Pembrokeshire council deputy chief ‘unacceptable' words row
A SPECIAL Pembrokeshire council meeting which includes a motion of no confidence in its deputy leader is to take place next week.
The notice of a motion of no confidence call, by Cllr Huw Murphy, leader of the Independent Group, has been backed by fellow members.
It is centrally due to concerns by Cllr Murphy about Deputy Leader Cllr Paul Miller's comments made during an April Cabinet debate on The Welsh in Education Strategic Plan (WESP), which led to a successful 'call-in' on that Cabinet decision by Cllr Murphy.
In a heated discussion at a scrutiny committee prior to the matter going back to a special May Cabinet meeting, Cllr Murphy claimed Cllr Miller's comments showed 'a bias against the provision of Welsh Language education'.
WESP is a ten-year plan, mandatory for all local authorities in Wales, that outlines how Welsh medium education will be developed within the authority.
The WESP aims to increase the proportion of school year groups taught through the medium of Welsh and focuses on Year 1 learners. The plans also aim to contribute to the Welsh Government's goal of having 1 million Welsh speakers by 2050, as part of the 'Cymraeg 2050' initiative.
Pembrokeshire County Council's schools and learning overview and scrutiny committee met on May 14 to consider the 'call-in', specifically an amendment by Cllr Miller to its previous recommendation to note a report.
The scrutiny committee voted for Cabinet to consider removing an amendment: 'That the Director of Education be tasked with exploring how demand for Welsh language can be better captured.
'In particular this work should focus on disaggregating demand for Welsh Medium Education from other school choice considerations such as perceptions of learning outcomes, facility quality etc,' replacing it with: 'That the progress being made against the objectives set out in the Welsh in Education Strategic Plan, and Welsh Government's feedback to the Council's 2023/24 Annual Report, be noted.'
Cllr Murphy's lengthy 'call-in' said: 'Some comments made by Cabinet appeared to display a degree of bias against the provision of Welsh Language education.'
He quoted Cllr Miller from that meeting, in relation to Welsh medium Ysgol Caer Ellen: '…basically we've opened Caer Ellen and loads of people went there and therefore by definition they must want a Welsh Language education.
'I'm not sure how true that is, might be partly true, might be completely true but also it might not be. I know quite a few parents in that particular area obviously given my constituency in Neyland West and all of them that I know who send their children to Caer Ellen honestly couldn't give a toss whether it was Welsh or English, they're looking for a good school and so what they've got is a good school in Caer Ellen, great facilities, and so they're sending their kids there.'
Cllr Murphy went on to say: 'Councillor Miller then continues and commented 'honestly the fact its Welsh medium has got nothing to do with anything so how do we differentiate those looking for a good school' and re-asserts this point where it appears that Cllr Miller by his comments does not think parents select Caer Ellen on the basis of providing Welsh education, rather that it's a 'good school' and requests data be collected to ascertain from parents why they choose Welsh Language education.'
Cllr Murphy also raised concerns that some members of the Cabinet 'had little idea of the workings' of Fforwm Cymraeg, a committee which examines in greater detail the provision of Welsh language education in Pembrokeshire, and any data collection 'would be a clear indication that some Cabinet members do not believe parental choice in electing Welsh Language education'.
At the May 14 meeting, Cllr Murphy said he had reported the matter to the Welsh Language Commissioner, who had shared his concerns, and was 'aghast what Pembrokeshire County Council recommended.'
Cllr Miller responded saying there was no evidence members displayed a limited knowledge of WESP, and allegations that his comments displayed a degree of bias were 'entirely without merit,' standing by his words.
'It must be the case it is at least possible some parents are choosing Welsh medium schools other than because of the medium of Welsh. It's currently unknown; surely it's right the council seeks to understand the impact of other forces.'
He said Cllr Murphy was 'trying to make something out of nothing,' in 'a naked attempt to create outrage, trying to paint some in this council as anti-Welsh,' adding: 'Cllr Murphy should be deeply ashamed of his actions over the last week in trying to create artificial division in the county of Pembrokeshire.'
Cllr Murphy's call succeeded by seven votes to five, with the matter going to a May 21 extraordinary meeting of Pembrokeshire County Council's Cabinet.
That May 21 meeting led to the council issuing a statement: 'Following Cabinet in April it became clear that there were some concerns about the council potentially capturing information on the school choices made only by those parents choosing a Welsh Medium Education.
'To allay those concerns, the Cabinet today determined to explore collecting the information on the school choices made by all parents, resolving as follows: That the Director of Education be tasked with exploring how the demand for school places can be better captured.
'In particular this work should focus on understanding the weight parents give to the different choice considerations, including: language preference; learning outcomes; quality of facilities; transport provision; ALN provision, etc.
'As the council continues to consider proposals to modernise the school estate we believe it's important we have the best possible information available to ensure we make informed decisions in the best interests of pupils and parents.'
