MAHA report cites fake studies, White House blames format
A highly-publicized U.S. government report on the health of American children referenced scientific studies that did not exist among citations to support its conclusions in what the White House said were 'formatting issues' on Thursday.
The report produced by the Make America Healthy Again Commission, named after the slogan aligned with Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., was released last week. The 14-member commission included Kennedy, Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins, EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin and Food and Drug Administration head Martin Makary among others.
It said processed food, chemicals, stress and overprescription of medications and vaccines may be factors behind chronic illness in American children, citing some 500 research studies, including those that did not exist, as evidence.
Digital news outlet NOTUS reported the citation errors on Thursday. It found seven studies listed in the report's footnotes that did not exist, along with broken links and misstated conclusions, raising questions over whether the report had relied on artificial intelligence. Reuters independently confirmed two of the erroneous citations.
White House spokesperson Karoline Leavitt told reporters that any citation errors were due to 'formatting issues.' The government said it posted a corrected version of the report later on Thursday, without providing details on how the mistakes had occurred.
'The substance of the MAHA report remains the same - a historic and transformative assessment by the federal government to understand the chronic disease epidemic afflicting our nation's children,' the Department of Health and Human Services said. Kennedy has spent decades sowing doubt about the safety of vaccines, which have long been backed by a scientific consensus on their effectiveness for controlling disease outbreaks, raising concerns within the scientific and medical communities over the policies he would pursue as health secretary.
Since taking the role, he has fired thousands of workers at federal health agencies and cut billions of dollars from U.S. biomedical research spending.
'Nobody has ever accused RFK Jr. of academic rigor,' said Marion Nestle, a professor emerita of nutrition, food studies and public health at New York University. 'The speed (of the MAHA report) suggests that it could not have been vetted carefully and must have been whisked through standard clearance procedures. The citation problem suggests a reliance on AI.' AI-generated fictions, known as 'hallucinations,' have also cropped up in court filings and landed attorneys in hot water ever since ChatGPT and other generative AI programs became widely available more than two years ago. Katherine Keyes, an epidemiology professor at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, was cited in the MAHA report as the author of 'Changes in mental health and substance use among U.S. adolescents during the COVID-19 pandemic,' which the report said was published in the medical journal JAMA Pediatrics.
She said that neither she nor the named co-authors of the paper had written it. 'It does make me concerned given that citation practices are an important part of conducting and reporting rigorous science,' she said.
Psychiatry Professor Robert L. Findling did not author the article cited in the report as 'Direct-to-consumer advertising of psychotropic medications for youth: A growing concern' in the Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology, according to a spokesperson for Virginia Commonwealth University, where Findling is a professor.
The studies attributed to Findling and Keyes no longer appeared in the MAHA report on the White House website as of Thursday evening.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sinar Daily
5 hours ago
- Sinar Daily
Measles roars back in the US, topping 1,000 cases
WASHINGTON - The United States' measles outbreak has surpassed 1,000 confirmed cases with three deaths so far, state and local data showed on May 9, marking a stark resurgence of a vaccine-preventable disease that the nation once declared eliminated. The surge comes as Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. continues to undermine confidence in the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine -- a highly effective shot he has falsely claimed is dangerous and contains fetal debris. An AFP tally showed there have been at least 1,012 cases since the start of the year, with Texas accounting for more than 70 per cent. A vaccine-skeptical Mennonite Christian community straddling the Texas-New Mexico border has been hit particularly hard. A federal database maintained by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has lagged behind state and county reporting, as the globally renowned health agency faces deep workforce and budget cuts under President Donald Trump's administration. North Dakota is the latest state to report an outbreak, with nine cases so far. Around 180 school students have been forced to quarantine at home, according to the North Dakota Monitor. "This is a virus that's the most contagious infectious disease of mankind and it's now spreading like wildfire," Paul Offit a pediatrician and vaccine expert at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia told AFP. He warned the true case count could be far higher, as people shy away from seeking medical attention. "Those three deaths equal the total number of deaths from measles in the last 25 years in this country." The fatalities so far include two young girls in Texas and an adult in New Mexico, all unvaccinated -- making it the deadliest US measles outbreak in decades. It is also the highest number of cases since 2019, when outbreaks in Orthodox Jewish communities in New York and New Jersey resulted in 1,274 infections but no deaths. - Vaccine misinformation - Nationwide immunisation rates have been dropping in the United States, fueled by misinformation about vaccines, particularly in the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic. The CDC recommends a 95 per cent vaccination rate to maintain herd immunity. However, measles vaccine coverage among kindergartners has dropped from 95.2 per cent in the 2019-2020 school year to 92.7 per cent in 2023-2024. Measles is a highly contagious respiratory virus spread through droplets when an infected person coughs, sneezes or simply breathes. Known for its characteristic rash, it poses a serious risk to unvaccinated individuals, including infants under 12 months who are not ordinarily eligible for vaccination, and those with weakened immune systems. Before the measles vaccine's introduction in 1963, it is thought that millions of Americans contracted the disease annually, and several hundred died. While measles was declared eliminated in the US in 2000, outbreaks persist each year. Susan McLellan, an infectious disease professor at the University of Texas Medical Branch, pushed back against messaging that promotes remedies like Vitamin A -- which has valid but limited uses -- over vaccines. Kennedy has led that messaging in frequent appearances on Fox News. "Saying we're going to devote resources to studying therapies instead of enhancing uptake of the vaccine is a profoundly inefficient way of addressing a vaccine-preventable disease," she told AFP. McLellan added that the crisis reflects broader erosion in public trust in health authorities. She said it is hard for an individual untrained in statistics to understand measles is a problem if they don't personally see deaths around them. "Believing population-based statistics takes a leap, and that's public health." - Issam Ahmed / AFP
