housing said its position was unchanged. A statement said: 'The minister is considering the report and will bring this matter to Government for consideration in due course. 'The Attorney General's office has been consulted on both the content of the report and also on the issue of its potential publication and dissemination. The review is a scoping report and as such it does not make findings as to the truth or otherwise of allegations that have been made by an individual against named persons. '[T]his is a matter that requires careful consideration given that the scoping report details unproven allegations against named persons.'
Sunday World
14 hours ago
- Sunday World
Irish woman who accused Madeleine McCann suspect of rape fears he will hunt her down if freed
Christian Brueckner (48), is due to be freed from a German jail in September Christian Brueckner was tried in Germany for Ms Behan's rape and was found not guilty on the basis of insufficient evidence (Getty) An Irish woman who alleged she was raped at knifepoint by the main suspect in the disappearance of toddler Madeleine McCann says she fears he will seek her out following his release from prison. Christian Brueckner (48), is due to be freed from a German jail in September after completing his sentence for the rape of a 72-year-old US woman in Praia da Luz, Portugal in 2005. Hazel Behan (41), who has waived her right to anonymity, said she fears the German man will 'hunt her down'. 'His sentence may be ending but mine never did. I have lived with fear every day for 21 years,' she told The Sun. 'Fear that I'll see him. Fear that he'll find out where I live and hunt me down. I also have fear that he'll do to someone else what he did to me. 'I've called him out in a public forum and I have genuine concern he could confront me. 'I wouldn't put anything past a person like him. 'If he is released, I will worry for every woman and child who, like me, believes the justice system is protecting them. 'A leopard doesn't change his spots.' Brueckner, a convicted sex offender, was acquitted by a German court in relation to the charge of violent rape of Ms Behan at her apartment in Praia da Rocha in Portugal's Algarve. Later this year, Ms Behan expects to discover the outcome of her High Court appeal in Germany against his acquittal for raping her, another woman and a girl in Portugal in 2004. Hazel Behan (Steve Humphreys) Today's News in 90 Seconds - 08 June 2025 Ms Behan has accused the Portuguese authorities of alleged 'inaction' in identifying and prosecuting Brueckner. In April, she lodged an application to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) against the Portuguese authorities over their handling of her attack. Ms Behan also expressed her sympathy and support for the Leicestershire-based family of Madeleine who went missing in Praia da Luz while on holiday with her family in 2007 when she was three years old. 'As a parent, I cannot begin to imagine what they have gone through and continue to go through every day for the past 18 years,' she said. German and Portuguese police and firefighters carried out a three-day search of an area near Praia da Luz last week in the latest efforts to find out what happened to the missing child.