Following the lodging of a no-confidence call, a Pembrokeshire County Council spokesman has now said: 'Following a formal request submitted to the Presiding Member, an Extraordinary Meeting of Council will take place on Monday ,June 2, at 1pm.
'The purpose of the meeting will be to consider a Notice of Motion of no confidence in the Deputy Leader of Council.
'The agenda will be published in due course.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
38 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Cesc Fabregas says he believes in ‘long-term' Como project amid links to Inter
A first season in senior management for the 38-year-old ended with his reputation as a head coach significantly raised, reportedly catching the eye of Inter who are without a manager after Simone Inzaghi departed this week in the aftermath of Saturday's 5-0 Champions League final loss to Paris St Germain. Cesc Fabregas played for Chelsea and Arsenal in the Premier League (John Walton/PA) 'I really believe in the Como project,' Fabregas said at the SXSW event taking place in London, as reported by La Gazzetta della Sport. 'I started with this club because I was thinking about a long-term project. I don't want to finish my career at a club where there's a project for one or two years and then everything ends.' Fabregas, who is a minority shareholder of the club, joined Como as a player in 2022 and played out the final year of his career with the club in Serie B. After retiring the following summer, he joined the coaching staff, briefly taking charge of the first team as caretaker after boss Moreno Longo was sacked. Welsh coach Osian Roberts took charge for the remainder of the promotion-winning season while Fabregas completed his UEFA coaching qualifications, with the World Cup and Champions League-winner taking over last summer. 'I really believe in Como's long-term project,' he said. 'I arrived here as a player and I'm very, very happy because I get to work in the way that I want. We have the same goals and the same ambition. 'The President allows me to work the way I want, the way I see things. Fortunately, we share the same vision and have the same goal, which is to go as far as possible. 'We've become a really good team together, in a small town, in a small club but with big, very big ambitions for the future.' Inter meanwhile have signed Croatia international Petar Sucic from Dinamo Zagreb. The midfielder, who has seven international caps, played last season on loan at Bosnian side Zrinjski Mostar.
Wales Online
41 minutes ago
- Wales Online
‘My baby died after I was left alone by midwives in Welsh hospital'
'My baby died after I was left alone by midwives in Welsh hospital' Emily Brazier gave birth to Liliwen Thomas at University Hospital of Wales in the absence of medics and midwives Emily Brazier, pictured with partner Rhodri Thomas, claims their baby daughter Liliwen Iris Thomas died after she'd been left alone by midwives during labour (Image: Slater and Gordon ) A woman claims her baby died after she'd been left alone by midwives while she gave birth. Emily Brazier gave birth to daughter Liliwen Iris Thomas at University Hospital of Wales in Cardiff on October 10, 2022 in the absence of midwives or nurses who did not know she was giving birth. Emily claimed she had been given so much pain relief after being induced that she wasn't able to call for help and didn't realise she was in labour. Despite having a high-risk pregnancy and having been monitored by medics prior to going into labour, Emily said no-one was present in the room at the hospital when she had Liliwen, who died 20 hours later after being starved of oxygen. On Wednesday Cardiff and Vale University Health Board issued a statement saying its 'sincere thoughts and heartfelt condolences' were with Emily and her family. An inquest is due to take place and the health board said they will comment further after the conclusion of the hearing. Emily claimed: 'I'm angry at how I was left alone. For all the checks I had during my pregnancy, what were they for if I was going to be abandoned when it really mattered? 'Being left unattended with the gas and air, which I heavily overused due to non-existent monitoring, I then vividly remember peeling back the covers and seeing Liliwen there, completely still and lifeless. I can only describe it as a blood bath. That image will be with me forever. I still have flashbacks and nightmares and have been in counselling since.' Emily's partner and Liliwen's father Rhodri Thomas said he wasn't there at the time because of the health board's policy of partners and friends not being allowed to be on the ward between 9pm and 9am. Article continues below He said partners are allowed on the ward if the mother is in active labour. 'I should have been there,' he said. 'I would have pressed the call bell and alerted midwives.' Emily Brazier and Rhodri Thomas with daughter Liliwen Iris Thomas, who died hours after her birth in hospital (Image: Slater and Gordon ) Emily was closely monitored throughout her pregnancy and was undergoing induction due to her having low pregnancy associated plasma protein A (PAPP-A) – the same as she had with her older daughter Carys. She was under the care of a consultant during her pregnancy with Liliwen and had several scans over the months to ensure the baby's welfare. As part of her monitoring, it was flagged that when giving birth to Carys three years previously, her labour progressed extremely quickly after she was given pethidine and entonox pain medication, which she was administered again for Liliwen's birth. Stay informed on the latest health news by signing up to our newsletter here Liliwen was due on October 7 so Emily was booked in for an induction under PAPP-A protocols, but twice was sent home due to lack of bed availability. When Emily was eventually induced on October 9, as her labour progressed she was told there was no room in the delivery suite. Emily was given pethidine and codeine for pain relief and claimed she was left unattended with gas and air at around 11.50pm. At 2.15am on October 10 Emily recalls 'being in a cycle of puffing gas and air, passing out, and repeating'. She recalled: 'They took Liliwen away and rushed me up to the delivery suite, I had lost a lot of blood and needed stitches, IV fluids and a blood transfusion. All this happened while I was still on the induction ward with only curtains around my bed separating me from four other women. It must have been horrendous for them too.' Rhodri claimed he was not informed of what had happened at the hospital other than Emily had gone into labour. When he arrived he said he believed he was about to meet his newborn daughter. 