Sky Ireland tells court it is not obliged to give end of contract notice
The Communications Regulator is seeking High Court orders requiring Sky Ireland Ltd to end its practice of automatically renewing customers' contracts without first informing them their contracts are about to end or of alternative tariffs.
Comreg claims Sky is in breach of 2022 EU regulations requiring communications service providers to inform consumers in a prominent and timely manner of the end of the contractual commitment and means by which to terminate the contract.
Advertisement
It says Sky is also contravening the regulations by failing to provide consumers with "best tariff advice" before the contract is automatically prolonged.
They are the only one of the five big providers refusing to do so, Comreg says.
Sky disputes Comreg's interpretation of the relevant legal provisions and says they only apply to contracts with a fixed duration. Its customers' contracts are subscription contracts of indeterminate duration, it says.
The regulations, Sky argues, are designed to address the potential harm of consumers getting automatically prolonged in the contract for a second term without their knowledge.
Advertisement
This harm does not arise in relation to Sky customers as its contracts do not follow this type of model in Ireland, it argues.
It also says the ultimate interpretation of the regulations is for the courts to decide.
On Monday, Mr Justice Mark Sanfey admitted Comreg's proceedings against Sky to the fast track Commercial Court on the application of Eoin McCullough SC, for the regulator, and on consent from Andrew Fitzpatrick SC, for Sky. The case was adjourned to December.
In an affidavit seeking entry of the case to the commercial list, Miriam Kilraine, Comreg compliance operations manager, said the purpose of end of contract information and best tariff advice, when a contract is nearing end and about to be "auto-prolonged", is that customers are afforded an opportunity of making an informed decision to stay with their current provider on the same or different package or to switch to a new provider.
Advertisement
This is important particularly as customers may be losing discounts and therefore incurring higher prices and, in the case of Sky customers, this could include bundled TV, broadband and telephone services, she said.
As part of its review and enforcement functions, Comreg began an investigation last September and Virgin Media, Eircom, Three and Vodafone all confirmed they are in compliance but Sky said it did not do so.
Further investigations into Sky followed and in December Sky said it would not be complying because of its interpretation of the regulations.
Entertainment
Former Sky News host Dermot Murnaghan diagnosed wi...
Read More
Ms Kilraine said it is clear there is a fundamental disagreement between the parties regarding the interpretation of the relevant legal provisions in this case.
It is Comreg's position that Sky has failed and continues to fail to comply with its obligations under the 2022 regulations, she said.
She also said Sky's UK arm, Sky UK Ltd, has taken a different position to its Irish counterpart and provides best tariff information to its customers.
This followed enforcement action against Sky UK by the UK watchdog, Ofcom, in 2021 which concluded in Ofcom's favour last December, Ms Kilraine said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
Why is Starmer ignoring Britain's tech sector?
The government's hotly-anticipated industrial strategy has at last arrived. In it are a handful of bold new announcements, and a lot of old recycled ones. There are some big shiny spending commitments – a couple of billion pledged here, a few hundred million spent there. But perhaps the most consequential element, especially for the tech sector, is a note right at the back of the document on page 152. It expresses an ambition for procurement rules to be consistent with the government's wider industrial strategy to grow the economy – or as the document puts it in fluffy Whitehall-speak, contracts must 'set at least one social value key performance indicator'. I've spoken to several British tech firms who say that current rules have become rigged against them More than £400 billion of the public sector's annual budget relates to procurement contracts. The government is the single-largest customer for virtually every kind of private sector service, including in areas like software. So the way it organises procurement has huge economic implications, much more so than throwing some cash at AI research or helping build a supercomputer. Current procurement practices in tech do not seem to align with the government growth mission. A cursory flick through the government's procurement database finds that at least £15 billion in software contracts have been awarded or part-awarded to one of Microsoft, Amazon, Oracle, Palantir and IBM since 2020, dwarfing any and all UK tech firms. That is the continuation of a longstanding trend of the UK being far more likely than its peers to contract services overseas. According to a 2021 EU study of the procurement market, more than a third of major UK government contracts are awarded to foreign suppliers, well above the EU average of 22 per cent. The UK approach is also quite different from that of the US, where there is a longstanding home bias in procurement. According to a World Bank report, 'In the case of the US, the federal government openly and actively discriminates against foreign firms when making its sourcing decisions.' That was written in 2023, long before the arrival of Donald Trump's erratic America First tariff regime, which has massively accelerated this practice. It would be foolish for the UK government to do the same thing, and game procurement rules to guarantee British firms get all the money – that would lead to inefficiencies and poorer quality services. But I've spoken to several British tech firms who say that current rules have become rigged against them. Some have even been told they were ineligible to apply for contracts, despite having won the same ones a couple of years earlier. Whether that is due to successful lobbying of the all-powerful big tech firms, or Whitehall incompetence, is hard to say. But the door is now open for this to change. The question now is whether the government will deliver – and there are some warning signs that it won't. The Prime Minister seems far more interested in chatting with – and working with – US business leaders than he does with execs in Britain. Since last year, Keir Starmer has tweeted a picture of himself in a meeting with a CEO on only three occasions: with Blackrock, Bloomberg and Apple. And in this week's industrial strategy document, the government pledged training for UK workers by partnering with Microsoft, Google and Nvidia. After meeting with Nvidia's Jensen Huang earlier this month, Keir Starmer published a new 'memorandum of understanding between the UK and Nvidia' in which the two parties 'are collaborating to support the upskilling and reskilling of the UK workforce across industry, research and the public sector'. When the government set up a new board to advise on British industrial strategy in October, to the British tech sector's astonishment, its pick for the chair was a CEO at Microsoft. Nine days later, Microsoft signed a five-year deal with the government on 'digital transformation' which would allow public sector bodies 'access to cost savings' when they procure Microsoft services – and earlier this month, that CEO was awarded a damehood. This attitude pervades Whitehall, and can lead to big government spending decisions. Officials from the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) meet with US companies far more frequently than they have British ones, departmental records show. DSIT officials met with Google on at least eight occasions in the fourth quarter of last year — more meetings than for any other company. Starmer seems to think blowing billions on deals, collaborations and partnerships with big US tech firms will somehow support British industry. But if the government's industrial strategy is to have any lasting impact, he must pick up the phone to British business instead.