The Sun
7 hours ago
- The Sun
‘Extended hours sidestep real crisis facing nurses'
PETALING JAYA: While the Public Service Department (PSD) decision to delay the 45-hour work week offers nurses a temporary reprieve, many on the frontlines warn that it skirts the real crisis, namely chronic understaffing, burnout and the long-term viability of the profession. In a letter dated May 28, PSD approved the Health Ministry request to defer implementation of the extended hours until Aug 1. The current 42-hour schedule will remain in place until July 31. For many nurses, the move does little to ease the mounting pressure in wards and clinics across the country. An ICU nurse in the private sector, who gave his name only as Ng, said the focus on working hours misses the point entirely. 'Even 42 hours feels like too much when you're constantly on your feet, managing critical cases. This isn't a desk job. We don't have the luxury of zoning out. We're dealing with lives,' he told theSun. He said the public healthcare system is still reeling from the after-effects of the Covid-19 pandemic, and staffing remains dangerously thin. 'Understaffing is the root of the problem. I know government nurses earning RM4,000 after 10 years on the job. Eight of my friends have already left for better opportunities overseas.' Ng added that management often focuses on performance targets while ignoring the actual workload nurses face on the ground. 'I've worked 14-hour shifts looking after 16 critically ill patients. What looks manageable on paper rarely reflects the chaos in real life. Nurses and patients aren't statistics.' Kanchana Murthy, 25, echoed the sentiment after more than three years in the field. 'Extending hours is not a solution. Most of us are already running on empty. Yes, we need more manpower but stretching the ones already in place won't fix anything.' She said work tolerance varies by individual and longer shifts should never be mandatory. 'You can't force exhausted people to give their best. It's unsafe for patients and it's unfair to nurses.' A 19-year-old nursing student who has completed placements at a private hospital in the capital city said the workload is overwhelming even for trainees. 'As a student, I'm already burnt out. I work alongside full-time nurses and the pace is relentless. I genuinely worry about how the staff cope,' said the student, who only wanted to be known as Tash. He shared his experience at a government hospital, where overcrowding and staff shortages are common. 'Sometimes, there aren't enough beds. One nurse might be caring for 10 patients. Some wards hold up to 60. It's exhausting and unsafe.' Tash said while the government's intention to address shortages is understandable, the approach risks causing more harm than good. 'Longer hours might help with task completion in the short term, but they lead to fatigue and that leads to mistakes. In healthcare, mistakes cost lives.' He pointed out that countries such as Singapore and the Philippines follow the International Labour Organisation recommendation of a 40-hour work week, which offers nurses better balance and stronger mental health support. 'A 40-hour week helps prevent burnout, keeps staff in the profession longer and makes nursing more appealing to new recruits. What's the point of getting more done in a day if we lose people in the long run?' His message was clear: 'Stop treating nurses like machines. We're overworked, underpaid and undervalued. 'At the end of the day, we're human and we deserve to be treated that way.'
The Star
20 hours ago
- The Star
Mouth taping to prevent snoring is a potentially risky practice
The social media trend of mouth taping while sleeping can be dangerous, especially to those who have a blocked nose. — dpa Mouth taping – the sleeping trend seen across social media and said to reduce snoring, dry mouth and bad breath – can lead to serious health risks, scientists are warning in an analysis of recent research studies. For months, influencers, celebrities and countless social media accounts have been talking up the process of taping over your mouth at bedtime to promote restful sleep and reduce sleep- related breathing disorders. But researchers who evaluated 10 studies on this trend with a total of 213 participants say that it brings clear risks and has little evidence to back it. 'Taping the mouth is a current practice that is often promoted by celebrities but is not necessarily supported by scientific evidence,' says the Canadian research team. Proponents claim mouth taping can help combat daytime tiredness and concentration problems, and even prevent facial wrinkles. Fans – among them American actress Gwyneth Paltrow and Norwegian footballer Erling Haaland – place a plaster, adhesive tape or special tape over their mouth at night to keep it closed to make sure they breathe through their nose instead. 'Many people are not suited to mouth taping, and in some cases, it can lead to serious health risks,' say the researchers led by ear, nose and throat specialist Dr Brian Rotenberg from the London Health Sciences Centre in Ontario. The practice aims to help combat obstructive sleep apnoea, which causes your throat muscles to relax while you are asleep, especially if you lie on your back, causing the base of your tongue to fall back and narrow your airways. That obstruction can not only lead to snoring, but also nocturnal breathing interruptions – often dozens per hour. It reduces the oxygen supply to the blood and also wakes people up, impairing their sleep and making them more tired during the day. ALSO READ: Sleep apnoea: A common, yet frequently underdiagnosed, sleep disorder Mouth taping can help some people with mild obstructive sleep apnoea, say two of the 10 studies the team assessed. But four of the studies showed risks, especially if your nose is blocked, which could be the case if you suffer from chronic rhinitis, hay fever, sinusitis or problems with the nasal septum. ALSO READ: Many of us have a deviated septum in our nose People are at a risk of a serious oxygen deficiency if their nasal breathing is impaired and their mouth is also taped shut, say the team. In a further danger, in the event of acid reflux, the contents of your stomach cannot leave your throat and so block your airways, says the team in the study published in science journal PLOS One . 'Overall, the social media phenomenon of mouth taping as a means of preventing mouth breathing appears to be based on weak evidence,' the team says. If you breathe through your mouth because you cannot breathe well through your nose, you are most at risk of adverse effects. Better studies are needed to fully assess the safety of mouth taping and its effectiveness though, the team says, as the few they looked at were very small and varied, and the overall data was of poor quality. But based on the current data, mouth taping cannot be recommended for people with sleep- related breathing disorders, the scientists say. – By Walter Willems/dpa