'I got a taxi to the hospital and remember talking to the taxi driver excitedly about how I was about to meet my newborn child,' he said. 'When I got there and saw Emily, she was white as a ghost and in a bad way, she told me: 'I don't know if our baby is alive.'' The baby died at University Hospital of Wales in Cardiff in October 2022 and an inquest is due to take place (Image: WalesOnline/Rob Browne ) Although Liliwen was put on life support she died later that same day. Her cause of death was given as perinatal asphyxia (lack of oxygen at birth), congenital bacterial infection and placental problems. Since that time, Emily and Rhodri say they have struggled psychologically, and Emily – who was studying to be a nurse at the time she had Liliwen – has opted against a career as a registered nurse after the trauma she suffered on a hospital ward. While the couple welcomed their third child, a son named Ellis, in December 2024, Emily says the grief of the loss of Liliwen continues to cast a shadow over the family's lives. 'So many happy memories and special family moments are tinged with sadness," she said. "I dread family events and Christmas as Liliwen will never be there, she will always be the missing piece, her death should never have happened and that's hard to live with.' A spokesperson for Cardiff and Vale University Health Board said: 'Our sincere thoughts and heartfelt condolences remain with Liliwen's family during this incredibly difficult time. The health board is fully engaged with the inquest process and it would be inappropriate to comment further until the inquest concludes.' Article continues below
Wales Online
an hour ago
- Wales Online
'How did you get it so wrong?' Mark Drakeford blasted over National Insurance shortfall
'How did you get it so wrong?' Mark Drakeford blasted over National Insurance shortfall The Welsh Government finance minister previously said the UK Government would fully cover the impact of its National Insurance changes but it later emerged that wasn't the case Mark Drakeford had said the National Insurance bill for public sector would be met by UK Government - it won't (Image: Rob Browne/WalesOnline ) Wales' finance minister has been asked to explain how he got it "so wrong" after previously saying the UK Government would fully cover the impact of its National Insurance changes on public bodies in Wales. In November the former First Minister told the Senedd extra money would be provided to plug the huge amount of money public sector organisations - like councils, health boards and government bodies - would have to pay. It has now emerged that the UK Government will only fund £185m of the £257m that its changes will cost. The Welsh Government has spent £36m of its reserves, but for this year alone there remains a gap of £36m. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here Charities and councils have warned that they face huge bills to make up the difference. Wales' 22 councils faced a £20m bill, they had predicted, while charities like Tenovus and Marie Curie have warned they will have to at least an additional £250,000 and £260,000 respectively. In November last year, Mr Drakeford told the Senedd: "The UK Government has said that it will provide compensation to public services for the additional national insurance contributions that public service employers will incur. The definition they are using of a public sector worker is the one used by the last government and set out in the Office for National Statistics classifications." However, the UK Government instead chose to use the Barnett formula to determine how much money to give to the devolved nations. Because the public sector is larger in Wales than it is in England, there is a shortfall. Article continues below Conservative MS Sam Rowlands told Mr Drakeford that was "clearly significantly different to what you would have expected" but said he had given guarantees. "You said that there would be additional funding for public sector workers to cover the cost of employer National Insurance contributions, adding that the Treasury would provide full funding to deal with the National Insurance contributions of employers, and now, as I just explained, they haven't provided the full funding as you assured Members of this Senedd. "So, it is concerning that, in November, you were giving guarantees that you are now having to walk away from because of your colleagues in Westminster. But indeed, organisations would have heard those assurances and would have made plans based on those assurances only for them not to come to fruition. "How did you get it so wrong and how can people trust your assurances again in the future?" Mr Drakeford responded: "The assurances that were given in November were based on the statement of funding policy. The statement of funding policy does seem clear to me. It says that when any one of the four governments in the United Kingdom takes a decision that creates costs for any other government, then the government that creates those costs must meet that bill in full. "That, I think, would have been the right way to have dealt with these national insurance contributions. Article continues below "The UK Government takes a different view and has used the Barnett formula instead. We continue to make the case to them for proceeding in a way that I think is consistent with what the statement of funding policy would require." Mr Rowlands said it was "another example of that working together not happening for people here in Wales". He reiterated concerns from the charity sector, which will not be eligible for any additional funding.