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
Trump tariffs fan calls by European metal producers for scrap export curbs
BRUSSELS, June 24 (Reuters) - Metal producers in the European Union are lobbying the bloc to impose export duties or curbs on scrap metal shipments "in the next few weeks" to stem a sharp increase in flows to the United States caused by the Trump administration's trade policies. Europe's metal producers are warning of a shortage of scrap and an upending of carbon-emission strategies after U.S. Donald Trump's 50% levy on imported steel and aluminium heightened demand, and sharply inflated prices, for tariff-free scrap. The aluminium industry is asking the EU to stem outflows using export authorisation measures, hitherto only used during the COVID pandemic, when the European Commission demanded companies request permission to export protective gear and vaccine doses. Export tariffs would be another option. "Scrap is a big issue," said Eurofer director general Axel Eggert. "We are asking for an export duty on scrap," he said highlighting that most non-EU producer countries had restrictions in place. Scrap is integral to the EU's push to reduce carbon emissions in the metal industry. Recycling saves up to 95% of the energy required for aluminium production and 80% for steel, the European Commission has said. Scrap metal exports to the United States nearly tripled to 6,028 metric tonnes in the first three months of 2025 versus the same period a year earlier, albeit from a low base, turning a trickle into a flood, said industry lobby group Europe Aluminium, which includes Alcoa (AA.N), opens new tab, Befesa ( opens new tab and AMAG Austria ( opens new tab. Total EU aluminium scrap exports were 345,000 metric tonnes in the first quarter this year, according to Europe Aluminium. With the United States now keeping its scrap, the EU will be left as the main exporting region, it said. Scrap exports were a growing problem for EU metal producers even before Trump imposed duties on imports of primary steel and aluminium in a bid to encourage U.S. domestic production, EU metal producers said. A record 19 million tonnes of ferrous scrap left the bloc in 2023, the majority to Turkey, but also to India, Egypt, Pakistan and the United States, said European steel association Eurofer, which includes Tata Steel ( opens new tab, Thyssenkrupp ( opens new tab and ArcelorMittal ( opens new tab. Metal producers cannot wait for the bloc to strike a trade deal with Trump before taking action, Europe Aluminium's head Paul Voss said. European officials have said the EU may not be able to strike a full deal by Trump's July 9 deadline. Export authorisations had not been used this way before "but extraordinary times call for extraordinary action," Voss added, calling for measures "in the coming weeks". The EU sees itself as a champion of free trade and export curbs are rare. Beyond pandemic restrictions, EU export controls have been limited to shipments of arms, products that have military uses and for countries subject to sanctions. The European Commission said it was engaging regularly with metal producers and recyclers, assessing the market situation. It said it would determine in the third quarter whether a trade measure was necessary for steel, aluminium and copper. The tariffs have given U.S. metal producers incentive to maximise their domestic purchase of scrap metal and scour overseas markets. Industry players said a so-called "arbitrage window" - a short-lived price gap between two markets - had hit around $750 per tonne with the 50% tariff. "If that arbitrage window stays, we will see massive damage to companies that invested the most into the Green Deal," Rob van Gils, CEO of Austria's Hammerer Aluminium Industries, said, referring to the EU's green policy agenda to steer the bloc to carbon emission neutrality by 2050. Van Gils said companies which rely on buying scrap would struggle if local scrap costs neared or even exceeded the market price of final product, or end up buying primary metal from third countries like India with high carbon footprints. "The CO2 footprint of the aluminium industry will be down the toilet," van Gils continued. Europe's scrap sellers oppose export restrictions. Recycling industry group EuRIC said there was no shortage of scrap in Europe and that EU demand only absorbed some 80% of supply for steel. Eurofer's Eggert said export restrictions would help prevent rival producers overseas from buying EU scrap to then sell low-carbon recycled steel back to the bloc. "We are not asking for a ban, but we need to retain more scrap, or incentivise its use scrap in Europe for our decarbonisation," he said.
Finextra
6 hours ago
- Finextra
Bank of Ireland launches kids account
Bank of Ireland has launched a new current account designed for children and young teens between the ages of seven and 15. 0 Family or friends can lodge money directly into the 'Smart Start' account and, uniquely in the Irish market, parents/legal guardians can set up an account for each of their children for free. The account, which is owned by the parent/legal guardian, comes with extensive parental controls and safeguards, including spend limits and alerts, as well as access to Bank of Ireland's 24/7 fraud team. There is no monthly fee, the child has access to their own app and debit card, and deposits can be made online and in 1000 locations across Ireland, including Bank of Ireland branches and An Post locations. Customers can also open a 'Smart Start Money Pot' as part of their application. This is a separate deposit account managed by the parent/legal guardian, with a variable interest rate of 2.0% AER. Susan Russell, CEO Retail Ireland, Bank of Ireland says: 'We designed the Smart Start Account so children and young teens can learn real-life money skills and build good spending and saving habits. "We want to safeguard children from the increasing threat of fraud, so we included extensive protective features to enhance their financial wellbeing, including access to our 24/7 fraud helpline.'
