5 years after national security law, has Hong Kong bounced back?
In the second of a two-part series on the national security law, we look at how the city has had to battle a negative narrative over the past five years. Read part 1
here
Soon after Hong Kong reopened in early 2023 as harsh pandemic restrictions were finally lifted, veteran lawmaker Regina Ip Lau Suk-yee embarked on a solo mission to the West.
Visiting Brussels to meet European Union officials in September 2023, she sought to explain fundamental political and legal changes in the city and how it would not be deterred by its critics.
Beijing had reshaped the political landscape, first by imposing a sweeping
national security law in 2020, then by introducing major electoral reforms to ensure that only 'patriots' ruled the city.
By then too, a dark shadow had settled over the city, blanketing more nuanced and varied views about Hong Kong into one coagulated negative narrative that it had become a police state. With the national security law, no one was safe.
Diplomats, bankers and business people were told to carry burner phones when entering Hong Kong. The city's future was over, its past a romanticised era where democracy reigned, or so this gloomy tale went.
It did not help that Hong Kong residents had also left the city in droves, drawn by easier pathways to emigration laid out by Western nations and partly because of the pandemic restrictions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
HKFP
an hour ago
- HKFP
Hong Kong gov't slams top US diplomat in city over ‘biased remarks' about national security law, Jimmy Lai
The Hong Kong government has slammed the top US diplomat in the city for making 'untrue and biased remarks' about the Beijing-imposed national security law and jailed media mogul Jimmy Lai. The government said in a statement issued late Thursday night that it strongly condemned remarks made by outgoing Consul General of the US to Hong Kong, Gregory May. Authorities accused him of smearing the national security law and its work to safeguard national security. May, who will assume a new role as deputy head at the US embassy in Beijing next week, on Thursday said he was concerned about the treatment of Lai as well as 'other political prisoners.' '[US] President [Donald] Trump himself has mentioned Jimmy Lai several times now, and he is very concerned about the fate of Mr Lai,' May told reporters after delivering a speech at a US Independence Day reception at The Murray hotel in Admiralty. 'There are many other people, unfortunately, in Hong Kong who are in jail for [the] peaceful expression of political views, for putting things on the internet,' he added. In response, Hong Kong authorities said it 'strongly urges US politicians to immediately stop interfering' in the city's affairs. 'The suggestion that persons or organisations with certain backgrounds should be immune from legal sanctions for their illegal acts and activities… is totally contrary to the spirit of the rule of law,' the government wrote. Lai has pleaded not guilty to two counts of conspiring to collude with foreign forces under the national security law as well as a third charge of conspiring to publish 'seditious' materials under a colonial-era legislation. He has been in custody since December 2020. The departing consul general also criticised what he called 'transnational repression,' referring to Hong Kong police issuing arrest warrants and bounties on overseas pro-democracy activists. One of the activists, Joey Siu, has US citizenship. 'It's very disappointing to see, over my three years here, attempts by Hong Kong authorities to enforce the national security law within the borders of the United States against US persons,' May said. 'This is attempts to restrict the free speech of people in the United States and unfortunately, we're seeing Hong Kong authorities go after the family members of these overseas activists, and that's a very disturbing,' he added. The Hong Kong government rejected May's criticism, saying in its statement that people should not comment on Lai's ongoing proceedings. It also defended human rights protection in the national security law, saying that defendants were entitled to a fair trial. It added that extraterritorial effect for the city's security laws 'fully aligns with the principles of international law, international practice and common practice adopted in various countries and regions.' Beijing inserted national security legislation directly into Hong Kong's mini-constitution in June 2020 following a year of pro-democracy protests and unrest. It criminalised subversion, secession, collusion with foreign forces and terrorist acts – broadly defined to include disruption to transport and other infrastructure. The move gave police sweeping new powers and led to hundreds of arrests amid new legal precedents, while dozens of civil society groups disappeared. The authorities say it restored stability and peace to the city, rejecting criticism from trade partners, the UN and NGOs.
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
China should be alert to risk of US being drawn into war by allies, analyst says
There is more risk of a global military conflict breaking out under Donald Trump 's leadership, with the US more likely to be drawn into wars involving smaller nations or allies, according to Chinese analysts. The assessment came after the United States joined Israel's war against Iran last weekend, carrying out military strikes on three nuclear sites in the Islamic Republic. US officials have signalled that the operation was a one-off intervention and – hours after Iran launched a missile attack on a US base in Qatar – Trump announced an imminent ceasefire between Israel and Iran. China, a key partner of Iran, condemned the American operation, saying it breached international law. 'Trump's current term in office is not about establishing a new international order – it's accelerating the deglobalisation trend that began during his previous presidency,' said Yan Xuetong, a foreign policy expert and international relations professor at Tsinghua University. 'The result is increased military conflicts and heightened uncertainty in the international community,' he said on Thursday during a press briefing on next week's World Peace Forum in Beijing.
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
What's ahead for US-China tariffs, trade talks? Top experts weigh in
After months of chest-thumping, accusations and threats, look for US-China trade relations to weather an uneasy pause as the giants retreat from extremist positions, guard against backtracking and alter the negotiating dynamic toward an eventual agreement, analysts and former US officials say. The breather follows this month's London sit-down after the two engaged in a high-stakes tariff battle then went for each other's jugulars, with China blocking rare earth exports and Washington choking off jet engines and semiconductor software. 'Absolutely the trend lines point in the direction of a truce, a pause, a respite in US-China tensions,' said Jeremy Chan, a senior analyst at Eurasia Group. 'We're seeing signs of short-term stability that weren't there even a month ago.' The pause, which went into effect on May 12, is set to last three months if it is not extended. That is likely to result in US tariffs being capped at 55 per cent and China's at 10 per cent, according to analysts, with Washington using the hiatus to ensure that Beijing resumes rare earths exports and Beijing seeking more organised negotiations to moderate Trump's unpredictable approach. 05:19 How are Chinese citizens feeling the effects of the US-China tariff war? How are Chinese citizens feeling the effects of the US-China tariff war?
